[M] Straight guy but had a rather gay experience

**TL;DR:** Jerked off to some porn with two other guys. We shared a fleshlight and I got sloppy thirds.

This happened last week. So I consider myself to be straight or at least mostly straight I guess. I like women, not really interested in men. However I’m open to doing stuff with men if there’s no touching, a woman is involved, etc. Also not gonna lie I can appreciate a nice cock but that’s about it lol…

One fantasy I had for a while was jerking off with other people and finally I thought fuck it, let’s try it for real. I went to my city’s subreddit and made a post about looking for girls or guys for group masturbation. As expected I got a bunch of messages from guys and none from girls, just how it is I guess.

After talking with some of the guys, I narrowed down two I thought I could do this with. Let’s give them made up names, Steve and Jim. Both were about my age, early 20s. Steve said he was straight but Jim was bi. I went over my idea, how they’d come over, we’d sit down, put on some porn, and just jerk. No touching and leave when you’re finished. They agreed so then I was just waiting for them to arrive.

Eventually both of them came to my place and at first it was kinda awkward and I think we were all a bit nervous so we decided to just get to it. We sat down on the couch and I got on my laptop which was connected to the tv. I also put some lube and a box of tissues on the coffee table in front of us. An interesting and important thing is Steve actually brought a fleshlight with him but we’ll get to that…

Anyway I pulled up pornhub and asked if there was anything they wanted to watch. Jim suggested an Eva Elfie video and we picked one that looked good. The video started and we took our pants off. Jim was already hard but it took Steve and I a minute. We all exchanged an awkward chuckle and then just started jerking off. We all tried to focus on the video but we definitely glanced at each other’s cocks at least once. It couldn’t be helped. Jim and Steve were both pretty average and about the same size. I was a little embarrassed to be smaller than than but tried not to think about it. Unlike Steve, Jim and I were both uncut.

So yeah there’s the three of us jerking off to Eva Elfie’s tight little body getting fucked and it’s pretty hot. Eventually Steve starts using his fleshlight after lubing up. Then the kinda crazy thing that happens is Jim asks if he can use it. Steve doesn’t really hesitate to hand it over. I watch Jim using Steve’s fleshlight and want to try it too. After I bit I ask for it and Jim hands it to me. I got so turned on putting my dick where theirs had just been.

We continued sharing the toy, swapping it between us every few strokes. Steve came in it first. Then Jim grabbed it from him and fucked it until he came too. He then gave me a look sorta asking if I wanted it too. I took the fleshlight and put my dick in and it felt so fucking good feeling their hot cum on my cock. I couldn’t help it and came instantly, filling up the fleshlight. When I pulled it off all of our mixed loads spilled onto my crotch and balls.

We then got cleaned up and I let Steve use the bathroom to clean his fleshlight. The boys left and I sat there going over it all in my head. We later messaged each other saying it was fun. I think we might do it again… Kinda over labels for my sexuality. I’m just gonna enjoy the things I find hot and not think about it too much.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/y4yzm6/m_straight_guy_but_had_a_rather_gay_experience