This experience is the one and only time I shared a woman with another man . It was mid fall and like most days during this time in my life I was waking up to house full of people in my home after a night of heavy drinking. There were about 6 guys and 4 girls there and the way my friend group was set up is that everyone was extremely close.
We would cook breakfast for each other, laugh consistently, sing songs, it felt like something out of movie to be completely honest. For some reason this particular day everyone in the house was very touchy feely with each other, especially the girl who this story is about, “Amy”.
Now previous to this day I had never really thought about hooking up with Amy because she felt a lot like a little sister to me but I would be lying if I said I didn’t think she was attractive. She was a 5’5 pale white skin girl with shoulder length black hair perky breast and darker blue eyes.
Around 2pm on this day we all started drinking again and listening to music, I had had a lot to drink so I went into the bathroom on the main level of the house but when I opened the door Amy was in there doing her makeup. I told her I really needed to pee and to hurry up and get out of the restroom. She laughed and said “just go ahead and pee” whatever, I started to try to pee but I couldn’t get started and at this point she says “what are you pee shy or something?” At this point I realized she was literally looking at my dick which is something that had never previously happened but it wasn’t sexual so I didn’t think much of it.
Eventually I finished up in the bathroom and we both walked out. One of the guys “trey” was waiting outside of the bathroom for his turn to go and Amy and I just hung out in the hallway for a second talking about who was going to make the next beer run, so on and so forth. Still, nothing sexual.
When trey walked out of the bathroom Amy says “do you guys wanna hang out upstairs? I don’t feel like being around all of the music right now” we both said yeah and figured she probably just wanted us to smoke her out or something so we go upstairs into my media room which is essentially just a big room with a leather couch and flat screen tv.
I don’t really know exactly how we got on the subject but Amy says at one point “well I just saw “Xxxx” (prefer to not use my name) dick in the bathroom, what’s yours like? Trey is way more adventurous than me and I honestly think I owe this experience to him because I wouldn’t have taken the leap. He just pulls his dick out and shows it to her. At this point Amy says “you know I’ve never been with two guys before” Trey says “today is as good of a time as any”
She didn’t need to hear more, she grabbed his dick and started sucking him off and stopping every few seconds to “brag” to us about how her technique is really good. She wasn’t lying she does the whole head twirling/tongue twirling thing that you usually only see in porn and her throat seemed endless. (She always tears up when she goes deep and that mixed with her beautiful eye color looks so sexy) at this point you could say I was getting a little “jealous” so I started to get up to leave the room when she says “where are you going don’t be so impatient” I sat back down and she pulled me out of my pants and gave me the same treatment Trey had just gotten.
After a little bit of her sucking me off Trey asked if he could fuck her and she said “that’s why we’re up here” this all seemed like a game to her because she literally made us Rock Paper Scissors for who was going to fuck her first. I won that battle and so I got on the carpeted floor behind her and started fucking her from behind. I didn’t go too hard or fast because I didn’t wanna be the guy to finish first (I don’t know why I cared but it was my first time in this kind of situation) Trey sat on the couch and she crawled between his legs so that he could put his dick in her mouth while I fucked her from behind. We traded spots in this position about 4 times before she asked us both to fuck her missionary, one at a time. We listened and did as she liked. He fucked her and pulled out and came on her face.
When it was my turn for missionary I couldn’t help but pound away at her roughly because the site of her freshly made up face covered in cum while I’m fucking her had me extremely turned on. I eventually finished on her stomach and she had me go get some towels from the restroom so she could clean up.
All 3 of us went back downstairs and she tried to act like nothing happened as did I. Trey on the other hand was getting more drunk throughout the night and trying to make cryptic and inside jokes to me about it in front of everyone.
This wouldn’t be THAT big of a deal except for the fact that Amy was literally dating one of the guys at the house and another of the guys at the house had a huge crush on her. I knew I shouldn’t have done what I did and her boyfriend who was there really was a good friend of mine. Karma eventually came back to get me for this day but in hindsight I still think it was worth it.
Trey and I are no longer friends over this day because nobody would have found out had he not been an idiot and trying to make it so obvious. The guy who had a crush on her said he had gone looking for us around the house and thought he heard someone hooking up in the media room but didn’t think it could be us because he didn’t expect Amy would be doing anything like that.
This definitely put a rift in the friend group for a couple of months but in the end we all ended up partying together again daily and Amy stayed in the relationship with her boyfriend. For about another year.
Amy and I hooked up one more time the next year but it wasn’t really anything notable or story worthy and occasionally at parties she would ask me to give her a kiss or make out with her before she left but it honestly felt more “friendly” than lustful.
I don’t really know why I bothered to change names in this story because if they ever read this they will know exactly who posted it 🙄
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/vyz8sk/mfm_the_first_and_only_time_i_fucked_a_girl_with