[fm] The beginning of my relationship with my older neighbor Part 2

Another repost from r/sluttyconfessions I wasn’t sure if I needed to put both parts here

Part 2 for those who requested it and for me because I’m having fun. This is a very eventful post I promise. I didn’t want to make a bunch of posts hinting at stuff so you get two long ones with our first full encounter. Sorry if that feels like a spoiler. Also, thank you for the encouraging messages and comments! I’m having a lot of fun writing my memories down so I’m glad people like reading it!
The next few days after our little diy incident weren’t very eventful. I was getting home late so I’d sleep in to the point I’d just have to get up and go to work. Finally I had a day off on even if it was during the week.
That morning I woke up to the sound of a lawn mower. I look out my bedroom window and it’s my neighbor shirtless pushing his mower around. I took a second to evaluate what I was seeing. He wasn’t overweight but he did have a more barrel shaped chest and stomach than a V shape. He was also very obviously sweating like crazy. His arms were lovely though. Not stupidly ripped but with that nice amount of tone that suggests strength instead of “I drink creatine and do 1000 arm curls every five hours” the overly ripped guys arms do.
I decided then I was gonna be a bit of a tease. I didn’t want to fuck him, but I was excited by the idea of seeing that shocked look again. I put on a swim suit but this time I went with a bikini. If I remember correctly it was light blue but I asked him and he swears it was red. Readers choice on that one I guess lol. The one thing we agree on about this bikini is it did a very poor job of covering my ass. It wasn’t ruched or anything just cut a little too narrow for the size. If I walked around it would inevitably turn into a thong if I wasn’t constantly adjusting it. It was my “man catcher” bikini as one of my friends called it because I only wore it when I wanted a specific guy to see me in it.
I wrapped a beach towel around me, grabbed some suntan lotion, and went to the kitchen and grabbed two water bottles out of the fridge. I walked out of my house and over to his waving to him. He smiled, stopped the mower and walked to meet me. I handed him the water bottle and told him I figured he needed a drink. He thanked me and asked what I was up to today. I told him if he still didn’t mind I’m gonna take a quick dip then do some tanning. He got that sheepish look again and said he was still ok with it. His eyes never looked below my chin once while we were talking and I could tell it was a struggle for him.
I let him get back to mowing and walked into the lanai. I set down my lotion and water bottle and removed my towel just as he was mowing behind me. I didn’t look back to see if he was looking but when I did see him again he was looking almost straight down with an intensity that I could tell was to not look my way. I swam a few laps enough to just cool off. Got out and dried off then went to lay in one of the pool chairs he’d bought. I grabbed my lotion slowly applying it over my arms, chest, stomach and legs. I know he took a few glances for that.
I’ll be honest I was feeling fucking fantastic. I get oggled all the time and it’s almost always annoying, but when I make an effort to get those looks and am successful I feel like the sexiest girl in the world. I was getting close to the point I’d have to turn over and was debating if I’d invite him to apply my lotion. It felt a bit obvious and I wasn’t sure if I actually wanted him to do it. Then before I can decide he comes walking onto the lanai from the yard.
He’s a little out of breath saying he could use a quick dip, but he wanted to catch his breath before heading upstairs to grab his swim trunks. I asked why he didn’t have them down here if he knew he was gonna hop in the pool. He smiles in this “aww shit you caught me” way. That smile was the first time I realized I was attracted to him. Attraction is an odd thing for me. Sometimes it’s instant othertimes the guy will do something that flips that switch in my brain. A few seconds pass with him saying nothing so I give him my best “well…?” face and he relents. He says usually he just jumps in wearing only his boxers. I laughed and said that he could do that now. Boxers cover more or less the same amount and he’s obviously in need of the cold water. He doesn’t seem super convinced so I tell him I’ll turn around if that’s what he needs. He says that’s not necessary he just didn’t want to be inappropriate or gross me out. I told him he wouldn’t gross me out before I realize what I’m saying. He pauses just enough for me to know he recognized the two meanings of what I said. My heart starts beating hard and suddenly I’m the one staring hard at the ground. He doesn’t say anything but he does take his shorts off and hops in the pool.
I lay back down with a million thoughts racing through my mind. Do I want something to happen? What if we got caught? What if I don’t actually want to and I’m just feeling something else? What if he doesn’t want to? And on and on and on. While my existential crisis is happening he finishes his swim and comes out of the pool. To this day he won’t admit if he knew what he was doing or not.
His boxers were clinging to him and in near perfect detail his cock was outlined. I mean they could’ve painted his boxers on and wouldn’t get as much detail. Now I’m no size queen and he wasn’t packing a mac truck. Instead it was perfect. Not perfect in general but for me. A bit thin and over 5 inches and under 7 in length. Now he did a pretty bad job of hiding when he’d glanced at my ass but I did much much worse. He couldve said two words or two hundred before I realize he was speaking I didn’t know.
He was asking if he could borrow my suntan lotion. I said of course and asked if he could get my back. He said yes but there was a big pause before he said it. I turned over making no attempt to adjust my bottoms. He sat down on my chair next to me and started to rub the lotion into my back. I untied my bikini back and neck ties while he did. He didn’t say anything but he was aware something was going on. I asked him to get my legs not trying to hide that I was enjoying the feel of his hands. He started to rub my legs starting at my calfs and working his way up. Suddenly his hands were on my ass.
I opened my eyes and looked at him. He stared at me for a second not moving. Finally he moved his hands, leaned toward my face, and asked what was going on? I just blurted out that I am attracted to him. I told him everything. How I’d caught him the first time, how I decided to tease him, how I was realizing I was into him; all of it.
He listened and when I finally stopped word vomiting all over him he just asked if I knew how dangerous this was? What if he wasn’t a good guy? What if I just wanted to tease and he decided that meant I was interested and ignored my denials? He was right, to be clear. I was 19 and acting like it. I’d made a decision with little thought to how it could go wrong and put myself in a position for something bad to happen. And instead of apologizing or acknowledging the mistake and leaving I turn over revealing my breasts and grabbed his cock.
Before he could do anything I have his cock out of his boxers and into my mouth. After a few seconds he pushes my hair out of the way and I feel his other hand go back to my ass. Eventually we move so that he’s laying down on the chair and I’m between his legs. That way I can see him as I bounce my head over his cock. The look on his face is perfect; a bit of shock mixed with pleasure. I run my tongue over it and even suck on his balls which I’d never done. The whole time I’m rubbing my pussy.
After a few minutes I can tell I’m gonna orgasm and I’m basically nothing but raging desire so I climb up, undo my bikini bottom, and slide him into me. He moans “oh fuck” as I slide him into me. It takes a few tries to get him all the way in but once I do I only have to ride him for a few seconds before I’m orgasming. His cock just perfectly pushes against my g spot and I’m practically screaming I’m moaning so loud. He uses his hand to shut my mouth and then pulls me down to him.
We finally kiss. His tongue swirls against mine while his dick pushes me into another orgasm. I start to shake from it and he wraps his arms around me and holds me down until it subsides. Then he keeps holding me down and begins to thrust into me hard. I’m near to passing out from the lack of oxygen as I keep moaning into his shoulder. Then I feel him get stiffer and he starts to cum. He keeps making little thrusts, and I can feel his hot cum shooting into me. One of the most satisfying feelings in the world. We lay there for a minute then he tells me we should get inside. We hop up and head in.
I’ll leave it there for now. I’ll continue to post because this is crazy hot for me to confess/retell. Hope you like and feel free to message me. Either to chat or if you have questions from my posts.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/r52hq6/fm_the_beginning_of_my_relationship_with_my_older