When she knocked on my door and saw I was hooking up with her teammate, I thought she would leave [FFM]

So this happened towards the very beginning of my senior year of undergrad. I had been on a club rugby team for all four years–at our school, there was a men’s team and a women’s team, but we were basically one big family unit who practiced and played separately, but always socialized together. Having spent this much time with and been to many parties and trips with all of the same people, I was already either very good friends with, already hooked up with, or both with a lot of the women’s team. You might have seen your school’s women’s rugby team, or have an image of a stocky lesbian with a mohawk in your mind, but for some reason my school’s women’s team was full of some of the most beautiful, powerful, sexy women at school. So having enjoyed but gotten familiar with this pool, a new class of freshman was a welcome excitement.

I was a senior so most of them seemed like they were like 15, but one of them, Ally, was particularly fit, tall-ish, like 5’8, and very hot. She had long brown hair, bright green-blue eyes with gorgeous, full lips, a shy smile, something like DDs, an athletic but curvy waist, cute butt, and long wonderful legs.

It was our first big party of the year after our team’s annual “freshman orientation.” There are some big moments of getting together as the full team and getting really wasted and having a dance party but this is probably the biggest. After an already long evening of ritual and festivities, I was on the dance floor of the house dancing with Ally. Her and I never really interacted before this, but after a lot of drinking and probably a short conversation, we pretty quickly began aggressively making out. It wasn’t long until we were groping each other in the dark there pretty intensely, and it was clear to both of us that it was time to go to my room. I took her hand and led her through the party, across the housing block and over to my house.

In my room, we picked up where we left off, going for the depths of each other mouths and I got to take a bunch of handfuls of her sweet and surprisingly substantial ass, and pretty quickly we had our shirts off. We wriggled together like this for a while, and I was reallllly looking forward to where we were headed. At one point she said she had to go to the bathroom, so she got up and went into the hall, and I happened to check my phone.

I see a text that says “Hey, where’d you go?” from Lana.

Who’s Lana? Lana is one of the sexiest women I’ve ever met, on the women’s team as well, and was hooking up with me for most of the semester prior. We left things off at the end of the previous year, but didn’t see each other over the summer because she was “with her boyfriend when she’s at home.” We’d interacted a bit throughout the beginning of the new semester, still super friendly with each other, but there was still a big question mark at the end of last semester for us, and I was wondering if/hoping we would pick up where we had left things. So this text was a relief and an enticement, but also felt ill-timed, considered Ally was in my bathroom.

I want to describe Lana here: she has wavy and bright brown hair, big eyes and a friendly smile, and is about 5’4. her ass looked ruthlessly incredible in yoga pants, and her tiny waist and full chest were so fucking mesmerizing. When I saw her naked for the first time, I had trouble believing what I was seeing–her tits truly defied gravity; they were much bigger than I expected, definitely DDs, and somehow perfectly perky. Her unbelievable ass was so full and thick in all the right ways beneath her amazingly thin tapered waist and fit stomach, and her legs were as good as you can imagine. She kept her pussy shaved, so beautifully set a little back between her legs in the most mouth-watering way. She’s a perfect 10 and I consistently had trouble comprehending my luck. Plus she’s extraordinarily liberal about sex and nudity, definitely proud and present in her slutty side.

So I thought about her, and about the almost equally-as-hot woman in my house who is about to come back to me and at some point and get naked with me, and I was like, shoot, I guess I’ll get back to Lana a different weekend. And I put my phone down.

As I heard Ally washing her hands, I had a thought that felt super risky but also bold, and I was very buzzed, and the possible reward seemed very worth it, and without thinking much more I quickly picked up my phone and typed, “hanging with ally in my room, come thru if you want, just knock!”

I put my phone down just in time for Ally to return. My heart was pounding, but I tried to get my mind focused on the present and not let myself analyze if or how that was a bad idea. I eventually settled back in after a few minutes and put the text as far towards the back of mind as possible, and got to unclasp Ally’s light blue bra. Her tits were so full and so amazing to look at, and amazing to touch. I kissed down her neck and began to suck on her big and supple tits, loving their voluptuousness. She was so sensitive and fun, and she seemed like she was really enjoying herself.

We maybe had been at it for 20 minutes or so since she got back from the bathroom, when suddenly there was a knock on the door. Ally and I paused, turning our heads to the door, and I said “who’s there?” kind of like I didn’t know who it was, just because it still felt like it could have been one of Ally’s friends or one of my house mates not knowing what was going on or checking on us or something.

“It’s Lana!”

My heart started pounding again, and Ally and I looked at each other. She seemed a little confused, also tipsy, and also like she had a question on the tip of her tongue. “Should we invite her in for a second?” I said, not sure what Ally would say. The text had already mostly slipped my mind, and I was really not expecting this knock on the door to be Lana.

Ally was like, “uhh, I guess?” We looked at each other for another moment, definitely awkwardly but also with a “I guess this is fine” shrug. Ally pulled some sheets over her tits, and we both sat up.

“Come in!” I shouted through the door.

Lana opened the door, and first narrowed her eyes while taking in the scene, then opened them wide and was like, “oh sorry!” and began to close the door, but I jumped in and said “wait! it’s fine, we’re just hanging out, no worries” I was not sure at all about what Ally would feel or say, like was this weird or insulting to her? but Lana peaked in again and said, “Ally, am I interrupting anything?” Ally looked at me and then back at Lana, then gave a shrug and was like “yeah kind of, but we can take a pause for a sec.”

I was hoping that Ally and Lana had been at least friendly with each other up to this point in the semester–I had no idea if they were already close, or what their dynamic was, but assumed they’d be decently happy to be in each other’s company. From this little interaction it seemed like they had a cool respect for each other, but weren’t, like, super tight. The awkwardness of the moment was helped a lot, though, by Ally and Lana’s inebriation from the evening. Lana stepped through the door and I asked her to close it behind her, and I got up to give her a hug. My mostly erect cock was pressing against my jeans, and I can’t imagine she didn’t feel it. We were still hugging but pulled away and looked each other in the eye, and it was hard to tell if she was confused, excited, or just kinda drunk, chill, and indifferent, and then I went back to sit next to Ally. I imagined it was clear what Lana had walked in on, and still she was making the mostly conscious decision to stay in the room with us.

I really still had no idea what was going to happen, and still felt my heart noticeably pounding in my ears. I asked, “how’s your night going?” and, still standing between the door and the foot of my bed, she described how the team was holding up, who was making out with whom and who was voming in the backyard. We all were laughing at the fate of our friends, and an easiness that wasn’t there before settled over us.

No one said anything for a moment, and another moment of boldness came over me, accompanied by even harder heart pounding. I said, “Well Lana, it seems like the vibe in this room is to have your top off, so if you want to hang you’re welcome to, you just gotta get on our level.”

I figured she’d most likely say “ha, nah I’ll get back to the party, have fun,” but, to my great surprise and great delight, she just smiled and shrugged, and was like, “ha, alright that’s fine with me!” and took off her crop top. She wasn’t wearing a bra underneath–just her absolutely juicy, perfect tits, with her large, hard nipples and thin athletic waist. and Lana sat down at the edge of the bed, smiling.

I was stunned, and rock hard, and shared, “wow, honestly, you two have the nicest boobs I’ve ever seen, I feel so lucky!” Which was cheesy but also true. Both girls looked down at their tits and smiled, Lana reaching up to hold them and looking at Ally, giggling. I was trying to figure out what to do next, but was really so dumbfounded by what was already happening. I figured I’d just keep complimenting them.

“And honestly, they both feel really incredible. Like, seriously both of your boobs are the best.”

And then, Lana said something else surprising, and I was so grateful for the amount that everyone had drank that night.

She looked at Ally and said, kind of matter-of-factly, “can I feel yours?”

Ally raised her eyebrows, caught a little off guard, but relaxed a second later and was like, “yeah sure, go for it!” And stuck out her chest a little bit.

Lana smiled, lifted her hands to Ally’s boobs, and closed her eyes. She let out a pleased “mmm” and took one of her hands to her own left tit, and opened her eyes and said “they’re basically the same size!” Ally went to feel her own open boob with one of her hands. Lana looked at her doing that, and said, quite casually, “Ally, have you ever felt another girl’s tits?”

“No! But honestly yours look really nice. so I guess if I’m going to have a first…” and with her free hand, felt Lana’s available tit. They seemed so casual about it, enjoying the novelty and the experience. Part of me was thinking about how it’s a way bigger deal for two dudes to be feeling each others’ dicks than it is for two women to be feeling each others’ boobs, so it really wasn’t that shocking that this was happening. But also it was incredible to watch, and I was still dumbstruck. They both had their hands on each other for a bit, sharing compliments and banter-y conversation, and then after a minute or so, put their hands down, and looked at me, both with coy and casual smiles.

And I was like, “can I…can I feel both of them, of you, at the same time now?” And they were both happy to, keeping that air of casual calm.

So I got to feel both of their tits at once (well, one tit each), and that was peak. Not of this story, but just, wow, that was so amazing. I could still not believe it all, and their tits were so plump, and perfect, and unbelievable.

And then Lana, the true MVP of the night, proclaims in a voice with more authority than before, “okay, I want you [esteemed author] to feel both of my tits, while I feel Ally’s tits.” And Ally says “and I feel [esteemed author’s] tits or what?” And I stuck out my chest and said “yeah go for it!” And we all chuckled for a second, and then I was like, “well, you can have something real to hold on to.” And I unbuckled my belt and slid my pants off, so my full erection was clear against my dark briefs. Lana was like, “good idea! But we’ll have to switch the order at some point.” With a cute little smirk.

So I lifted my hands to Lana’s glorious breasts, and her hands to Ally’s, and Ally, quickly, excitedly, reached under my briefs and grabbed my bare cock. Both Lana and my eyebrows went up in surprise, and Ally noticed and got a little flushed but kept her hand on me and said “well it seemed fair!” And I said “oh yess it feels just right” I close my eyes and feel the incredible sensation of Ally’s cool hand on my cock and Lana’s full tits in my hands, and quicker than I was imagining, after like maybe 20 or 30 seconds, Lana says “okay switch!” Ally and I look up with a small bit of disappointment, but Lana already dropped her hands from Ally’s boobs and was sticking her chest out towards her. Ally reached out a hand to Lana’s breast and lingered with the other on my cock for a second, then slowly slid out of my briefs and onto Lana’s chest.

I moved my hands up to Ally’s breasts and was just noticing the initial subtle differences when I felt Lana’s hand dive under my briefs, and she began teasing and lightly stroking my cock before grabbing it fully and slowly moving up and down. Lana eye’s were closed, her hand resting above her waistline, and I saw Lana lift my cock out of my briefs, feeling the cool air against my exposed skin. Meanwhile, me and Ally’s heads drifted close to each other. After feeling something drawing us closer towards each other, we found each others’ lips.

We were making out, my hands on her tits and hers on Lana’s, for maybe like 20 seconds, my eyes closed, when all of a sudden I feel a warm wetness over my cock where Lana hand was. I quickly open my eyes and see Lana with my cock in her mouth, and her big eyes looking up at me. And just like that, she pulled my briefs down my legs, looked back down at my cock, and starts slowly taking all of me (6 inches for this who are curious) into her mouth, and smoothly and amazingly going up and down a few times, seeming to be committing to what she was doing. I was so incredibly turned on, I didn’t really get to register Ally’s reaction but I went to kiss her with ferocity, and could feel her being turned on by my heat and intensity. We were all building; Lana’s pace was becoming more and more steady, and Ally’s hands, free since Lana’s move, began exploring my body.

I took one of hands off Ally’s tits and felt around the waistline of her tights jeans, trying to find a suitable entrance but they were just too tight. I put my mouth next to hers and whispered, “I think you’ll have to join me in taking these off.” She quickly slid off the bed and stood up, unbuttoned her pants, and gripping her pants and thong, pulled them both off, and was now completely naked, giving me a brief but wonderful glimpse of her fully shaved pussy. She sat next to me again, and as our mouths met I wasted no time in bringing my hand to her inner thighs, and teasing around the warmth and wetness of her pussy, and finally feeling her, soaking, from her taint up to her clit, and began massaging her steadily, alternating between her clit and her juicy lips. This whole time, Lana was focused on my cock, sucking steadily and pulling me out of her mouth and vigorously licking up the sides and underneath, and going back to sucking me deep into her throat.

Lana noticed that Ally was fully naked, and clearly getting very turned on, and came to a slow pause, looked up, and asked, “do you want a turn?” Ally smiled with her mouth open, nodded, and slid down my body towards my crotch as Lana got up from the bed. While Ally began to like along my cock, already slippery from Lana’s saliva, Lana began unbuttoning her jeans, and quickly slid them off, so she was just in a see through lacy gray thong, and slid that off as well. So she was naked, coming towards me to sit next to me on the bed, and Ally was naked, sucking my cock after Lana had just done so. I was so overwhelmed and still buzzed which is probably why I hadn’t come in anyone’s mouth yet.

Lana’s mouth finds mine, and she takes my hand and places it directly on her soaking, shaved pussy lips, pushing my fingers towards her hole insisting that I plunge in. I waste no time pulsing in an out of her with my index and middle fingers as our tongues clash wildly with each others’ mouths. Her hips were bucking against my hand, going faster and faster; Ally is steadily working her magic, taking my cock into her mouth as my hips speed up along with Lana’s.

Lana moves her face back away from mine and just stares at me as she slows down her hips, enjoying every inch of my fingers. And she says to me, “lay down.” So I lean back onto my bed, and Lana moves up towards my head and brings her leg over to the other side of me, straddling me and pushing her pussy towards my face, and I start voraciously licking her fully soaked lips and clit. She’s already so turned on, after just about a minute of her increasing her pressure against my mouth and upping the rhythm of her hips, she’s convulsing in pleasure. She pauses her motions and takes a deep exhale, and looks back towards Ally, still (bless her) going down on me, and says, “you should definitely do what I just did.”

I feel Ally’s mouth leave my cock, and Lana moves off of my face, leans down and gives me a deep kiss, and slides down the bed. She takes my cock in her hand and slowly strokes it as Ally climbs up and moves her pussy over and onto my mouth. She’s just as wet, but starting off slower than Lana. At my hips, I feel Lana shift so she’s straddling me. Fuck, I thought, I finally get to be inside of them, I can’t believe this is happening! Lana glides the tip of my cock against her still soaking pussy, sharing her moisture for a few moments, until the guides me towards her hole and sits down slowly, and quickly coming up almost to the very tip, and sitting down again, continuing that and picking up her pace.

I’m truly in heaven, and Ally begins rocking back and forth quite quickly on my mouth, tightening her thighs as she comes for what felt like a pretty long time. I’m getting close, so as Ally climbs off I tell that to Lana. Lana starts moving up and down on me faster than before, leaning forward on to my chest, looking at me straight in the eyes, and after a dozen or so more thrusts I’m blasting more cum than I thought I possibly could into her pussy. I lay back, close my eyes and take some deep breaths. Ally and Lana come to lay on either side of me, all of us exhausted, and we kind of drift off eventually. At some point in the night, Lana leans over and tells me she’s heading back to her dorm, and Ally stays the night. And that morning, we do what we didn’t get to do that previous night :) Wow, such an incredible night, thanks for reading all of this!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/kugxri/when_she_knocked_on_my_door_and_saw_i_was_hooking