First, I’d like to thank u/TechnomancerWitch for his DPP post and our short roleplay that inspired this story. I’ve adapted this from our roleplay so I’ve kept the tense as if I’m still myself in the story, but also the narrator. I don’t know how this will come across, I’ve never written anything like this before. I hope you like it and encourage any feedback about how I could have written this better
Themes: Passionate sex, intimacy, light humiliation and encouragement, body modification (penis enlargement & shrinking)
—
We’ve been together for over a year now. I was never one for long serious relationships, I’ve mostly kept more casual friendships while I focused on school and my career, but we had that spark and our relationship grew until I decided I was ready for something more.
You always knew I was more experienced than you, and you eventually found out I slept with many of our mutual guy friends. That never really bothered you, but in the back of your mind you always worried that you weren’t enough for me. It’s no secret that you were self conscious of your size, you have bemoaned your below average endowment on multiple occasions. I’ve done my best to be supportive and reassuring, but you’ve always been skeptical of my support praise. You are on the smaller side, yes, but you aren’t afraid of using toys to help me finish too, and that was always fine by me.
One evening in mid December, we’re hanging out on the sofa watching a movie and making out. I start playing with you and start to stroke you through your clothes. “Loose the pants” I whisper in your ear as I fumble to play with your cock through your jeans. As you slide your pants down to your ankles I stand up and drop my PJs bottoms to the floor then sit on your lap. We kiss as I peel off my top, my hips pressing against your naked body as I gyrate and rub my clit against you through my underwear. I slowly slide my underwear down over my ass and shift my weight to kick them away. I hover my naked body over you and lick my finger tips before I reach down and wet myself then guide the head of your cock against me. I smile and giggle as your cock just pushes inside me.
“Holy shit…” you groan as you throw your head back. I adore that you sound as excited as our first time every time we fuck. “That feels so fucking good…” you add, then you place your hands either side of my chest, gently cupping upwards to push my small breasts together. I giggle and gyrate on your lap as we kiss. I roll my hips as you release gentle grunts. With as much enthusiasm as you’ve ever shown me you grab my hips and start thrusting upward. Short, shallow strokes, desperate to fill me as best you can. “Oh, god…fuck, fuckkkk!” you let slip as you erupt inside me.
I crack a smile. “That was nice” I say calmly. I climb off and sit next to you with my head on your chest, I can hear your heart pounding. “Baby.. think you could go again?” I ask hopefully. “Uhm… maybe in a few minutes?” you reply as I look down at your softening cock. I play with you for a bit trying to get you excited again before conceding defeat. “It’s fine.” I say as I put my underwear and shirt back on. I wander into the kitchen to grab a drink and my phone and I notice an unlabeled prescription bottle on the counter. I bring it back “Hun… what’s this?”
You turn scarlet the instant you notice what I found. “Oh, er.. .that? That’s nothing. In fact I need to throw it away, that’s why it was on the side. I guess I just… forgot.” you stammer. “What is it?” I open the bottle and look, they don’t seem familiar. You are obviously acting strangely. “Serious?” I press harder. “What are these for?”
You take a deep sigh and look down at your naked lap before you cover yourself with a blanket. “You promise you won’t laugh? Or judge?” you ask nervously. “No, of course not. Just tell me…” I say softly as I sit with you. Then you continue… “Look, they’re definitely bullshit. I don’t know what came over me, she was just…a very compelling sales person. She said they were dick growth pills, recommended them to me in fact. But obviously that’s not true so I was just going to throw them away.”
“Dick growth pills!? From where?” I look down at the pills… then with excitement I ponder out loud “I mean… it can’t hurt to try them, right?”
“That new witch’s shop, the one that seemed to sprout out of no where.” you reply, I don’t know what you are talking about but I pretend that I do. “You’d actually want me to try them?” you ask a little embarrassed. I shrug like I’m trying not to get too excited “I mean… it doesn’t hurt to try them… just once. Right? Like, I think your size is fine but maybe they will help you go again?” I say with a hopeful shrug.
You look away like you are lost in thought. “Alright then, I’ll try one.” You concede, then take the pills from my hand and pop one into your mouth, swallowing it down with a gulp of water. “I wonder how long we’d have to wait? I mean, not that it’s going to work…” you say with a chuckle
My eyes open in amazement as I see the blanket covering your lap begin to lift. My eyebrows go up with surprise “Well that was quick!” I say with excitement. I pull away the towel and suddenly look totally astonished. You are rock hard, longer, and thicker. I stare in amazement… “Is that…. you?” I grab your cock and start inspecting it like I’m suspicious of a trick. You have the same overall shape, just everything is… bigger. “How’s… How’s that possible?” I ask as I look at you in amazement…. “Holy fuck…” You say in astonishment.
Before you can reply I stand up and drop my underwear. I straddle your lap on my knees and reach down, then sit as I guide the head of your cock. “Fuuuckkkk!!” I grunt loudly as I slowly adjust to your size. I take a deep breath then slide myself down and moan loudly. “Holly fuck you are big!” I say with delight as I sit mostly still enjoying the full feeling. I stare at you and smile. I lean in for a passionate kiss as I start to ride you, slowly at first as I moan, but I cum almost instantly when you slap my ass. My body tenses up and my legs grip you tight and I pant as I try to catch my breath.
You seem conflicted, as if you are both embarrassed I’ve never finished like that before, and excited that your cock brought me to climax so quickly. “Fuck babe, that feels incredible. You feel so… tight.” you add sounding surprised and almost turning red.
“Slap me again!” I say with enthusiasm as I stare at you with serious eyes and start to ride you hard and fast with my hands on your shoulders.
“My god I fucking love it.” I whine as I’m riding you hard but my legs are going weak. I cum again and have to stop for a moment as my whole body feels weak. I collapse off you onto my side and breath heavily… “How are you still going!?” I ask in amazement. I climb off and slide back with my knees on the floor and bend over the sofa with my legs spread wide, inviting you to take control. You’ve never fucked me with such domination. My hands claw at the cushions of the sofa as I moan and loose myself in wave after wave of pleasure. I’ve lost track of the number of times I’ve cum, it’s just one long orgasm now. Finally I reach a hand back and twist my body… “I’m done, I’m done. I can’t handle any more. Please… ” I ask I lie on my side almost like a ragdoll “I’m done. ” I rest my head on a cushion and try to catch my breath as you admire my sweaty body draped over the sofa.
A similar scene plays out pretty much every night for the next several weeks. I cum harder and more times than ever before trying the pills, and eventually you start to worry about what will happen when you run out. One morning after a particularly vigorous night of love making where you didn’t finish, you were masturbating yourself in the shower when you notice something different. The pills had worn off now but you could swear you were smaller than usual. You dismiss your concern as nonsense, you have simply gotten to used to your size with the pills now, but just to be safe you measure. With shock and horror you realize you are now almost a full inch shorter, and thinner, than before. You try to convince yourself it’s a mistake or you measured incorrectly, but you can’t shake the feeling that you really feel smaller than before.
That night I again initiate sex but you express that you are getting concerned about using the pills too often. I’m disappointed, but I understand. “We can still fuck without them” You add with clear excitement. “It’s okay.. ” I say dismissingly. “Tonight… I will help you.” I climb down on my knees, pull down your pants, and blow you almost without pause until you explode in my mouth. “I forgot how much easier that was!” I say with surprise as your cock barely tickled the back of my mouth before you finished in under a minute.
The next day you decide you had to know what was going on. You had already used half your pills, and now your “normal” size and stamina were obviously affected. To your horror the shop was now gone, as mysteriously and suddenly as it appeared. There was nothing but a “For Rent” sign hanging in the door with a hand written note taped to the glass.
“Everything has a cost. What you gain today may take away from tomorrow.”
Then reality hits you like a ton of bricks, you almost fall over. You realize the pills do have a cost. Your temporary gains in size and stamina have cost you a permanent amount of the same.
—
Thanks for reading. I hope you liked it.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/rrgz9a/your_magic_enlargement_pills_comes_at_a_cost_part