Part 2 [here.](https://old.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/10ao1tm/hooked_up_with_a_girl_from_craigslist_pt_2_more/?ref=share&ref_source=link)
I made it back home pretty frustrated, really. Things with Mandy did not go as I hoped, and in the confusion at the end of the night I didn’t even get her friends’ name or number that I made out with. I didn’t really know what I had with Mandy, but whatever it was, it was gone now.
I turned on the tv and started dozing off as it was about 2 am, when I heard a knock at the door. Bewildered, I opened it to find Mandy. Her car was in my driveway, so it was obvious she was an idiot and drove drunk to my place. She had her head tilted slightly and was biting her lip looking at me.
“Hey, I’m sorry about all that back there. I get a little carried away when I drink. I didn’t want to drive back to my place, is it ok if I stay here tonight?”
I invited her in. Still not sure what she was thinking, I told her I’d sleep on the couch and she could sleep in my bed.
“Oh, that won’t be necessary. I’m needing something a bit more tonight from you.”
She pulled me into my bedroom and shut the door. We began furiously making out with all of our clothes flying off. In less than a minute, we were naked and I was kissing down her neck to her tits. This was quickly about the farthest I’ve gone with her, as she hadn’t let me “south of the border” before. While sucking on her tits, my hand started creeping down without any resistance.
My hand kept moving down to her clit. I could feel the warmth radiating from her as she immediately spread her legs to welcome my fingers. I started teasing her clit, rubbing it in circles while sucking on her tits. She arched her back in pleasure and let out a small moan.
“Finger me,” she whimpered. “Please.”
Without hesitating, I pushed my middle finger inside her. I was surprised how tight she felt just around my finger and wondered if I would have to go easy on her later. After she stretched out a little, I put a second finger in, her moans getting louder and her pussy getting messier.
After fingering her for a while, I pulled them out and shoved them in her mouth. She greedily sucked her juices off of them before shifting positions, sitting on my face in the 69 position so she could suck my cock. I’m always in heaven in this position, eating pussy is my favorite and it’s so hot having a girl squat down over your face. I grabbed her hips and pulled her pussy down to where my tongue could give it a good fucking, making sure to give her clit plenty of attention too.
I noticed she wasn’t as good at sucking dick from this angle, but figured she was a little more distracted than normal. Plus, I didn’t want to cum yet, so I was fine. Soon though, I could feel her pussy contracting. She went silent, almost like she stopped breathing, while I sped up the movements with my tongue. Her whole body was like a statue, before all the tension released at once.
“Fffffuuuuuuccccckkkkkkkkkk” she yelled, as her whole body convulsed. This was one of the hottest orgasms I’ve ever seen. She rolled off of me and sort of curled up into the fetal position. I could not get enough of her pussy though and before she could react, I pushed her legs apart and started eating her out again.
“OH MY GOD, OH FUCK OH FUCK” she started screaming. I started fingering her while licking her clit, her pussy gushing every time I pushed them in. I wanted her to cum again and I wasn’t going to stop until it happened. Soon, she was clenching my hair hard as her whole body tensed again. I knew the routine and kept going until she let out a guttural “uhhhhhhhh” and felt her body relax.
I decided to give her a little break if she needed but she quickly pulled my face up to hers and made out with me, hungrily tasting herself on my tongue. With one hand, she grabbed my cock and guided it to her entrance. Without breaking the kiss, I immediately pushed it inside her.
She yelped with surprise. I was fully inside her and let it stay there for a bit, fully feeling the grasp of her pussy lips. I knew I wouldn’t be able to last long but thankfully I had given her two orgasms prior. I fucked her in missionary for a while, trying to keep my thoughts away from how amazing this all was. Watching her eyes roll back, hearing her yell, and watching her tits bounce all soon became too much though.
I quickly pulled out and flipped her around. If I was going to cum, I wanted to watch her ass bounce while I fucked her. Before fucking her again, I admired the view of her face down, ass up, her pussy glistening and inviting. I started getting lined up when she interrupted.
“Fuck my ass, baby, please. No one has ever fucked my ass before. I need your cock in my ass, please baby.”
I went and grabbed some lube from my drawer, although my dick was already absolutely soaked. I was a little apprehensive here, as my cock is above average in size and the few other times I’ve tried, the girls had tapped out pretty early. Still, I wasn’t going to crush Mandy’s hopes.
After getting lubed up, I lined up and very slowly started pushing inside her virgin asshole. I thought her pussy was tight, but holy shit this was something else. She grunted and groaned as she slowly took my cock inch by inch. I had to hand it to her, Mandy was a trooper.
“Fuck yes, destroy my asshole daddy!” she cried out. I started fucking her faster, the squelches of the lube and her juices speeding up in time with my thrusts. I had a firm grip on her hips, unable to let go as I focused on not cumming. It was a hopeless battle though, and I could soon feel it building up.
“Oh fuck Mandy, I’m gonna cum. I’m gonna cum.”
“Yes daddy, cum in my ass. Cum in my tight little asshole daddy.”
Her saying that pushed me over the edge, as I sprayed rope after rope inside her, continuing to fuck her until every drop had been released. I pulled out, watching my cum slowly leak out of her asshole.
“Holy fuck,” I said.
At this point it was almost 4 am and we quickly took a shower and passed out soon after. We woke up naked and soon she rode me until I got to cum inside her pussy.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/10cc242/hooked_up_with_a_girl_from_craigslist_part_3_mf