A spinoff to this storyline HERE(Can be read without the old story context)
Part 1 of this story HERE
*A commissioned story*
Message me if you want me to write a story for you!
UPVOTE IF YOU ENJOYED THE STORY
Part 3
**Ashlee Tries Something New For Her Birthday**
The girls were getting along perfectly. Chloe was able to be a dominant figure in the bedroom while Amber and Ashlee got to be submissive ladies. They slowly started introducing the shy redhead to new kinks and toys over the next month. Ashlee was still reluctant to try many things but she tried anything that felt good.
Chloe had tried pushing the boundaries with Ashlee many times. Most of the time it went well but she had a hard line with anal. The redhead would not let Chloe use more than her tongue back there. She was too tight and found even a slight finger to be too much. Ashlee admitted that a part of it felt pleasurable but mostly it was awkward.
After knowing each other for a couple of months, the girls found out that Ashlee had her 26th birthday coming up in just a few weeks. Chloe and Amber were secretly planning a special party for the girl since she did not have any other friends or family in the new city. The blonde wanted to make sure it was fun for all three of them while putting a special focus on Ashlee for the special occasion.
It was difficult for the girls to keep the three-person party a secret while planning it. Ashlee was hanging out most afternoons so they had to be careful. A few times they almost let some of the information slip. The girls somehow were able to keep it from the redhead until the day of her birthday but it was not easy.
They had bought her a few gifts but the main birthday surprise was going to be the way they treated her for the day. Chloe thought it was a brilliant idea for the girl whose sex life was just starting to blossom. Everything seemed to be coming together nicely as the girls kept everything hidden.
Ashlee’s birthday was on a Sunday so on Friday before the girls started making sure the girl would be spending the day with them. As expected the redhead told them that she had nothing else to do.
“You should spend the day hanging out with us. We will try to make sure you have some fun when turning 26.” Amber offered with a big smile.
“That would be nice. No one else lives around here and I don’t have money to fly to my hometown,” Ashlee explained while telling them that she would be coming over for sure. She always enjoyed spending time with the girls. Amber and Chloe had become her best friends since they were the only ones she hung out with in the new city.
“Maybe we will get you a present,” Chloe teased before Ashlee left their house Friday night. That was all they needed to know to confirm that the surprise was going to happen. Ashlee went home excited for her first birthday in years.
The ginger girl went out on Saturday to buy a new dress for her birthday. She tried on a bunch of dresses before deciding on a form-fitting white one. It was not like her typical modest summer dress. This one was meant to impress the people seeing it. The top showed a little more cleavage than she would normally be comfortable with. While the skirt was just a few inches under her firm little butt.
Ashlee knew that it was not something she would wear out often but thought it would be perfect for a birthday with the girls. The morning before going to Chloe’s, the redhead made sure to do her hair for the special occasion. She braided the long red strands into a long french tail that hung down over her shoulder.
When she showed up at the apartment, she fixed her dress while ringing the doorbell. Chloe and Amber answered the door wearing only lingerie. Ashlee could not believe that they were daring enough to open a door like that. The girls were stunned by how sexy the redhead looked with braided hair and a slutty white dress.
“Well you dressed up for us too I see,” Chloe joked while pulling the redhead into the house. They all had to take a second to admire how good each other looked early in the afternoon. All of them were dressed to arouse.
Amber was wearing her hair in a long ponytail that rested on the back of her ass cheeks. Her thick body looked great in the bright yellow lace one piece. It left little to the imagination with her pierced nipples poking out of the lace. Her finger and toenails were all painted neon yellow to match her sexy outfit.
Chloe had her short hair spiked up for the night. She was wearing all black for the night. It was part of their surprise plan for Ashlee. Long leather boots covered most of her leg, just over the knee. Above that, she was already wearing her pink harnessed strap-on that made her ass look great. Then her perky white tits were covered by black straps that barely covered her nipples while holding her boobs close to her chest.
Ashlee was not wearing lingerie but it was her sluttiest dress yet. She had her perky breasts pushed up in the tight outfit. Her freckle-covered cleavage was spilling out of the low-cut neckline. Her thighs were exposed enough that she could not bend over without exposing herself to others. The black heels made her ass look great above her slender legs. Amber found her long braid in her hair to be sexy. It was similar to her ponytail but held together firmly.
“We got a gift for you to get started,” Chloe told the birthday girl before handing her a wrapped present. As she started opening it, the blonde said, “ Happy birthday. Another year older but just as sexy.”
“We thought you would like to match us,” Amber explained as Ashlee opened the lingerie. The redhead loved that they even thought to get her an outfit that had a tiny skirt on it. Her outfit was a see-through red bra that had a sheer gown hanging down from it. The skirt was just long enough to cover her pussy while leaving most of her butt still exposed. It made the girls wet watching her change out of her dress into their gift.
“This is so sweet of you two. I love the little skirt,” Ashlee thanked them with a sexy little spin to make her skirt lift to expose her pale nude body underneath. It was already visible through the sheer material but it was to tease them.
“We thought you would like that detail. You look so sexy in it too,” the brunette said while Chloe nodded her head to show that she agreed.
“So what did you two have planned for these outfits?” Ashlee asked as she looked down at her perfect body. She was already starting to think it was her best birthday in the past few years. It was better than spending the day shopping alone.
“We have an exciting night planned so that we can all explore our fetishes,” Chloe said before reaching behind the sofa to grab the next gift. There was a box covered in red paper for her to open.
“You got me a pair of collars?” Ashlee said when opening it. The girl did not understand why there were two and had never worn one before.
“There is one in there for me too. You will love wearing it and being pulled around,” Amber said biting her lip while thinking about it. She could not wait to see if the redhead enjoyed being on a leash as much as she did.
Chloe reached into the box and grabbed both collars out. One was purple with the word, “SLUT” written in sparkly letters on the leather. That one went on the neck of Amber. The other collar said, “Princess” in sparkly letters but was on a pink leather strap. Chloe put that on the redhead’s neck before stepping back to see them.
“Why does she get slut and I get Princess?” Ashlee asked as she thought about what the girls were trying to imply by it.
“She lets me fuck her in the ass. A princess would never do that,” Chloe teased before putting the leashes on each of them. Then she tugged them gently to guide them to the bedroom. She teased them with her ass while walking in the front. Ashlee could not argue with the logic of why the collars gave them different nicknames.
Ashlee could already see a few new toys around the room. The most noticeable one was a foldable black table with metal loops coming out of each corner. Her imagination quickly guessed what that could be used for.
“Since it is your special day, my slut and I are going to be working together to please you. We even got some new toys for you to try being more submissive with us,” Chloe explained while sitting both girls down on the new table.
“Some of the new toys I have been wanting to try for months so you will love it,” Amber said to hype up the shy redhead. She could not wait to see her opening up for them again. As a fellow sub, she loved seeing others learning to express themself.
“That is enough chatting for you slut,” Chloe said while giving her a sexy smirk. Then she ordered Amber, “Why don’t you get on your knees and get Ashlee ready for us?” The brunette knew exactly what her girlfriend meant by that.
Amber got down on her knees in front of the ginger. Her hands spread open her slender white legs, exposing her pink pussy between them like a treasure. Amber smiled as she looked into Ashlee’s eyes before licking the wet lips. It sent shivers up the ginger’s spine as her labia were spread open.
While she was getting warmed up, Chloe went to get something from the closet. She returned with a few black ropes in her hand. Ashlee moaned out when seeing them as she knew what she was going to get to try. The redhead told them about a fetish she had to be tied down by a lover for passionate sex that she did not have to worry about being too rough. Chloe found the pure request to be sexy so she had to make it happen.
“That is enough for now,” Chloe said as she pulled Amber’s leash to get her out of the wet pussy. The brunette’s tongue tried to reach out for more but obeyed reluctantly. She had not gotten enough yet.
The tall blonde grabbed Ashlee’s arm while pulling her down onto the table. Her back laid on the cold metal as her wrist was tied in a knot. It was tighter than the cuffs that were used in the past. The constricting feeling made the redhead start feeling her body react to the arousal of being tied down. That arm was connected to the corner above her head.
“This is my big surprise?” Ashlee playfully asked while biting her lip seductively. She was so excited to have Chloe take control in that way.
“This is only the beginning,” the blonde teased back before giving her a slap on the ass. Amber crawled up onto the table. She wanted to kiss her while being tied down. The thick brunette’s ass was up in the air just begging for Chloe to slap it. Their lips met just before the blonde slapped her fat white ass.
They made out on the table while Chloe went around to each corner to tie down the ginger’s limbs. Once they were all bound tightly to the table, she put two fingers inside each girl to show that she was finished. Chloe let them continue kissing for a few minutes while she made sure they were nice and wet down there.
“Alright girls, that is enough for now,” the blonde ordered while slapping them on their hips to get them to separate. Ashlee’s face was bright red from being so aroused already. Chloe could tell that she was going to love the rest of the night.
“Now that she is tied down for her fetish, we can show her what one of ours is,” Amber told the other two girls while standing up from the table. It made Ashlee wonder what they meant by that statement.
“What fetish are you teaching me about today?” The redhead asked in a playful voice. In the past, all their fetishes had been fun for the most part. Ashlee felt safe knowing that they would not make her do anything she did not feel comfortable doing.
“We love playing with each other’s asses as you know. So today we are going to show you our special plugs,” Chloe explained as the brunette collected the toys from the closet to show off. Amber already stuffed her long foxtail in her asshole before bringing a pink gemmed plug to Chloe.
Ashlee knew exactly what a butt plug was but had never seen one in person. Both girls already knew that from their subtle questioning in the past. Amber handed Chloe her toy before going to flaunt her tail in the redhead’s face. She put her round ass cheeks just at the edge of the table before bending over to give Ashlee a good view.
“That looks like it hurt,” Ashlee said when seeing how it spread her open to dangle the long tail out the rear.
“They feel great,” Chloe moaned out while slipping her chrome plug into her tight ass. It only needed a little saliva to get her butt to accept it.
“That one is my favorite,” Ashlee said as she saw the tall girl turn to show off the sparkling gem stuffed in her ass.
Once the girls felt properly stuffed, Chloe went back over to the birthday girl displayed on the table like a treat. Both the girls started running their fingernails gently across Ashlee’s pale skin to tease her. They giggled while watching her try to squirm still constrained to the black metal table.
Amber climbed onto the table again. This time the thick lady got on all fours facing the opposite way of Ashlee. Her tail hung down from the table with the red-haired braid. The brunette lowered her hungry pussy down on Ashlee’s face before starting to suck on her clit. In the 69 position, they started trying to pleasure each other.
Chloe took a moment to watch as her plan began to unfold. Both of the submissive women were putting on a show for her. The redhead loved feeling sexual arousal while being tied down. It made everything seem more intense than it really was.
While Ashlee practiced her box eating skills, Chloe climbed on the table to sit on her knees between the ginger’s slender legs. Her hands started stroking her soft skin as she poked at her mound with the strap-on. The redhead wanted to ask her to put it inside but had her mouth covered at the moment.
The brunette stopped licking her clit to watch as the toy spread open her pink hole. It pushed through to make it to her sweet core. Amber could feel the pleasurable humming of the girl moaning while trying to eat her pussy underneath.
“She loves that,” Amber teased before starting to circle the little sensitive nub with her tongue again.
“Then she is really going to love this,” Chloe said as the toy started being pushed through the tight entrance of her body. The pink hole expanded around the realistic looking dildo as Ashlee moaned
Her humming lips were pressed deep into the pussy of Amber as the redhead moaned out loudly from the penetration. The brunette loved the way it felt, almost like a vibrator. She was rubbing her pussy across Ashlee’s face while Chloe started to fill her up with the pleasurable plastic rod. All of them were enjoying the birthday surprise.
Chloe took control of the brunette’s motion by grabbing her long ponytail to manipulate her like a robot. She made her shake her mouth rapidly over the clit until Ashlee’s legs started shaking while constrained to the table. Not being able to clench up made her orgasm feel crazy. Her entire body tugged at the ropes but was not strong enough to break free.
When she finally reached her climax, both girls could see the cream on the toy. They loved seeing that she enjoyed their gifts so much. Amber stopped licking her clit and dismounted her from the table. She walked around to the back of Chloe to give her a taste of her tongue. They kissed while looking down on the redhead.
Then the brunette slid down her back like a seductive serpent. She gripped her firm ass cheeks in both hands to spread her open. Amber slowly twisted the butt plug until it slipped out of her ass. Then she replaced it with her slippery tongue. She started by rimming the outside while trying to keep her face stuffed in the thrusting cheeks.
“What is she doing to make your face do that?” Ashlee asked when noticing her showing pleasure through facial expressions.
“Amber has her tongue in my ass right now,” Chloe told her in a sexy voice. Then she stopped thrusting to lean down to steal a kiss from the ginger woman. Their lips met as they moaned into each other’s mouths.
That gave Amber full access to her gaping hole. Her tongue went as deep as she could before starting to tease along her inner walls. Chloe could not hide the arousal. Her pussy was leaking juices down the harness of her strap-on.
“You are soaking wet tonight baby,” Amber informed the girls before licking up some of the sweet nectar from the leather strap. Then she returned to her girlfriend’s tasty asshole to finish her off.
Chloe was starting to gyrate her hips to let the toy wiggle around inside of the core of Ashlee. Both girls were feeling the euphoric pleasure from exploring a fetish as they kissed on the table passionately. Ashlee wondered if Amber would get jealous since she did not know how hot the brunette found it to share her girlfriend.
The girl’s moaning synced up as they started getting closer to having an orgasm. Chloe found it difficult to continue moving her hips when being brought to a climax by her girlfriend’s skillful tongue in the ass. She powered through until seeing that Ashlee was going to climax too. It took nearly a minute of gasping between the girls before they both relaxed at the same time. Their pussys flowed like a river on the inside as Chloe collapsed on Ashlee’s chest like dead weight. Amber slipped her tongue out, knowing her job was done.
Before Ashlee could even start to recover on the table, Chloe and Amber got ready for the final present of the night. The short brunette went over to the closet to grab the final box. It was tiny but they knew that it would be fun for Ashlee.
“How many gifts did you two get me tonight?” The redhead cheerfully asked while accepting another present. She had to wait until Chloe finished untying her from the table. She left the ropes dangling from her limbs since she knew that there was still more to come.
“Here open it up,” Amber told her while passing the small box over. The redhead ripped the paper off before opening it up. Inside was a tiny remote control and a pink toy that could be controlled from inside her pussy. She was excited to use it even though she was unsure how to put the odd rubber shape inside her body.
“Try it out,” Chloe said with a big smile on her face. The blonde took the remote while Ashlee started sliding it into her wet hole. A little pink antenna hung out of her pussy before Chloe pressed the button to make it buzz.
“This is going to be a fun one,” Ashlee moaned when feeling the powerful little toy vibrate. She closed her legs but it still got a connection.
“Now let me get you tied back down,” Chloe ordered with a maniacal grin. She quickly bent Ashlee over the table as her puffy nipples touched the flat metal. The redhead barely had time to react before each of the ladies grabbed her arms and tied them to the opposite end of the table. Then they went down to spread her ankles when tying them to the legs of the table with little hooks on the end.
“What are you going to do to me?” Ashlee teased since she knew that it would be something that she would find pleasure in. Neither of the girls answered before Amber climbed onto the table in front of the redhead’s face.
“You are going to eat Amber out while I teach you to enjoy my fingers,” the blonde said before slapping the princess on the ass.
Before Ashlee was able to ask where her fingers would be going, her face was shoved back into Amber’s mound. The brunette had control this time as she started making her lick up and down her slit. Chloe bit the pale skin of her soft ass playfully. Ashlee’s butt clenched when feeling the teeth dig into her soft mound. Just as it clenched, the blonde pressed the button to buzz the toy inside. It made her toes curl on the hardwood floors.
Then the blonde started kissing and licking all around her asshole. Ashlee could tell that she was warming her up for another rimjob. It took a while but the redhead started to enjoy the playful licking back there since meeting. Chloe was a little more aggressive this time as she wanted to get the birthday girl to push her boundaries a bit. She slowly worked the tip of her tongue deeper and deeper into her tight asshole. Throughout the blonde was randomly hitting the button to vibrate the pink toy.
It was more than Ashlee was expecting but she tried to enjoy it. Amber made sure to keep her busy with her wet pussy so Chloe could explore her freely. The redhead was still moaning when her tongue started being pushed in and out of her ass. That made Chloe happy, she knew that she was at least enjoying something inside her butt.
While eating her ass, Chloe soaked her fingers in lube under the table before moving them up towards the ginger’s genitals. In one swift motion, she slipped her tongue out and replaced it with her fingers. The blonde was careful not to go too deep and get caught. She was grinning from ear to ear when Ashlee did not stop her like she had done in the past many times.
Ashlee did not know there were fingers in her. She still thought it was the slimy tongue poking her butt. The redhead slowly caught on when feeling them start to get deeper inside. Chloe was busted when she got bold enough to curl her fingers against the inner walls of Ashlee’s asshole. It made the ginger stop eating Amber’s pussy.
The brunette looked down as she asked earnestly, “What is wrong Ashlee?” She did not know how far Chloe had gotten down there. Amber was caught up in her own pleasure until it was stopped abruptly.
“Did you put fingers in my ass?” Ashlee asked quickly after the pussy was pulled away from her mouth.
Chloe continued finger fucking her ass while reply, “I replaced my tongue with them almost 5 minutes ago. You seem to be loving it.” It turned the blonde on to know that she had successfully pushed the limit back but had to make sure it stuck.
“I guess it does feel good but be careful and no more butt surprises,” the redhead warned before returning to her meal between Amber’s thick thighs.
The lesbians smiled at each other when knowing that they had broken her down a little more from her sexual innocence. All of them resumed having sex on the metal table. Chloe was fingering her asshole with two stuffed deep inside the anal cavity. Her mouth went down to tease her clit below. Ashlee was feeling intense pleasure from her first time being fingered in the butt. She struggled to continue eating Amber’s pussy but wanted to taste her cum. The brunette was lucky enough to just get to take it.
A few minutes passed before Ashlee’s restrained legs were shaking. If she was not tied down by her arms to the tabletop, she would have collapsed to her knees. Chloe did not stop when seeing how intense the orgasm was going to be. Amber could see the lust in her girlfriend’s eyes from getting to be a woman’s first anal pleaser. It aroused the submissive woman until the tongue on her clit caused an orgasm.
Together, Amber and Ashlee moaned out loudly as they reached a climax. The redhead was surprised when Amber squirted all over her chin. It tasted better than she expected as it splashed into her mouth. The brunette was gasping for air as Chloe stood up to watch the aftermath of her birthday surprise. They were all worn out after hours of playing together in the bedroom. Ashlee was panting while lying limp on the table.
Chloe untied her before carrying the smaller girl to the bed. She could tell that the princess was going to need some time to recover. Then the blonde laid down beside her with the redhead in her arm. Amber crawled into the bed on the other side of her girlfriend as the girls passed out after the perfect birthday party. Ashlee could not believe how things turned out but did not wish to change a thing.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/nchlnh/ashlee_f25_explores_her_sexuality_with_lesbian