[MF] She only came when I said “I love you…” (on our first date!)

I met Carly online, and we decided to have our first date at a local bar known for their wide variety of beers. We clicked immediately, and were laughing and flirting throughout the night. She was tall with thick, long brown hair and large blue eyes- a little like Alison Brie, and totally my type.
When the timing felt right, I walked her back to her car. I went in for a hug, which turned into a kiss, which quickly became furious making out, her back against her car door. A couple walking by wolf-whistled at us, and we laughed.

Carly asked if I was parked nearby, and I explained that I’d walked. She invited me over for a “nightcap.” Now I’ve got to admit, I’ve never really known what a nightcap is, but I had a feeling it didn’t matter.

Carly drove me to her apartment, and even on the walk from the car to her door we kept stopping to kiss and feel each other’s bodies. She had this tight little body, firm belly and small but round boobs. Her butt was extremely perky, and I ran my hands over her jeans and gave her a squeeze. She smiled and kissed me deeper.

We didn’t bother with a nightcap. I didn’t even get a tour of her apartment. Our clothes came off quickly, and we kissed our way to her small bedroom.

Carly was wearing a lacy pink bra and panties. I kissed my way down her long neck and over her smooth, pale shoulders, unclasping her bra and freeing her amazing round breasts. She had large, pink nipples that I absolutely worshipped with my lips and tongue. I continued to kiss down her belly and hooked her panties with my fingers, slowly pulling them down and chasing them with my kisses. Carly’s pussy was completely shaved, and pink and glistening and just delicious looking.

I grabbed Carly by the hips and lowered her to the bed, spread her knees, and started exploring. I kissed up and down her thighs, teasing her pussy lips with just brief kisses. Then I dove in. Carly had one of those wonderful pussies that just tastes terrific and responds so well to every touch and tease. She was moaning, writhing on he bed, her hands grabbing at the sheets.

But I couldn’t make her cum.

Eventually she pulled me up on top of her and we kissed, her pussy juices mixing with my saliva. Her hands were on my cock, stroking it, getting it nice and hard. She fished around in her bedside table for a condom and slipped it onto me.

I lifted Carly’s legs to my shoulders and teased her pussy with the head of my cock, running it up and down her lips. Laughing, Carly grabbed my cock and slid it into her pussy. She moaned with pleasure as I fucked her slowly, and I enjoyed feeling her tight, wet pussy swallow every inch of my shaft.
I rubbed Carly’s clit as I fucked her, and a blush spread over her breasts, neck, and face. She told me how good that felt as I started to fuck her harder. Carly pinched her nipples and squeezed her breasts. It was honestly hard for me to hold back, seeing this beautiful woman in such a state of ecstasy before me.

I turned Carly over onto her knees and massaged her ass, kissing down her back. I entered her from behind, and started to fuck her harder and harder, responding to her moans of pleasure. I was slapping against her ass hard, her cheeks turning red.

Carly slid down onto her belly and I straddled her, continuing to fuck her. Now this is my absolutely favorite position, and usually my finisher. I cannot last long at all like this, it just feels too good, and I love to see her boobs squished up under her, her ass right there in front of me. I was playing with Carly’s ass cheeks, spreading them apart, my eyes on her rosy little asshole. Her arms were up around her thick, dark hair, which was spread out on he pillow. Her eyes were closed, her face blushed red, and she moaned and panted with each thrust.

Knowing I wasn’t going to last long, I paused and lowered my face to Carly’s ear. I kissed and licked her ear, then whispered, “I want to make you cum.”

Carly smiled and gave me what I can only describe as a crazy look. Her blue eyes seemed to glow.

“Tell me you love me,” she said.

I asked her to repeat that.

“You don’t have to mean it. I just can’t cum unless I hear it. Tell me you love me.”

Now this was our first date! I thought Carly was sexy as hell, funny and fun to hang out with, and a great kisser. But love???

On the other hand, I was balls-deep in her beautiful, tight pussy, and I figured this wasn’t too far from roleplaying.

I started to fuck her again, slowly, trying to keep from cumming. I whispered, my lips close to her ear, “I love you.”

Carly moaned and shuddered. I saw her slip a hand under her body and start rubbing her clit.

“Say it again,” she said.

I sat up and started fucking her harder, riding her from behind. I ran my hands down her back and over her ass cheeks.

“I love you.”

Carly gasped, her hips writhing. I could tell she was close.

“I fucking love you!” I almost shouted.

Carly moaned loudly. I could feel her pussy squeezing my cock. I spread her ass cheeks and thrust as deeply as I could.

“I’m cummmmmming,” Carly groaned.

“Oh god, me too,” I said.

We came together, and I collapsed next to Carly, holding her in my arms. We laughed, and kissed some more, then settled down, spooning.

…

Carly and I went on a few dates after that, and slept together a few more times. Every time we did, she couldn’t cum unless I said I loved her. We didn’t last long enough for me to find out what it was all about, but I’ve got to admit it was pretty hot! Sometimes when I’m masturbating, I think about Carly, and how crazy it felt to tell her that I loved her as I fucked her on that first date. I always cum hard when I remember it, just as we both did that night.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/10lakn5/mf_she_only_came_when_i_said_i_love_you_on_our