Truth or Dare Ball – Part II: Thor is Sexy [Group]

[Part I is here.]
(https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/9jfd47/swapping_at_a_halloween_party_an_intro_to_truth/)

*Names and minor details have been changed for anonymity.*

It was a few days after Halloween, and my wife Michelle and I were anxious to play with our friends Mark and Winn again. We’d had threesomes with women before, but we’d never swapped with another couple. Just the small amount of playing we did with Mark and Winn had been so hot, we were constantly horny just thinking about it. We wanted more. But how, with a willing but reluctant Winn controlling the pace? We went through a bunch of ideas: Spin the bottle? No, that’s fun for a minute but it’s just kissing. Truth or Dare? Maybe, but it’s usually lame. I scoured the internet for hours looking for swinger games to ease in newbies, but there’s nothing good. They progress from “Make out for a minute” to “Anally gangbang the mailman” in like…2 rounds. No thank you. But then Michelle knocked it out of the park.

In college, she was an orientation leader. They played a game called “Introduction Ball” where they wrote a bunch of questions on a soccer ball and passed it around. Wherever your thumb landed, you had to answer that question. Boring shit like “Where are you from?” and “What’s your major?” But her idea was to modify the concept into “something like a Sexy Ball?” Basically a combination of Intro Ball, Spin the Bottle, and Truth or Dare. She’s so smart.

We sat down and came up with options. Obviously there would be “Truth” and “Dare.” But we wanted some more specific ones. “Kiss the person to your left,” “Remove 1 article of clothing.” Michelle asked if we should put “Oral sex” or “PiV” on there, but no. What if we got that on the first round? There’s no way it would happen. So…we got clever. “Do something nice for the person on your right.” That could mean anything from a shoulder rub to making them orgasm. We liked that. I’ll spare you the details, but we spent about a week coming up with ideas and refining them. We ended up with 30 options to put on the ball (and were so very pleased with ourselves). I bought a cheap volleyball at a discount store, and Michelle [marked it up with sharpie](https://i.imgur.com/0Izi4eW_d.jpg?maxwidth=640&shape=thumb&fidelity=medium). Her handwriting is much nicer than mine.

While this was happening, we were trying to keep things steamy with Mark and Winn. Unfortunately, Winn was not super receptive to my communications (she prefers calling instead of texting, the freak!) so after confirming that she had enjoyed herself, I let her have her space. Michelle has no game, so her text conversations with Mark were fun, but not really moving things forward.

>Had fun at Halloween.

>Whatever do you mean? ;)

>I mean, you’re fun when you’ve had some wine.

>Oh yeah?

>Yeah.

>Well we should do it again soon.

>Absolutely.

That sort of thing. So it fell to Mark and me to make it happen.

>Hey man! Enjoy fingering Michelle?

>Lol. Yeah, could you tell?

>Yeah dude, when you stood up you were harder than a Roman statue XD

>Guilty.

>Well the only reason you didn’t see me standing at attention is because I was sitting. Winn had me just as hard.

>I bet. She’s real good with her hands.

>From what I’ve experienced, I agree 100%

>Would you say you experienced it…first…hand?

>I let you get my wife off and you give me puns?? You’re dead to me!

>Hah! Tell you what, I’ll make it up to you.

>I dunno man. You cut me deep.

>What if I told you Winn really likes your cock, and wishes she had gotten to spend more time with it?

>I’m listening.

>Haha. It’s true. She was weird for about 2 days and didn’t talk about it, but it’s because she was worried I was secretly jealous.

>Oh no!

>She’s good now though. I told her that if anyone else is going to fuck her, I want it to be you. And I…quite vividly explained how badly I want to bang Michelle, so that helped, haha.

>Well yeah, she’s super hot. And since we’re being candid, I should tell you: She’s done nothing but fantasize about fucking you for days.

>XD And that’s absolutely cool with you?

>Honestly man, I’m hard right now just thinking about it. The ladies making out while they ride our faces. You taking Michelle from behind while she blows me. Me fucking Winn on her back while she eats out Michelle, and she jerks you off. Can you imagine?

>Indeed I can, yes!

>…I might have to take care of business right now actually, haha.

>You have great ideas. I might have to join you.

We texted some sexy images back and forth until we had both finished. It was even hotter knowing that my friend was jerking off at the same time, lusting after my wife. It’s not really relevant to the story, but I’ll include some of the pictures because why not? Unsurprisingly, we have similar taste in women. Favorites include: [Anna Kendrick](http://picture-cdn.wheretoget.it/w4bqok-l-610×610-dress-party+dress-body-bodycon+dress-boots-anna+kendrick-knee+boots.jpg), [Margot Robbie](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/9a/56/b7/9a56b7f730fd3baeec725be13e1a6205.jpg), [Emma Stone](https://orig00.deviantart.net/42e9/f/2016/160/2/6/emma_stone_spicy_bikini_stills___hollywood_hot__ac_by_heroinesapp-da5k3gm.jpg), [Kristen Bel](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/79/b5/bd/79b5bd88fa9d9e4b5895180101607f1a.jpg), [Stoya](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/f5/9a/8d/f59a8d613f4bea24105b682d782d3614.jpg), and [Kat Dennings](https://saucemonsters.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Kat-Dennings-05.jpg). Anyway!

Once the ball was complete, we invited them over to our place. I wore my best date outfit: dark wash jeans and a white button-down with the sleeves rolled up. Michelle wore a scandalously tight pencil skirt, thigh high stockings, and low cut top that screamed “I’m fucking someone tonight.” They knocked on the door, and Mark walked in wearing his usual grunge-rock clothes. Winn was wearing….jeans and a cardigan. Shit. Not a good sign. They entered and offered some chaste hugs. We made small talk and Michelle asked if they wanted a drink. “Just water,” Winn said. Double shit. She *always* has a couple glasses of wine when we hang out. There was no way Winn would play Truth or Dare Ball sober: she must not be feeling it tonight. Damn it.

Michelle also noticed. The last thing we wanted was to pressure Winn, so it was time to triage. Maybe she needed more time? Maybe she didn’t want to seem too eager? I kicked myself for not thinking of this possibility. On Halloween, Winn was partying, having fun, flaunting around in a very sexy costume. She was drunk, Halloween is already sexy, the good energy was flowing. Tonight…not so much. We needed to buy some time. “Anyone want to watch a movie?” They agreed. I figured that a film is about 2 hours in the dark, we could use that time to relax and build a mood.

We sat on the couch and picked the movie. In our texts about sexy performers, Mark had mentioned that Winn thinks [Tom Hiddleston](http://stylemnl.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Tom-Hiddleston-2016-Photo-Shoot-W-Magazine-800×1199-690×1050.jpg) is the hottest actor around. Michelle happens to like [Chris Hemsworth](https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/61v8Z1dNHyL._AC_UL320_SR240,320_.jpg). Mark and I love [Kat Dennings](https://zemanceleblegs.com/wp-content/gallery/k/kat-dennings/Kat-Dennings-Sexy-Celebrity-Legs-Picture-Zeman-Celebrity-Legs-00003.jpg), so the choice was obvious: Thor. Maybe that would help get everyone in a sexy mood. I started the movie and shut off the lights while Michelle and Winn got water. Mark sat on the end of the couch. I had hoped that Michelle would sit with Mark, and Winn would sit with me, but Winn practically leapt over us to get to her man. Triple shit. I started resigning myself to a regular night of watching movies with the chums.

But as I said, my wife is very smart. The second Hemsworth appeared on screen, she made a fake orgasm sound. Everyone chuckled. When Hiddleston showed up…Winn did the same. Alright alright. When Kat made her appearance, I said, “What I’d give for a night with her!” and Mark replied “You’ll have to share.” Michelle interjected, “He likes sharing, don’t worry.” Winn smiled. Good! This was going well. About a half hour into the movie, we had gotten pretty crass. Michelle said “Thor can hammer me any time.” I said, “Mark, which end of Kat do you want first?” And finally Winn added, “I hope they all had sex after they were done filming. If not, what a waste of pretty people.” Excellent. Michelle paused the movie, stood up and declared “I need some wine. Anyone else?” Winn concurred, and they went into the kitchen.

Mark and I made idle chatter until the girls came back with HUGE glasses of wine. It looked like they had each taken half the bottle. And this time, Michelle sat next to Mark. Winn sat with me. We turned the movie back on, and they drank. Mark put his arm around Michelle. I put my arm around Winn. Michelle started stroking Mark’s leg. Winn ran her fingers along my chest. As the girls got tipsy, their comments became more direct. Out of nowhere Michelle said “I’m horny. Is anyone else horny?” Mark and I said, “Yup” at the same time. Winn giggled. Michelle started rubbing higher up on Mark’s thigh. Winn was watching closely, but it was dark so it was hard to tell exactly what was happening. It seemed like Michelle might be rubbing his cock through his pants. Winn downed the rest of her wine, set her glass on the coffee table, and started rubbing my thigh as well. I was immediately erect. Winn noticed and said “Brian’s hammer is rock hard.” Nerd. Michelle laughed. “Mark too.” “Guilty,” he answered. Mark leaned into my wife, and they started kissing. Winn and I did the same. Michelle shifted her weight and straddled Mark, her hand reaching between them to keep rubbing his junk. Winn copied her. After a couple minutes of dry humping while the credits rolled, Winn suddenly jumped up and yelled, “I need to pee!” and scurried off to the bathroom. Michelle got off of Mark and adjusted her skirt. She went to the kitchen and refilled their glasses with more wine.

I wasn’t about to let the energy die, so I said, “Your wife is so hot” while I put on that fireplace show for mood lighting. Then I grabbed the Truth or Dare Ball and tossed it to Mark. “Think she’ll go for this?” I asked as he looked it over. “This is genius,” he said. Winn came back into the room and I tossed her the ball. “Want to play?” I asked. She inspected the ball, biting her lower lip. I could tell she wanted to, but was conflicted. Michelle entered the room and playfully brought her another half-bottle glass of wine. “This will help” she cooed. Winn smiled and tossed the ball back to me, taking her glass. “What are the rules?” she challenged. Excellent.

I had rehearsed this part. “This is the Truth or Dare Ball.” I tossed it to Michelle. “We sit guys across from guys, girls across from girls, and toss it to the right. Wherever your right thumb lands, you have to perform the act. Most of them are self explanatory, and I’ll explain the odd ones if they pop up. For the game to go smoothly, we’ll assume consent as a given. Instead of asking for permission, we’ll all agree now that permission is granted. If you’re not comfortable doing something, just ask for a new suggestion and no one will be upset! But without a “no,” anything goes. Sound good?” Winn smiled and said “Yep!” Mark nodded. Michelle blinked, a little drunk. Lightweight.

We sat on the carpet. Mark was across from me, Winn to my right, Michelle to my left. “Here we go!” Michelle shouted, and lobbed the ball to me. My thumb landed on **Make out w/ person to L 30 sec.** “Alrighty, I have to make out with my wife for 30 seconds! Someone set a phone timer!” Michelle practically leapt at me and we made out for half a minute. I really like making out with her when she’s drunk, she just melts into me completely. On top of that, having our friends watch really upped the hotness. I was half hard already. “Time!” Mark called, and we returned to our spots. “Your turn!” I said, and tossed the ball to Winn. “It says, **Truth** and there’s an arrow,” she said. Michelle asked, “Who’s the arrow pointing to?” “Brian.” “That means Brian has to ask you a question and you have to answer truthfully.” “Okay,” she said nervously. I thought for a second. “Have you ever had a sexual experience with a lady?” She blushed. “Yeah…Mark and I had a couple threesomes last year. The other girl ended up being crazy, but I really enjoyed it before that.” Awesome.

She threw the ball to Mark. **Describe a sexual fantasy, -1 clothing** “So I’m guessing this means I take off a piece of clothing while I describe a fantasy?” he asked. “So ssmart!” Michelle joked, slurring a little. Winn giggled too, her face flushed. It looked good on her. I noticed they had both finished their wine and were feeling good. “Well,” he said, pulling his shirt off and revealing his 6 pack, “I’ve always wanted a happy ending massage. And not from a seedy rub’n’tug parlor. Like, a licensed massage therapist who just can’t keep her hands off me.” Winn looked surprised. “I didn’t know you had that fantasy. I’ll have to keep that in mind.” Then she winked at him. Michelle’s turn: **Remove 1 item of clothing** “Simple enough,” she said, unbuttoning her shirt and removing it. She was wearing a blue lace bra that made her DD cleavage look fantastic, and Mark couldn’t stop staring. She tossed the ball to me. **x2** “What’s that mean?” Winn asked. “So there are a few modifiers on here. ‘x2′ means I re-toss the ball and have to double whatever I get next. 30 seconds becomes 60 seconds, or one item of clothing becomes two. Something like that.” They nodded, I tossed the ball straight up, and caught it again. **Remove 1 item of someone else’s clothing** “Haha. Winn, I’m going to take two articles of clothing off of you.” She smiled and presented herself to me. I ran my hands up her sides as I pulled her cardigan off her shoulders, then had her lift her arms so I could remove her undershirt. She was wearing the *sexiest* black cage bra. The little scamp had come prepared after all. “Very cute,” I admired. “Thank you!” she grinned, and caught the ball.

**Link Across** “Is that another modifier?” she asked. “Yep, toss it again and whatever you get has to involve Michelle now.” “Okay.” She threw the ball straight up and landed on **Make out/heavy petting Your Choice 60 seconds** “Okay, so I pick a person to make out with for a minute?” she asked. Michelle answered, “Yes, with heavy petting. Plus me, because of the modifier.” Winn thought for a second, “Hm. I pick Mark. So do I make out with Mark and then Michelle?” Now that would be fine given the rules we had come up with, but I wanted to get things rolling. “Nope. It means you both have to make out with Mark, with heavy petting, at the same time.” Everyone seemed to enjoy that answer. “I’m not complaining!” Mark exclaimed. The girls giggled, and Michelle made the first move. As I set a timer on my phone, she kissed Mark deeply. She ran her hands over his chest and shoulders, down his stomach, and onto his crotch. She kissed down his neck to make room for Winn, who began making out with him. Together they started rubbing his dick through his jeans. Winn moved down to the other side of his neck, and he looked up at me and mouthed “Thank you!” as the women both felt his cock. I shrugged like, “What did you expect?” and because I am a benevolent god I let them go over time by about 15 seconds. “Time!” I called out, and everyone sat back, flushed. After a second of silence, Mark yelled “I like this game!”

He caught the ball: **Describe a sexual experience, -1 others clothing** “So, recently I was playing a gig,” he started, and moved toward Michelle. He motioned for her to stand, which she did. “And Winn showed up at the bar unannounced.” He unzipped Michelle’s skirt and started pulling it down. “She was wearing my favorite plaid skirt, tall heels, and had done her hair and makeup differently than she normally does.” Michelle stepped out of her skirt, now only in her blue lace bra, matching blue thong, and thigh high stockings. He gave her firm butt a smack before they sat back down. She loves that. “She pretended like she didn’t know me, then acted like a slutty groupie trying to take me home. During a break between sets, we snuck off to the bar’s bathroom and fucked until I came inside her. She left her panties in my pocket, and sat through the rest of the performance in no underwear with my cum dripping out of her.” Winn looked a little embarrassed, but Michelle and I applauded. We’re supportive like that. He threw the ball to my wife.

**L and R do something nice for you (Ls choice)** I said, “So Mark, you get to pick: What’s the nice thing we do for Michelle?” “Hmm,” he thought. “Why don’t you massage her back while I massage her front?” “Great idea!” I moved to sit behind my wife, who leaned against me as I began rubbing her neck and shoulders. Mark sat in front of her and started rubbing her hands and forearms. He worked his way up her arms until he was rubbing her breasts. She moaned as he slipped his hands under her bra. I kissed her neck, and she startled a bit when Mark tweaked her nipples. “How long are we doing this Mark, a full round?” I asked. He nodded, and my wife tossed the ball back to me and began kissing him. **+Hotness** “What’s that?” Winn questioned. “It means that whatever I get next, we have to increase the level of sexiness. Push the boundaries a little bit.” “Exciting,” she said. I flipped the ball up again: **Make someone happy with a partner** “You’ve been sitting by yourself for too long, Winn, so you’ll be my partner. And we’ll make Mark happy: You do whatever you want to him, and since we have the Hotness modifier, I’ll say that Mark: you should remove Michelle’s underwear before we continue.” Everyone smiled. Michelle practically ripped her bra off while Mark pulled down her thong, leaving her in only thigh highs. Winn took the opportunity to remove Mark’s pants as well, leaving him in nothing buy gray boxer-briefs. His cock was as hard as mine was, bulging out against his underwear.

Michelle and Mark sat facing each other, mostly naked. Winn kneeled behind Mark in her jeans and bra. I sat behind Michelle, still fully clothed. I reached around and began lightly stroking Michelle’s clit, as Mark kissed down her naked chest and began licking her nipples. She was already soaking wet. Mark groaned, and I looked up to see that Winn had reached around his body and slid her hand into his underwear. She began slowly stroking his cock. Mark and Michelle moaned together as Winn jerked him off and I fingered Michelle. I took my hand away from her pussy and played with her breasts again, which freed up enough space to let Mark’s fingers find her wetness. She moaned and shoved her tongue down his throat, while Winn released his cock from his boxer briefs. He sighed with relief, and it was his turn to moan when Michelle’s hand joined Winn’s in wrapping around his dick. This was the first one she had touched (besides mine) in years, and it was amazing how much it turned her on. They both stroked him for a bit while Michelle’s breathing quickened. She gasped when Mark inserted a finger into her pussy. That did the trick, and after a few minutes of the “come hither” motion she shuddered and came all over his hand. He removed it and looked her in the eyes as he licked his fingers clean. Winn and I made eye contact over our spouses, and she bit her lower lip.

She pulled Mark to the couch, knelt on the floor, and began licking up and down the shaft of his penis. With the head of his cock in her mouth, she turned to look at Michelle and I, motioning for us to join them on the couch. “Your husband is wearing too many clothes!” she said to Michelle, who wasted no time in stripping me completely. I sat next to my friend and watched his wife deepthroat his cock. Michelle knelt next to Winn and started stroking me. The girls kept glancing over at each other while they serviced us, admiring the others’ technique. Winn mostly used her mouth, taking in Mark’s entire dick and holding it there while he groaned. Michelle used both her hands, twisting them in opposite directions while her tongue flicked the tip of my cock. They kept at it for a few minutes, while we got closer and closer to orgasm. I was harder than I’d ever been: apparently I’m more of an exhibitionist/voyeur than I thought: a blowjob is great, but a blowjob with friends was even better. Right before I reached the point of no return, Michelle stopped sucking me and leaned towards Winn. Winn took the hint, and the women kept jerking us while they locked pre-cum soaked lips. “Holy fuck,” Mark said. The sight of our wives making out with cocks in hand must have been too much for him. “I’m coming!” Winn smiled, broke off the kiss, and took her husbands entire dick into her mouth once again. His body locked up as he came down her throat, and she swallowed it all. The sight was too much for me and I started my own orgasm. Michelle also took me all in, not letting anything go to waste. As Mark and I recovered, the girls kissed again. Winn had a bit of Mark’s semen on her chin. Michelle noticed and wiped it off with a finger…then licked it clean. “Yum,” she complimented, “Can’t wait to try the whole load myself.” She winked at Mark, and the girls scampered off to the bathroom to wash up. Mark turned to me. “Dude.” “Haha. I know.” “*Dude*.” “Yuuuup.” “I think Truth or Dare Ball is my favorite game,” he laughed. “Just you wait, brother. You haven’t seen half of what we’ve come up with.”

Everyone cleaned up and got dressed. We chatted for a few more minutes before Winn declared, “I’m drunk, horny, and I’m the only one who didn’t cum. My husband is going to take me home and fuck my brains out!” As they left, Michelle asked “So do you guys want to do this again?” The moment of truth. Winn thought for a second. “Are you free next week?” she asked. “Yeah!” we replied. “Then next week it is!” she said, grinning from ear to ear.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/9ta2j9/truth_or_dare_ball_part_ii_thor_is_sexy_group