[M]y nerdy [F]WB and me put on a show (Part 5 of my saga with Beth)

If you haven’t kept up with the previous accounts of my time with Beth, the previous one is [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/xn4jwi/how_my_nerdy_fwb_and_i_reconnected_part_4_of_my/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf).
So after the incident with Steven led to mind-blowing sex with Beth, we fell asleep. It was the most peaceful sleep I’d had in a long time, laying next to her totally happy and content. It must have been late the next morning when we woke up with bright sun already peeking around the edges of the curtains in her room. I rolled over next to Beth as she was starting to stir, and I ran my hand lightly across her stomach and just brushed her nipples. “Mmmmm…good morning,” she said as she stretched her legs and arms out. I took that as an invitation to play with her nipples more deliberately. “Good morning indeed,” I replied and kissed her on the cheek. Beth rolled onto her side to face me and put an arm across my side as I slid my hand down to cup her ass.
“That was amazing last night,” I said. Beth smiled at me and moved her hand up to run her fingers through my hair. She moved in for a deep kiss, tongue swirling into my mouth. I pulled her closer to me as I felt my cock start to stiffen. She pulled back and said, “yes it was,” as I slid down to take her nipple into my mouth. I swirled my tongue around it and sucked as she moaned softly. She reached down, taking my cock in her hand as it thickened and stiffened fully, and she stroked slowly.
There was a noise in the kitchen. Dishes rattling in the sink, cupboards opening and closing loudly. Heavy footsteps. Beth stopped stroking and said, “Laura’s awake.”
I looked at Beth and said, “and…?”
“I should go check on her,” she replied. “She was really upset with Steven, obviously. That fucking pig.”
As much as I wanted Round 4, I knew Beth was right. “Yeah, go see how she’s doing,” I said. “I’ll stay here.”
Beth got up and threw on some short shorts and an oversized t-shirt, pulling her hair back into a tie. Damn, her ass looked good in those shorts, and her nipples were poking out of the shirt. She saw me staring, gave me a sly grin and a wink, then walked out into the kitchen.
I laid there for a while, waiting for Beth to come back to bed. I could hear them talking, a bit of Laura crying, and Beth’s voice saying what sounded like all the things Laura needed to hear. I couldn’t make out all the words, but I did hear my name mentioned a couple of times. Probably she was explaining how I showed Steven the door. A little while was turning into a long while, and it became clear this wasn’t going to be a short conversation between the girls. I got up and threw on my clothes, borrowed a baseball cap from Beth’s closet, and quietly walked out. The girls were sitting in the kitchen. Laura’s head was down but I could see her red puffy eyes. I exchanged a look with Beth to indicate I’d catch up later, and she slightly nodded back as I crept out the door to their apartment.
It was a couple of days before I saw Beth again before class. She told me how she and Laura talked it out about Steven, how even though Laura wasn’t totally into him, she still felt bad about how things went down. Apparently when Steven came over that night, Laura told him she wanted to take it slow, but Steven had other things in mind. He called her awful names – slut, whore, cunt – and told her to shut up and take his cock. That led to their verbal argument, and when he grabbed her and tried to push her down onto the couch, that’s when Laura slapped him. Beth did tell Laura about what happened after she ran into her room, both what Steven said to Beth and my throat-slamming him after that. She said Laura was fine now, and they both agreed that Steven wasn’t likely to come around any more.
Beth and I met up for coffee later that day. We talked about our classes, going home for winter break, and other mundane topics. But its was really nice to just have a conversation, we enjoyed each others’ company. But I had to bring up the question that had been hanging in the air. “So, I really enjoy all our time together,” I said.
Beth grinned at me. “So do I,” she said.
“And I want to keep doing that,” I continued.
She deepened her voice with a dirty look in her eyes. “So do I,” she said more suggestively.
“What are we now?” I dared to ask. That changed the mood.
So we had That Talk. I was really into her, and she was into me. We were both interested to continue our relationship and to be exclusive sexually. But Beth explained how she didn’t want to label our relationship, just to be friends who slept together. (FWB wasn’t actually a common term yet). She said she just really needed to stay focused on school and wanted to get an internship for the next summer, and she didn’t want either of us to feel the obligations of being an official “couple.” I was a bit disappointed, but in the end I agreed with her. After all, the last thing I wanted was to ruin what had become a very good thing.
So we continued on like this for a while. We got together a lot and hung out together and in groups of friends, staying over at my place or hers most weekends, fucking like rabbits and enjoying it all.
A few weeks later, Beth was coming over to my place and called me up. “Hey, David’s single, right?” David was my roommate.
“Yeah, why?” I asked.
Beth wanted Laura to get out and start seeing guys again. She hadn’t really been doing that since Steven, and she thought it would be good for Laura to hang out with us and David. He was a super nice guy, always respectful of women, kind of the anti-Steven, and Beth figured that even if nothing happened between them, he might restore Laura’s trust in men. I agreed and thought it was a great idea.
We set it up. David agreed – he’d always thought Laura was nice and didn’t have any plans. We were just going to order pizza and watch movies at our place. Laura had club soccer right before, but she said she’d come over straight from there. Beth came over around 7:30 with a couple of DVDs and the pizza, which she stuck in the oven to keep warm. She and I were sitting next to each other on the couch with David on the other end of the couch. We were talking and having a couple of beers when Laura rang the doorbell. “Hey,” Laura said when I answered. She seemed in a good mood.
“How are you?” I asked her.
“I’m good, thanks. I appreciate you guys inviting me over, it’s about time I start hanging out with my friends again.”
“Good,” I said, as David came over.
“Hey,” he said, “how was the soccer game?” They chatted about soccer and made small talk for a minute. Laura and David had met each other before but hadn’t really hung out much. They seemed to hit it off right away.
“I’m sorry to ask this, but I’m kind of sweaty from the game,” Laura said. “Do you mind if I hop in the shower real quick?” No problem, of course. Laura knew that Beth kept some toiletries and extra clothes at my place. She went off to the bathroom to clean up. “Go ahead and start the first movie without me,” she offered.
We started to watch, Beth and me nestled together on our spot with David on the other end. It felt good to have everyone in a happy mood. Beth leaned her head onto my shoulder and held my hand with hers. She ran her other hand through my hair, which she knew drives my crazy. Pretty soon, I was sporting a semi, and Beth noticed the bulge. Without saying anything she moved her hand over to my dick and started rubbing it through my jeans. I immediately got fully hard. “Dude,” I said to her, “David’s right there.”
She just whispered, “shhh….,” as she continued slowly rubbing my cock. I turned and kissed her; I could see David still staring at the movie. With my arm around her, I moved my hand to her right breast and squeezed while I rolled her nipple between my fingers. Beth had a way of making me lose track of everything around me. I was so ready to go; all I wanted was to take her to bed and fuck her senseless.
“Should we go to my room?” I whispered.
“Just stay here,” she said. Laura came out of the bathroom wearing Beth’s tight shorts and oversized t-shirt, her hair only towel-dried. With her long tan legs and perky B-cups, she looked so hot. David noticed too.
“That feels so much better,” Laura said. She caught sight of my bulge and Beth’s hand on my crotch, and she smirked a little, then plopped down on the couch next to David. “What did I miss?” Laura asked. David filled her in on the first part of the movie, while Beth turned up the heat a notch. She stroked my cock through my jeans, swirling her fingers just up under the tip. I was full-on raging hard.
Beth reached up and unbuttoned my jeans. “Beth…” I protested, but she shushed me again. She slid the zipper down and rescued my cock from my pants leg, pulling it up to stroke it through my boxers. I squeezed her nipples some more. From the angle of Beth’s back, I didn’t think Laura and David could see us, but I kissed Beth again to check on our couch-mates. They were watching the movie, talking quietly to each other, giggling to each other here and there. Beth pulled my rigid cock through the fly of my boxers, fully exposing me. She stroked slowly up and down, spending extra time on my frenulum with her thumb. Damn, she knew how to get me going.
I had never done anything overtly sexual in public before. The idea that we were just a foot away from our friends had me really turned on. Beth was stroking faster now. I told her she’d better slow down as I squeezed her nipples harder and went in for another kiss. That was when I noticed Laura and David. She was leaning on his shoulder looking over at us, and he had put his arm around her, his head turned to see as well. Beth leaned back, and my hard cock was in full view now. I panicked a little, unsure what to do. Beth just kept stroking, smiling, happy to put on this show. To my surprise, it was David who broke the silence. “Damn brother,” he said. David and I had seen each other naked before, just by happenstance being roommates and all. But he’d not seen me hard before, and I’m quite the grower.
Laura chuckled and said, “I’ve seen his cock before. Thick, isn’t it?” And to David’s puzzled look, she said, “I’ll explain later.” And I knew that David would get the full story of Laura walking in on me and Beth that first night we got together at the party.
Beth decided to take this further. She knelt down in front of me and wrapped her lips around the head of my cock. She still couldn’t get my girth fully in, but swirled her tongue around it. I could see David’s cock bulging now too, and Laura had reached hand between her thighs to rub her pussy. They were enjoying the show. Laura turned around and looked at David as if to ask him if he wanted to join in. Without saying anything, he unbuttoned his pants as Laura slid around to the front and got on her knees. In one motion, David slid his pants to his ankles as his cock sprang free. “Wow,” said Laura. David’s dick was not as thick as mine, but maybe half an inch longer. And he was rock hard. Laura took him straight into her mouth, swirling and licking and bobbing up and down straight away. I stiffened even more at the sight. David threw his head back and groaned.
Not to be outdone, Beth reached up and pulled my pants down to my ankles, giving her the same access to my cock and balls that Laura had to David’s. She cradled and squeezed my balls while going down as far as she could on my thick cock. Laura was fingering herself with one hand while stroking David’s cock with the other, still sucking like a champ, drool now dripping down David’s balls. Beth stopped sucking my dick to look over at our friends, and she immediately started fingering herself. She stood up and stripped while Laura continued to work David’s cock. I reached up and grabbed Beth’s waist to turn her around, and I sat her on my lap. My cock was sticking up between her thighs as she rubbed it along her slit. With one hand I fingered her clit, while with the other I worked her nipples. We both watched Laura and David go at it, totally absorbed into each other but knowing we were watching them now. Laura stood up and stripped as well. She sat on David’s lap facing him and he immediately took Laura’s breasts to his mouth. He sucked her nipples as she moaned. Laura lifted herself up slightly, reached down with one hand and guided David’s cock into her dripping wet pussy. “Oh my god,” David said as Laura started riding him.
The idea of us all fucking together like this was amazing to me. I could hear the slurping sound of David’s cock as it slid in and out of Laura’s wet hole. I guided Beth forward onto the floor and got behind her on my knees. I slid my cock into her warm, wet pussy and started thrusting. Beth let out a scream, which seemed to send Laura over the edge. She moaned and arched her back, continuing to ride as she came. David started to groan, indicated that he was close, so Laura pulled herself off him and knelt down to stroke his cock. He let out another “oh god” as he exploded hot streams of cum into the air and onto his chest. At the sight of this, Beth’s pussy tightened up and she convulsed, legs shaking as she came hard. That did it for me too, as I felt my orgasm building up. I pulled out of Beth’s dripping cunt an shot my load all over her back.
We all stayed there for a few moments, catching our breath, covered in pussy juice and cum. Beth finally said, “dammit.”
“What?” I asked.
“We left the pizza in the oven. It’s probably ruined.” And we all laughed.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/xtxl6b/my_nerdy_fwb_and_me_put_on_a_show_part_5_of_my