At the beginning of our senior year of college, my girlfriend of 4 years, Lily, and I were invited by a mutual friend to go to the biggest frat party for a particular house of the fall, together as a couple. Lily is a bit shorter than me at 5’8”, but she’s very cute. She has dirty blonde hair and she has a kind of an hourglass figure that slopes down to a great butt. She’s so hot, guys. Obviously, most people going to the party were looking for someone to go home with, but we thought that as a relatively older couple, we would just have some fun. We were joined at the hip for the first part of the night but gradually lost each other to the flashing lights and pounding music. It wasn’t until I left a long conversation that I felt a buzz in my pocket.
“Upstairs bathroom, now,” it read.
I ventured up the staircase, filled with people, and finally made it to the first door on the left of the second floor hallway. I knocked and was greeted by an outstretched hand pulling me in. Lily grabbed my collar and kissed me deeply. I could taste the cocktail she had brought on her lips. She broke the kiss.
“I’ve been dancing with a girl while you’ve been fucking around with your friends.”
“Okay.”
“I want to mess around with her. Are you okay with that?”
“Only if you still love me afterward.”
“Didn’t I get upset when you didn’t propose on our trip to Canada last summer?”
“Yes.”
“Then don’t worry about it.”
“Do you want me to come with you?”
“No, I’ll text you. She told me about an empty room.”
She left and I returned to the party. Admittedly, I lost track of time playing pong with a couple of freshmen and I never received a text. I got a bit worried, so I went looking for the bedroom she was in. On the third floor, there was an empty hallway except for a younger kid who looked like a pledge sitting in front of a door.
“Hey, don’t go in there. There are two naked girls asleep and I got assigned to look out for them.”
I heard them sawing logs from outside the door.
“One of them is my girlfriend.”
“You can go in, but I’m keeping an eye on you.”
Lily’s face was buried into a pillow with an unhooked bra still over her shoulders, and the other girl, a skinny brunette’s, pants were off. I sat up my girl and kissed her on the cheek to wake her up. She mumbled something to me to give the other girl her number. I opened a drawer on the nightstand, scribbled it on a piece of paper and tucked it into the pants laying on the floor. I had to pick Lily up, as she was down for the count. The house was mostly empty by that point, and there were similar situations going on around me so we didn’t make much of a scene. I don’t drink, so I laid her across the back seat of my car and drove us home. She dozed off so much harder that I couldn’t even wake her up, so I carried her up the stairs to our second floor apartment and managed to only bump her head on the wall once.
I woke up in the early morning to her snuggled up to me, per usual. She gets cold, a lot. I broke free without waking her even though she stirred a bit. I thought about the night before all the while making her breakfast. We had talked about her being interested in girls before, but I always thought she was joking. Didn’t matter to me, though, definitely a really fucking hot idea. I brought her some eggs and bacon on a tray as she was just doing her morning stretch and yawn combo and asked her how the night before had gone.
“I’m pretty sure she’s a sophomore because I noticed a girl that I knew among her group of friends that’s involved in the pre-law sorority. I never got her name, but we started to grind up to each other on the dance floor. I guess she noticed I was into it because she kissed me and told me that she knew somewhere we would be alone.”
“So what did you do?” I asked.
“I had to find you, dummy, so you wouldn’t break up with me since I fucked another girl without telling you,” she replied.
“So you fucked?”
“No, you kind of ruined the vibe. By the time we met up again we had gotten a little too drunk. We obviously made it to the bedroom you found us in, but by the time we had started touching and kissing we had only managed to get second base before we fell asleep.”
“How did it feel?”
“I liked it, but I don’t know, we’ll have to try again.”
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*five year jump into the future~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*
We hadn’t tried again anytime soon after that .We always kept experimenting after college, and now that we were married we had tried everything that two people could have possibly done. The one thing left to do was to include someone else. Fortunately, on the particular day I was getting ready to approach Lily about finding a third, she bounded into the kitchen with a beaming smile.
“Remember that girl I made out with at Illinois?”
“Of fucking course, babe.”
“We’ve had each other on Instagram for a while, but she just DMed me saying she was coming down to Savannah for the week to visit family and wanted to stop by.”
“Invite her over for dinner, I’ll put something on the smoker for you guys.”
Lily snickered to herself as she went back to our room to play with the dog.
I’d soon learn her name was Margot. She arrived in a sundress on a very humid summer night, though it was dark enough for the temperature to be pleasant. She had kept her brown hair, but now straightened it instead of leaving it naturally curly. She had a similar figure to my wife, but she had a smaller butt and a bigger chest. Earlier in the day, I threw a citrus-soaked pork shoulder in the smoker and planned to make cubanos. The girls talked while I sliced and prepared the sandwiches on our panini press. They’d gone through a half bottle of wine by the time I set the plates on the table.
Dinner was great and the small talk that ensued was fun. Nothing sexual was said. Margot had just finished school and was here to see her aunt and uncle for this upcoming weekend. I learned she and my girlfriend had forged a good online friendship over the past couple months and Margot wanted to see the only other people she knew in our city. I got up to clear the plates and made my way into the kitchen. I heard the girls laughing behind me, but thought nothing of it.
As soon as I faced the sink to wash the plates, Margot sauntered in behind me. She turned me around by my shoulder and softly kissed me as she started to stroke me over my pants. Wordlessly, she unbuckled my belt, drooled on my cock and sloppily took me into her mouth. Lily came around the corner soon after.
“Do you like it, baby?” she asked.
“Mmhm,” is all I could muster in reply.
She bit my earlobe, then whispered, “Do you think this was a coincidence? We’ve been sexting about this for months, but she was finally able to meet us down here after she graduated. She doesn’t have any family here. She came down here to fuck us. Every night that I was more wet than usual when you came home was because I was talking to her.”
I can’t describe how hot this was.
“I hope you like how she feels on your cock,” she continued, “ I told her just how you like it. Unfortunately, it’ll be the only pleasure you get until the next time I allow it.”
She roughly grabbed Margot by the neck and pulled her off my soaked cock.
“You’re usually dominant with me, Mason, but she lets me take control of her.”
“You get off on sucking my husband’s cock don’t you, you fucking whore.”
Margot’s gaze was firmly on the floor and her bubbly personality at dinner had completely changed to submissiveness, “Yes, mistress.”
“I guess we’ll both have to punish you for being such a dirty homewrecker.”
Both Lily and my outward personality are different in the bedroom. I tend to avoid conflict and make a little too many concessions in the real world, but I make her my pornstar in bed. She tends to be the dominant one in her workplace, so she almost always gives it up to me. I sometimes enjoy when she controls the flow of the night, but to a point I cannot resist acting upon my urges and she always submits. While I am more dominant, I also get off on her pleasure since I love her so much, and I never fail to make her cum. I planned to play along tonight, but I knew I could make her melt whenever I wanted to.
“Finish cleaning up the dishes, Mason. We’ll be in our room.”
“Yes, mistress,” I joked. She shot daggers into me with her eyes.
They went off and I distractedly resumed the chores while pitching a tent. Eventually, I could hear moans coming from upstairs and I couldn’t take it anymore. I started to walk throughout the house. As I moved closer to our room, the moans grew louder and louder until I reached our door. The next sight I saw has been etched in my mind ever since. Margot, this girl that I had just met a couple hours before, was completely naked with her ass in the hair on my bed licking my wife’s pussy. She was doing a good job. I’ve fucked Lily for long enough to know when she’s going to cum and she wasn’t too far away. She always starts to flutter her eyes and can’t control herself too well. Lily noticed I had walked into the room and gazed into my eyes while writhing on the bed, moaning. I walked closer to Margot and slapped her ass and then kissed my wife deeply. I knew that watching that sent her over the edge, but when she came, she screamed Margot’s name loudly in an attempt to make me jealous. Unlike she often does, though, I don’t get jealous because I know she will always be mine. I was only enjoying the show After her orgasm subsided, she tied Margot up to the bedpost and told me to participate.
“Get her as close to cumming as you can but don’t finish her,” Lily ordered.
I walked over to our bed and kissed Margot. I moved down to her neck and then licked around her already exposed nipples. I kissed down to her mound. Lily and I went to high school together and she is the only girl I have ever been with. I looked over to my wife and prepared to dive into only the second pussy I had ever licked. I could tell Margot was ready as she bucked her hips into my face and I guessed if she wasn’t tied up that she would drop the submissiveness and shove my face into her. I decided to tease a bit more. I bit her inner thigh and dragged my tongue to her outer lips. I hovered my mouth over her pussy and only breathed on it, then suddenly flattened my tongue and licked from her hole to the top of her clit. Margot instantly seized and let out a large breath. She loved it.
Lily was sitting in a chair with her legs up rubbing her clit while I made another girl moan. I could tell she was jealous and I wanted to push it. Once I got Margot sufficiently hot and bothered, I took my pants off and rubbed my cock against her clit. In a I stuck it in and started to fuck her. It was wetter than Lily’s was but wasn’t as tight. Margot moaned my name and I knew that my time inside of her would be shorter than I’d like.
Sure enough, I was getting into a good rhythm when I was pushed off and flipped over. Lily got on top and started riding me. She didn’t say a word but she was clearly telling Margot that I belonged to her. She leaned down and stuck her tongue down my throat while she bounced her ass on my cock. I finally reached the point of succumbing to my own desires, so I grabbed Lily by the hips and flipped her into doggy and pushed her face down to eat Margot out. I knew I was in control now. I pumped into her hips and slapped her ass until it was red.
“Cum inside me, please Mason. I need it,” she groaned.
“Or what?” I asked.
“Nothing! Just fucking cum inside me!”
I hated ending the sex in doggy because I needed to look into her eyes. I enjoyed pounding her from behind until I pulled out. We started again in missionary with her legs on my shoulders and me fucking her from an upper angle. This way I could kiss her and see how my cock made her feel by her facial expressions. It was her favorite position and she was getting close. Margot had gotten out the rabbit I bought Lily in college and started to fuck herself. The thought of two girls cumming in front of me sent me to the brink and I only had a few pumps left. I told Lily I loved her and shot my load inside her warm, tight, cunt while she contracted on my cock. At the same time, I saw Margot cumming hard on the rabbit. We all collapsed into a tired, sweaty mess, but before we fell asleep we promised to all fuck again before the sun came up. I kissed my wife on the forehead and she fell asleep naked in my arms. We spent the entire weekend taking turns using each other at our own leisure.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/m38t5y/my_first_experience_with_any_girl_other_than_my
Super hot ?