Was my bday and me and my girlfriend at that time threw a party. Bunch of mini games and drinks.
She invited her friends and some of my friends as well. So roughly about 6 girls and 7 guys. Two of the guys were my girlfriends’s ex. One dated her during middle school. And one dated her sophomore year of highschool til senior year. The girls they were pretty, besides two cause female always need someone to make them look better. Single guys besides me, taken girls besides 1ugly and one pretty. What my gf didn’t know was one of them was lily(the name i used on the girl from my last story) her brother didn’t come cause he had work and no pto left. She is dating now in a serious relationship and has one kid now. Beginning of the year, so it’s still cold out and party started at 4 but didn’t kick off until people started drinking more.
I wouldn’t say I didn’t pay attention to any of the other girls, as they were wearing some revealing clothes. So me and the boys just sat in the living room casually drinking our beer laughing and joking as we watch videos. From my point of view i can see the girls in the kitchen laughing and making some gestures. Single girl was the one talking the most.
So i told my friends that she is single, (ill use the name Kaitlyn in place of her name) she is a white girl with blond hair down to her middle back, bubbly butt and decent boobs size?(Like b-c cup. Slender and 5’5”. So i told them to make a move before she gets drunk and passed out. So 2hours of us guys talking bout girls and jokes about movies and videos. Then we started migrating to the kitchen one by one and drinking with the girls. We talk more and drink more and then played some card games.
Then 9pm rolled around my girlfriend invited us all to play a game. Loser slams a can or take a shot. It was hide and seek in the dark. Since we all were getting drunk from the beer, we decided it could be fun and at least if we dont lose we dont get a shot or slam and slow doen so we don’t black out later if we drink harder.
I was bday boy so i was the seeker and when the lights go off, it was dark as shit. Plus with a blindfold on. As i stumbled around I couldn’t find anyone. The house is a two story house and my girlfriend already out very dark curtains so no light from outside reaches in. So as i stumble around i managed to tagged someone. Then that person gets to help me as well. As i venture forth, i heard something like the friction of two jacket rubbing. I followed it hitting may things along that 3-10 feet distance. It stopped here and there so i had to slowly continue. Listening very carefully, i got to the spot. I quickly reached my hands out and it was one of my buddy. He was surprised but at the same time i heard a stumble on the floor so I quickly try to reach the ground and grab who ever that was. 10 minutes more i finally got all of them. First person caught became seeker this time.
Now its time i run and hide. So i ran and hide and when lights out i was slowly moving around since it’s my place i know some area. I found my way to a room but a girl was in there startle me. I thought it was my girlfriend, so held onto her waist. Didn’t want to make a noise we we both remain quiet. I then got horny and ran my hands around her waist and onto her pussy. Then i slowly lift her dress up and rub her clit and kiss her neck. I pulled my dick out, and slide it on her pussy making it nice and wet to enter. Just as i was about to put it in, i heard my girlfriend laugh down stairs. I quickly pulled away and didnt say anything. Quickly made my way down stairs in the pitch black. Hid under the dinning table so when lights turns in that girl won’t know who it was me touching her.
Fast forward since I think the game took too long. Ill sum it up. After that I pretty much stayed one area as other people were laughing and ect.
11 pm we were more and more drunk. Kaitlyn and one of my friend hit it off well, they kept talking to each other all night long. The girls and them were all laughing with the me and the guys. For some moments i see lily looking at me, makes me think that it was her up stairs. I got nervous. We the guys went on smoke break and one of them went in early to use the bathroom. I stood out with my boys for 20 min smoking drinking and talking. Then realize the other dude never came back from peeing. We went inside and i saw lily sitting next to kaitlyn and the guy she was into, the girls sitting in one area and us guys finding seats. Only one missing was my girlfriend, the hot taken lady and my friend (the 1st ex) I thought maybe she’s in the bed room and my friend is with the hot chick. So i went to bathroom only to see the hot girl coming out hugging me. So i forgot bout my girlfriend and started talking to her and she went on about her bf being boring and rude and ect. She then lean in and told me that one if my boys probably the one hitting on kaitlyn(ill use john). So she told me john was about to fuck her during the hide and seek, i was like damn okay i got a pass. Then she confessed she was so horny. So i pull her aside and she pulls me back into the bathroom. We kissed then eventually we had sex for 5 minutes and she changed into a different happier gurl for the rest of the night. As we were doing it, i heard my girlfriend mentioning something hurts, as she walked by the bathroom.
As i got out if the bathroom we continue the same as before. 1am some people passed out and just my gf, lily, john, Kaitlyn, and one guy and girl. My gf got tired and went to bed, john and Kaitlyn went to the basement for privacy and lily and me just sat there with the other two.
Eventually they fell asleep and i asked her to come with me to check on john and them. We went and closer we got the more we can hear moaning so we peeked. Kaitlyn was leaning on the wall as john was giving it to her. Me and lily went back up and i pinned her to the wall. Telling her how much i missed her. She kept trying get away then i went for a kiss and she returned the kiss. But thats all to it.
I went to bed and as i got there my gf was laying down face first. I grope her slowly, and lift her dress up only to see a buttplug. I got aroused but didnt think or wonder how she got it. I then kissed her cheeks and flip her. I kissed her neck but she didn’t respond, i lick her pussy she didn’t respond. So i put blanket over her and went to check on the others. Lily fell asleep on the couch like everyone. I gave them blankets and when i got to the 1st ex there was a bulge. And then there was an thong peeking from the front. I was too tired, so i went back to bed and yank the butt plug out quickly. My gf woke up holding her ass as discoloration cum flows out of it.
Idk what happened but all i know was, my girlfriend got fucked pretty hard in the ass by the plug and her ex.
– had more details about the event DM for more info. Too much to write on here or else it wouldn’t be vanilla.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/t6l3c9/fm_mf_friends_or_backstabbing_vanilla_story_if_my
Thats one chaotic story