How a threesome with my timid girlfriend turned into a humiliating twosome (Part 2) [MFM]

Sophia was still resting her head in my lap, as the reality of what had just happened sunk in for me. I felt my heart drop to my stomach, having just witnessed my beautiful girlfriend being dominated and humiliated by my friend, Ben, in what was originally supposed to be a threesome. My head was dizzy from the weed and my dick still straining against my pants, adding to my feelings of confusion. I was trying to speak up about my more than conflicted feelings, but I hesitated. Sophia slowly opened her eyes, her freckles framing her innocent face as she was looking at me.

‘Jesus…’ she exclaimed. ‘That was intense!’ She lifted herself up and before I had the chance to say anything, she showered me with kisses.

Ben smirked at us, and my heart started pounding again. I did not like that look on his face. It was almost as if some sort of devilish plan had just unfolded in his mind. He gently caressed Sophia’s thigh and said to my surprise: ‘I think your boyfriend feels a little left out. Maybe you should take care of him?’

Sophia’s face started turning red and she looked at me with a hint of embarrassment in her deer-like brown eyes. ‘I’m sorry, babe’, she muttered while tying her curly red hair into a ponytail. ‘It was just… I don’t know what came over me. I hope you didn’t feel bad about it! This is about all three of us, right?’ she said, while unzipping my pants. My semi-hard dick sprang out and she immediately put her mouth to work, eager to prove she had not forgotten about me.

I was still conflicted about the entire situation, but I must admit that feeling her beautiful lips work their way down my shaft did ease my nerves tremendously. Before I knew it, my aching heart had vanished into thin air, and only weed-fueled horniness remained. Ben seemed to lay back for a bit, relighting the blunt and taking a few hits before offering me some. I was getting more and more optimistic about actually being involved in the threesome now. Maybe this just had been a bumpy start into an awesome night?

Meanwhile, Ben started undressing. He first removed his shirt, showing off his muscles. He had always been a bit of a jock, and from the looks of it he was still keeping up the game. Then his pants came off and he was sitting right beside us in nothing but his boxer briefs. Slowly but firmly, he took Sophia’s hand and guided her to his crotch. From the corner of my eye, I could see her jerking him through the fabric of his boxers, as he was growing larger and larger in her hand. Finally, he wriggled out of his underwear, revealing his rock-hard cock.

I could see Sophia’s eyes widen. And when I looked over, I immediately saw why. Ben’s cock was enormous, probably about 9 inches in length and quite girthy. It looked massive, especially compared to my medium sized dick still half buried in Sophia’s mouth. I could feel her lips moving away from my dick as she looked at him in shock. ‘You like what you see?’ he said teasingly. He took her hand and pulled her closer. Without hesitating, she started stroking him, her eyes still fixated on his throbbing cock. Then, he slowly guided her head to the tip of his cock, signaling her to suck it. She did not hesitate and eagerly put her mouth to work.

Again, her attention had entirely shifted to him, with me being sidelined. But this time, I wouldn’t give up that easily. Moving behind her, I took my fingers and started playing with her sore pussy. She moaned, her lips still wrapped around him and both of her hands working their way down his cock. It didn’t take long before she was decently wet, so I took out a condom as she was not on BC. With a swift motion, I wrapped it around my dick and positioned myself behind her. When I entered her, she left out soft moans of pleasure, partially swallowed by Ben’s cock in her mouth. I could feel how wet she was as I slowly worked my way into her. Sophia seemed to absolutely love getting split-roasted, pushing her entire body against me while licking and sucking her soul out on him. I do not believe that I ever saw her give such a wet and sloppy blowjob before.

When I was finally ready to pick up the pace, Ben interrupted the scene, pushing her away and flashing me a cocky grin. ‘How about we switch up for a bit?’ he suggested. Sophia turned around, her innocent eyes searching for mine. ‘Is that okay for you, babe?’ she asked nonchalantly. I wasn’t thrilled, as I was just getting started, but her sweet look melted my heart.

We moved around and I could see him get a condom out of his bag, taking his time to slide it down his giant cock. Sophia did not waste any time and put her mouth to work, licking my balls while gently jerking me off. I could see him position himself behind her, his throbbing cock about to enter her pulsating pussy. As he was pushing into her, I felt my heart sink a little. I still remember that I thought she wouldn’t be able to take it completely, seeing the outline of his cock against her small frame.

She gasped for air, as he was very slowly working his way inside of her. My dick slipped out of her mouth as she had trouble concentrating on anything but Ben and his slow thrusting movements. ‘Fuck, you’re tight’ he said while giving her ass a slap. Sophia let out a moan upon impact, and he started laughing. ‘You like that?’ he said, slapping her ass a few more times. With each hit, her moans grew louder. She buried her head in my lap and started resting her hand on my thigh for support. He grabbed her by the hips and pushed further and further into her.

‘Fffuckk!’ she groaned as he was pushing her against me. ‘Ffuucck… you’re so fucking big… I can’t believe… Fuuuckk…’ was all that came out of her mouth. He just started laughing and answered: ‘Brace yourself. I’m going all the way in now.’

I could see him thrust a final time and immediately, a sound I have never heard before came out of my girlfriend’s mouth. It was a strange mix of pain, but mostly pleasure, almost animalistic in nature. He gave her a few seconds to adjust to his size and then started picking up the pace again. Grabbing her by the wrist, he shoved his fat cock deep inside her, filling her up more than she had ever been in her life.

At that point, she had completely forgotten about me, only using my lap and thighs to support her. Hearing her ecstatic moans, her deep groaning, her indescribable sounds of pleasure, my dick was still rock-hard even though extreme jealousy flooded my mind. Our threesome had basically become a twosome and at that point I had no clue how to get back into the game.

Ben took her ponytail and lifted her head up by her hair. My sweet, innocent girlfriend was directly facing me now, her freckles framing the same face I woke up to every morning. But this look, I had never seen from her. Her eyes were aimlessly wandering about, rolling back into her head, almost as if she was going unconscious.

He was relentlessly pumping in and out of her pussy, while holding her up by her hair with one hand and spanking her hand with the other. ‘You still know who you belong to, slut?’ he shouted. In her state, I did not expect any answer. But again, Sophia surprised me. In between thrusts, she answered him: ‘You… daddy…’

‘That’s right, slut’ he said while grinning at me. I was completely in shock, looking directly at my girlfriend as she was again helplessly submitting to this jerk. And he did not stop either: ‘You know the rules, slut. If you want to cum again, you will submit to me. Completely.’

‘Yes… daddy…’ she stuttered in between moans. I couldn’t believe my eyes and ears. What was he doing to her? She was never like this with me. ‘Babe…’ was all I could mutter, but she didn’t even seem to hear me.

Ben slapped her ass and pulled her up by her ponytail again. ‘Look at your boyfriend’ he said, loosely pointing her head in my direction. Her eyes were trying to focus on me but kept wandering off aimlessly as she had basically lost control over her body. ‘Tell him who owns your pussy!’

She moaned but kept silent. Immediately, his thrusts started going slower, to which she let out a surprised, squeaky sound. Still holding her ponytail, forcing her to look at me, he slid out of her gaping, wet fuck-hole. He smacked her ass with force. ‘Tell him, whore! Or do you want your boyfriend to fuck you instead?’ Another few hits on her ass left her groaning in pleasure and pain. I could see that his hands had left deep red marks on her butt. Positioning the tip of his cock at the entrance of her pulsating pussy, I could hear desperate sobbing sounds from her. He smacked her again and repeated himself a final time: ‘Tell your boyfriend who owns your pussy, slut!’

My heart sank as she answered him: ‘You… daddy… Please fuck me again… I will do everything… My pussy belongs only to you, daddy!’ He slid into her again, this time with ease. I couldn’t believe this.

I felt a wave of embarrassment hit me. Never in my life had I felt that humiliated… defeated… but they just kept going. Sophia was now basically screaming in pleasure as he forced her to say more and more humiliating things.

‘Have you ever been fucked like this before, slut?’ ‘No… daddy’

‘Does your boyfriend’s cock feel this good?’ ‘No… daddy’

‘Will you beg to cum on my cock, whore?’ ‘Yes… daddy’

At that point, her body was already shaking. She had never cum from penetration before, and we both didn’t think that it was possible for her. But he just worked his cock on her, his large frame towering her as she helplessly spread his legs for him. ‘Fffffuuuuucckkkk’ she screamed. ‘I’m gonna cum I’m gonna cum I’m gonna cum.’ Her entire body was trembling.

Another smack on her ass. ‘Beg for it, slut!’ he shouted.

‘Please let me cum… ffffuuuuckkk… I can’t… you’re so deep… please… daddy.’ She threw herself against his massive cock, her limbs shaking uncontrollably.

‘Tell your loser boyfriend how much better daddy’s cock is.’

My heart sank as she was struggling to take him and control her orgasm. I told myself that she was high, not herself. That it wasn’t her talking. ‘I’m sorry, babe…’ she whimpered. ‘His cock… Daddy’s cock… is just… it’s just… ffffuuuuckkk… so much better… Please, daddy… My pussy belongs to you… Fffuuck… I’m gonna cum, daddy, please…’

‘Good slut, he said and picked up the pace. ‘You may cum on my cock.’ What followed was again something I had never seen before. First, she went completely silent. Then, her trembling returned, even more heavy than before. It was almost like I was witnessing a seizure, as only incoherent screams of pleasure escaped her mouth. I could see a huge wet spot forming under her, soaking our couch as she was squirting on his cock. For what felt like an eternity, she seemed to just let go, giving herself completely to Ben.

Then, finally, she stopped shaking and a crushing silence filled the room.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/vnr6lt/how_a_threesome_with_my_timid_girlfriend_turned