[MF] I thought I could handle sharing my girlfriend

I’ve got a very pretty, and kind of secretly kinky girlfriend of over three years, Alex. In college, where I met her, guys referred to her as a tease. She’s cute as hell and nice to all the guys, but she almost never hooked up with anyone. But I was lucky enough to start dating her, to the jealousy of a lot of my friends. And I was very surprised to discover that she loved sex more than other girls I’ve been with, basically the opposite of her reputation.

She also confided in me that she’d had a slutty period, it was just mostly with guys off campus, and a few guys at our school smart enough to keep their mouths shut. Initially I was one of those guys, then we became exclusive after about three months.

After college we kept dating, and we both started grad school. We had a very monogamous relationship, so what happened this year was a step in a very different direction. It grew out of our natural desires. Besides our normal (fantastic) sex, she likes to tell me about sex she’s had in the past. And I love to listen. For some reason hearing about how she fucked some guy on a balcony is just a big turn on, especially since with her reputation as a prude. So many guys that have huge crushes on her, and they’d never believe that she had a threesome with two guys from a rival school. But I get to enjoy this slutty side of her, and I love it. It’s become part of our foreplay talk. She tells me about a guy she slept with or gave a blowjob to, while we fool around and then have sex. There’s not a ton of stories, but the ones she has are really hot, and shocking if you know her.

This year a new guy started hanging around our friend group, Jake, and for the first time I felt my relationship threatened.. He’s handsome, charismatic, and energetic, pretty much all the girls have a thing for him. He’s a bit arrogant, but he’s got the physique of a pro athlete so I think he’s able to get away with acting like a jerk more than most men. For some women , it’s kind of a turn on. My girlfriend falls into this group, although it took her forever to admit it.

Alex was completely in denial about being attracted to him, calling him an asshole after he hit on her the first time they met. But as she got to know him I could see her subtly flirting with him, touching his arm and laughing at his jokes, whether they were good or not. After one night where she got drunk and was more obviously flirting with him, I brought him up during our foreplay talk. And she finally admitted to me that she thought he was hot. I asked her if she’d thought of sleeping with him and she said no. This was new territory for us. We’d never talked about her potentially screwing somebody. I knew she was lying, so I pressed her. Eventually I wore her down, and I fingered her while she confessed to me that she’d wanted to fuck him the moment she met him.

The next day she said to me, “So… you wanna talk about this?” in the cutest possible way. We had a very adult discussion. I didn’t actually want her to sleep with him, and she would never cheat on me but we both agreed that talking about it had been the hottest thing we’d done in awhile. It had been somewhat stale in the bedroom. So we kept doing it. I knew I was playing with fire, asking my girlfriend how badly she wanted another guys cock. But it was really, really fun to see her get so worked up thinking about him. And she loved how honest she could be. She could be her pure, sexual self and it was beautiful to see.

We didn’t plan it, but finally one night this summer I think we both just wanted it enough. She had thrown a party and her roommate was out of town. Her ass looked amazing in short jean shorts, and Jake had noticed. He’d been hitting on her all night while he thought I wasn’t looking, to the point where she was practically beating him off. He danced with her and got aggressive. She was just tipsy enough to dance close to him, his hand on her as their bodies bumped together. She played it cool, but I got her alone for a minute after that and her eyes betrayed her dirty secret. She gave me the horniest smile and said, “Jake’s something else tonight, isn’t he?”

I told her how beautiful she was, and said if we were ever going to do something crazy, it should be now. I was just intoxicated with her horniness, even if it were for another man. That night, I wanted her to experience everything. She was more level headed, though, and said “Maybe.”But an hour later he was in her bedroom. I saw them in there together and panicked. There were still people there and I didn’t want anyone knowing we were even considering an open relationship. But they hung out with another guy and listened to music. They were just smoking weed. Alex found me in the hallway and said he had said he might need to crash here and she’d said okay. This was it. “That’s cool, right?” she said to me, and I said yes. She asked me if I wanted to be involved and I said no, I’ll guard the front door for a bit then go home.

Most people had left, it was almost 3am. Finally the last few left. Alex kissed me and gave me the biggest smile as she went to her bedroom and closed the door. She had another man in there, a 31 year old rock climber stud, and I’d given her permission to do whatever she wanted with him. Or whatever he wanted, rather.

I hung out on the porch, and it turns out that was a good idea. A few friends had come by after another party, and I kept them out there, telling them the party was over. Alex was probably inside getting felt up, and the last thing either of us needed was our friend group finding out exactly how kinky she would be. Finally they left, I was going to hit the bathroom and leave, but I heard her moaning through her bedroom door. And fuck if it wasn’t the hottest thing Id ever heard. I went to the bathroom, then listened for more, but didn’t hear much.

But that moan was in my head and I just had to see what they were up to. Alex and I had discussed me potentially watching while we fooled around once and she’d liked the idea. It was a very kinky moment that she said that, but then so was this. Plus she’s my girlfriend, so I didn’t feel too bad when I went to her absent roommates room, and then snuck into the shared bathroom that connects their rooms. I quickly locked the door to her room so they wouldn’t find me if they had to pee. In there I could hear everything, and peeking through they keyhole I could see them on her bed.

She was naked on her bed, getting fingered, while stroking his enormous cock. He was naked, his muscular body next to her slim, curvy one. I thought I was ready for this. And emotionally, I think I was. Relationship-wise, I was ready.

The sheer beauty of Alex was what drew me, and I hated the fact that I was watching her stroke another guys very large dick. I was okay with her experiencing her sexuality to the fullest, that’s what I wanted. But at that moment what became very real to me was that I’d given some jerk permission to enjoy my girlfriends perfect figure skater body. Her toned legs and ass, which I obsessed over, were about to be his. I don’t think I’d realized how much I enjoyed having her body to myself. Not to mention she was the love of my life. And I could only watch as he caressed her slim waist, marveling at her hourglass figure.

They kissed, then he said “Let’s try again.” And I really wasn’t ready for that. But I couldn’t look away. I watched as he got on top of her and spread her legs. She said “Go slow,” and he slid his huge dick inside her. She moaned. He only had like half of it in her but she wasn’t used to him. He slowly started fucking her, going deeper and deeper.

I was as hard as a rock but felt like I’d made the biggest mistake of my life. I loved seeing her get off on giving herself to him. He was like all her kinky dreams in one man. A cocky athlete, feeding her his huge dick. Being submissive for this alpha male.

Once she was used to him, he started fucking her hard. And I could only jerk off and watch while Jake treated her like a piece of ass. He had her get on her hands and knees and fucked her from behind, her perfect ass on display for him. He spanked her, he pulled her hair. She moaned his name and told him when she was cumming on his dick. He slowed down and she said, “Spank me again.” She loved it.

He had her fuck back on to him, and I’ve never seen her body look more slutty. She’s so beautifully curvy for a very slim girl, and seeing that soft body of hers grinding back on his muscled one was mesmerizing. As was her ass which he had both hands on, as it bounced back onto his long thick dick. I remember she looked back at him, smiling, and said “I love your beautiful dick.”

Finally he came, pulling out of her and cumming on her back. I came too, and snuck out of there as they talked and kissed. The next day she came to my place and after we had dinner she told me everything. I told her I’d watched, too, and hadn’t been ready for it. They’d gone at it again after I left and another time in the morning. I was worried about how he’d treated her, but she said it hadn’t been that bad, and she’d enjoyed it. She was actually hoping he’d give her something to remember. He’d been on top of her later, and she’d looked at herself in the mirror, this huge hunk on top of her, totally dominating her, her legs splayed out to the side as he filled her with more cock than she’d ever imagined. And she came right there, watching herself get fucked.

Sorry this was so long, it probably needs some editing. Send me a chat if you want. Obviously me and Alex had a loooong talk after this

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/x6adhr/mf_i_thought_i_could_handle_sharing_my_girlfriend