I was 22 when this all happened, a few years ago. I had been dating a girl named Sara for a few months, and it had been going great. We really vibed with each other, and had mind-blowing sex all the time. She was easily the sexiest girl I’d been with up to that point, and I couldn’t keep my hands off her. With her insanely high libido, she couldn’t get enough of me either.
Quick description: Sara was also 22 at the time, and was mixed white/Mexicana, with great light caramel skin. She was about 5’4, athletic tight body. Her thighs were thick and her ass was almost disproportionately big on her frame. Her boobs were on the smaller side, perfect to fit each in my hands. I have always been an ass guy, so her body was literally perfect for me. Me: Paul, I’m 6’1, athletic-type body, 7.5” cock (pic in my profile).
Back to the story: we had been spending our summer working restaurant jobs and partying, as most of us did at that age. When we weren’t working, we were either banging or hanging out with friends, getting lit.
On one of these nights when we were both off work, we went to my friend Jim’s house for a house party. His parents were out of town for the weekend, so the house was ours. There were about 15-20 people there, mostly our friends. It was a great party, filled with drinking games and dancing. Sara had been acting extra flirty with me all night, so I was excited to have her all to myself once the party died down. We planned to stay the night on the pullout couch so we could drink and not worry about driving home.
After a few hours, people started to head out around midnight. I had worked up quite the buzz, and was borderline drunk at that point. So now it was just Sara, myself, Jim, and a girl named Elise. We knew Jim had been hooking up with Elise on and off for a while, so we assumed she would stay over as well. It was just the four of us in the basement now.
Sara, definitely the most outgoing of us, suggested we keep playing drinking games. She suggested we play poker, and the loser would have to drink. We all agreed and started to play. Jim whipped out some whiskey and after a few turns we were all feeling quite drunk.
“Guys, I don’t know if I can keep drinking like this, I’m already wasted,” I told the group.
“Baby, come on, I’m having fun, let’s keep playing!” Sara replied. I could tell she was feeling pretty turnt as well.
“I don’t know babe…I’m wasted right now,”
“Well fine, then why don’t we change the game. Let’s play strip poker instead!” she suggested with a grin. We all looked at each other for a moment, as I don’t think any of us had played strip poker before. Jim was grinning, it seemed like he was down. Elise was blushing next to him, and didn’t seem so enthused.
“That sounds like fun to me, since I’ll definitely win. I wouldn’t mind seeing you girls naked,” Jim said with his grin still on his face.
I looked at Sara and she just raised her eyebrows at me.
“Elise? What do you think? It’ll be funn!” Sara said to Elise, who was still blushing.
“O…kay I guess so.” And so it was agreed to play. This would be fun, I thought. Elise was super sexy, about the same height as Sara, with a tight body. She was a bit skinnier than Sara, blond, with sexy tanned skin. I had definitely fantasized about her a few times.
So we began playing. It was slow-going at first, as most of us just took off a sock or something minor. Then Sara lost her next hand. She immediately stood up and ripped off her shirt, revealing a small black lace bra. She proudly danced around a bit, shaking her boobs for all of us. I saw Jim staring at her boobs, with a mischievous grin on his face. It then hit me that he would likely see my girlfriend naked, which I hadn’t considered before, in my drunken state. I didn’t know how to feel about it, but I was a bit turned on by showing off my sexy girlfriend. She sat down and we continued.
A few hands later, many more clothes were lost. Jim and I were both sitting in our boxers, Sara in her bra and panties, and Elise in her bra and tight shorts. I knew in the next hand or two, someone was getting naked. I was feeling excited and turned on, and I could tell Sara was too. She was throwing out sexy comments, complimenting Jim and Elise on their bodies. I could see Jim sneaking looks at Sara’s almost nude body as she laughed and played the game.
The next hand was out, and Sara lost. She looked at me with a guilty, mischievous look as she stood up once again. She reached behind herself, unclasping her bra, and letting it fall as she kept her boobs covered with her arm and hand. Jim cheered, and Elise sat there laughing. Wow, she was so sexy, I though. She then raised both her arms, letting her boobs fall and showing them off for to see.
“Damn Sara, I knew you had nice boobs, but damn!” Jim exclaimed to her. Elise looked at him and didn’t look to happy. Sara then turned around and twerked her big ass for us, as we watched it bounce around. Now I was turned on, and was sporting a not quite full erection in my boxer briefs. I looked over and could see Jim was enjoying himself as well, with his bulge quite apparent.
“Ok, I don’t think I want to play anymore, I’m going to head home,” Elise stated. We all protested, but she was adamant about leaving, so Jim walked her out, still in his underwear. When they were outside, Sara began to kiss me and rub my cock through my boxers. I had to fuck her right there and then. Then we heard the door open, and we quickly separated. Jim walked in and sat in the same spot.
“Well, should we continue?” he said. We all looked at each other, and I shrugged.
“Yes, I still want to beat you boys!” Sara exclaimed as she shook her boobs for us again. We were both mesmerized for a moment, then Jim and I looked at each other and laughed.
“You’re on!” So we dealt out another hand.
The cards came out and I was the loser this time. Damn, so I would be the first one naked, I thought. I stood up as they both looked at me.
“Sorry guys, I gotta admit I’ve got a boner right now,” I said with my finger in my waistband. I was hesitating, not quite ready to strip down.
“Oh whatever! I can tell Jim is hard as well. Plus I can’t blame you boys after staring at my tits all night.” Sara replied. I saw her looking at Jim bulge, as his hard-on was quite apparent. I’d never seen him naked before, but it seemed like he had a decent sized package.
“Alright then you sickos,” I said as I pulled down my boxers. My dick ripped free, and bounced into the air, sticking straight out. We all shared a laugh and I sat down. The next cards were dealt out. I had pretty good cards luckily. After the last card, Jim had lost.
“Haha, so much for beating me!” Sara taunted at him. He just smiled and stared at her as he stood up, across the table from us. He slowly pulled down his boxers, revealing his dick. I looked at Sara as she watched him enticingly. As his boxers came down, his cock bounced out just like mine had. I heard Sara gasped and I looked back over at him. There he was standing naked, staring right at my girlfriend, with the biggest cock I have still ever seen. This thing was straight out of a porno. I’m definitely no slouch in the cock department, but I felt intimidated looking at his. It looked about 9 inches and thick, with a slight upward curve.
“Holy shit Jim, you could kill someone with that thing!” Sara said, laughing. He stood grinned at us, shaking himself back and forth before sitting down. So now the game seemed to be over, as Sara beat us.
“Well, that’s the game I guess,” I said, trying to put an end to it before anything escalated.
Sara looked at me with puppy-dog eyes, and said, “C’mon babe, I’m still not naked, we can keep playing.”
“Well the two of us are naked, what do we do if we lose?”
“We could play truth or dare for the person who loses. By the winner’s choosing,” Jim suggested. Sara agreed, and I reluctantly agreed as well. The next hand went out, and I lost to Sara.
“Alright babe, rub your dick for us for 20 seconds,” Sara demanded as she was the winner.
“Uhh…I don’t know if want to do that in front of Jim,” I pleaded, not so sure about this.
“She won dude, it’s her call,” Jim said to me, grinning.
“Okay fine, you weirdos,” I gave in. So I sat back and slid me hand up and down my rock-hard cock while they watched. This was a bit weird being watched, but so be honest I hadn’t felt this turned on in a long time. I sped up the pace as Sara clapped her hands. I watched her boob bounce as she clapped, and saw Jim staring too. After about 30 seconds I stopped and sat up.
“That was hot, babe,” Sara said to me, giving me a kiss on my cheek. I could feel myself blushing.
“Okay okay, let’s just play the next hand,” I said. So we drew again. This time Jim lost and I won. This was strange, I didn’t know what to dare him. The three of us were all naked or almost-naked, and I could feel the sexual tension hanging in the air. I had never thought about sharing Sara, but something about the alcohol and energy in the room gave me some courage to push the envelope.
“jim, why don’t smack Sara’s ass a few times,’ I suggested.
“Baby!” Sara exclaimed. She looked at me with a smile, but I could tell she was into it.
“Hey, hey, it’s his choice,” Jim said. He got up and walked over to us on the couch, his cock bouncing as he walked. Sara just stared at it as he walked over. He stood over her and she looked up at him.
“C’mon babe, it’s just an ass smack,” I told her. She looked at me again, looking annoyed, but then turned around the kneel on the couch, sticking her ass way out. In just her thong, she shook it back and forth as the two of us watched. Jim then put his hand out and lightly smacked it once, before pulling his hand back and smacking her a bit harder. Her ass jiggled up and down a few times and he smacked it again. Sara moaned lightly, I could tell she was horny. Jim then stepped forward a bit, grabbed his cock, and smacked it on her ass a few times.
“Hey, that wasn’t in the dare!” Sara yelled at him.
“Well Paul didn’t say what to smack you with,” Jim replied with his shit-eating grin. He proceeded to smack his cock on her ass a few more times, before rubbing his cock head one time quickly up her ass crack.
“Ohh…,” Sara moaned. Jim, happy with himself, then sat down on the couch with us, on the other side of her. Sara flipped back around so sit between us two boys, both sporting erections. She looked at us both and giggled. “Okay, next hand!”
****
This is my first story, feel free to give me pointers. And let me know if you’re interested in a part 2!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/xtgp4i/my_first_threesome_with_my_girlfriend_and_buddy