She thought I was gay, and then she took my ass.

If you’ve read about the relationship I had with my friend Brad during high school you might remember Steph.

Here’s a link to that story: https://www.reddit.com/r/gaystoriesgonewild/comments/k8wy6p/hooking_up_with_the_gay_kid_at_a_house_party/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

She found out about us and continued letting us fuck at her house for the rest of our senior year, including one time where she watched us.

Well after high school Brad went to another college far away, but Steph and I attended the same school closer to home. In high school we hadn’t been very close, but college forced us to become friends. We were basically the only other people we knew and that led to us relying on one another. We ate dinner almost every night at the dining hall together to start with and eventually started hanging out in her single dorm room since she didn’t have a roommate.

We would cuddle on her bed and watch movies but somehow nothing happened for a while between us. She treated me almost like a brother which was unfortunate because I was incredibly turned on by her athletic, petite body.

During this time I was still seeing Brad fairly regularly during breaks from school, Steph knew about it and loved hearing about me and him messing around.

The first night after returning from spring break of our freshman year, we ate our usual dinner together and she seemed a little horny.

“Do you miss fucking Brad,” she asked.

“Not really,” I told her, “we have great sex, but I don’t want to be tied down to doing it every night.”

“What makes it great,” she asked.

“We’re just compatible in bed,” I said, trying to explain something that was hard to put to words, “it’s like porn sex that’s been scripted out about what’s going to happen, but it’s all just natural.”

“That’s incredibly hot,” she said.

We finished our dinner and headed back to her room to smoke a bowl and watch a movie. She had pushed two of the dorm room twin beds together making one gigantic bed. We made a couch out of pillows where the headboard would usually be. I laid down while she connected her laptop to the TV to queue up a movie.

When she connected her tv though, porn came on instead of a movie. Two twink boys were kissing and beginning to take their clothes off.

“What’s this,” I asked her.

“Hey, only one of us got to have amazing sex all week,” she smiled, “humor me for a bit.”

She climbed in bed next to me leaving a little gap between us. She was wearing short shorts and a white tank top.

“This turn you on,” she asked me, gesturing at the two boys who now had their dicks out and touching on her TV.

“Yeah,” I laughed awkwardly, “they’re pretty hot.” I watched her move her hands down her shorts as she watched the two boys play. You could tell her hand was fondling her clit by the motion it made.

“Come on, Cory,” she teased me, “you do it too or I’ll feel weird.” I listened and pulled my dick out of the sweats I was wearing. It wasn’t hard but that would change quick enough.

“You’ve got such a nice dick,” she said, paying more attention to me stroking than she was the video. She whimpered in pleasure and I couldn’t help but notice her nipples poking through her tank top. Somehow this girl had seen me with a dick in my ass but I’d never even seen her in a bikini.

“Cum for me,” she told me gasping as her hand moved faster in her shorts. I stroked faster and erupted all over myself and then watched her quiver and shake next to me as she came.

I wiped myself up with a towel and she hugged closer to me and fell asleep on my chest. I could smell her cum though and I had a hard time thinking about anything else.

Things went on like normal the rest of that week until we went to a party on Saturday. We arrived together, but she left me to go to the dance floor with a guy from one of her classes.

I was pretty jealous about this. They were flirting and all over one another, and I was just dumbfounded as to why she didn’t want to do any of this with me.

So nursing a bruised ego I started flirting it up with another girl I had met. We ended up grinding on the dance floor and making out before this girl asked me if I wanted to go back to her apartment.

As I got to her place I checked my phone and noticed a slew of messages from Steph.

“Dude, what the hell,” was the first one, followed by, “I thought you were gay.”

It all made a little more sense now in my head as to why she’d ignored me.

“Meet at your dorm,” was all I answered back.

“Sure, I’m on my way back now,” she said. I made a quick excuse to the girl I was with about my friend needing me and headed off. She was pretty pissed but I didn’t care.

I knocked on Steph’s door but she had left if slightly ajar so that it just opened when I did. She was in her bed all covered up. I closed the door behind me, kicked my shoes off, and got into bed with her.

“I thought you were gay,” she said again.

“How many times do you have to hear that I’m bisexual before you understand it,” I said, laughing at her.

“Well I just thought you hadn’t been with anyone but Brad for like the last year,” she said and I told her I’d been with girls in that same time frame.

“Oh” was all she said, as I got under the covers with her. She scooted away from me as I did.

“Do you want me to leave,” I asked.

“No,” she said and I reached for her waist and pulling her close to me. She was naked already and kissed me as we came together.

I ran my hands over her body, touching her petite little tits and hard nipples before I went to work on her clit with my hand.

“Oh you’re good at that,” she gasped and then I kissed my way down her body so I could taste her. I made her cum as fast as I’ve ever made any woman.

Then she turned her attention to my cock. Flipping me around so she was between my legs. I was rock hard and she went to work gagging on it, until she suddenly stopped and told me to flip over.

I instinctually listened and soon felt her tongue exploring my ass. I moaned to let her know how good she was doing.

“Can I use my vibrator on you,” she stopped to ask, and I told her yes. She had a little lube and eased it in to me while she squeeled in excitement. She began fucking me hard with it very quickly until I pushed her back and grabbed her by her legs.

I held them up and pushed my cock deep inside of her. I was close but managed to hang on to fuck her til she came on me. She pushed off and onto my back where she reentered the vibrator into my ass and climbed into my cock again, reverse cowgirl style.

She used one hand to hold the vibrator in my ass, while balancing herself on my dick with the other. She slowly worked up and down on me and I couldn’t contain it.

“I’m going to cum,” I shouted, and she just kept working her pussy on me.

“Yeah you are,” she said and I released deep into her, having a twitchy orgasm that I couldn’t control.

We cuddled and talked for awhile after that, with Steph suggesting that we should find another guy for a threesome.

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/kf1dwi/she_thought_i_was_gay_and_then_she_took_my_ass