Amy is my girlfriend, she has a pretty bad gag reflex and can’t get most of my dick in her mouth (6 inches long, 5.2 inches girth).
Jacob and Tara were our best couple friends and we decided to spend New Years together. The year was 2005.
I got bold and asked Amy if she’d suck my dick when midnight struck. She looked flabbergasted and said “no, babe. Jacob and Tara are here too and we are going to celebrate together”.
Jacob, the genius that he is, quickly follows up with “I think that’s a great plan, Tara are you down to do it too?
Tara was thinking and it took a few seconds but she finally said “sure but I don’t want anyone else seeing my suck your dick… it’s a little degrading”. Jacob looked defeated, but that’s when I casually pull out a blanket and say, no one will be able to see with a couple of these over you two.
Tara took another minute of convincing but finally said “fine, but just cuz I love Jacob’s big cock”.
We all get set up in front of the tv in the living room and as the count down begins our ladies start get in position under the blanket.
I’m already rock hard, and Amy is under the blanket already, her hand at the base of my dick. Tara came out to put her hair in a pony tail, and since Amy wasn’t sucking my dick yet, just pointing it straight up to make a tent, Tara got an easy view of my size.
Tara went back under the blanket. The countdown hits 5 and the girls start. Amy begins gagging on my cock damn near immediately. When the clock hit midnight, I turn to Jacob and it my hand up asking for a high five.
I could see Tara’s head moving fluidly up and down Jacob’s cock, while Jacob could hear Amy choking on mine. Tara was so impressive, now I couldn’t see her sucking the dick, just the movements. I immediately noticed there was no gagging.
To my surprise, Tara sat up and said “Amy, need some help over there?”
Amy replied “what?”. Tara says “let’s switch for a little. Give these guys a new years they’ll never forget.”
Amy pulled her head out. Looked me in the eyes and could tell that I was 100% game. I knew Amy was always curious about other guys cocks…. “Let’s do it” she replies.
Without moving the blankets, they back up and switch spots. Before Tara disappears, she goes “I’m excited” gives me a wink, then ran her hand up my thigh.
Her hand found my cock and when she touched it she gave an audible “huh”.
I look over at Jacob and his face is in full bliss. Amy was working that dick…. And I noticed that she wasn’t gagging one bit.
That’s when I felt Taras lips hit my cock. And boy did it feel good. She got about 4.5 inches down before I heard her start gagging.
That’s when I realized that I must have a bigger dick than Jacob.
About two min goes by of us enjoying each other’s girlfriends when I ask do we really need the blankets?
Amy says “idc anymore, there are no more secrets I guess hah”
Tara was a little more hesitant. Then Jabcob says “let’s do it, I’ve got nothing to hide…. And I’d like to see some boobs….”
Without waiting for approval, Amy ripped off the blanket and took off her shirt and bra. Tara carefully pulled off the blanket and looked at her like “wtf”, and Amy replied “I’m already sucking his dick, are you really that worried?”.
Tara says “alright!” Then whips out her beautiful perky C cups and pulls the blanket off me revealing my cock. Amy goes “yep about what I expected”.
I look over and finally see Jacob’s cock. It was much thinner and about an inch shorter than mine. Jacob’s looks over at mine and he goes “damn I was hoping I had the bigger dick”.
Tara responded quickly “did you not hear me gagging? That was my hint lol” the girls get back to sucking dick topless.
About five min later I hear Jacob go “im about to cum” I look over and see Amy catch his load in her mouth. Amy sits up and just looks at Tara and said “i win”.
Tara take my cock out of her mouth and says “it’s not realy fair, I’m not it used to sucking a dick this big.” Realizing what she said she goes “that’s not what I meant—” Jacob cut her off as goes “we know what you meant, now finish up” clearly embarrassed.
Amy clearly saw how embarrassed he was and said “don’t worry, it isn’t that small. You got a fun dick to suck!”
I’m just sitting back with Tara sucking My cock and both Amy and Jacob watching, when I feel Amy start rubbing my shoulders, I look up at her tits are in my face.
I then look down at Tara licking the head of my cock Then all of a sudden deep throating me. I cum so much i can see Tara look worried she didn’t have enough mouth to hold it all. When I finish she just takes one big swallow and goes “finally, I thought I’d never get you off”
We say thank you to our ladies and just pass out watching a more. Best night of my life.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/p6wyr5/a_happy_new_year