During the summer after my freshman year of college I was semi-seeing a girl from the town of my school, Cara. At the same time I was fucking my good friend Becky pretty much every time we got together. You can find a couple other stories I wrote about Becky in my profile.
Cara was the opposite of Becky in every way. She was tall, almost 6 feet. Athletic with a stunning face that was downright beautiful in every picture. Auburn hair that went past her shoulders. Her body’s was toned but not overtly sexy. She was a basketball player. So that type of body.
Cara was also from a super religious family and was a virgin in every way possible. We met and just clicked right away.
But she was a tease and we hadn’t gotten far. What I had gotten to see looked amazing. She had the most perfect B cup perky tits that just completely defied gravity.
Plus. I just genuinely liked her. We hadn’t talked about being exclusive. But I was aware I was probably being an ass by sleeping with someone else.
Cara came to visit for a day while I was home. It was over halfway through the summer break. I hadn’t seen her in a while but she looked great and I was into her the entire visit. Near the end of her time we finally were completely alone in my room. House empty.
It was the usual makeout session. Dry humping. It wasn’t going anywhere and I was super frustrated. She had to feel how hard I was but made no moves to help me out. Based on our conversations I wasn’t even sure she had ever given a handjob.
After a good 30 minutes we came up for air as I had maybe pushed her too far. My hand was under her shirt pinching her amazing perky tits and nipples.
She sat up and smiled and took her shirt off.
“This easier?” She said. I must have been smiling ear to ear. I just attacked her tits. My mouth all over her nipples and just going crazy. My hand roaming her breast and stomach. I wanted more. But scared to push her.
“Relax. Let me try something,” she said and pushed me back down. I laid calm and let her take the lead. She just slowly moved her hand over my jeans feeling the outline of my cock that was ready to explode.
I wasn’t thinking straight and reached down and undid my jeans. Pushed them down a little and took my cock out in front of her.
Classy move. I know.
She stopped suddenly and looked at me. Unsure what to do or what to touch.
I grabbed her hand and had her wrap it around. She figured out quickly to just stroke up and down a little.
It was hot because it was new. Not because she was any good at it. In fact she was terrible and I would never cum with her doing it that way.
I decided that maybe she wanted me to take the lead. So I leaned up and kissed her which got her excited. As I rolled back down I took her head with me. She got the idea of what I was aiming at and moved her head to my dick.
She kept a hand on it and slowly opened her mouth and took me in her.
It was…not good. It was obvious that she had never sucked dick. But then an odd thing happened. I realized that she had never had a dick in her mouth and that made the experience hotter.
I started to help her stroking the lower part of my cock. Her eyes were closed and she kept moving up and down on my dick. I don’t know if she was a quick learner or just the whole scenario was erotic in its own way, but i felt my balls tighten and started cumming hard. I closed my own eyes and just let loose.
Once I was done I looked down and saw Cara smiling at me. Sitting up with her perky tits.
“Well I didn’t plan on that,” she said while laughing a little.
She must have swallowed it all down because I didn’t see a mess anywhere. She put her shirt back on.
“I have to go soon and I know you had plans with friends,” Cara said. I kissed her and slowly put myself back together.
We talked for a few minutes and the doorbell rang. I went to the door to see Becky there. No one else as planned (I was really going out with friends) and early. Shit.
To be continued…(sorry this went longer than I thought, and no a 3some doesn’t magically occur)
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/9rcuh1/the_virgin_and_the_town_slut_part_1_of_2_mf