A spinoff to this story line [HERE](https://www.reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/n9pmuy/james_pays_a_lesbian_couple_for_kinky_sex_part_3/)(Can be read without the old story context)
*A commissioned story*
Message me if you want me to write a story for you!
UPVOTE IF YOU WANT PART 2
**Part 1**
Chloe And Amber Pretend To Be Exploring Too
One afternoon Chloe was at the gym. It was a normal way for the fit girl to spend her time. She was running on the treadmill when she noticed a beautiful redhead on one of the stationary bikes. Chloe could not stop looking over at her. The girl’s ass was pushed back on the bike giving her the perfect view from across the gym.
After a few minutes of watching her from a distance, Chloe decided to try to get closer to her. She got off of the treadmill to get on the bike beside her. The redhead did not seem to mind that she took the bike next to her even though there were 10 others to choose from. Girls were too busy watching for creepy men to have their eye out for lesbians too.
Chloe tried to spark up a conversation by pretending not to know how the bike works, “Excuse me, do you know how to change the resistance on this?” The redhead took out one headphone to hear her question.
“Oh, of course, it is the red knob on the front there,” the sexy redhead said before wiping sweat off her forehead.
“Thank you, I am Chloe by the way,” she said with a smile.
“Just being friendly. My name is Ashlee,” the redhead responded happily. She was breathing hard from the endurance bike.
“Are you new here? I have not seen you around before,” Chloe asked while adjusting the resistance. She could not believe how good the woman beside her looked.
Ashlee was a 25-year-old ginger girl with long fiery red hair and freckles. She was about 5’4 and had a slender build to her body. With a small frame, her long legs made her little round ass look amazing in her dark green yoga pants. It was hard to tell underneath the grey tank top and black sports bra but she had a nice rack on her too, 34C.
“I just moved into town about a week ago,” Ashlee explained while continuing her exercise. She seemed to be enjoying the company so Chloe stuck around.
Chloe rode the bikes with her until the redhead finished her workout. They chatted about where Ashlee had moved from and why she decided to move to that town. It seemed like the girls had a decent amount in common besides Ashlee was much more reserved than Chloe. After the workout the two of them found out that they basically had the same workout schedule. That meant they would see each other most weeknights at the gym. They decided that they could both use a workout partner.
Over a couple of weeks, they would do their cardio training together at the gym. Ashlee always got there a little earlier than the blonde, Chloe. The redhead girl just assumed that she was making a new friend after moving. While Chloe was trying to get close enough to her to invite her over to meet her girlfriend for sex. It was a major turn-on for the blonde woman to convert a straight girl.
Although Chloe was in a long-term relationship, she knew that seducing Ashlee would not be an issue. The blonde girl with a pixie cut was dating a brunette with long hair named Amber. Both of them were escorts who only worked together. They had been together for two years and were very open in their relationship. As long as Chloe shared Ashlee then it would not be a problem between the lesbian couple. That was her plan.
Meanwhile, Ashlee met Chloe at the gym each night unknown to her plan. The blonde was always very sweet but subtly flirty. She would get handsy when spotting Ashlee during weight lifting days. When running or on the bikes, Chloe was always catching peeks at her ass from behind. A few times she even got a glance in her stall in the locker room. Ashlee was too shy to change in front of other people.
Chloe was able to learn a lot of useful information about Ashlee over the few weeks too. She found out that the redhead was not a promiscuous girl. In fact, she had only been with two men at her age. That made Chloe want to turn her out even more. Knowing it could be a challenge was fun for her.
One Friday night, Chloe decided that she did not wait until after the weekend to see Ashlee again. She waited until they were changing in the locker room to bring it up. The blonde figured it was the best time.
“Do you wanna come to hang out for a girl’s night tomorrow?” Chloe asked with a hopeful look on her face.”
“Sure. That beats sitting around the house alone,” Ashlee joked since she knew her normal weekend would involve books and movies.
“It will be me and my best friend Amber so just come by around 8,” the blonde explained before giving her the address. Chloe was keeping the fact that she was a lesbian that dated Amber a secret for now. It was a part of her plan to turn the straight girl.
While Chloe went home to tell Amber the great news, Ashlee went home to decide what to wear. It was her first time going to hang out with her new friend outside of the gym. The redhead picked out one of her many dresses. It was all she typically wore outside of the gym. She was a modest girl, only allowing them to be a little higher than her knee while showing a little cleavage. For her girl’s night, Ashlee decided on wearing a black summer dress. It was a casual dress so it was loose and flowy.
Ashlee rang the doorbell just before 8 o’clock. She nervously waited at the door for an answer. The only reason she was even feeling anxious was knowing she was going to be meeting another new girl tonight. Her nerves calmed down a lot when the door opened to the two young ladies. The lesbians were both younger than Ashlee since they were barely 20. They were cheerful as they told her to come inside.
“We were just about to open a bottle of wine,” Amber said before introducing herself to the redhead.
“Then we were going to watch a movie,” Chloe pointed out while going to get the bottle and some glasses from the kitchen.
Amber took the redhead into the living room while they waited for Chloe to get their drinks. She tried to tell Ashlee that she was happy to meet her after hearing great things about her from the blonde. The conversation started slow because they both had submissive personalities but they quickly hit it off. Ashlee felt that she had a better connection with the brunette already. They just had so much in common.
“Who wants a drink?” Chloe said when returning to the room with her hands full. She put it all down on the coffee table before pouring three glasses.
The movie started but the girls were not paying much attention. Before the opening scene even started they were having a new conversation. For the first half of the movie, they talked about fun things to do in the city and the best places to get services. Then as the alcohol started kicking in the conversation became more open.
“Sorry if this is weird to ask but are your nipples pierced?” Ashlee asked after noticing them through her white shirt. The thick brunette giggled at the question before pulling the shirt tighter to her chest.
“I got them pierced when I turned 18,” Amber explained while making them clearly visible through her thin shirt. Ashlee looked but felt a little weird about it.
“Did it hurt? I have thought about getting mine done but am too afraid,” the redhead explained while wincing at the idea of the needle going through her nipple.
“It doesn’t feel much different from getting them pinched,” Amber said before jokingly winking at the ginger girl. Ashlee laughed even though it was a little awkward for her. She was not that open about her sex life.
“Are those the only piercings you have?” Ashlee asked since there were plenty of other possibilities for her to have them hidden.
“For now. Chloe has a couple though,” the brunette told her before inviting her girlfriend into the conversation.
“I know about her tongue but what are the others,” Ashlee asked after her interest peaked. The blonde stuck her tongue out to show the ring in it.
“That one and I have my clit pierced,” Chloe explained as she watched the innocent redhead try to take in the information. There was an odd look on her face for a moment. Ashlee did not know how to respond as she sat silently on the couch.
“You really got that done? What made you want that?” Ashlee wondered as it seemed like something no one in real life actually did. She was the first person that the girl had met with anything like it.
“Yes, I got it done. It was just something fun to do and my partners usually like it too,” Chloe teased.
After the conversation dried up, they all started watching the movie again. Their attention did not stay on it long. Ashlee kept glancing at Amber’s pierced nipples while wondering if she could handle getting it done. It was not for a sexual reason that she looked at her chest. The redhead was just curious.
“Do you wanna see the piercings?” Amber playfully asked when catching the girl looking at her boobs. She was not trying to embarrass her but wanted to be flirty. It caught the shy redhead off guard being called out for staring though.
“No, I j-just was thinking about if I could handle getting mine done,” Ashlee nervously explained the truth so there would be no issues. She could feel her heartbeat rising from the awkward moment.
“It is okay. I can show you them so you see it isn’t that big of a needle and they don’t hurt at all after a few days of healing,” the brunette explained.
Chloe could see what Amber was trying to do. She liked watching her try to get a chance to expose herself to the shy guest. It turned her on to watch her sexy girlfriend help corrupt the redhead.
“That seems a little weird. I can just take your word for it,” Ashlee told her while trying to back out of the conversation. Then Chloe decided to nudge her right back in.
“You know, I have never seen them either,” the blonde lied to try to keep it going between them. She could tell that the new girl was too nervous to say anything. Even though they were younger, Ashlee just wanted to fit in.
“Here I will show the both of you. I mean, we are all girls anyway. We have seen a pair of titties before,” Amber joked while grabbing the bottom of her white shirt. Then her arms pulled it over her head before dropping it on the couch. Her perky tits were fully exposed with no bra underneath. She used her hands to lift them from under to give the girls a good view.
“Does it hurt if someone pinches or tugs on it?” Chloe asked already knowing the answer but it was leading her into something else.
“Not more than it normally would. Besides it occasionally getting caught on a shirt, it is like any of your nipples,” the brunette said before pulling on one of them playfully. Ashlee was shocked to see her doing it but thought the piercing looked great.
Then Chloe reached out to poke the metal ring in her girlfriend’s little pink nipple. Ashlee wondered how Amber would react since she did not even ask to touch it. The girl did not seem to care as the blonde grabbed the ring with two fingers.
“So this feels normal?” Chloe asked while lightly twisting, pinching, and tugging on her pierced tit.
“It feels pretty good actually,” Amber flirted jokingly while letting her breast be groped by the short-haired blonde woman. Then she decided to be friendly as she offered Ashlee a try, “You wanna feel one?”
The redhead felt her face getting flush when being offered to touch a boob. She nervously told Amber, “That is okay. I don’t think I need to, I see that you are not being hurt by it.” Then she tried to shyly look away.
“Girl, you are way too shy. I know you are just as curious as Chloe,” Amber teased before grabbing her wrist. Ashlee did not know how to react when the brunette started moving her hand to her breast. She was not being forceful but the redhead could not make herself stop it. Instead, she mentally prepared herself for it to happen.
“This is going to be weird,” Ashlee said just as her hand made contact with her breast. It was softer than she expected. Against her palm, she could feel the metal ring. Amber used her hand to make the ginger girl squeeze the soft mound.
“See it does not hurt and it isn’t weird either,” the brunette said while letting Ashlee’s hand free. Once her hand was free to stop groping, it did not. Ashlee was too focused on how much different her breast felt from her own. The girl started touching the ring in her nipple lightly before pulling on it.
“She is having fun,” Chloe teased before the redhead got embarrassed again. Her hand snapped away from the tit before Amber put her shirt back down. The two younger girls could tell that Ashlee was enjoying the playful flirting by the way she blushed. She had rosy cheeks while trying to hide the embarrassment.
“Have you never experimented with a friend before?” Amber asked the shy girl. The redhead shook her head no. She wondered why she asked like it was something that everyone tried with their friends.
“Every girl has done it. You are saying you’re the only one?” Chloe said as she tried to make it sound like a normal occurrence.
“Not every girl. I have not done anything with a woman,” Ashlee nervously replied while sitting between the two of them. She was confused by the way she felt. Mostly it was the uncomfortable feeling of being embarrassed but there was a little sense of arousal.
“I have touched and kissed all of my best friends at one point. It is just a bonding experience while practicing for dates,” Amber explained as she tried to make their new friend feel comfortable.
“So have you two ever done anything?” Ashlee asked while looking at both of them. The secret lesbian couple gave each other an evil grin when realizing they had the same idea. Then both of them looked back at the redhead before starting to lie through their teeth. They were still going to try to hide the relationship a little longer.
“No we have not but we would,” Chloe lied before moving in towards her brunette girlfriend. Their lips seemed to meet in slow motion as the two girls kissed above the shy redhead’s lap. Ashlee could not believe what she was watching.
From Ashlee’s perspective, it was two sets of soft pink lips meeting as the two women started passionately kissing on the couch. Chloe placed her hand down on Ashlee’s thigh to support herself while they were making out. When the redhead saw a little tongue starting to be used, she put her arms between them and used them to separate the two.
“You have never done that with each other before?” The new girl asked once she was able to stop their lustful kissing.
“That was our first time together but we have been with girls before,” Amber explained as her hand was placed on Ashlee’s other thigh. That was when the redhead started realizing that they were willing to try it with her too.
“Amber is better than most other girls I have kissed,” Chloe teased while trying to convince the ginger to give it a try. Ashlee would have been lying if she said she was not tempted but it seemed odd to her. She was never the type of girl to do things just because others were doing it already. It was not like her to fall to peer pressure from younger women either.
“Thank you,” the brunette replied before giving her another quick kiss. She was having fun helping Chloe and it aroused her to be teasing Ashlee.
“Do you want to see what you missed out on being so shy growing up?” Chloe seductively asked Ashlee while rubbing her hand on her thigh. The blonde’s hand was going a little higher than the hem of her modest dress. It made the redhead feel the heat between her legs rising while being teased by the two secret lesbians.
“I don’t think I should try it out tonight. It looks fun with you two but it is not my type of thing,” Ashlee explained while stopping her hand from rubbing higher on her thigh. Chloe looked into her eyes to show how passionate she was about teaching her.
“Just let us show you how to open up and enjoy yourself. You are too beautiful to be so shy and reserved,” the blonde girl said before unexpectedly moving in for a kiss. Ashlee gasped as their lips met. She could instantly feel the connection between them. Chloe knew how to make a first-timer feel special.
Her hands continued stroking her inner thigh as Chloe was able to start feeling that heat radiating from her mound. Amber was turned on by seeing the redhead not stop the kiss. She was smiling as she leaned back on the couch to watch. The blonde ran her fingers through Ashlee’s long red hair while using all her techniques to impress the inexperienced older girl.
When their lips finally separated Chloe said, “Didn’t that feel better than any of your past boyfriends?” Ashlee’s lips were still in the kissing position because she was stunned by the intense kiss. She could not believe that was just her mouth.
Before Ashlee could respond, Chloe’s knuckles were starting to graze against her moist panties. The feeling of the damp crotch of the redhead made the blonde want to dive between her legs. She knew that would only scare her away so she continued going slow. Every few strokes of her soft thigh Chloe would lightly rub against her mound under the dress.
“You should try kissing Amber to see how much better she is at it,” the blonde said to attempt to distract the girl from her wandering hands below.
“Are you sure?” The shy ginger asked before getting a swift answer from the brunette. It only took one second from the time the words left her lips before Amber was kissing her on the couch. Chloe smiled as she watched her submissive girlfriend help turn the straight girl from the gym. She was always a good wingman.
Ashlee was having fun making out with Amber before freezing up. She felt the blonde girl getting brave. Chloe stopped being so subtle with her touches. With the girl distracted, Chloe started rubbing up and down the front of her panties. She could feel the wetness seeping through as they worked to arouse the woman.
“Let me show you something else that girlfriends are good for,” the blonde playfully said while lifting up the skirt of her dress. Chloe stuck her head down underneath.
“That might be too far,” Ashlee started to say before the brunette placed her hand on her face to take the attention back.
“Just let us teach you,” Amber told her in a sexy voice before starting to kiss Ashlee on the couch again. The redhead was a little worried but it all felt so good. She tried to let herself go a little bit. If only to enjoy herself for the night.
“O-okay,” the ginger girl shyly responded before returning the kisses. Chloe heard the conversation above going well so decided it was time to push the girl a little further. Her hands started trying to pull down the grey panties from her hips.
“Wait, how far…” Ashlee started to say before being shushed by Amber’s soft lips. The brunette had an idea of how to get the girl distracted again. She grabbed the redhead’s wrist and put her hand back on her tit. It was over the shirt at first but Amber quickly took off the white top for added pleasure.
Once her panties were on the floor, Chloe started slowly teasing her wet lips under the dress. Ashlee could not see her under the skirt but it was feeling great. The blonde rubbed up and down the slit before teasing the clit with her fingers. Amber could feel the first-timer starting to get into it as she moaned while fondling her breasts.
Ashlee’s fingers played with the nipple rings as she felt a quick kiss on her clit. It caused her to flinch on the couch but enjoyed how it felt. Chloe could see her joyful reaction before trying it again. She gave the sensitive nub a few kisses before starting to tease it with the tip of her tongue.
Amber could tell that Chloe was making progress on breaking down their new friend by the playful kissing. The redhead was starting to start trying things on her own. Her hands pinched the nipples and her tongue tried to be creative. Amber found it amusing to see the cute girl try to impress her.
Then there was a pause when Ashlee felt something new happening below. Chloe was not only starting to suck on her clit but she was also sliding two fingers into her wet pussy. Ashlee unintentionally squeezed the perky breast in her hand as it slid inside. Her long moan showed the girls that they were doing a good job.
“How does it feel?” Amber whispered softly into the ear of the ginger woman. She was breathing heavily as she tried to reply.
“It feels amazing. I never enjoyed oral this much,” Ashlee admitted while moaning out into the air.
“That is because you have never been with a woman before,” the brunette playfully reminded her before starting to grope Ashlee’s soft boobs. Her hands squished them together while starting to kiss again.
Chloe was proud of herself for pushing Ashlee so far on the first night but she still wanted to try more. Her mouth left her clit while still fingering her tight pussy. Ashlee did not expect what the blonde was attempting. Her tongue quickly circled the outside of her asshole from under the dress.
“Woah! I don’t wanna try that Chloe,” Ashlee loudly said between moans. Chloe got off to knowing she had gotten away with it, even if she did not get to keep going. Her mouth went back to Ashlee’s sensitive clit to continue pleasuring her.
It did not take long after that before the redhead was starting to feel her toes curl on the edge of the couch. Chloe kept her pace up while tasting her juices start to flow. Amber could sense her orgasm coming by the way her breathing changed. Then her thighs started trying to close like a trap on the blonde’s head. Chloe pushed them back open while licking even faster.
“Oh I am about to cum,” Ashlee moaned out in pure ecstasy. Her body felt weak as she felt her pussy starting to gush with the fingers still inside. Chloe kept going for a few extra seconds before finally sliding out from under the dress.
“How was it?” The blonde asked with a glistening wet chin. Her fingers were coated in Ashlee’s cum as she started to suck one of the clean. She let out a moan to show that she thought it tasted good.
Ashlee’s face was bright red after the orgasm on the couch. Her mind was starting to clear of the sexual fog as she realized what just happened. While starting to think about what she just did, Ashlee watched as Chloe let Amber lick the other finger clean. They were sharing her cum after converting her from a straight girl to a bi-sexual.
The ginger felt awkward and embarrassed in front of the girls before running out of the house. She did not say a word. Once she got out the door she started thinking about how great it felt to have Chloe between her legs. Ashlee was not upset or anything, she just did not know how to handle finding out that she enjoyed sexual relationships with women. It was something that she never thought of in the past.
Chloe thought about chasing after Ashlee but the brunette said that she would come back. The girls talked about how she enjoyed it much more than most girls experimenting. They wondered if they had found a closeted lesbian as they had hot sex after the girl left that night. Chloe decided to give her the rest of the weekend to cool off. She planned on talking to her about it at the gym on Monday.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/nbw8gi/ashlee_f25_explores_her_sexuality_with_lesbian