My stepsister—we’ll call her Bethany—asked for my advice on increasing her OnlyFans audience, and it’s starting to make me uncomfortable. I guess I am posting here because I want to make sure I’m not the only one who thinks this whole thing is getting weird.
It started out the other day, with Bethany awkwardly asking out of the blue if I’d heard of the site while we were watching TV in the living room and just browsing on our phones. I said yes, but said I wasn’t a bigtime user or anything like that. (Lie.)
She admitted to me that she had been using the site to make extra money and increase her confidence about her body. For some reason Bethany is convinced that all guys just want to jerk off to thicker women who look like the Kardashians. My stepsister is on the skinnier side, though if I am being completely objective, she’s very cute and body looks great.
Anyway, she asked me not to mention any of this to our parents (my dad, her mom) and I said of course. She said she wanted my help choosing outfits that could boost her engagement and earnings on the site. Bethany helps me with shopping and has even helped me pick clothes for dates, so this doesn’t seem like a weird request.
We waited until yesterday when our parents were out of the house and she did a “runway show” in the living room. (Her idea.) She let me DJ the music on her bluetooth speaker and she would walk into the room to reveal the look she’d put together. The first few were too—I dunno—casual? Like low-cut tank tops and denim short shorts. The last few were kind of corny, like schoolgirl outfits and she’d even managed to find a nurse outfit from a Halloween costume store.
I said those were pretty good and that they really showed off her legs, which are long and toned, but that I wasn’t sure they showed off enough of her body. “I have no idea what OnlyFans users like,” I explained. (Lie.) “But I’m just not sure any of these are ‘it’ based on the Reddit memes I’ve seen about the site.” She playfully pouted and dramatically stomped off the “runway.”
Here’s where things started getting … interesting. From the other room she told me to put on her favorite song by The Weeknd. This made me uncomfortable because this track came on my Spotify playlist a few weeks ago while we were in the car and she told me it was the song that she lost her virginity to, and that it makes her feel extra sexy. But whatever, I put the song on.
She comes crawling—*crawling*—into the room on her hands and knees in a strappy piece of lingerie. I have no clue where she would even get something that looks like this. But it looks amazing on her. The material is tight in all the right places that make Bethany look like she has insane curves, and her boobs were practically spilling out. I could only see her from the front, but I knew this was a winner. (From a purely objective standpoint, of course.)
“Oh wow, that looks awesome, Beth,” I stammered. “Uh, that color looks great on you!” I had told my fair share of lies over the past few days, but right now I was telling the absolute truth. It was a light coral-pink color that made her skin look tan and smooth. She kept silently crawling across the living room, stopping at one point to roll on her back and basically grind the air to the beat of the song.
“Um, yes this one should definitely be in the keep pile,” I said. I was starting to worry that I was staring too much and I felt the tingle at the base of my neck that told me my mind was starting to slip into the gutter. “W-what else do you have lined up for the runway?”
“Nothing,” she said. But she said it in a weird out-of-breath way. “Haha, uh Beth, are you trying to do that weird talking thing—the ASMR stuff that you said some women do on OnlyFans?”
She stood up, looked me dead in the eye and bit her lip. Her tits were rising and falling and she was breathing hard. She seemed exasperated. “Let me ask you this: Does this outfit make you want to *fuck* me?”
“Holy shit, Beth, *what*?”
“I want to know if you are hard right now. Like, your cock. None of the other clothes seem to be your thing, and I want to know if what I’m wearing right now makes your *cock*. *Fucking*. *Hard*.”
She said the last words super slow, like she was tasting the syllables before she let them out of her mouth. At this point, my mind basically dissociated from my body because I didn’t want to know whether my dick was hard from watching my stepsister strut through our living room.
“Uh, that’s a really weird thing to ask, but if I theoretically saw this on OnlyFans, I’m sure my, uh, I’m sure this will make guys hard. Is … is everything okay? Did I say something wrong?”
“Nope, you’ve said everything right,” she said with an odd intensity. “I just want to make sure there isn’t anything you’re *not* saying. I want the complete truth about what guys want. About what *you* want.”
“Yes, okay? You look amazing. Really, Beth. This … this is definitely something you should wear on cam.”
The song ended and the tension in the room was suddenly gone. Bethany smiled and placed her hand on her hip. “Thanks, bro. I really appreciate your opinion.”
Bethany turned around and confidently walked out of the room, channeling her inner runway model. I can’t say for sure but I think she intentionally swayed her hips back and forth more than usual. Or maybe it was just more noticeable because of the skimpy pink thong between her cheeks.
A moment later, I could hear her changing in the other room and she said, “I’ll try these out and then we can do this again next week if I don’t see the results I want.”
Like I said, I want to make sure I’m not the only one who thinks this whole scenario is weird. And, like, I definitely had a slight cum stain in my boxers after her “show,” but I would never tell Beth that. Should I tell her that I can’t help her with this stuff anymore?
Edit: Fixed typo
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/p3q8jb/should_i_stop_giving_my_stepsister_onlyfans
No, I would most definitely keep judging her runway shows but be stoic and almost clinical. Take the power from her. She’s pushing you for a reaction and is succeeding in at least making you uncomfortable. If you treat it as the goal being to see how far she will go, you then control the situation. Time to make her uncomfortable. Maybe after a few weeks ask if she would like another opinion. Then ask if your best friend could come over and give his opinion.
To be honest, its a bit strange but nonetheless just be professional and objective it should be no problem. Try to involve someone else to make it more playful rather that sexual. I dunno….