So I wrote up part I of this story ages ago about my first MFM threesome from Craigslist, but I never finished it. Here is is below, and the first part is here: https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/z01t19/my_first_craiglist_threesome_pt_i_fmm/.
I hope you enjoy the ending!
—
After Max arrived, he and James pulled me off the bed. For a minute I was sandwiched between them–both of them tall, muscular men, much bigger than me. I’m not short, but I’m thin. They both took a second to kiss me, then pushed me down to the floor on my knees so I could take turns sucking their cocks.
Both of them had large dicks, and I had to work to get them fully in my mouth and down my throat. To my delight, after I slid Max’s cock into my mouth while playing with James’ cock with a free hand as I kneeled between them, Max moaned and told James he had been right about my oral skills (James and I had hooked up before this, in the planning stages of the threesome. Had to make sure we vibed, after all. Later, driving me to our next threesome, Max told me that he and James both raved about my mouth afterwards and said I was like some sort of slutty vacuum, which is a surefire way to get me to suck your cock again–I love a good compliment).
After I spent a few minutes kneeling and gagging on their cocks as I sucked and jerked them, they both pulled me back onto the bed and positioned me on all fours. They took turns fucking my mouth and my pussy. They both had incredible stamina, and were aggressively using my body, grabbing my hair and slapping my ass, leaving red marks and making me moan. My skin marks up easily, and later once I was home, I got wet all over again seeing the hand prints they both left on my ass.
We developed a rhythm each time they switched places: as one drove deep into my pussy I’d be pushed forward to take as much cock into my mouth as I could, moaning at the feeling of getting fucked roughly from both ends and sometimes gagging a little. They wore condoms to fuck me but took them off when I sucked their cocks, and I could taste their precum. The cock in my mouth would quickly become slick with saliva as I struggled to balance breathing with deep throating. Both had dicks that were at least 7 inches, possibly 8, and thick. They filled me up and I had to work to get them in my mouth and down my throat, choking a little as each man took turns to fuck my mouth. My pussy felt stretched each time they changed places; it’d be suddenly empty until the other cock would thrust deep into me, making me moan and squirm each time. At first I was using my hand to help guide the cocks in and out of my mouth, doing my best to suck and flick at the head before taking it all in my mouth again until the last time they changed positions, when Max just pushed my hands aside and literally started to just my mouth. He moaned as he used me, and James paused, dick still deep inside my pussy, to watch me take Max’s cock down my throat.
Eventually, James pulled out and signaled to Max. James then laid down on the bed and had me straddle him, sliding his cock inside me and completing filling my pussy. I leaned forward and moaned as I felt Max’s fingers probe my ass. He tried to slide his cock in, but he wasn’t a small man, and with James’ cock filling my pussy I felt like I was already stuffed beyond belief. James wrapped his arms around me and pulled me down against him, telling me to breathe slowly in and out as Max fingered my ass, gently getting it used to one finger, then two, then three; finally he slowly eased his cock inside as I let out little gasps each time he pushed it a little deeper. When he finally got it all the way in, James high-fived me and complimented me on fulfilling my slutty goal of being fucked by two men at once. I was dripping and utterly stuffed, with the two biggest dicks I had ever seen filling my ass and my pussy. Yet again, we developed a rocking rhythm as they fucked me, back and forth and gradually speeding up until they were just using my holes again and I was moaning and touching myself. It was almost too much sensation and my fingers on my clit weren’t quite enough to get me over the edge with a cock in my ass and a cock in my cunt. Sadly I hadn’t brought my vibrator. Otherwise I am positive I would have utterly exploded on those two cocks. Eventually I gave up on touching myself and just enjoyed being used and filled up; I tried not to yell too loudly but I am not sure I succeeded, considering I moaned and whimpered each time one of them thrust his cock into my ass or pussy as deep as they could go.
Just as it seemed like I wouldn’t be able to take any more, then Max stopped and pulled out of my ass, leaving me suddenly empty. He told James there was one more position he wanted to do, and they gently moved me to the edge of the bed, my arms and head on the ground like I was doing some sort of sex yoga (and in fact, they rolled out a yoga mat so I wouldn’t strain my wrists). My legs and pussy were open and in the air. Max grabbed a new condom and began fucking me in a true porn star pose, helping to prop me up and giving him a perfect view of my pussy as he pushed in and out.
Then he pulled out and slid his strong fingers inside me, working my pussy and my clit. It was almost too much.
“Have you ever squirted?” He asked. “Because this will make you squirt.”
I don’t know if I actually squirted–I was pretty overcome with the what his hands were doing and my body ached from being used for several hours–but I was certainly wetter than I had been probably ever. I came with a sort of shout, and wiggled down to the ground so I was no longer half-standing on my head with my pussy exposed. I was breathing heavily and drenched in sweat, and my clit was swollen, pussy and ass red from getting fucked and slapped and grabbed.
James smiled at me. “All right, how do you want us to finish?”
I knew immediately what I wanted. “Will you both come on my face?”
Quickly, they stood over me, condoms off and jerking as I watched them and opened my mouth. Two hot sprays of come hit my face, some going into my mouth and some dripping onto my chest and my hair. I had just had two random men from Craigslist basically use me like a pornstar. It was awesome.
After a few minutes rest and some Gatorade, I took a shower and Max drove me home after we all shot the shit for a little bit. A few weeks later we ended up doing it all again, and James fucked me a few more times on his own too.
Honestly, they were both super nice dudes who were happy to help a slut get fucked. And boy did I get fucked
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/12fwboy/my_first_craigslist_threesome_pt_ii_mfm