I think I was a unicorn for a couple when I was in college [FMF]

It was sophomore year of college, roughly 14 years ago, apparently my sluttiest year (check my post history and read the only other story I’ve ever shared). My fuckbuddy at the time was Jim. He lived off campus, and would sometimes visit me in my dorm room. We would have amazing sex on my Twin XL bed (remember buying sheets in college? Does Twin XL even exist anywhere else?) Sometimes, after class, I would drive to his house off campus and I would be his little sex slave for a bit. The reason I couldn’t get enough of Jim is that he had an incredible body. He loved to work out and was pretty built, and he was hot. And he knew it. He was always dominant in bed and he loved treating me like the little slut that I am. He had a sort of mental hold over me, too. He had me mindfucked and I knew it, but I didn’t care because I loved pleasing him.

The other thing about Jim is that he had a girlfriend who lived with him. She would always be at work when I came over….except for this one time……..

Jim asked that I come by after class. When I got to his house, we immediately couldn’t keep our hands off each other. I’m a good whore, horny all the time. We stripped each other naked and went to the bedroom, where I climbed on top of his thick meaty cock. He pounded away while I rode him, my juices slick all over. He spanked my ass and made me cry out. He fucked me hard until he came. After he released his load of cum inside me, we went to go take a shower.

He had a very small shower, barely big enough for one person, but it was still fun to squeeze in there together and get all wet and soapy. We washed each other while making out some more, and when we got out of course I was already thinking about when I’d get more of his cock. My pussy was all wet. We both got dressed, though, because I figured his girlfriend would be home shortly, and I was going to leave. Right as I was finished getting dressed, however, he looked me in the eye and said, “Huh. Would you look at that. Lisa is home early.”

I looked out the window, and sure enough, Jim’s girlfriend Lisa had pulled in the driveway and was getting out of her car. My heart started racing so fast I nearly collapsed. “Holy shit holy shit,” I thought to myself. I looked at Jim, who was smirking. He said, “It’s OK, why don’t you meet her, I think she will like you.” At this point, I had an inkling that something very exciting and new for me was about to take place.

Lisa walked in the door. She was petite like me, with small tits. Unlike me, she had short brown hair. She was very pretty. Jim introduced us, and she immediately offered me a drink. I liked her. I had a vodka and orange juice (to this day, screwdrivers remind me of this experience), and we started chatting. I have no clue what we talked about, because the whole time I was looking her up and down and thinking, “I think Jim is going to fuck both of us. I think I’m going to hook up with a girl for the first time. I think I’m going to like this.”

Suddenly she gets up to “go change”. When she comes back, she has no shirt on. Instead she is holding a red bandana folded in half like a triangle up against her chest, hiding her tits. She asks Jim to tie it around her, like a shirt. This should give you an idea of how small she was. She could literally wear a bandana around her torso and be able to tie it in the back, although just barely. Jim helped her out with this, but it was sort of hard to tie, and it didn’t last long. The bandana came down and I was treated to seeing her perfect small tits. I’d never been with a girl before, but I wanted to touch them and play with them. I was incredibly turned on by the idea of pleasing Jim like this.

Jim goes to the bedroom, leaving his topless girlfriend with drunk and horny me. Lisa takes my hand and says, “Here’s what I think we should do. Let’s make him lie back on the bed while we start making out over him. Let’s force him to jerk off.” This idea turned me on so much I can’t even explain. We go to the bedroom and Jim was already lying naked, on his back on the bed. I realized in that moment that this whole scenario was completely planned deviously in advance by Jim and Lisa. She knew that I fucked her boyfriend on the regular and she wanted to get me in this situation. It was no accident that I was at their house when she came home from work early.

With a dripping pussy, I climbed onto the bed with Lisa. We start making out over him, just like she had suggested. I was buzzed from my drink, but I’ll never forget how exciting it was to kiss a girl for the first time. Jim started to touch his cock, as Lisa had predicted, but she stopped him. We both started kissing Jim’s hard, muscular chest up and down. Honestly, I was just following her lead. Slowly, we both make our way down to Jim’s throbbing cock, which was standing straight up at attention. She licked one side while I licked the other. It was so unbelievably hot to suck a dick with another girl.

Next, Lisa said, “I have an idea” as she reached for the drawer in their bedside table. I was a little nervous. She pulled out some strawberry flavored lube or oil or something, I’m still not really sure what it was. She squeezed it all over Jim’s chest, and told me that we were both going to lick it off. I eagerly obliged. We licked the flavored goo off of Jim’s chest together. It tasted…..like chemicals. Not good. But in that moment I would have sucked anchovy paste off of the both of them; I was so horny. Together our tongues worked his whole upper body up and down as he moaned out. I imagine it feels pretty good to have two horny girls with their tongues all over you.

The next thing I know, Lisa had removed her bottoms and had climbed on top of Jim’s face. She was facing me. She straddled Jim’s mouth as he started to lick her naked pussy. My own pussy was gushing, so I did what I am best at: I shimmied down to suck Jim’s cock. He moaned loudly into Lisa’s pussy as he felt my wet mouth grip his big dick. I took him deep into my throat as he pleasured his girlfriend. All I could think about in that moment was making him feel good…I sucked him as best as I could, moving my mouth up and down while flicking my expert tongue. I heard him moaning, which also made Lisa cry out. Suddenly, I felt the familiar, delicious salty taste explode in my mouth. Jim came hard. I swallowed his load, as I always do. I love having cum in my mouth and down my throat…I just love it so much.

All of a sudden, Lisa is angry. She is upset that Jim didn’t warn her before he came. She is mad that I got all of his cum and she got none. I think I said something friendly, but honestly I was thinking about how lucky I was that I didn’t have to share his cum. I had it all to myself. I was the one that made him cum. I had earned it.

She wasn’t actually mad in reality, but I don’t think that she had an orgasm right then. Instead, we all got dressed. We chatted for a bit as I realized that this visit from me should be ending. I wished that Lisa and I had both gotten fucked by Jim, but I thought that maybe this was something I could hope for from my next visit. I made myself cum over and over in my dorm room thinking about this encounter.

I visited Lisa and Jim once more, but it wasn’t as eventful as my first rendez-vous with the two of them.

Now, I am married, but I still wish I could have some fun experiences like this! I’m sure my husband would be on board ;)

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/94gfgh/i_think_i_was_a_unicorn_for_a_couple_when_i_was