The Day I Discovered I Was Bisexual [M/M] Part 2

Here is part two of the story. It picks up right where the last one left off. The original can be found here.

I should probably describe James and me.

James was 6’2”, about 190 lbs, all muscle and a washboard stomach, sandy hair that was a bit shaggy, and gray eyes. His dick was uncut and about 6 ½ inches long, and thick at the base. It tapered at the head. It made me think of a butt plug.

I’m 6’ even, and at the time was around 175 lbs, also all muscle, but my stomach wasn’t as defined as James’. I had brown hair that I kept short (think military-style) and green eyes. My dick is 7 ½ inches long, not as thick as James’, and has more of a mushroom cap for a head.

James pulled back from the kiss and smiled. “How was your first blowjob from a guy?” he asked.

I thought for a moment, and said the only word that came to mind. “Unexpected, I guess. And amazing.” James kissed me again. When he pulled back, we locked eyes. I had never been with a guy before but I suddenly wanted to explore so many things.

James stood up. “I’m gonna take a shower before we get some sleep,” he said, and walked away toward the bathroom.

I laid my head back for a minute, taking in everything that had happened. I had only ever fantasized about being with another guy before tonight, and now I was in my refractory period after jerking off one of my best friends, and then getting a blowjob from him. My head was spinning with a mixture of confusion, euphoria, and a wanting for more.

James had just switched on the shower, and I thought about joining him. Thinking turned into psyching myself up, and before I knew it I was standing up and walking toward the bathroom. I opened the door slowly, and saw him through the shower door, soaping up a washcloth. I slid the shower door open, and he turned. A smile grew on his face. “I was hoping you’d join me.”

I stepped in and he kissed me softly on the mouth. I pulled him closer and our bodies pressed together. My cock rubbed against his and we both started to get hard again. James reached between us and took both of our dicks in his hand, jerking them back and forth. He pulled back long enough for me the speak up. “I wanna return the favor.”

James nodded and I kneeled in front of him, his dick pointed straight at my mouth. I grasped it in the middle and pushed back to the base, pulling back his foreskin again, revealing the red head of his hard cock. I stuck my tongue out and licked the tip, causing James to jump a little at the sensation. I swirled my tongue around as he had done to me, and it had the desired effect. James sighed and I felt his dick grow stiffer in my hand. I opened my mouth and pulled him toward me. I liked the feeling of him filling up my mouth. I flicked my tongue along the bottom, and before I knew it I felt his hand on my head, urging me on. I took him deeper, having to open my mouth wider as I went to accommodate the girth. I pulled my head back, took a breath, then took him in again, this time deeper. I got most of him into my mouth before I felt the tip pressing against the back of my throat. I slowly pulled back and jerked him a little. “I’ve never done this before,” I said. “You have to tell me what you want.”

James looked down at me, his eyes glassy. “You’re doing great,” he said. “Don’t stop.” I obliged and went back to sucking my friends thick cock, jacking what wouldn’t fit into my mouth. After a few minutes of , I felt him start to tense up and had a feeling he was going to blow. I was determined to make him cum, so I sped up. With my free hand, I grabbed his hip and pulled him deeper, trying to fit all of him.

His hand on the back of my head pushed me into his crotch, helping it along. “Fuck,” he said, “I’m gonna cum.” I made no attempt to pull off. Instead, I redoubled my efforts. His fat dick swelled in my mouth and I felt the first spurt hit the back of my throat. I did my best to swallow while I sucked, but with that much of him in my mouth some spilled out, landing on my own hard dick. He tasted like he had earlier, salty and sweet. I kept going until I was satisfied he was done, then milked the last of his jizz out with my hand, onto my tongue. I let his softening dick slip out of my mouth.

I stood up and James took my face in his hands, kissing me. “Let’s finish up in here,” he said. “I want to get into bed with you.” We washed up quickly, dried off, and went back to the bedroom. We stood at the edge of the bed and kissed, and James laid down. He pulled me down on top of him, the two of us making out. After a few minutes, he reach into the nightstand and pulled out a condom.

I looked at it, a bit scared. “I don’t know that I’m ready to be fucked,” I said.

“That’s okay,” he said. “It’s not for me, it’s for you.” He kissed me again while he opened it and reached between us, unrolling the condom onto my dick. He reached back into the nightstand and grabbed a bottle of lubricant. He squeezed some out and began rubbing it onto his asshole, the rubbed some more onto my condom-covered cock. “I want you to fuck me,” he said.

I leaned back a little and he pulled his legs back, revealing his freshly showered asshole. I positioned the head of my dick against the opening. “Easy,” he said. “Press in slowly. I don’t want you to tear me apart.” I started applying pressure and his anus expanded to accommodate me. Soon, the head of my cock was inside him. The tightness was almost too much, and I nearly came right then. We both took a moment to get used to the feeling, and I began exerting more pressure, sliding deeper into him. I pulled back a little, then pushed in again, working myself into his tight hole. After a couple of minute, I was buried completely inside my friend’s asshole.

I leaned down and kissed him, and began sliding in and out. James wasn’t shy about letting me know that he was enjoying it, and his hand began working on his fresh erection. Every time I bottomed out inside him, he let out and shout of pleasure. I knew I wasn’t going to last long, and slowed down to squeeze every second out of this. “Oh my God,” he said. “If you keep fucking me like this, I’m gonna cum again.” I picked up the pace, pushing as deep as I could. James stopped jerking himself off and his hands went to my ass, trying to pull me deeper. My orgasm was building and I started slamming into him. “Holy shit!” he shouted, and his dick began to shoot his warm cum onto his stomach.

That sent me over the edge. I pulled out and tore the condom off, jerking my cock until I fired my load, covering more of his stomach. When I’d finished, I collapsed onto James, our spent cocks pressed together, our semen mixed together between us, a sweaty, cum-covered mess, kissing. After a few minutes, we wiped off and laid down. We’d never shared the bed before but we held each other anyway, falling asleep that way.

I woke up a couple of hours later, my back to James, his arm draped over me. I scooted my ass back into him and felt his dick against me. I reached back and began playing with it, rubbing it up and down the crack of my ass. If I could go as far as I already had, I should try everything, I thought to myself.

James stirred awake as I played with his cock, and he kissed my back. “You just can’t get enough, can you?” he asked.

I looked back at him. “I want you to try and fuck me,” I said. James looked surprised but didn’t try to talk me out of it. He reach into the nightstand and grabbed the bottle of lube and a condom. He put the condom on, the started rubbing the lube onto my asshole. I tensed up at first, then relaxed as he started pressing his finger into me. I let him enter me, then felt a second finger try to join. It wasn’t the most comfortable feeling, at first, but as he began sliding them in and out I felt my dick start to harden.

When James was satisfied that my hole was ready, he rolled me onto my back and began to press his dick against my ass, just as I’d done to him. I felt him start to enter and instinctively tensed up again, then forced myself to relax. He started to push deeper, and I felt his head push all the way through. In my head, I was screaming, both for him to stop and for him to keep going.

The part that said to keep going won out, and my asshole relaxed enough for James to start slowly working himself deeper. It took a while, and when I thought he was all the way in he said, “okay, I’m halfway there.”

“Half?!?” I lifted my head up and, sure enough, he was only about halfway inside me.

“Do you want me to keep going?” I nodded. He leaned down and kissed me, and that helped me to relax a little. He kept working in and pain started to give way to pleasure. I completely relaxed and he was finally able to squeeze his fat cock into my virgin ass. James used short strokes at first, building me up and getting me used to it. The strokes started to get progressively longer, though he kept going slowly.

I needed more. “Fuck me harder,” I said. James did as I said, and his tender strokes built into harder and harder pounds. Soon, James was fucking me hard enough that my own dick was slapping against my stomach. I grabbed it and began jerking it. James fucked me harder and I cried out in pleasure. I never knew that being fucked by another guy could feel this amazing.

James announced that he was getting close, and not a moment too soon. I was ready to shoot, too, but I wanted him to keep going. “Don’t stop,” I said. “Fuck me until you cum.” This was too much for James and he began filling the condom while he pounded me. His cock pulsing and my own masturbation sent be past the breaking point, and I shot my load onto my chest and stomach, some hitting me in my chin.

James’ spent cock slipped out of my spent hole with a sound that was almost like a slurp. He tossed the condom aside and laid down next to me, rubbing my cum into my skin for a minute, then tasted it off of his fingertip. We fell asleep again, this time for the rest of the night.

James and I fooled around plenty of times after that, but that time was by far the most noteworthy. I didn’t come out as bisexual for a long time after that, but James was always happy to keep my secret, especially since he’d been my first.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/399k36/the_day_i_discovered_i_was_bisexual_mm_part_2