Threesome checklist review: how’d we do? [MFM]

Hi Reddit, you may recall an earlier post where my gf detailed her hopes and dreams for an upcoming Threesome by way of a checklist. I, the male half of our account, am here to report on said threesome. TLDR: a new pal and I fucked the shit out of her.

For the full review please note that the checklist was written by her. After each of her goals I have written a yay or nay and an explanation. You’ll notice that male and female voice alters in accordance to this format. Ok! This user manual has concluded — onto the review!

++++++++++++

An incomplete list of things I’m looking forward to:

– meeting for a drink for a quick chemistry check. I’ve been chatting with this guy for months now, so there’s a lot of buildup. I want to flirt innocently with clothes on so the transition is even more stark.

* Yay | we made good on this goal right away BUT I added in a surprise for her. At some point during our planning we moved the convo from Feeld to Telegram. I reached out to the guy privately and filled him in on the plan.

Once it was established that we were all comfy with each other, as demonstrated by her rubbing our hardening cocks over our pants while we sat in the bar’s back booth, I produced a chrome butt plug and told her to go into the single stall bathroom, insert it into her asshole, door unlocked, and text us to join when ready.

Her eyes lit up and one could practically hear her getting wet when I revealed this plan. She grabbed the plug and dashed to the bathroom. Soon she messaged us “come and get me”.

I went in first and found her waiting, biting her lip. I reached around and checked for the plug, finding it snugly in place inside her tight ass. I’ll take a sec to describe her for you. 5”4’, gorgeous Asian-White sexpot, with 34Bs that love to be squeezed, and a perky butt that loves to be fucked. A smile that seduces everyone and a personality to match. She IS the party. This late afternoon she was wearing a thin little sundress, with a slutty body necklace underneath. It was hot out and so was she.

Instructed her to the floor and down she went, immediately undoing my pants. As she took my growing cock into her mouth the door opened. Instead of our guy, an old man popped in stopping short with an “oh shit sorry!” and the door closed. We laughed and 5 seconds later, our friend came in flustered.

“Lock the door and get out your cock,” I said plainly. And so he did. She was fucking delighted. She grabbed him with one hand and started throating me like the whole scenario was a regular occurrence. It was awesome.

We both looked down at her, next to the bar toilet as she took turns sucking us off, always stroking the mouthless cock like a good girl while she gagged on one of our dicks. Eye contact, moaning and lots of spit were all there like a perfect ensemble cast to the only play worth being in.

After about 8 min I got antsy and announced it was time to go. Her and I would leave for the hotel, a few blocks away and he would join us in ten min.

Off we went giddy and exhileratedly horny.

– sucking one dick while stroking the other, switching, switching, getting grabbed by the hair and face fucked and slapped with cock while my throat is full with someone else.

* Yay | starting in the bathroom and for the next 24 hours this happened several times. She had teeth marks on the inside of her lips for days because she sucked so much cock.

– Hearing the two of them talk about me like a toy slut, compare notes about how to get deeper in any hole they want

* Yay, mostly | plenty of dirty talk and lots of degrading name calling but I retrospect I wished that he and I had more of a report in talking through how we were using her. I kind of used “slut” variations over and over. Any suggestions for more colorful name calling? Goals for next time…

– Feel the immense force into my throat and crotch as I get fucked from both ends at once

* Yay | she was spit roasted early and often.

– trying to occasionally seize control, tell them where and how hard to fuck me to make me explode. I might want to cum riding the new guy with my baby’s cock lodged deep in my throat, holding my nose, tits clamped for extra intensity

* Nay | while she did offer suggestions and desires, she did not cum in this way.

– having my boyfriend hold me by the throat, kiss me, ask me if I’m getting what I want while another man plows my ass

* Nay | I did not remember to do this. More choking next time is in order. Especially if you’ve read her last post.

– being an atm carousel, taking each of them in my ass and back in my mouth and back around again (I expect getting slapped and dirty talked to a lot during this one. I’m grinning thinking about it.)

* Nay | we both took turns fucking her mouth and ass, according to true ATM values. However, we didn’t do it at the same time, switching from each side of her. I really want to do this next time. Seems like a quick way to make her completely dick drunk quickly.

– hearing them both groan in pleasure, hearing them both admire what a skilled slut I am, how available I am for anything in their imagination

* Yay | a thousand times yay

– DP. for the love. Please. Please put a dick in each hole and go hard. Don’t stop when I scream.

* Yay | although not super successfully. She sat on my cock as I lay on the bed and he fucked her pussy. It was crazy feeling her fill up as he pounded her but I didn’t stay inside for long before popping out. We should have switched positions but didn’t. Room for improvement.

– taking two loads in my ass, one after the other, plugging them inside me, and going out to buy more beers

* Nay | we did both cum in her asshole, at different times. But we didn’t go through this more elaborate plan. It was incredibly hot that she even considered this. I have a growing obsession with her being spotted in public with cum running down her legs, or dried on her chest by a fellow slut. Anyone ever experience this?

– so much cum. Sprayed on my body like paint. Across my face. Dripping off my tits. Out of my ass and down my thighs at the liquor store, if I’m very brave (bf’s request 🙃)

* Yay | she was out cumrag, no doubt about it.I have the glorious vid to prove it (although I’m not sharing sorry not sorry). After a couple hours of fucking her ceaselessly, we both came on her face, one after another. She sat back on her heels and reveled in her cum shower, later saying she was in “slut heaven”.

– going for round 2 after a little banter, maybe being told to put on a terrible little show of some kind

* Yay | we actually went out for burgers between rounds 1 & 2.

– feeling someone fuck me/use a toy/collar me when I’m too cockdrunk with someone else to even see it coming

* Yay | she was collared and man handled.

– admiring my wrecked, puffy, possibly bruised body after the whole affair, trying to remember the exact moment the fingerprints got pressed into my skin

* Yay | she was marked and feeling it for days. She seemed to revel in this physical memory.

K I’m super wet so gonna end here for now.
Am I missing anything good? Suggestions welcome ✍

++++++++++++++

REVIEW OVER
Any questions?

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/prx7b3/threesome_checklist_review_howd_we_do_mfm