[M]y New [F]ucktoy – Day 2 [LONG]

Wednesday morning and a text pops up: “I still hate you” Cindy, why am I not surprised? For those who didn’t read the first story, Cindy is my bitchy sister-in-law that I turned into my little fuck toy the day before. I responded quickly “I don’t fucking care. Go shave that messy twat of yours. I want it bare and smooth tomorrow morning.” No response, so I went back to work.

The next morning, I was up around six and knew my brother usually left for work early, so I texted Cindy: “This morning, after you shower and make sure that your cunt and ass are baby smooth, I want you to put on the outfit from Tuesday. Panties, jeans, and the shirt. If anyone at drop off asks about the stains, just tell them you’re my little cum slut. I’ll see you at nine.”

Her one worded response: “Gross”. To my pleasure, when I got to the house, she was in the same plaid top and stained white jeans. I could see the panty outline and they looked similar, so this little slut actually listened. After closing the door behind me, she came in as if she wanted a kiss, but I spun her around a little forcefully and smacked her ass. “Ow”

“Upstairs, now, bitch” I commanded. She was flush but did as I asked. I walked behind her and could clearly smell the mix of dried cum and arousal as I watched her ass sway up the stairs. “My good little slut is going to suck my balls dry on the bed she shares with my asshat of a brother. Then, if you are good, I’ll let you scream into his pillow as I bury my cock into your fucking ass.”

She did not comment, but she faltered a little on the stairs, so I knew each word hit home and was driving her crazy. I followed her into the bedroom and told her to strip. While watching her undress, I slowly did the same. Seeing her completely naked for the first time, I was impressed how well she kept in shape. Her tits were not huge, but she had pert nipples begging to be pinched and playfully bit. I was happy to see she shaved that mess of hair and was smooth. Her thick pussy lips were sticking out and glistening in the sun. She was clearly wet! I wanted to throw her on the bed and dive between her legs, but before I even considered giving her the satisfaction of oral pleasure, I need to exert my dominance.

I moved to the edge of the bed and sat down. “Cindy, kneel” I commanded. She did and moved to suck my cock. I pull her head back though and told her to wait. Lying back, I lifted one of my legs and told her to suck my balls. “What? Suck your what?” “My balls slut. Take them in my mouth and suck on them. She hesitated, but then moved in. I cannot say I was surprised she’s never sucked on someone’s balls before, but still, I was a little amused. I grabbed her head in encouragement and held her against me as she sucked and licked my ball sack. Like my cock, I would guess my balls are average and not too hard to suck on without gagging. I shave and wax, so I am smooth. Always enjoyed the feeling of bare skin against bare skin, so lost interest in keeping hairy. Cindy’s hesitation did not last long and within a minute, she was sucking like a champion. She even grabbed hold of my hard cock and stroked while getting into it.

After a few minutes of ball licking enjoyment, I pulled her head back and moved a bit, exposing more of my ass to her. “Go ahead slut. Lick and tongue my asshole.”

“No fucking way. That’s disgusting!”

I answered by grabbing her ponytail and forcing her head to me. I was a little off so rather than her mouth hitting my ass, her nose did, slightly parting my tight hole. “Oh my god, I just fucked your ass with my nose.”

“You did and unless you want to do it again, lick it you stupid cunt.”

This time, again with hesitation, she gingerly stuck her tongue out and flicked against my ass. I absolutely love getting my ass rimmed and tongued. Hell, I love ass play in general, but those are other stories. I’m clean and showered that morning, which Cindy quickly figured out, because before long, she was licking and sucking at my asshole without further need of encouragement. I let go of her head and used both hands to hold my legs up. She alternated between tonguing my tight asshole and rubbing it with her finger. After getting into it, she started to go to town between my cock, balls and ass. Guys and Gals, if you have not done or had this done before, I highly recommend it. It feels incredible and while Cindy was not the best I’ve ever experienced, the girl made up in effort. She definitely wants to show me she was my good little slut.

“Suck my cock now until I drain my balls down your throat, you stupid slut!” Seconds later, as promised, I unloaded into her mouth. She coughed and swallowed as she tried to take all of it, but it was too much and she finally sat back on her knees, cum dripping down her chin onto her chest. The site was kind of sexy, but….

“Get over her and bend over the bed. I told you to let me drain my balls down your throat, not let it dribble over your chest.” She was bent over, half on the bed, half on my lap. Her perfect white ass presented high in the air for me to slap away at. I was gentle and only gave her a few whacks. She bit into the bed cover to keep quiet. While still in the same position, I reached in and started to massage her clit. My hand was tight against her ass and pussy, so while I played with her little nub, I was able to put a small amount of pressure against both areas.

Once two of my fingers were sufficiently coated in her juices, I slid them into her ass. This time, like the last, she tensed, but different from before, she didn’t try to move away. I was afraid she was going to eat a hole through the bedcover based on how hard she was sucking down on it, but I kept up, slowly building pace until both fingers were buried deep inside her ass. It felt amazing as she involuntarily contracted and relaxed against my fingers, her body still trying to understand why it was being violated. As with the last time, her pussy was a flow of leaking juices.

“You like when I violate your ass, don’t you, you worthless waste of space?” I have asked, half joked. She moaned into the blanket again. I couldn’t believe how turned on she got by being verbally degraded. I stopped fingering her and slapped her ass again, this time going until both cheeks were nice and rosy red. I told her to get up and get on the bed on all fours.

She moved quickly into place, staring at me with tears in her eyes. Behind the tears, the look was pure lust and desire as she silently begged me to fuck her. I walked behind her and admired the view. Her ass cheeks were really red and her asshole slightly puckered. Her pussy lips, wide open and so much more inviting without a jungle of hair surrounding, visibly dripped with juices. I couldn’t help it, so I got on my knees and dove my face between her legs. Her muskiness was almost overpowering, but I persevered and explored her with my tongue. Cindy definitely had a more “lasting” aroma than my fiancé, but to me, pussy is pussy and I can’t get enough. She came while I sucked on her clit. I was surprised because trying to eat someone out in this position usually makes for far less ability to access than other ways, but the girl creamed my face, crying out over and over that she was cumming.

Nothing gets a dick harder than a woman crying out that you have made her cum, so there I was ready for round 2. Before moving to the main event, I rimmed around her ass and gave it a good tonguing. Cindy was squirming and moaning her approval.

I made sure my cock was lined up, grabbed Cindy’s hips, and pulled her back onto my dick. We both groaned in pleasure as her lips greedily engulfed my hard cock. Neither of us needed encouragement as we both slammed into one another. This time, I’m sure my dick pounded in and out of her wet and willing pussy for ten to fifteen minutes before, fortunately or unfortunately, she cried out that arm had cramped. The stoppage led to a few hard slaps against her ass for good measure, but then I decided to switch positions.

I lied on the bed and told her: “Ass slut, straddle me and slide that hard cock into your ass. I want you to look in my eyes as you sit on my dick. Don’t stop until you feel my balls against your cheeks.” Her face was already flush but she eagerly complied. Once in position, she reached back, gripped my dick, and slowly sat into me, letting my cockhead part her nice, hot, tight hole. She was painfully slow, but deliberate in letting me in. Each small movement towards engulfing my cock, she paused. During each pause, I pinched one of her nipples, laughing as she cried out, stared daggers at me, and clenched against my dick, all at once.

“Admit it you little cunt. You love being fucked in the ass! From now on, I may just exclusively fuck that tight stay at home ass of yours. You’d like that you little bitch.” That’s all it took. Those words, deliberately and slowly delivered while staring into her eyes and she took my dick, all the way to the balls. “Fuck you Jake! You are such an asshole!” That comment brought a slap to her cheek. It was quick and delivered in a way to sting, but not cause lasting damage. She was surprised, but it only caused her to grind against my dick harder. I reached up and grabbed her throat, again gently enough not to cause pain, but forceful enough to let her know she was mine and under my control. Our bodies continually gyrated, meeting as her ass took my cock until her cheeks hit my balls, until I finally couldn’t control the building pressure and let loose in her ass. As my balls tightened, I reached up and pinched her nipples, holding tight while my cum shot deep into her ass. It was too much for her and soon she convulsed and cried out. For a second, I thought she may have squirted because I could feel the puddle of juices against me. No, she was that turned on from being fucked and manhandled that she came really, really hard against me.

She collapsed on the bed next to me, unmoving despite my milky cum leaking from her gaped asshole. We were both spent and ended up falling asleep for an hour nap. We woke up, both startled that we were still tangled together. I must have shown on my face that I was worried, because Cindy started to get up and said: “don’t worry, even toys are allowed to get a little love now and again.”

I followed her into the bathroom and watched as she turned on the water and peed. No, watching her pee was not a turn on, but it did help serve the purpose of letting her know she had no privacy. Once the water was warm, she went to get into the shower, but I had other ideas. I pushed her towards the toilet bowl and had her sit. The seat lid was down and likely cold, because she jumped a little when she hit it. Standing in front of her, I grabbed her by the ponytail and pushed her towards my quickly hardening cock.

She was still a little groggy with sleep, but right before parting her lips, I could feel a little resistance, so I figured she realized she was about to suck a dick that was in her ass an hour before. One more little bit of pressure and too late, my cock was in her mouth. She gave in and quickly started sucking me off. Before too long, the steamy shower had the room completely fogged and I was sweating profusely. I pulled away and pulled her into the shower.

Needing no encouragement, she put both hands against the wall, leaned back and gave me a clear opening to push my cock in her waiting pussy. I won’t lie, pounding my sister-in-law in the shower for twenty plus minutes, knowing I was violating everything sacred to my fucking dick of a brother, and driving up his water cost, gave me a huge amount of satisfaction. And yes, I realize I have family issues that I have not shared, but dick or not, you have to admit right now, you wish you were me. Cindy’s tight wet twat tightened multiple times against me as she came in a continuous wave of mini orgasms.

After a very long time in the steamy shower, I knew I was close. “Turn around and swallow my cum. You know what happens if you don’t, so be a good fuck toy and don’t make a mess.” She turned and slid to her knees, full in the jet of the shower. Whether it was practice over the last two days, the position or just the heat in the shower, really did not matter, but somehow, Cindy was able to take 3/4’s of my rock-hard cock into her mouth, slowly savoring each inch. She reached out and grabbed my balls, grinding her hand gently against them. Each time, the tip of her finger grazed my asshole, sending waves of pleasure direct to my cock. I wanted to last forever, but like all good things, I came to a hard, quick end. Being the third time, I think it was far less volume and Cindy had no issues swallowing and cleaning me dry.

We finished our shower and got dressed. It was close to noon and I had to get work done. Before leaving, Cindy asked if I would be at the family dinner Saturday. I responded: “Instructions to follow” and left, leaving her wonder what I had up my sleeve.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nc7bpn/my_new_fucktoy_day_2_long