Beach House Foursome – Part 2 – Stealing a Girlfriend [MFF]

So, like I said in the last post, things got interesting from here. It’s only been 48 hours since this happened, so the details are rather fresh. Quick recap for your tl;dr people: Kate (25F) and I (39M) had a foursome with Dave and Valerie (30M). Dave was kinda of awkward during it and this is the following day’s shenanigans where we inadvertently stole Dave’s girlfriend.

The next morning Dave is acting weird as shit. He keeps trying to get Kate to fuck him again, but way too aggressively. I didn’t know this yet. Kate’s just dealing with it. We spend the day together and it’s increasingly cold between Dave and Val. Shit, we broke up another relationship because we were horny. Not the first time. Probably won’t be the last. I have never claimed to be a good person.

Kate finally gives me a heads up that Dave is acting too forward and that she asked Val to tell him to chill. Note on consent for y’all out there: just because someone agrees to fuck you once, doesn’t mean that’s a yes forever. Anyway, I decide to approach Dave. He’s buffer than I am, but I have 20 lbs and 4″ of height on him, so I’m hoping for the best. Dave is pissy as fuck about the whole thing. Acting entitled and shit. I was trying to be cool, but he was just not. He finally does the thing and threatens to kick my ass.

Just as he says it, Kate and Val walk into the room. “What the actual FUCK, Dave? They’ve been super awesome and you threaten him?” Val to the rescue. Well, at least I’m not likely to get my ass kicked! this is where shit gets weird though. They start fighting and Kate and I watch them air out the dirty laundry. It’s like a train wreck and we can’t look away. Plus, I don’t want to leave Dave alone with Val just in case. Long story short here, she kicks him out. The place is rented in her name, so she just says, “GTFO” and sends him packing.

We’re consoling her and she says things have been bi-polar for awhile and she just can’t take it anymore. In her crying, she says she doesn’t want to go back to her place (checkout is today), so we invite her to stay with us. She moves her stuff into one of the other bedrooms. Kate and Val spend most of the afternoon bitching about Dave and his jackhammering moody ass.

We all get high and wander the streets. We end up in a sex shop that’s full of giggling tourists. We giggle, too. Val, now high and with no filter, grabs a purple and white dildo screaming, “KATE! LOOK!” We turn and she yells again, “Isn’t this the one you had last night!?” People are watching and I’m cracking up. We get our new friend out of the store, only spending money on some new lube and riding crop.

Back at the house, Val gets the riding crop out and is mocking her best dominatrix, but we’re laughing. “What? What is it?” Well, Val, you’re not exactly dominant. You liked getting DP’d by a couple you just met. Kate grabs it from her to show her how it’s done. Val ends up at Kate’s feet with a heel on her shoulder and clothed vagina shoved in her face in her face. It’s all kind of comical with a hint of sexy. Just enough that it ends up sexy.

In the sake of brevity, I’m gonna yadda yadda us to the hot tub 30 minutes later. Kate and Val are making out and I’m watching. They just get each other all worked up and I get to sit back and relax. It’s nice after a few weeks in non-stop meetings for work. Before I know it, Kate has Val bent over the side of the hot tub eating her pussy like it’s made of french vanilla ice cream. Her pale skin next to Kate’s dark brown hair contrasting nicely. Her pink lips matching Kate’s pink lips. The only difference in the two girl’s complexion really is the complete lack of freckles on Val.

Val cums and slides back into the hot tub. “I want to watch you two make love. I know you love each other. I see the way you look at each other. Can you be that intimate with me in the room?” I’m not sure, but hell, I’ll try almost anything. We get to the shower and rinse off. I take the girls’ bathing suits off and we make out in the outdoor setup. Completely naked, we get to the bed in the studio. The studio bed is only a full, barely big enough for a threesome. Val plops onto the floor next tot he bed and Kate and I climb into it.

Our bodies move in the unison we’ve come to learn over the last year plus being together. I know everything she likes and she knows how to respond. It’s a ballet. A performance. Two people becoming one. We get into a groove we haven’t been in since we had Stacey. We both know the catalyst is Val, but we refrain from looking at her, giving her what she wants. When we cum, we do so together. Our gasps and grunts and moans fill the living space and once completed, only then do we look at Val.

“I want to be your third,” was all she said to us. She got up and left, tears in her eyes. Kate got a robe on and followed her. After about 20 minutes she asked me to come in. They both wanted to ask me something. Kate said she knew last night something special was happening once Dave left and she wants to keep it going. I ask about the recent break up and Val said it’s been over but now she knows what was missing because she sees what we have.

I told her it’s not something that happened over night and after a few hours of discussion we decided to let Val into our lives, tentatively. She lives near us and, luckily, her and Dave had separate places. We’re gonna take it step by step, I guess, but starting out fucking her in front of her boyfriend and then jumping right to anal might be a stretch to overcome. We’ll see.

As I’m typing this, ignoring work meetings, Kate and Val and sitting on the couch in the living room binging Twilight. Everyone has their guilty pleasures, so who am I to judge. Just bring that vampire/werewolf animalism to bed later, okay?

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/qwxs4p/beach_house_foursome_part_2_stealing_a_girlfriend