[MFM] first time sharing girlfriend (with my cousin) doesn’t go as planned…

This was last night and I don’t know how I feel.

I’ve been with my girlfriend (Laura) for about 3 years. She’s 23 and I’m 25. We’re pretty active but not super kinky. One thing I’ve always gotten turned on by is threesomes with 2 guys, where they’re both focused on the girl. It just turns me on to think of seeing her with another guy, like porn in real life. I’ve told her this, and we’ve dirty talked about it a bit, and she’s talked about it while giving handjobs.

I don’t think I ever expected it to actually happen. As much as it turns me on, I thought I’d also be jealous. But then this week my distant cousin from Italy (Davide) said he’d be visiting us in Connecticut. I’ve spent a few summers with him and always knew he was a real player. The kind that goes through dozens of girls, but always acts romantic, like he loves each of them even if only with them for a few hours.

Before he arrived, I definitely thought about him hitting on Laura, it would be their first time meeting, and got hard at the thought. She’d never met him and I knew she’d like the accent and how flirty he’d be. The first couple days when he arrived were quite normal. Then one day we spent out at the pool. Laura was in a bikini, not too revealing, but she’s quite slim but still with large breasts and looked great. Davide also looked great – he’s very fit from years of soccer and was wearing pretty short swimming trunks. We were drinking a bit and laughing around. The conversation got a bit sexual, and Davide talked in this way that I thought was silly, but Laura seemed to love – he was saying “women are the most amazing thing, and nothing is better than pleasing a woman, etc”. If I didn’t know of all his past sexcapades and misogyny I would buy it. He then pretty straightforward asked if I make sure Laura is pleased, she giggled and said yes. He then asked “does my cousin have any dirty interest?” and I was surprised she told him how I like her to talk about threesomes. Davide acted like it was normal and said “yes, a woman deserves many hands and lips on her.” To which Laura replied “we’ve only discussed it”. Davide acted surprised, again like this was normal, and said that we should change this. We all kind of awkwardly laughed, and then went inside to change.

When we were in our room changing, Laura asked me what I thought about his flirting and discussing this, and I could tell she was interested. I was both nervous and turned on, and after a little discussion we said we should start things and see what happens. She decided to then stay in the bikini, and we went back out to the living room. Davide was sitting on the couch and Laura sat near him in the bikini. He was smiling, like her knew what was up, and I mumbled about actually turning the conversation into action. Davide said “this will be good for you” and then immediately starting kissing Laura, on her neck, while his hand explored her. I sat down on the other side and began doing the same.

It wasn’t long before Davide stood up and removed his shorts. His cock was completely hard. It wasn’t much bigger than mine, but noticeably thicker. He also was uncircumcized, I’m cut, and he had surprisingly big balls. He was also just way more fit than me. Laura started sucking him, and I kinda was a bit left out. She always likes giving blowjobs, but I felt she was more into it for him. She was really playing with his balls a lot and also enjoyed pulling his foreskin. Davide was really vocal. It all turned me on a lot, so I grabbed a condom and went behind her and starting fucking her.

After a bit of that, we traded positions. Davide wanted to go in without a condom, but we insisted that he put it on, because she’s not on birth control and is very particular about it. It actually was a bit of a discussion, with him saying he can pull out and it’s not nautral, etc, and us saying no no. I’ve never even fucked her without a condom, and I don’t think any guy has – she’s always intense about it – so we really drew the line. When he finally went in, protected, Laura was again seemingly more into it. Maybe because of the girth, or hearing his big balls hitting her, I’m not sure. I was really turned on by it all, and soon came in her mouth, and soon Davide came in the condom.

We all quickly showered, which was more fondling and kissing, but not much more, and then we, all fell asleep in our bed. I thought this was a bit weird, Davide had been sleeping in the guest room. But the day was so different, that I didn’t think too much of it.

Sometime in the middle of the night, I woke up to moaning. I turned to my side and could see them fucking in the spoon position. Laura was staring right at me and moaning so much. It was so hot. I scooted over and starting kissing her. She reached and grabbed my already hard cock. It was again somewhat of a shock, but really hot to have my girlfriend moaning like this while we kissed and another guy fucked her.

After only a couple minutes like this, Davide turned her onto her stomach. It was a really sudden move, like he was throwing around a doll. We were in the middle of a kiss, and it was like suddenly I was left out. I kind of just stayed there and since she couldn’t jerk me any more, I played with myself more.

Davide starting going really hard on her, really loud spanking sounds of his hard muscled body against her ass and his balls slapping. She was moaning and almost screaming in a way I literally had never heard her do before. It was again this confusion of being so hot but also I felt a bit leftout.

Davide started to groan a bit and pump really deep and hard, I could tell he was about to cum, and Laura, who could obviously tell was dirty talking him saying “give it to me” and “fuck you’re so good”. It was honestly incredible to watch. Davide then started to moan, and pushed very deep, a couple more thrusts, and then like wound his hips in a circle. Laura exhaled and just said “fuck that was amazing”.

They laid there for a minute and Davide made eye contact to me and winked, which also turned me on. But then he started to get up and pull out, and I then looked and realized he didn’t have a condom on. I swear my heart stopped, and I asked angrily, “wait did you fuck her without a condom?” Davide said “don’t worry cousin.” I was shocked and felt jealousy and fear and I don’t even know what. I said to her “Did you know?” and Laura quickly said “It’s okay” and before I could react Davide said “No problem – it was her ass”.

I didn’t know what to feel or think. I had never even once been inside Laura without a condom, never once fucked her ass, or even asked about it. And then here was my girlfriend laying there with the cum of my fit cousins inside of her hole. I honestly felt like crying, and they settled back into bed. She didn’t even get up to clean it or anything.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/mt042z/mfm_first_time_sharing_girlfriend_with_my_cousin