So my fiance and I went to a bar to watch some games last night with a friend from work that she just met. Well call them "the fiance" and "the friend". So for background the fiance is about 5'6'' 120 lbs, athletic, and brown hair. The friend is probably about the same height 100 lbs, blonde, and has a tight body. We grabbed drinks, food, and chatted. During which the friend revealed that she was bi and was more into girls than guys. Nothing else was really memorable from the bar, except the steak quesadilla which was phenomenal.
Post game the fiance and I decided that we were going to head home, and the friend was thinking about meeting some friends out. The friend and I were fairly intoxicated, but the fiance (who doesn't drink much normally) was maybe only a few drinks in over the course of the night. So the fiance and I decided that we would drive the friend over to meet up with her friends and we made the walk back to our apartment to grab my car. Standing in the garage the friend hadn't solidified plans yet and kind of hinted at coming up to the apt. I'm not sure the fiance noticed the hint, and not wanting to stand in the garage all night I took charge and decided that we were going up to the apartment. Walking up the stairs the fiance was in front, the friend in the middle, and myself holding up the rear. I'm not sure how it came up, but the friend said that she liked the view. The view was the fiances ass in yoga pants. I'm pretty sure the fiance heard this comment. To which I replied agreeing that I liked the view as well.
We got to the apt. made small talk, it looked like the plans that the friend made were falling through, so we started talking about taking her home. I think at one point I was like ok so what should we do, and the friend suggests we do a round of shots. Done. I was sitting on the couch, the fiance was standing up a few feet away and the friend was somewhere in between us. The friend goes over to put her glass on the table by the fiance and puts her hand on her hip. It was that hand on the hip move that tipped me off that something was about to happen. The friend then kissed the fiance, who was visibly taken aback and didn't really seem too into it. On the couch witnessing this all happen I knew I had to do something or this would be over before it started. So I kind of motioned for the fiance to come sit next to me and started kissing her, she seemed like she was into kissing me. I think the friend noticed this too and she started to come over. Now this couch is actually a fairly small love seat and there wouldn't have been room for the friend. So she comes over and straddles the fiance. They start kissing again and the fiance was still very hesitant. Whenever I noticed she was a hesitant I started kissing her, otherwise I sat back and watched them kiss.. I was drunk.. seemed like a good idea at the time.
Next the friend slips the sundress that she had on over her head. Wow.. she had a fantastic body. The fiance was definitely taken aback by this but they started kissing again. I'm next to them now watching this all go down with my left arm around the fiance and my right hand running over the friends back and ass. The friends body was very tight and she has a fantastic ass. Her boobs were in a nice little pushup bra which I really wanted to take off. Somewhere down the line the friend too off the fiances hoodie and pulled up her sports bra. The friend and I are now alternating between kissing the fiance and when I'm kissing her the friend is kissing her neck, boobs, and putting her lips right next to ours. I fiddled with the strap of the friends bra for a second in a bit of a suggestive way, to which she took it off. She had amazingly perky b's that fit her tight little body perfectly. At this point she's holding herself up with one hand on the back of the couch, kissing the fiance, and she starts touching herself over her underwear and is now grinding a bit and moaning. The fiance is definitely a bit hesitant still, but she is still kissing the friend and seems into it… At some point the friend leans over and kisses me, I'm definitely into it, she's hot, I'm drunk… Next – I get a look of death from the fiance.. Daggers… She is not upset that I'm kissing another girl. Shit. In retrospect this was the beginning of the end. Ok we agree that we won't kiss…
They're kissing, the fiance and I are kissing, the friend is getting herself off on my fiances lap. I had been touching the friend's ass, back, and thighs all along. But I grabbed her boob as she was moaning and kissing the fiance. It was firm, just like the rest of her body, and I really wanted to put my mouth on them. But then the fiance noticed and again got upset that I was touching her. We agreed that I was not to touch or kiss.. ok…. fuck. For the next 10-20 minutes I sat next to them as we alternated between kissing my fiance and playing with her boobs. Her sports bra is pulled up and her yoga pants are getting pulled down by the friend. They both looked hot as their tight bodies pressed together, at this point I'm rock hard. Then as the friend tries to take off the fiances yoga pants the fiance hit her limits. She said she wasn't comfortable doing anymore. She said something about trying again some other time. The friend didn't like that comment. They kiss a little more. The friend puts her bra back on and is sitting on the couch. She looks hot.. Fuck.. The friend said sorry for making the fiance uncomfortable with me and was really into my fiance and wanted to "make her cum". Now it had been slowly going downhill, but at this point I knew it was over. We chatted. The fiance put her cloths on and gave the friend a t shirt to wear. The friend put the t shirt on and still had her underwear on. As a guy, thats so sexy… I'm still turned on. But we leave off on maybe "trying again sometime" and the friend decides to sleep on the couch and the fiance and I take the bed.
Fast forward to the morning. The friend takes a cab home before the fiance and I wake up. When we wake up its awkward as fuck. She said she likes the friend but isn't sexually attracted to her. Fuck. How can you not be sexually attracted to this girl..? So fast forward a few more hours, still awkward as fuck between the fiance and I. We haven't carried on a full conversation (besides the not attracted to the hot blonde friend convo) and have talked about what were doing today and how we both enjoy the new kind of toilet paper that we bought. I'm not even kidding… Its fucking thunder storming out right now or else I would have headed to the golf course a long time ago.
Hope you enjoyed the story. Let me know if you have any advice/questions.
Edit – Paragraphs :-)
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/3jvhpf/my_ffirst_almost_threesome
Paragraphs. Use them!
Wow. We hoped it would work out as badly as you did.
She is *not* upset?? (After "daggers") I don’t think that’s what you meant.