The only threesome [MMF] I’ve (31m) had… wasn’t really a threesome at all

This happened a few years ago. I live in an area with a lot of people in open relationships… including one of my former coworkers and her bf.
She and I have always been pretty tight. We both worked the same closing shifts at the restaurant (neither of us work there any more.. both moved on to bigger and better things) Lots of late night drinks, “what does it all mean” kind of conversations–not just your typical jokey coworker relationship. we never hooked up, but we would definitely flirt a lot. She had a boyfriend and I knew that they had been together for a long while, but I didn’t know they had an open relationship. (even if I had known I probably would have held off on coming on to her because in my experience those relationships are very fraught…)

Anyway, she got a new job, and I was bummed because I lost my drinking buddy, but it happens all the time. I kind of figured I wouldn’t see her again, save one or two times that she came in to get some food or something. But, maybe a month later, she texted me and asked to get drinks.

So I met up with her. (I should probably describe her she’s got dyed blonde hair, blue eyes, *very* petite…probably 5’2”… she’s a little spinner I’ll call E. Probably about 24 or 25 at the time of this story, I was 28) we catch up, she tells me about her new job, but I can tell there’s something going on with her and so I say “whats up? is there something you want to say to me?”

She talks about how her bf and her have an open relationship and how her birthday had just happened and what she asked for was a threesome… and she wanted to know if that was something I would be interested in. She was very shy and cute asking me this–bright red. Immediately I saw her in a new light. I said hell yes! I wanted to put her at ease. I told her I’d never had a threesome before and she said that they hadn’t either. I asked her when, and she said whenever I wanted, but that her bf was waiting at home, and that we could do it pretty much right then.

As soon as she propositioned me I was hard, so I was down for right then. I got our drinks. We were about to leave, but I pulled her into the game room at the bar and kissed her. I pressed her against the wall so she could feel my cock through my pants and said something like “I’m so glad we’re doing this” and she just kind of moaned and kissed me back. I followed her back to her house.

Her bf was there in the living room. I had never met him before, but he was kind of drunk. He stood up and was like “we doing this?” or he said something like that, but like I said he was kind of
half in the bag. In the kitchen there was a bottle of tequila about half gone. I poured the three of us a shot each and took it in to the living room. We all sipped…it was kind of a tense scene. Like the bf started asking E about her day at work and just making small talk with me about the restaurant, and I just kept thinking “what have I gotten myself into??” So after like thirty minutes of this boring stuff, E and I exchanged glances. She gave me a look like “well?”

I said: “E, why don’t you take your clothes off for us?” and she jumped up, obviously eager to get things going. All she was wearing was a dress and some leggings. I said, “slow E, make us savor this. start with the leggings.” she started to pull them down like they were pants and I stopped her and stood up. I put her in position where she was on the couch and her ass was facing out. She peeled the leggings down like that and let us see her ass and pussy. I can be kind of crass when I’m horny (+a few drinks) so I said something about how bad I wanted to use that pussy up, and her bf shot me a look. “stand up and take off the dress.”

She stood up and took off her dress. Her body was really sweet. Her breasts were really small but very perky… she was soo teensy. I suggested that she go over to bf and sit on his lap. She very sexily walked over to him and did her best stripper impression, smoothly straddling him. They started kissing passionately, but she kept looking over at me as they were doing it. The looks were making me go totally wild. I was rubbing my cock through my pants. Eventually she stopped kissing him and said “it’s the guests turn now” she got down on the floor and crawled over to my chair. I told her to take out my cock, but she was way ahead of me and pretty soon I was getting a nice, slow passionate cocksucking, lots of eye contact…I had already been hard, but now I was super fucking hard. As she was sucking me she was kind of wagging her ass a little bit– I took that to mean she wanted bf to start fucking her. I looked over at him and he had his dick out, but it was just a taffy pull–I think dude had too much to drink. she looked over at him to, to see the situation, but I really didn’t want us to get too distracted. I pulled her up off the ground and sat her on my lap and said “why don’t you give us a show?” She was sitting on my belly, with my cock kind of wedged in her ass crack. I lifted her up and let her guide me in… she was so fucking wet. There was just the littlest bit of resistance before she sank down my shaft and started to ride me.

she took my “show” comment very literally, and she did all the work, grinding, writhing, moaning. She kept saying my name over and over. I spun her around so she could face bf, who still was jacking off. It didn’t take long for her to wear herself out. I picked her up and put her on the couch with the bf and I took her from behind. I was being pretty rough with her, man handling her and shaking her a lot. I grabbed a fistful of her hair and directed her head toward bf’s crotch and he got up on his knees and started to fuck her mouth… but he kept falling out. eventually he just sat back and watched.

Eventually I said I was going to cum and where did she want it. All she did in response was start fucking me back and moaning even more. I did what any guy would do in that situation and came in her. I collapsed on top of her. The bf said he was going to get another drink. While he was gone, E quickly stood up and took me by the hand and led me to the bedroom and shut the door. She apologized over and over about her bf (as though I really wanted the threesome and not just her!) I told her I didn’t give a single shit about him and that I was glad we finally hooked up. We got into bed, cuddled a little, and then we literally spent the rest of the night fucking until dawn. An amazing night.

We sort of dated for a little bit after that. We would just hang out and hook up. She complained a lot about her boyfriend, and eventually they broke up, and I’m almost positive our “threesome” was the main catalyst for it.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/9p00qz/the_only_threesome_mmf_ive_31m_had_wasnt_really_a