Alissa was a little flirty that night. She showed up to our college party house with her tight white tshirt ripped down the middle so her cleavage was out all night. Alissa was about 5 foot 2 and skinny. She wore dark black glasses that gave her a Librarian look. We were both 19 and I was living with a few buds at a college house in Maryland.
She didn’t wear a bra and had small boobs and short hair and we had been seeing each other for six months or so.
She was especially flirty with my friends that night but I never thought twice as she always came upstairs with me. She nudged me to go upstairs with her and I followed obediently.
Instead of going into my room, she pulled me into the single bathroom on the second floor. It was kind of naughty because we still had a handful of people downstairs drinking and carrying on.
She turned the shower on and got me undressed told me to get in. Alissa quickly stripped and joined me. I reached out of the shower and locked the door when she got on her knees.
She sucked my cock like a pro, it was almost concerning how good she was and how easy it was for her to take my cock all the way down, not that I was very big.
There was a knock at the door. Alissa answer “I’m in the shower” and a male voice, Kevin my roommate said “I just need to pee”. She sucked me harder and looked up, and slapped my dick against her pale face.
Alissa responded “ok but are you gonna try to fuck me?”
“Ugh, should I?” He responded.
She reached her hand out of the curtain and unlocked the door and closed the curtain again.
She stood up and pressed her firm small ass into me and put her finger over her mouth gesturing for me to shhh. She slid me into her and started pushing back on me.
Kevin peed for a long time as she kept fucking me behind the curtain. She let out a moan and the curtains opened. Kevin looked in and saw me and quickly closed it. “Sorry I had no idea” he said. “Uh, I should go.” There was a long pause and he didn’t make any sounds of someone leaving. Alissa was really making a lot of slapping noises with how hard she was fucking me. She was moaning out loud and grabbing my balls from underneath and she was pressing on my taint. Finally he spoke “Right, I should go right?”
“No” Alissa responded and pulled the curtains open halfway so only she could see him.
“Lady’s choice, looks like we’re gonna have a sword fight bud” he said to me.
Alissa reached her hand out and I can only assume grabbed his cock because I still couldn’t see, “oh fuck yeah that would be hot” she was still humping back into me but reaching for and looking at him.
“Sound good baby?” She said to me.
I wasn’t actually feeling the idea, kevin was a soccer player and in really good shape. He was tan and athletic and skinny. I was just skinny. But I also didn’t want to let this hot girl down so I rolled with it. “I’m in” I responded a little faster than I should have.
We decided to go to Kevin’s room. Alissa toweled up and I put my underwear on and then stood awkwardly in his room when he closed the door.
He looked at us both, “winner gets the girl?” he asked. “Yes” she responded before I could. “And the loser?” Alissa asked rhetorically. Nobody answered. “The loser does whatever I say”. Kevin and I agreed.
She dropped down to her knees and dropped the towel. She pulled me over and reached her hand under my boxers and started stroking me. I was already pretty hard when Kevin walked over and dropped his jeans and stood there in his underwear.
She started doing the same to him. We both kind of eyed the other one but couldn’t tell. He asked if she knew the winner. “Oh I know, but that’s no fun”. I was nervous but still pretty confident. She pulled out dicks out at the same time and I felt like I was looking bigger. Then again I was just fucking and he wasn’t fully hard yet.
“Both of you, on the bed, scissor” she instructed.
It was a little weird getting into position and we exchanged a few laughs and hey buddies. She helped position us so we were cock to cock and balls to balls. Kevin handed Alissa some lube and she dripped it on us, put the bottle down and started jerking us off. Oops she said as she rubbed them together. He started to grow and in about 15 seconds I knew he was going to dwarf me. She rubbed her hand up his muscular chest and then back down to his dick.
“This is so fucking hot” she said as she kept rubbing them together. Kevin asked if there was a winner and Alissa laughed “you’re the winner baby but this is so hot I wanna keep doing it” she held both our dicks together, his was at least an inch and a half bigger than my 4 and a half, and he was thicker. We were both cut. And then she did something weird.
Alissa slid behind him and kept jerking us together. She was giving him a reach around while stroking our cocks together. She started guiding him to where we were in the missionary position with me on the bottom.
And she kept jerking us, but paying way more attention to him. “I want you to fuck my hand” she whispered to him. And she held my dick against his. And he obliged, he started fucking her hand and my dick. “You’re the big dick winner Kevin, show him who’s boss” and he his grinding became more powerful.
“You like this baby? You like my big dick dominating your boyfriend?” This was the first time he said anything like that. I was starting to feel emasculated instead of sheer horniness, and this guy was my roommate.
“Show him” she said “show him how much more of a man you are” now I was helpless. I was rock hard but wanted to get the fuck out of this situation. I thought I was losing my girlfriend and was about to be the laughing stock of my friends group. Kevin isn’t shy about giving me a hard time, no pun intended. “I think he likes this” kevin said to her as they exchanged their first kiss. And out of nowhere I came. “Did you just cum on my dick dude?” He didn’t have a joking tone, he was annoyed.
Alissa mumbled something reassuring into his ear and then got between us and started sucking up my cum and cleaning him off.
“Dude what the fuck?”
“Don’t worry about it baby, I’m yours tonight.” And she started jerking him again over my shrinking small dick.
“Oh one last thing before I fuck your brains out” Alissa said and winked at me. Alissa grabbed Kevin’s phone and had him unlock it. She positioned him over me and arranged our cocks. She took a picture from above and showed it to him and they both laughed.
She whispered one more thing into his ear, and looked at me. He started to move his hips over me until he was sitting on my chest, dick and balls a few inches from my face. “That’s it” she encouraged.
She was behind him again, rubbing her lubed up hands over his fit chest. And he hands came down and got to his cock and balls. She bit his shoulder and then slapped me in the face with his dick. He laughed “you like that man?”
“Yeah he does” and she started rubbing his dick against my lips. “Open” she said a few times as I tried to look away. “A deal is a deal baby” and she pushed him inside of my lips. It felt pretty good, but I had to keep my manliness so I closed my eyes and pretended not to enjoy it.
And then she released him, his dick in my face and I felt her hands on my dick. “He’s harder than he’s ever been with me”. Kevin snickered and then started forcing my mouth onto him. I started sucking and Alissa started jerking me with her oily hands. She started playing with my ass and slipped a finger in me while she jerked me furiously. “Kevin come fuck him”. He held my nose and forced his dick in my mouth and out again. He listened to her.
He pushed my legs up and Alissa guided him into a condom and into me. She was behind him again and I was rock hard. She was playing with his chest encouraging him to “fuck this little faggot”
“Is that what you want baby? You like seeing me fuck your faggot boyfriend”. And without anyone touching my dick I came again all over my belly.
Alissa came around to me and gave me the hottest kiss of my life. Her eyeliner was dripping and she had a look of lust on her I have never seen before. After a big kiss she told me that was so hot and used her towel to clean off my belly.
“Now get the fuck out of her and get me breakfast in the morning” she said to me.
She moved over to Kevin and started licking and feeling his chest. He looked at me, “time to go dude”. I got up and put on my underwear. I looked back and she started sucking him “god I love your cock”.
He looked up one last time, “lock the door too”
I left and locked his door from the inside and went to bed. I cried that night. I also jerked off for a few hours.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/ku2pl1/sword_fight_mfmmf_bi_cuckold