This story happened almost exactly 10 years ago and I was feeling nostalgic and wanted to share. I apologize in advance that most of this is probably backstory and if its feeling long.
It started 12 years ago when I met Erica as a freshmen in college. I know many people here are visual readers, and so Erica in college was 5’7, around 115 lbs with most of that in her ass, while I stood at 5’9 and was probably around 140 as a freshmen but at a bit better slim but athletic build at 150 when this story actually takes place. No idea what she saw in me as a scrawny freshman, but we hit it off and eventually started dating for about 4 months. During this period we never had sex, as in actual sex. We were 18 year old, horny, unexperienced virgins and some how avoided going all the way. Looking back, I actually have no clue how we didn’t sleep with each other freshmen year. The first time we made out, I had bypassed 2nd and just fingered her as well as someone with barely any experience could. The next day we almost got walked in by RA as she was giving me a blowjob in her dorm. One time my roommate actually walked in on us as I was titfucking her in my dorm. You get the picture, we were plenty horny and attracted to each other, but were putting off the big home run because we wanted it to be special I guess? I really don’t know why, maybe just fear. Unfortunately I had a mental breakdown freshman year and we broke up as a result.
Fast forward 2 years later. I live off campus and Erica ends up moving in next door with a couple friends, including my friend Amanda. I was helping Amanda unpack when I saw Erica for like the first time in 2 years. She was absolutely stunning in that blue sundress, looking more gorgeous than she ever did as a freshman. We acted cordial around one another, but I knew then that I had to have her back. Besides living next door, she also shared a small class (16 students) with me that semester, so we were about to see each other plenty. A month into junior year, I had my 21st birthday. Most of my friends were not 21 so it was not much of a bar crawl for me, but Erica came to my birthday dinner and we shared a way too long hug, the most close contact we had with each other in 2 years. I definitely felt a spark, and later would figure out, she did too. A week after my birthday, my favorite baseball team was in game 5 of the playoffs, loser is out. My friends and I, Erica included, decided to watch the game at the Student Union on the big screen. There were only 2 of us there over 21, and with the strict ID rules there, we were the only 2 drinking as well. Too many pitchers were consumed, but my team won and I was ecstatic!
After the game, the group of us went to Erica and Amanda’s place to hang out and so that the rest of the gang could drink/pregame for a party. I apparently had too much to drink and ended up taking nap on the couch while everyone else went to the party (remember, I live next door, so there is no reason for me to stay). Amanda comes home before Erica, see’s me sleeping on the couch, and she wakes me up to give me water and a sandwhich. Amanda always was the motherly one in the friend group. Honestly, no clue why she didn’t just tell me to go home, but instead, she just suggested I sleep on the futon in living room instead of couch since it would probably be more comfortable (same futon from Erica’s dorm freshmen year).
Finally the good stuff. Sometime late in the night, Erica comes home from the party. She does wake me and asks why I’m still there (good question) and I boldly suggest she just join me on the futon. She does and we just begin to cuddle like we were inexperienced 18 years old again. I make a move to kiss her and she shuts me down…for a moment. Her roommates can’t see she says and we should move to her room. As soon as that door shut, all bets were off, we wanted each other more than anything in the world. I couldn’t wait to taste that pussy again and I went straight for my prize. I won’t claim to be a master in bed, but I do have a talent for going down on a girl. I loved to tease her, I would kiss her thighs, softly kiss just the outside of her pussy, pretend to go push my tongue inside, but then come up and make out with her some more. I would keep teasing her until she pushes my head down between her legs. But tonight was all business, I put my tongue straight inside of her and slowly took it all in, exploring in a circle around every inch of the pussy. As I moved my tongue in and out, I began to work my fingers inside too, working my way to a “come hither” motion until I could feel that g spot, just as where I remembered it on her. She knew I had her at that moment. I worked that g spot until I could feel her getting ready to peak. Just before her orgasm, I plunged my tongue as deep insider of her as I could while still working the g spot and she just melted right there. Had to quickly grab a pillow over her face to prevent her from waking the whole house.
After a minute or so, she told me to lay down because she needed my cock (I still was not believing we were actually going to have sex that night). She started to blow me with enthusiasm that was somehow greater than what I had just been showing her. She didn’t keep it on for long though, for my initial disappointment. But to my surprise, she had stopped to grab a condom. She put it on me, straddled over me, looked me right in the eyes, and then plunged right now on my dick. I could not believe how wet and warm she felt at that moment. With all the emotions going on in that moment though, I did not last long, it was too unbelievably hot and unexpected and it was probably less than a minute before I came.
Luckily, I pretty much stayed hard as I was completely turned on by Erica’s sexiness in the moment. I grabbed another condom, fucked her doggystyle while working my hands between her boobs and her clit while she grabbed my balls from underneath my legs and managed to last a more adequate amount of time for us to both cum again. That night was the hottest moment of my life. Erica and I are still together 10 years later, and amongst all our adventures, I still don’t think it could top the euphoria from our first time together. It was like we did 2 years of foreplay and somehow the ending still exceeded the expectations.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/q9e104/my_first_time_with_my_ex