First Threesome [MFF]

Hello ladies and gentlemen, sorry for mobile formatting and all that. This is kinda a long one (seriously its long as hell) with a fair amount of behind the scenes relationship flavor. If it’s not your thing i feel ya, you do you. Well here we go.

The set up. I’ve been with my girl, Sam, for a over 3 years now. We both are in our mid 20s. Sam gets me in ways no one else ever has and we are very much happy and in love. It’s just easy being with her. One day she told me she had a sex dream but was shy to share, which isn’t like her. Sam is usually very open with me especially about sex. After some coaxing and pleading she finally opened up it was a dream of us having a threesome. Of course inside my head was fireworks, I asked how she felt and if she enjoyed it. She did but she was was already seeing where my mind was attempting to sprint too, and told me she was wary of actually acting it out.

What if I liked the other girl more? What if she liked the other girl more? What about health risks? She wasn’t sure she would feel comfortable seeing me balls deep in another girl. And didn’t want to just fuck some random girl, there would need to be a connection and she didn’t want to share our connection with anyone like that. After some talking we agreed that it might have been a sexy dream but the reality is it might not be for us. At least for now she said, she understood my desires and wanted to be fair to them but I got where she was coming from. Honestly I can be hypochondriac at times and the health risks of a new unknown partner did kinda kill the mood. So we continue our loves together having enjoyable sex just between ourselves.

About a year later we were trying to watch porn to spoon fuck too and threesome vid caught my eye. I put it on and Sam rolled her eyes. She berated me to, “Typical guy, always wanting more. One girl isn’t enough is it?” Some good kisses silenced her and she did seem to enjoy the girls in the video, both were gorgeous in their own way. Afterwards, she brought the subject up again. She was looking for reassurance about “us”. I reinforced how happy I am with her and how just because this act seems fun doesn’t mean I’d throw her away for it. She just needed some emotional support and I was happy to provide her with it I’ll spare you the rest of the conversation but she seemed satisfied with everything.

So much so she wanted to know what exactly I would want from a threesome if we ever did have one some day. After some thinking i said seeing her kiss another girl and be sexual with another girl would be fucking amazing. Watching her go down and be gone down on. Or going down on her with another girl, sharing her pussy with licks and kisses and vice versa seemed…well hot. She agreed and said she liked in the video when the guy was fucking the one girl missionary while the other rode her face. We cuddled and watched some Netflix but I could tell something was up with Sam. Finally she asked if I was willing to a agree to some ground rules, would I want to try a threesome still?

I said yes but only if she was ok with it. She shrugged and said she wasn’t sure if she was. That was one of her conditions, if she says no at anytime its off. Of course I agreed. She also said she’s not really comfy having me penetrate another girl, again I’m ok with that. She also wanted to get to know our would be partner first, again I agreed. She was nervous and a lil down. I told her this is supposed to be something fun we experience together and I don’t want proceed with this if it makes her uncomfortable. Again, she just needed some emotional support and reassurance. After another conversation I won’t subject you too we agreed we wouldn’t rush into this and we would find a good match via the ever trusty Tinder.

So we made a Tinder to find a Unicorn, just like every other couple on here has done. We didn’t want to be the skeevy couple you always see being made fun of so we posted nice pics of us together and alone and tried to write genuine bios that spoke about us while not being misleading. I’m not sure if we pulled that off exactly but we tried. Fast forward to 2 months of swipes, matches, ghostings, comparing and turning down matches. While I was at work Sam texted me saying she matched with a girl, Dani, she liked. They had been chatting for a few hours off and on and had been talking about a podcast they both liked. She sent me screenshots and wanted to know if I approved in case Dani was “The One” before she went and got her contact unfo.

The pics showed a cute girl, very thin and younger than both of us but she seemed cool and definitely hit it off with Sam from their chats. It wasn’t anything oozing with sex, but just two people randomly getting to know eachother. I said sure why not? Dani gets my blessing. So Sam spoke with Dani one on one some more before I got home. Sam decided it was time to let our intentions be clear, she had been talking to Dani for over 3 hours off and on. She told Dani that, “Hey soooo just to be honest I’ve enjoyed talking with you on here and would love to exchange numbers or snapchats! But also I have a bf and we were kinda hoping if things go well we could take you out for dinner together. Random I know!…thoughts?”

Dani was not as surprised as we thought she would be, apparently this wasn’t the first time someone had propositioned her like this; but Sam was the first she felt a connection to. Dani asked if the guy in pic 2 and 3 was the bf, it was. She thought he/I was cute, Sam agreed that he/i is/! Dani seemed to know what we were getting at, though she had never done it before but was down to swap numbers and snaps. So we did. We made a group text and talked for a while like that. Sam and I made dinner and texted Dani and we slowly formed a connection. She was different than us, more millennial trendy, with a strong passion for fashion (Sam has good fashion senses, but it’s something I sorely lack) but we liked her all the same. She wanted to see our cooking skills and we realized this was pic time. Sam wanted to quick get dolled up, I told her she was pretty and not to fret and we exchanged some incredibly goofy PG snaps of us cooking. It started off well though keeping it light as we all exchanged snaps back and forth. Dani looked just like her profile pic and we even exchanged some video back and forth, and she whined how she wanted dinner too. We offered to fix that and take her out to dinner that weekend if she was open to it. She said she was suddenly nervous but yes she would love dinner Friday; but maybe just dinner if that was ok?

I had kinda forgot the whole point of this exchange and the “just dinner” comment brought me back into focus. I was looking at Dani differently now. She looked gorgeous and I would love to see her with Sam at dinner. Suddenly I wasn’t hungry for dinner. I put Sam’s hand in my lap and she laughed and said, “Really?! That easy?” We both agreed JUST dinner friday no pressure no strings but we were excited. Sam mentioned one of us was a VERY EXCITED. The response from the girls laughter and I responded by bending Sam over the table right there. She didn’t mind, in fact she seemed to be enjoying it herself as I slipped right in her easily. Dani must have realized why we went silent for 20 minutes because she asked if dinner was good to be AFK for so long, accompanied with the peach eggplant and water drop emojis. We laughed afterwards, told her we had no idea what she was insinuating and that we were excited for Friday.

Friday rolls around and Sam is nervous. I ask if she wants to back out its just dinner and she says no that would be rude to Dani, plus she wants to go. I remind her this is a date its ok to be nervous but at least she has me with her! She agrees and we check in with out third. She’s in the same boat but excited and not gonna ghost us. The girls exchange what are you gonna wear texts and finally we head off. Sam wears a lil make up and a casual black dress that I like, shows off her curves very nicely in my opinion.

We arrive first and I order Sam a drink and ply her with tons of calming kisses and hand squeezes. She’s excited but nervous, hell I was too. Dani texts us shes parking! And suddenly we see her and shes at our table. The girls hug and exclaim how awkward it is and then its my turn, they both talk about how tall I am. I eye Dani and realize between her and Sam, I want this end game to happen. Dani is dressed in tight dress pants with heels and lose cardigan top combo thing. Next to Sam they are complimentary opposites. Dani is inches taller than Sam with their heels on and very lithe while Sam is straining her dress’s poor bust, something Dani mentions in surprise and admiration. The girls hug again and Sam jiggles her boobs into Dani and they laugh together. I offer drinks and we begin our dinner date! The conversation flows smoothly, and I can already tell two girls will be friends.

Midway through I decide to steer the conversation to romance, something we have all three semi avoided. I ask if Dani has had any luck meeting any cute boys off Tinder. She has had a couple dates but, “boys be basic af on tinder”. That’s partly why she was swiping on girls. I seized the opportunity and asked if she has had any luck meeting cute girls on tinder. She smiled shyly and twittered at Sam, “yaaa maybe. She’s pretty pretty”. From there we slowly moves to sex and intimacy. We share likes dislikes, I offer more drinks which Sam enjoys but Dani shouldn’t since she’s driving sadly. We find out that we are VERY compatible in the bedroom and tipsy Sam places her hand in my crouch proclaiming oh someone’s enjoying the conversation! Dani leans in and laughs but doesn’t seem bothered. Sadly that was the sauciest moment of the night I refuse the girls money and pay, we walk Dani to her car and tipsy Sam kisses her cheek saying good night, to which I playfully slap her ass and remind her to be cool and take it easy. Dani laughs but again doesn’t seem to mind, and we go our separate ways.

Sam and I talk the whole way back to my place about our date and I wonder if we will see young Dani again. Sam hopes so even if there’s no sex. As soon as we walk in we get a text asking if we are busy fucking already. We reply not yet but give us 20 min and we we won’t be able to answer the phones wink. Dani says we are dirty with all the appropriate emojis attached. I know we got her. I ask Sam if we should invite her over and she wants to but maybe not tonight cuz of roomates being home. I agree. So we offer Dani to come over tomorrow for another date. We can go to dinner or get drinks and I make it clear that Sam and I will be staying at a hotel near the downtown. Dani gets what we are implying and agrees. Saying it’ll be fun to cut loose. In that case, Sam and I agree to hold off until tomorrow, though we send some spicier than usual snaps to her. One of us kissing and a video of me kissing Sams neck. We see that she has seen them and finally she responds teasing us with just a pic of her face and bra asking if she can have neck kisses too. Check. Mate. We sext back and forth before we settle on plans to meet up tomorrow. We agree that drinks at the hotel, with both girls wanting to smoke some weed. Sam and her talk about potential ground rules, and then Sam talks to me about the same. She says she is down for tomorrow but says she’s not sure she wants me fucking Dank. I kiss her and tell her what ever she wants, she is what’s important and this is just a fun thing for us to share. She agrees and we make out for a while before bed.

The next day I gathered everything up that morning, making sure the hotel still had our room. I bough beer and wine and premade shots. I also got a ton of food too because who knows? Never had a threesome before and we may get hungry! 3 hours before our meet time tell Sam, who is starting to fret, to pack all her toys and pick maybe 2 lingerie outfits just in case we want some variety. She frets and tries some on and sends them in the group chat. Dani proclaims that she enjoys what she sees and she’s excited and nervous too. I try to calm them by offering we are all in the same boat, lets be calm and cool and just have fun. Dani says that’s a good plan cuz she is bringing a good amount of weed. The girls both talk about that and I share that i have booze since I don’t smoke (just not my thing).

Well 5 o clock rolls around and arrive first. Dani says she’s on her way and Sam and I get everything set up. Music on, booze cold, Sam looking hot in her dress with her stockings on. We here the knock on the door and we kiss for luck before opening. Dani and Sam share a hug while I grab her surprisingly full bag of stuff, before they launch into conversations about how crazy and amazing this is. I offer shots to ease into things which the girls agree too. They also step out to use the vape and I enjoy a beer and check the playlist, making sure nothing crazy comes on.

The girls come back in gigglier than they left, big surprise. I tease them about it and they tease me back and over all everything is just friendly and smooth. Too friendly. I remember that to get things rolling I gotta give them a push. So I point out the fact that we are barefoot and Dani is not, and that Sam has stockings on. Dani seemingly notices for the first time as she takes her Converses off says Sam’s legs look good in them. Sam says thank you, the weed kicking in, and raises her dress showing the attaching snaps of her garter with a giggly wink (she is a happy giggly lil stoner). I walk over behind Sam, pressing my erection into her ass and grab both her tits and jiggle them at Dani saying these look good too huh? Sam laughs grabbing my hands with hers and turning to kiss my neck. Dani laughs as well though she looks admittedly shy. I offer her to put on what ever music she wants to snap her out of her shyness and she lights up at that. As she passes Sam to put adjust the Spotify, Sam slaps her ass. Dani gives a surpised smile and playfully slaps back at Sam. To which Sam says no get her good, and bends over. I wonder internally where the nervous emotional girl went that I’m dating.

Dani lifts Sam’s dress and slaps her voluptuous ass, seriously Sam’s ass is amazingly round and balances out her amazing boobs. Dani also coos and compliments Sam’s thong of choice. I sip my beer amazed at the happenings and say she shod see the rest of it. Sam laughs but offers to show Dani and once they both agree through the giggles I offer Dani a chair and help Sam with her dress zipper. Once it falls off her, Sam cocks a pose at Dani, again surging with that confidence, showing off her black lace pattern bra, mercilessly smooshing her boobs together, coupled with her black garter belt and thong. Again, check mate.

Dani proclaims that Sam looks so sexy and her tits are just woooow. I jiggle Sam’s boobs at Dani again, this time free of the dress watching her watch them bounce freer. I ask how everyone is feeling and Dani says she’s good, Sam says she is horny as she reaches back to grab and stroke me over my pants. Dani gets up stepping closer to Sam, and the girls hesitate and giggle before finally kissing. I wisely shut the hell up and let them kiss, Sam stroking me all the while. I notice Dani running her hands over Sam’s soft skin, tracing down to her booty where she plants a hand, grabbing it. Sam pulls me in placing my bulge over Dani’s hand, effectively sandwiching her between a soft butt and a hard place. I ask of Dani minds, she breaks the kiss saying she doesn’t though she wants another quick hit before…trailing off into giggles. Sam agrees but doesn’t want to get dressed again so Dani pops out for her hit then offers it to Sam he blows it through the door. Dani comes in locking the door smiling saying that, “weed makes her horny” as she pulls her top off to reveal her neon green bra and tonned tummy. I’m grinding into Sam’s ass kissing her neck and tell her to look at Dani. She sighs and lets out a soft moan as Dani approaches her. I offer to take my shirt off if she looses her jeans, something Sam says is a fair trade. Dani agrees and I pull my shirt off as We get to see Dani’s clashing neon pink panties. Somehow the girl could look good in clashed colors though.

I push Sam to the bed and offer the same to Dani, giving her ass a little spank. The girls giggle and instantly devolve into a tangled mess of wandering hands and kisses and moans. I undress fully before sliding behind Sam, grinding against her and whispering if its ok if i touch Dani. She moans a yesss and I trace Dani’s jaw line as she makes out with Sam following it down to her neck and small breasts. I give them a squeeze and she smiles with fluttering eyes as she and Sam kiss like crazed high schoolers. I follow it down to her ass griping it and pulling her into Sam, the girl skillfully working a leg between Sam’s greedy legs in the process. As I grab and admire Sam humps Dani’s leg until Dani mentions that Sam is so wet she can feel it on her thigh.

I tell Sam to get on her back as they kiss, before getting between her legs and removing her thong. I tell Dani to hold her leg open and she does, breaking the kiss to watch me lower myself face to Sam’s wet, warm, shavedpussy. I look into Dani’s eyes as I lap my girlfriend, she groans out a ffffuuuuuuck and drops a hand to play with herself. Sam places a hand on my head holding me in place as she humps my face, sighing and moaning into Dani’s neck. We proceed like this for a while, Dani removes her panties exposing her pink pussy and its neat landing strip. I ask Sam if she wants to taste Dani, she nods and Dani adjusts to accompany us, spreading her tan legs wide for Sam. I lower myself next to Sam, realizing she has never licked a pussy before. We share a tongue frenzied kiss and I murmur that she tasted great, before she begins licking our new friend’s pussy. I joined her face to face, taking turns nibbling her thighs, lapping her pink folds, and sharing kisses. Dani had her hands wrapped tight in our hair as bra covered breasts heaved with every breath, moaning the whole time. Eventually Sam told me she needed me in her, so I obliged happy to climb behind her and enter her incredibly wet pussy, all while she enjoyed Dani’s pussy.

Given this much new stimulation, I knew I wouldn’t last long so I just hilted myself in Sam letting her grip and flex on my throbbing cock. After a few minutes I told Sam I was ready whenever she wanted me to cum, offering to let her choose where. Dani was watching us through half lided eyes, her moans filling the room louder than the music. Sam told me to fuck her hard and cum inside her, I happily obliged, my hips slapping her ass as I pumped her full of my cum. Dani said she wanted to cum too, and asked for me to get her toy in her bag. Sam expressed similar desires and I brought each girl their preferred toys; Sam a small purple bullet and Dani a pink curved vibrator. Both girls lay back side by side legs spread open and began pleasureing themselves. I kissed Dani for first time, our tongues playing, before I crawled back to Sam, eating her out like I know she loves while she played with her clit.

Eventually she moaned she was cumming and clenched her legs tightly around my head shaking as she did. Dani stopped her own pleasuring to forcibly kiss my girlfriend, all while i was trapped between her stocking clad legs. Once Sam came down the girls offered a drink break (and then another smoke). We proceeded to fuck for a long ass while. I fucked Sam again while she ate Dani. I made out with Sam as Dani ate her, and switched so I could make out with Dani while Sam devoured her, she seemed to enjoy eating her new found pussy. The highlighting moment was Sam riding me cow girl, with Dani on my face buzzing her clit with her pink toy, both girls moaning and kissing each other. After a shower, we all tried to sleep in the same bed, but admittedly we were all too handsy to really sleep well.

The girls gave my a good blowjob in the morning, Sam taking my load while Dani provided some excellent dirty talk. We checked out feeling sorry for the maid and agreed to keep in touch and maybe get actual dinner again soon. The girls hugged and Sam grabbed her ass as she did and then they kissed. I got the same treatment and that marked the end ofour first threesome together. Thanks for reading or skimming. Sorry not sorry for the long slow build!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/9ylqox/first_threesome_mff