This happened last January, but we’ve had our second playdate with this redditor, u/TylerDurdenWannabe, so I figured I’d share this first experience in warming up for another story.
Tyler found a posting I made on Doublelist, thought he recognized the writing as belonging to me (he’s a Reddit fan of us here) and took a shot. It paid off! The fact that he was a fan, and a good-looking and respectful one at that, made us schedule a date pretty quickly.
(I’m skipping written descriptions of us because you can see Aly and Sam at u/fun_in_love, her and myself in my own post history, and Tyler at his profile. And a picture is worth a thousand words, yeah?)
He and I had a session together wherein we got to know each other a bit and feel each other out. Then we had a little fun, some videos of which I may post again soon. After that we started a group chat with Aly and Sam. Tyler sent us some vids of him tributing Aly’s photos, and she teased us in return. We arranged for a Wednesday night get-together. Just a brief casual encounter that evening without our usual meeting at the bar first. We were feeling comfortable with Tyler already and invited him right over to Aly’s place.
I arrived first and hung out with Aly and her husband, Sam, while we waited. I’d bought a card game, one of those Truth or Dare games, as an icebreaker for us. We had a beer and around 6:30, Tyler messaged he was outside. Sam was upstairs at the time so Aly answered the door. She gave Tyler a big hug and I said hey. Then Sam came down and introduced himself with his real name.
You could see the look of surprise on Tyler’s face. As far as he could tell, this was an as-yet unheard-of *fourth* guy who’d just appeared from upstairs. How many more of us were there?!
Sam realized and clarified he was Aly’s husband. We exchanged our real names all around, grabbed another round of drinks, and moved to the living room to start the game.
The game was…well, not a very exciting game by our standards. As far as an icebreaker to get to know Tyler it was alright. But nothing too risque was asked. When it came to the dares, we spiced them up a little. When the question came up for Aly, “At this moment, would you rather have me squeeze your ass or kiss you,” I told Aly she’d need to experience both to decide. She and Tyler stood and they shared their first kiss as he gave her ass a firm squeeze.
“You’re a good kisser!” Aly said, relieved. Not everyone is.
I can’t remember the rest of the dares (we went through two rounds) but for the last one. Aly was dared to strip, go outside, and flash us through the window. She went to the bathroom and changed into only a robe and then stepped outside. Below zero temperature in Minnesota, mind you. Tyler and I stood at the window and she flashed us, pressing her breasts against the cold glass. She rushed back in.
It was nearly 7:30 at this point, and Tyler could only stay a couple hours. So we moved upstairs. Aly, Tyler, and I went to the bedroom first. The three of us stripped and Aly got on her knees right away to take our cocks in her mouth. Sam came into the room at this point and stripped as well, watching his wife start to gag on two cocks. One of them, essentially, a stranger’s. Aly got on all fours on the bed and sucked me off as Tyler hopped up behind her, eating her out from behind. It was the only time that night he got to taste her pussy, but from the way he eagerly went at her, it seemed he enjoyed it immensely.
We all moved to the bed at Sam’s suggestion. He told Aly he wanted her to suck each of us off, moving down the line. We laid with me in the middle and Tyler and Sam on either side. Aly started with Tyler. He was rock hard, and Sam and I watched her spit on his cock, stroking him, and then taking him all the way down her throat. She moved to me next, and I continued to stroke Tyler as she sucked me off. Sam reached over and began stroking me as well, as his wife’s head bobbed up and down my shaft and I took a photo (you can see in my profile).
Aly continued on to her husband while Tyler and I kept jerking each other. (There is more bi play ahead, so be warned if you’re not into it). Then Sam told her to go through the lineup again, this time fucking each of us. Aly returned to Tyler, straddling him, and slowly impaled herself upon his cock. He has a nice dick (we’ve got length and girth covered between us so she was a happy girl), and she let out a gasp of satisfaction as he hit her deep. She rode him as he squeezed her breasts. She tilted her head down to kiss him as they fucked.
Meanwhile, I started to get into my head. Aha! You thought gangbangs always went perfectly, didn’t you? With no jealousy and no performance issues? You’re such an optimist. I like that about you. Unfortunately, it’s not always the case. Just like the last time we had done this, I was starting to worry that I’d have performance issues, and then, because I was worrying about it, it happened. Don’t worry: my erections came and went. I had a great time, but I want to be honest about the realities of group sex. In fact, all three of us guys had varying degrees of trouble keeping it up. We pulled through, but my advice is this: don’t rush the experience. Don’t rush anyone. Take breaks if you need them. If it’s appropriate and okay with everyone, have a little one-on-one time. That usually helps me.
Back to the topic at hand: Aly rode Tyler for a few minutes and then I had her skip me to fuck Sam instead. Aly rode him cowgirl for awhile, and then I was ready for her to do the same to me.
BUT! she didn’t. She whispered to me that Sam wanted Tyler to fuck her ass while he was in her pussy. I was pretty disappointed for a few minutes, to be perfectly honest. Here I was ready, but was being passed over. Jealousy, guys. It’s a real beast.
Tyler moved behind her and I got off the bed to record their DP. There was some initial trouble with the lubing and entry, and Aly ended up reverse cowgirl with Sam in her ass instead, while Dan took her pussy. I got behind them and took a crappy, poorly-lit video that mainly featured two pairs of testicles bouncing wildly in the dark. But Aly responded to the DP with moans and breathy cries as she got close to climaxing. She didn’t though. Not yet. I asked her the next day how many times she came and when, and she said she thought only twice. Once when I went down on her, and once when her husband did. Again, realities here. There’s a lot of stimulation going on, a lot of balls (heh) in the court, and it’s not always going to be a marathon of squirting on her part.
The guys pulled out and Aly laid on her back. This is where I went down on her for a long time while each of them fucked her mouth. After Aly came, her clit pressed against my tongue and her hips bucking, I moved up and pushed into her for the first time (finally) that night. As I fucked her, her gasps were muffled by Tyler’s dick in her mouth. I lowered my head to assist her in sucking him off. Both our mouths slobbered over his shaft and head, my lips above and hers underneath, as we took turns taking his entire shaft in our mouths.
It gets hazy now, my apologies. We switched positions *a lot* after this. The greater part of the next forty-five minutes, Aly was on her back with her head off the side of the bed. We took turns pounding her wet pussy as the other two guys fucked her face. My favorite part of this was when Aly flipped over and tried taking Tyler’s and my cocks in her mouth at the same time. She did great! I don’t think either of us was 100% hard, however, so we’ll have to test her throat’s elasticity next time.
I don’t remember who came first. It was either Sam or me. We wanted Tyler to be able to experience one of his bucket-list items – fucking a cum-filled pussy. We both came inside Aly, and then let Tyler take his turn. He fucked her missionary and I said to him, “Feel as good as you imagined?”
“Fuck, so much better,” he said. He was in heaven. He filled Aly with her third load. We took a brief water and bathroom break. But not for long. We had about another thirty minutes before Tyler had to take off.
We started with head again. Tyler laid on the bed and Aly and I both got between his legs. We hadn’t discussed bi play too much, but based on the fact I’d already sucked him off tonight, I figured I’d take a more deliberate approach to it. He groaned as Aly and I shared this cock between us, passing his hardness between us, each having plenty of opportunity to give him a mind-blowing blowjob. No humbleness here – I give fantastic head. Just saying.
Sam fucked Aly as we did this, and eventually pulled out and shot a huge load over her back. Then the rotation of positions commenced again.
One highlight was Aly blowing me while Tyler fucked her doggystyle, aggressively, until his legs started to cramp. He and I both like a particular which I don’t know if there’s a term for: doggy but you’re in a crouched position, on your feet? Someone save me in the comments. I love it as it allows much more force.
Aly loved it too. She was screaming and creaming as he fucked her. It got to a point, finally, where Tyler and I figured we wouldn’t be cumming again. Sam went downstairs to take the dog out, and Aly climbed atop Tyler one more time, as he was still hard. As she rode him and I watched, I got the most turned on I had that night. I was watching her bouncing on his shaft, her ass exposed and eager for another cock. And the last time we had had a foursome, I had missed out on the DP. So, ready now, I jumped in. Aly didn’t expect it at all. Suddenly she had two cocks inside her. Sam returned and found his wife being doubleteamed by two dudes intent on filling her with cum. He took a couple photos as we pounded her relentlessly. I reached that point shortly after, gushing a second load into her ass. I pulled out and laid down. She rode Tyler for about two more minutes and then he exploded inside her. We were spent.
“Did you cum inside her?” he asked. I said yeah.
“Damn, if I had known you were cumming, I would’ve cum at the same time,” he said. I thought I had been pretty vocal, but that’s another thing about foursomes: sometimes you’re in your own little, perfect, world.
We got dressed and went downstairs. Aly kissed Tyler goodbye and he left. The three of us hung out another thirty minutes with a final round of beer. It’s always good to have some post-coital discussion. We agreed we’d definitely do this again with Tyler, which we were finally able to do this last week. One year later.
Tyler did admit in a message he was bummed he didn’t try sucking me off with Aly. That was hot to hear – I’m definitely down for another jerk session with him where we play orally as well. And we’re already trying to schedule round three with this lucky fan, who has since become a much bigger fan. Cheers!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/kpswme/a_vixen_has_her_first_reddit_fan_foursome_group
Damn! I wish I could join