Tinder girl gets more than she bargained for [MFM]

Hello all you deviants. This story is from mid 2019, but hey better late than never to share it.

​

This story involves a friend of mine from college (Ben) and a girl that he had matched with on tinder (Mel). Ben and I are not exactly close friends but we are good enough to have stayed in touch after college and hang out occasionally. We live in the same city but on opposite sides of town, so the hang outs are not as often as we would like but every time is still nice to catch up.

​

At the time of this story, Ben and I were both single, and rather active social lives (incl. dating apps). Ben is a bit of a jock type, 6ft, strong solid build, with a pretty typical face and dark hair. Whereas I am 6’4, more athletic build, with light hair. Regardless of a few differences between us we both got along quite well.

​

One Saturday afternoon I went around to Bens place to catch up with him and some others. We started at his place having a few drinks, and as the light started to fade we decided to head out to the local bar scene which was in walking distance. The group continued drinking and socialising, as the night wore on splintering off a little bit. Then at one point, Ben approached me, we were chatting, then he said that a girl that he had been texting on tinder was at a bar around the corner and wanted that he went to have a drink. Considering our group had dissipated, and being a good wingman, I agreed to go around with him, and if it wasnt relaxed we could always bail. I had also prearranged to stay at Bens place because my car was there and to save on the expensive cab home.

​

As we made our way around to the next bar, Ben showed me a couple of photos of Mel – who he was yet to actually meet in person. Mel has a nice face with strong features – dark hair, dark eyes that could kill, high cheekbones, and luscious lips which I am pretty sure have filler. She is kind of short at around 5’4, and has tanned skin thanks to her Brazilian heritage. Fortunately, she also inherited the Brazilian booty in a big way. She is petite and has a tiny waist, but an incredibly round butt with strong thick thighs to match. Every last bit of fat clearly went to her booty, as she was also rocking itty bitty titties on top to match that thin waist.

​

When we arrived at the bar, immediately we saw Mel and her friends, approaching them and running through all the pleasantries. Initially it was slightly awkward but we had all had enough drinks that it faded within about a minute and we started to all have fun. At first I had not really paid much attention to Mel, apart from noticing her very conspicuous butt which was in a ridiculously tight pair of black jeans that made it hard not to look. As the night wore on, and more drinks were consumed we were all chatting, dancing and laughing having a good time. However as things started to wind down, it became clear I would be going home alone (most of Mels friends were taken). On the other hand, it was clear that Mel was going to come home with Ben as we were leaving the bar. All of her friends were jumping in cabs, but she decided to stay. So off we went, making the drunk walk back to Bens place.

​

When we arrived we were all still pretty buzzed and had been laughing/joking the whole way home. Thinking that I would give the other two some space I mentioned that I would head to bed, but before I knew it Mel was putting another drink in my hand that she had found in the fridge – clearly wanting to party a bit longer. Of course I agreed to another drink. As we were sitting in the lounge chatting away, Ben started making some jokes, teasing that Mel should have invited one of her single friends for me. Mel jokingly jumped on me, saying that she would call one of her friends for me, one of them would definitely want to sleep with me. Suddenly Ben chimed in laughing with ‘Yeh, they better! Otherwise I guess you will just have to be enough for both of us’. I was not so shocked at Ben saying something like this – he was often pretty inappropriate even when he wasnt drunk. At that moment, Mel was pulling her phone from her purse then responded with ‘well my phone battery is actually dead, so I guess I will have to do! haha’. We were all laughing away, and I continued the joke with ‘Well, who is first then!’. Thinking we would all keep the laugh going and that would be it.

​

However, at that point, Ben stopped laughing a bit and just look at me – at first I thought I maybe took it too far, but then he gave me that ‘why not’ facial expression. Noticing this, Mel stopped laughing, started smiling, and swiveled her head looking at both of us. There was an extremely awkward few seconds (which felt like a minute) of this, before Mel broke the silence.. “Same time I guess?” with a ‘did I really just say that’ look on her face.

​

Immediately the mood changed. Ben kinda pushed Mel over towards me on the couch, so it ended that she was sitting between us. Giggling, Mel reached each one of her hands towards our crotches, rubbing from outside our jeans. We had a bit of an awkward look at each other, then thought ‘fuck it, lets do it’. Mel laughed, saying that she had never done this before, then trying to unbuckle our belts at the same time “its just like skiing apparently?”. With some assistance from us, suddenly, both our cocks were out and her hand wrapped around each one. As we grew harder in her hands Mel let out a “holy fuck”.

​

To give you some reference – at over eight inches, and decently thick – I am not exactly hurting for size. Ben also, his immature nickname among the guys in the college changerooms was ‘coke can’. Obviously referencing the thickness of his cock. His length is maybe around 6 inch, but he is packing some serious girth that although not quite a coke can, would have to be near as thick. Mel was clearly a bit shocked to have two such cocks in her hands at once, almost laughing at them. (sorry for the humble brag!)

​

While Mel practiced her ‘skiing’ technique, we had quickly removed her top and (with a short break from stroking our cocks) her jeans. She was then sitting on the couch in a black thong and bra, jerking us off. Honestly, this was the most awkward part because I had no idea where to look initially. Ben was already rubbing Mels pussy through her thong, when we kinda all motioned for her to get on the floor. Next moment, she is kneeling on the floor, with Ben and I standing over her, suddenly taking turns sucking and jerking our cocks.

​

Before long, Ben moved away and dropped to his knees behind Mel, clearly warming up her pussy with his hands. I dropped back down to the couch as Mel concentrated on sucking my cock. Coating it in her saliva as she tried to deep throat me. Suddenly, with a gagging noise, I realised that Ben had just thrust inside her. Mel was trying her best to suck my cock through muffled moans, but you could tell she had never done this before, and kept coming up for air. Ben was fucking her hard, which she seemed to be really enjoying. I joined in on the fun, pulling her hair, and moving with the motions so that her mouth was fucking my cock. My cock between her juiced up, plump lips was a sight to behold while she was almost drooling over shaft. I pulled her head back, letting her moan and take in some air, and to my surprise she let out a “dont stop”. This encouraged me to push her head back down and thrust into her mouth.

​

After quite some time of this, we stopped for a breath, and changed positions. I jumped down behind Mel, and Ben took my place on the couch. Realising Ben was wearing a condom, I also grabbed one and put it on. Kneeling behind Mel, I got my first real view of her ass. It looked even fatter than it did in her jeans. These big juicy round cheeks popping out from her tiny waist. Immediately I gripped them tightly and thrust in. She let out a big gasp, clearly not as wide as Ben, but I was hitting a deeper spot. As I started pumping in and out, my hips were slapping into her ass, causing it to make waves. Mel continued to try sucking cock while being fucked. Honestly, the harder we were fucking her, the more she relished the challenge.

​

This went on for what felt like hours, Ben and I constantly swapping positions, taking turns fucking her and her mouth. By the end of the evening, Mel had cum three times I think, and was completely exhausted, shaking a little bit and needing to just lay on the couch. There was also like 7 or 8 used condoms on the floor next to us, because we would take them off while she sucked on us, then grab a new one to fuck her. After finishing we all passed out pretty quickly. The next morning we all woke up extremely hungover, and had a good laugh about the night before.

​

We never repeated the deed, but Mel would occasionally send us both messages, often something naughty about threesomes, and being horny. I am not sure if Ben ever slept with her individually again, but a few months later Mel let us know she was in a relationship (i.e dont send me any more naughty texts!). Still one of the most random nights.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/naqijh/tinder_girl_gets_more_than_she_bargained_for_mfm