***This story doesn’t end in sex, but it came very, very close.***
My FWB, Penny, and I had been trying to meet another couple for a few months. It was surprisingly difficult to find people we considered attractive and who were interested in the type of full-swap situation we were. One day, however, we connected with a couple that lived about an hour north of us in the boondocks.
The wife was gorgeous. Probably Latina or Native American mixed with something. Large breasts, great smile, killer curvy body. The husband looked athletic, jacked, bald-headed and bearded. We talked a few times on AdultFriendFinder, switched to emails between us as couples, and eventually all four of us talked on the phone a few times. We shared nude photos with each other and regular photos of us in our normal lives and the connection seemed really strong.
The other couple were brand new to this and had never tried anything before. Penny and I had done a few things with a few other people, but never a couple so we were the experienced onces in the situation. The wife and I hit it off great and started to text, sext, flirt, and talk on the phone all the time. Penny and the husband not as much, but there was still some effort there.
We tried to set a date to meet up — we were pretty flexible being in our mid-20s, not married, no kids, easy to make plans. They were married, a few kids, and their jobs were more restrictive so it was hard to negotiate free time. This went on for a few weeks — months probably — until finally one day the wife reached out to me and let me know that her husband was not really sure about the non-monogamy lifestyle and was changing his mind. She was upset — she and I had very strong chemistry and she really, really wanted to meet up with me.
We didn’t hear from them for a while, until one day my phone lit up and it was her. She asked if we could meet that day at around 3 pm. My cock sprung to instant hardness and I immediately said yes. I thought, foolishly, that they were finally ready to meet up with Penny and me. I told the wife I would reach out to Penny to coordinate, but the wife told me ‘no’ she just wanted to meet with me.
I asked if her husband would be there and she said ‘no’ she just wanted me. Badly. I called her and we talked for thirty or forty minutes and she explained that they were moving soon — I don’t recall where — and that this was probably the last chance for us to meet up. She didn’t care that she would be cheating on her husband, she admitted, I was everything she wanted in a man. She was willing to leave him for me if I was as good as she thought I would be once we finally met, kissed, and made love. I will admit, I was tempted to take her up on the offer. I had connected to her in a really special way and I wanted her badly.
I was not, however, willing to break Penny’s trust over this, nor did I think she really wanted cheat on her husband. I reasoned that she was worked up and would consider this whole thing a major mistake. So, I told her no. I talked her into being with her husband and working through the issues they were having in their sex life and personal life. I talked myself out of an amazing experience with an incredible woman.
It wasn’t long after that Penny and I finally — formally — split up. More or less. As a consequence of that break-up Penny and I deleted our shared couples email address and I lost this woman’s email. Within a few weeks of that I also switched phone carriers and only added the phone numbers of people I knew in real life so I lost her number too.
Now, years and years later, the one person I think about the most is her. I have no idea what her name was anymore. Don’t remember why, exactly, we connected so strongly. I don’t even have her photos anymore — they were lost to an old hard drive failure at some point and became unrecoverable. She still crosses my mind all the time. What happened to her and her husband? Has she had a good life? Should I have met with her that day? What would our lives have been like if we had? All unknowable questions. A mystery I will never be able to solve.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/n2tnke/almost_a_couple_swap_sadly_nothing_came_of_it_mf
Check out her name on social media
Shame