“Why don’t you, me and John give a kiss?” – my girlfriend suggested.
There it was. Out of nowhere (kinda). I felt a lot of things at that moment and my only response was to say “Never. I can’t do it. Not now not ever.”
I joked around for years in our relationship that we should do a threesome with one of her friends but I mean, I never really expected it to happen, I’ve always said it as a way to mess with her. And now, she splatters this idea all over my face.
———–
How it happened: Saturday, night out with some friends in the beginning of the year.
We were all at our usual spot where we drink and then go to the main bar in the city to dance. Around 5:15 when it closes, and after playing with her at the start of the night saying we should kiss (me, my gf and her friend Mary), that’s when she said it.
———
Back to the reaction: Now I just stay there and I say “I would never do that”. She responds, well, but you wanted with Mary so I can give you that first, let me bring her.
I thought she was joking and she legit tells her and she accepts. I, once again, I’m left there stunned by actually not believing she would want to do it and that Mary would wanna kiss me. But like I said at the start, I was always JOKING… And, of course, I said I didn’t wanna do it. I mean, I wanted, but didn’t want too because I love my girlfriend and couldn’t imagine ruining the most precious thing I had for the past 5 years since high school.
I then said to her “Were you really serious about wanting to kiss John?”, and she said “I mean, I don’t think it was such a big deal, it was just an idea like you always said about Mary, so I thought about it and then, for fun, decided to suggest you this since you always think that it’s funny to ask what you would like to do with us”.
Bammm, I was put in my place. I couldn’t argue back because she said she was, just like me, joking around. The walk home was kinda silent and it was her saying to stop thinking about it, and that she was sorry to suggest that and me responding that she had nothing to apologize about and that it’s fine since I make the same jokes myself but that it was surprising since you’ve always said you’d never wanna do it with other guy and even worse, one of my best friends.
The night ended by me taking her home (she wanted to sleep in my house but I left her at home) and then fell asleep thinking about it.
——— Sex part ———
The day after she came to my house, apologized again, I said it was fine and then we went to the business. The fun part? I was just so f*kn hard the whole time with the idea stuck in the back of my head. She came twice, I came after and was really one of the hottest sex I’ve had and I spent the whole time thinking about her getting fucked by me and my friend John and just enjoying it more than she enjoys with me. I ended telling her midsex if she wanted it to end what the kiss would start like this and she just said no. I asked again, fucking her even harder in doggy style (my God her ass) if she was sure she didn’t want another hard cock inside her.
I was afraid I had push it too far and couldn’t even believe I said that to her. Quick witted as she is, she just answered while moaning and this I’ll never forget “Hmmm… maybe Hmmm… I’m not the one who wants it more because you are the one who’s even hurting me inside by how hard you are and how deep you are fucking me”. As you all can guess, that’s when I came.
Post story: That was it, now more things have happened (related to it, not a lot freakier) but we just decided that maybe one day we should do it, but it was just too soon and we couldn’t imagine it happening in the near future (since we’ve never even been with anyone else, and we date since highschool).
Sorry if it’s not your usual threesome story but I didn’t wanna ruin a real story by adding fake shit to it. By the way, we’re both 23 and John and Mary from the story are also the same age.
Also, even if the dialogues are not exactly correct it is because the alcohol made my brain a bit blurred and was all I remembered. If you wanna hear any more of my stories that happened just comment and give feedback. Also, English is not my main language and this is the first time writing a story so any typo detected, feel free to correct.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/x0x3ct/girlfriend_and_i_m_a_night_of_suggestions