My girlfriends first DP was with a strapon [MFF]

It seemed that I had been given an early Christmas present in the form a threesome with my girlfriend Elle and her ex-college roommate Cee. I was ecstatic. Even more so knowing that they both had hooked-up before [several times before](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/kd30g2/i_told_my_boyfriend_about_my_first_lesbian/). This actually gave me the idea of combining the previous blindfold play with this new adventure. I know it seems silly, why was I willing to let her sex with another woman but not another man? I guess my own fantasies took the best of me.

 

I gathered my courage and texted Cee with the plan: before our threesome we would blindfold her and then tell her that there was another guy waiting for her in the bedroom, when in fact it would be Cee with a strapon. Cee loved the idea and even suggested we used two condoms each so that she couldn’t tell apart which one was real or note. She also suggested that we should ask for a voice actor on Fiverr to record some lines for us to playback to Elle to add credibility to the fantasy.

 

We scheduled the threesome for the weekend before Christmas and, although we had talked details and safewords, me and Elle were both a bit nervous. Cee on the other hand was at ease judging by her enthusiastic greeting when she met us at the door.

 

She was wearing dark lycra shorts and a white top that perfectly outlined her figure. We both gawked at her while she gave a little turn to show us the view and then ushered us to the sofa in the living room, keeping Elle in the middle.

 

While we made small talk to lighten the mood I noticed that Cee made small advances on Elle, placing her hand on her leg, brushing aside strands of hair from her face, holding her hands, etc. As Elle was getting flushed, I decided to make a move and began kissing her neck. Cee mimicked me and then went for a nice and sof kiss on her lips. I distanced myself a bit from them to better enjoy the view.

 

This was, by far, the hottest thing I had witnessed in my life. They kissed like old lovers reunited and I was surprised to see that Elle was being dominant with Cee, caressing her breasts under the top and slapping and grabbing her ass. I took out my cock and started stroking it slowly since I wanted this to last. Eventually Cee undressed Elle until she only had her lingerie on and then she directed her attention to my hard cock.

 

“Show me how I should suck your boyfriend” Cee commanded.

 

Elle didn’t say a word, got on her knees in front of me and started to suck my dick. She began by looking at me straight in the eyes but eventually diverted her gaze to Cee as she licked my shaft from the base to the tip. Cee got up and placed herself behind Elle and started nudging her head to encourage her to go deeper on me. She did this until Elle gagged on my cock.

 

“Good girl. I’ll be right back.” and she winked at me.

 

I took off my clothes and Elle kept sucking and stroking me, but it didn’t take long before Cee was back. She now had her hair tied up and was wearing sweatpants that did little to hide the bulge of the strapon. She moved silently and placed a blindfold on Elle.

 

“Hey! Wait a minute! Shouldn’t this go on him?” she asked.

“It could… but what if I told that there’s a very shy guy in my room eager to fuck you in every hole.” Cee whispered in her ear while caressing her breasts from behind.

Elle swallowed hard. “I thought this was about a threesome for my boyfriend…”

“Me and Cee talked and figured that we probably wouldn’t get another opportunity for you to have this, so you might as well take advantage of the situation.” I winked back at Cee and she smiled.

“Are you sure?” Elle asked and bit her lip.

“Absolutely. I’m sure we’ll have fun.” and with this I gave her a long kiss while Cee went to grab her phone and a piece of gum.

 

I helped Elle get up, started chewing the peppermint gum that Cee handed to me and moved slowly behind Elle. We waited a couple of seconds letting Elle simmer for a bit and then Cee played one of the pre-recorded messages. The show was about to begin.

 

“Turn around.” said an unfamiliar voice coming from the phone.

 

I waited for Elle to fully turn around and then I started kissing her in the mouth making sure that she could taste the peppermint that she didn’t felt before when I was kissed her. I stepped away and switched places with Cee.

 

“On your knees.” the stranger’s voice commanded.

 

I knew she recognized the smell of chocolate and she proved my right by eagerly licking it and swallowing Cee’s strapon. I let her do this for a couple of seconds while massaging her right breast, making sure that she knew that she had a pair of hands on hair. The illusion was in place and we were both perplexed and excited with Elle’s enthusiasm.

 

“Switch.” I said.

 

And switched she did. Elle went straight for the deepthroat and proceeded to suck and lick my hard cock. Cee guided Elle’s hand to the strapon and let her stroke it. We let this go on for a couple of minutes telling her to switch. We even switched places from time to time since the goal was to make sure that Elle was unable to know which one of us was which.

 

“Are you ready to get pounded by the both of us?” said the stranger’s voice.

“Yes, I think I am.” Elle said smiling.

 

We helped Elle get up and moved her to the bedroom where she knelled in front of the bed. Cee then grabbed Elle’s head with both hands, pulled her towards the strap-on and proceeded to fuck her mouth roughly. I was impressed with Cee’s waist movement, this was not her first time wearing one of these. As Elle was completely absorbed in getting her face fucked, and I didn’t want to get left out, I grabbed her hand and made her stroke my cock.

 

Eventually Cee let go off of her head and Elle went with her mouth straight to mine. She started alternating between sucking us both and jerking us off while we pinched and twisted her nipples. She was getting flushed and every now and then she would slightly rock her hips, clearly eager to get some dick inside of her.

 

As much fun as we were having, the flow had to keep going. I sat her up on the bed, pinned her hands so that she wouldn’t accidentally touch Cee’s breasts or her hair, and started licking and kissing her breasts. She giggle at first but eventually her breathing got faster and she started moaning lightly.

 

Cee got up and teased her mouth with the strap-on, which I recognized as one of our predetermined signals. I moved my head down and placed myself between Elle’s thighs and slowly kissed and licked her pussy and clit. As she started to moan and suck the strap-on more vigorously, I began to finger her, working my way up to three fingers. I wanted her properly wet and stretched out for the pounding that was about to come.

 

As I was doing this, Cee pushed Elle back on the bed, got on top of her and started fucking her breasts and mouth. Her round ass was moving back and forth right in front of me and I really wanted to smack her. However, we had previously agreed that I could not touch Cee while Elle had the blindfold on since that could be considered cheating.

 

So instead, I spread Elle’s legs and gently inserted my dick into her. I had to go in really slowly because the two condoms didn’t let me feel much and I didn’t want to hurt her. This also made it extra thick. After a few gentle thrusts I started fucking her faster and harder.

 

Cee looked over her shoulder to me and mouthed “slower” but I just smiled and kept going at it. She then got up and out of the bed and gestured that we should switch positions. I removed my wet cock from Elle and, instead of getting on top of Elle, moved to the opposite side so that I could play with her breasts while I fucked her upside-down mouth.

 

The view was incredible. Cee was sweating from the pounding that she was giving to my girlfriend, Elle’s boobs were swaying with the motion and I was getting my cock sucked. Eventually Cee flipped Elle over and we took turns fucking her from behind giving her her first orgasm. She moaned non-stop. This was going to be the best fuck she ever had.

 

As I was fucking Elle, Cee went to grab some lube and a shiny plug.

 

“Are you ready for another surprise?” she tease Elle.

“Hmm hmm…” moaned Elle in response.

 

I did my part by spreading Elle’s cheeks while Cee inserted the plug in Elle’s tight asshole. No questions asked. It just slid right in. Cee then proceded to play with Elle’s ass, inserting and removing the plug, causing her to let out these dragged out moans as I fucked her gently.

 

We switched places once again but this time I laid on the bed besides Elle so that she could suck my cock. Cee was going hard at it while slapping Elle’s ass and pushing the plug further with her thumb. After some minutes I signaled Cee that it was time for the finale and she nodded in agreement.

 

I pulled Elle on top of me and let her ride my cock. Meanwhile Cee had removed the plug and was applying generous amounts of lube on the strapon and on Elle’s asshole. I eventually stopped thrusting and enjoyed watching the look on Elle’s face as Cee slided into her asshole. She took it like a champ and I couldn’t help but kiss her.

 

We kissed until she started moaning and was lost in the pleasure. I held her arms behind her back as Cee hold her hair and pounded her ass as fast and hard as she could. It didn’t take long for Elle to have the biggest leg shivering orgasm I had ever seen.

 

Cee stepped back, took out the strapon from Elle’s ass and let her roll over to my side. Although neither myself or Cee had cummed, we had the biggest grins on our faces. Elle was breathing heavily and eventually lifted her blindfold.

 

“Fuck… You tricked me again.” she said in a tired voice.

“Are you upset?” I asked warily.

“No at all but one of these days I’ll demand a real threesome with another guy,” she said as she pulled the blindfold down. “but for now, I want you to keep fucking me.” she said with a devilish smile.

 

Me and Cee glanced at each other and then spent the rest of the afternoon fucking Elle in every possible way.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/kj5o34/my_girlfriends_first_dp_was_with_a_strapon_mff