I met Elle at a Halloween party roughly a year ago. Since I’m not a huge fan of dressing up, but do enjoy the role-play aspect of it, I went as the Low Effort Pirate, with a tricorn hat, an eye-patch and a thick piratey accent. Looking back, it sure is surreal remembering jam-packed parties such as this one where everyone was dancing and jumping and having fun, not having a care in the world about social distancing or pandemics.
Two girls in particular, a Catwoman and an Harley Quinn, did not care about social distance or their surroundings at all. They were making out with such lust and passion that I could not avoid my one-eyed pirate gaze.
“Yeah, that’s pretty hot. I bet you wouldn’t mind getting in on that action. After all it’s every guys dream, right?”, I hear someone say besides me.
“Ahm, sorry, what?”, I blabber, forgetting about my pirate accent and pretending I was not fantasizing about exactly that.
To my left, with dark green eyes, dark brown hair and a pale complexion, is the cutest Low Effort Nurse, with a red cross stamped on an almost shear white shirt, that I’ve ever seen. She’s staring straight at me and I can’t avoid looking at the outline of her black bra underneath.
“Going to bed with two girls. It’s every guys fantasy right?”
“Well, not every guys but yeah. Most of us have that fantasy.”, I reply, feeling a bit boxed in by her accusation.
“I mean. They are pretty hot. Would you join them if they asked you?”
I laugh my best pirate laugh.
“That would never happen in a million years. Besides I’m enjoying the party and the company as it is right now.”, she smiles at my flirtation attempt and shifts her weight from one leg to the other.
“Have you ever told anyone about it? I’m sure the pirate life has led you to tell a girlfriend or a friend that a threesome was your fantasy?”, she asks in a mocking way.
I ponder a bit wondering if I’m actually going to give an honest answer to this cute stranger or tell her good night. Maybe it was the alcohol or maybe it was her beautiful eyes but I figured I’d answer her earnestly.
“I guess I never told them for fear of ruining the relationship. I mean, it’s a fantasy, it’s not something I keep looking forward to at every chance. But that’s hard to convey to your SO right? Would she be jealous all the time or wondering if I’m truly satisfied when we have sex? Would she stop introducing me to her female friends fearing that I’d want to plunder that booty?”, I laugh at my own joke. “Looking back maybe I should’ve taken that risk and walk the plank!”, I laugh again but notice that she is taken aback by my response.
“What about you Nurse? If two guys were making out right now would you go up to them and try to get into that threesome action?”, she laughs way too hard at this, probably because her glass is almost empty.
“For the same reasons you described. And because I don’t want to be labeled as a slut by my friends or get abused by strangers. It’s hard for a girl to find two guys that are willing to fuck her senseless but at the same time not take advantage of her. You know?”
“So it’s not about submission then. You’d genuinely like to please and be pleased by two guys, is that it?”
“Absolutely! One mouth on each titty or one mouth on each cock!”, she says giggling.
We kept chatting throughout the night about sex, relationships and other things. It felt good talking and confiding to this stranger. Before the end of the night we scheduled a coffee for the next day and in the following weeks we eventually started fucking and dating. It was the most perfect first month of relationship and I never really forgot that her fantasy was to get fucked by two guys.
Fast-forward to be beginning December and we were closing in on our first month anniversary. Inspired by the holiday season, I thought of doing something special for her.
Since I wasn’t ready to share her yet I had this idea to give her a fake threesome. My plan was to blindfold her, then use some pre-recorded messages on my phone to create a fake physical distance in the bedroom, a dildo for her to suck, and some flavored condoms so that she’s clearly able to distinguish what she’s sucking on. Besides, the condoms would disguise the texture and flavor of the dildo.
With everything clearly outlined, I went to a sex shop and bought a nice dark blindfold, a suction cup dildo roughly the size and girth of my cock, and flavored condoms. I even asked the lady at the store which ones tasted better and, instead of throwing me out, she told me that chocolate was the best and strawberry was the worst. I bought a couple of packs of each and hid everything on my flat.
————————————————————————
It’s our first-month anniversary and we’re having a nice stroll before dinner. She has this green winter dress that matches her eyes and allows a small peek of her leg tattoos under her black tights. It doesn’t have much cleavage but it squeezes her B cup tits just enough for me to notice them. I wish I could do her ass justice but you’ll have to trust me on this one that it looked phenomenal.
I’m a bit anxious and keep revisiting in my head the plan I made for her. By now she knows me pretty well and picks up on something.
“So… I bet you’re daydreaming about taking this dress off of me.”, she says in a confiding tone.
“Actually, I have a surprise for you tonight…”, I tease her a bit.
“Do you now? Care to share any details?”
“Do you like chocolate and strawberry?”, I inquire.
“As a matter of fact I do. Is it a dessert?”
“You could call it that if you will…”
“Is it going to be served in the restaurant or…?”
“No. Not at the restaurant. It’s way too messy. You’ll have to trust me on this one.”
I tease her throughout the night without going into specifics, but I was sure that she was as eager as I to get home and get laid.
We drive back to her place and, before locking the car, I very obviously take out an opaque bag from the trunk.
“Don’t tell me you left the strawberries and the chocolate all this time in there!” she says laughing.
“As a matter of fact I did. You’ll find out that they’re going to taste even better this way.”
She keeps trying to peer into the bag all the way up to her apartment but I’m not letting her have her way.
We’re now back at her living room and I’ve left the bag on top of the bed while she waits on the sofa in the living room. I revise my plan once more in my head and head over to her.
As we start making out and taking each other clothes off, I stop to admire her body in a sexy dark grey lingerie. She bits her lip and moves her head to my waist.
“Hold on a bit. Do you remember telling me about your fantasy?”
“Which one? The one about fucking two guys? I can’t believe you remembered that silly conversation.”, she responds blushing a bit.
“Yeah, exactly that one.”
“Really? Don’t tell me you hid someone on the closet.”
“Would you like if I did? Maybe I did. Maybe I didn’t. I want you to believe I did but I also want you to know that I would never betray your trust.”
She has a puzzled look on her face while I grab a couple of pillows and place them on the floor.
“Kneel here facing the sofa and don’t turn around.”, I tell her and she complies with a devilish smirk.
I move hastily to the bedroom, arrange the pillows on her bed and move a chair closer to it. The chair is going to be useful later on. Then I grab the dildo and put a strawberry condom on it and a chocolate one on myself. I leave the room with the blindfold, my phone and the dildo in hand.
On the way back I grab a chair and place it gently on the floor, with its back to her. Without her seeing me I place the blindfold on her and start kissing her gently on the neck. She giggles at this.
“I’ll be right back, don’t go anywhere”, I whisper in her ear and she wiggles in excitement.
I take a few steps back and watch her looking sexy and eager. I open the list of pre-recorded audio clips on my phone, press play on the first one and approach her again from the back, silently counting back from 30 in my head.
I kiss her on the shoulders, back and neck while reaching for her tits, groping and caressing them through the bra. As I’m closing to 20 I move my hands down her flat tummy and to her panties. I run my fingers through the fabric. She shivers and her breathing turns heavy. As I’m putting my fingers underneath the band of her panties I can hear my own voice coming from the pre-recorded message.
“Oh, I see you’ve met each other already.”
She’s startled “H-how did you…?”
At this point I’m wondering that maybe I went too far, too soon, and that she’s going to take the blindfold off. However, she doesn’t.
I get up, stand in front of her and tell her:
“There’s only three things you need to know tonight: I’ll never betray your trust; you can take the blindfold off at any moment or say stop to end your fantasy; and you have to keep your hands behind your back.”
“Alright, I like that. You’re in control but I’m in control.” she replies, smirking that devilish smirk again.
I kiss her on the mouth and tell her to look to her left. As she does, I gently pass the strawberry dildo in her lips. She doesn’t flinch and opens her mouth to suck on it. I tap the dildo on her tongue, letting her take a couple of licks.
“That was Strawberry. Look to your right.”. I wait a couple of seconds and move slightly to her right.
She knows what’s coming and promptly sticks out her tongue. I give her a few taps with my cock and let her give a few licks just like she did with strawberry. I step away and to her left again.
“And that was Chocolate. Look left.”
I do this a couple of times alternating in silence. I let her suck the dildo a bit before stepping back, prompting her to look the other direction to suck on my cock. She’s enjoying this and starts moving between cock and dildo on her own. We do this for couple of minutes with me gently fucking her mouth and then stepping back.
“So, which flavor did you like the most?”, I ask her innocently, already knowing the answer.
“Chocolate.”, she giggles.
“Ah that’s a shame, I actually picked strawberry for myself.”, I say as I move behind her so that I can attach the dildo to the back of the chair.
“Turn around. Hands on your back. I guess you’ll have to endure the strawberry flavor for a bit.”
She takes the cue and blindly reaches out with her mouth for the dildo, sucking it on her own. As she does this I kneel behind her and gently grab her tits. She freezes for half a second but then keeps sucking on the dildo anyway.
I move my hands down her body and to her ass cheeks, grabbing them firmly and pushing her gently into the dildo. Then I start rubbing her pussy from behind through the fabric, making her let out a small moan while her mouth is full.
With my right hand I pull her panties to the side and with my left hand I start moving my middle finger all the way from her clit back into the edge of her asshole. I do this a couple of times feeling her wetness until she starts raising her ass and letting out small moans. With my right hand I grab her left hand from the front and place it over her clit. She doesn’t objectify and immediately starts masturbating. I’m so hard with the whole situation that I have to control myself not to fuck her right then and there.
As she picks up the pace I slide a finger into her as deep as I can. That proves to be too much and she moves her mouth away from the dildo, letting out a moan. I promptly take out my finger from her and get up quietly, moving in front of her.
“You’re coming already? How?”, I ask her. “Oh, you’re playing with yourself. I thought I told you that you had to keep your hands on your back all the time.” I say with a scolding tone.
“But, I wasn’t the one to-“, she replies, a bit upset as I move her arm again to her back.
“Since you’re almost ready, I’ll go and prepare the bedroom.” I move quickly to my phone and play another pre-recorded message. I start counting in my head back from 90.
I place myself behind her and spin her gently so that she’s facing my cock. Again I gently tap her lips with it and this prompts her to start licking. Ten seconds in, we hear my voice.
“Well, I guess I’ll leave you there playing with Chocolate.” She moves her head away from my waist as she hears this.
Without giving her chance to reply I grab her head with both my hands and start fucking her mouth. Occasionally going really deep and fully taking it out, glistening with her spit only to shove it back in again. I do this until I’m close to the 60 second mark an then I move her hand towards her clit. Once again she promptly starts masturbating.
I keep at it for more 10 seconds and we hear my voice coming from behind her to the right:
“Hey Elle”
I quickly move her hand away from her pussy and to her back and step away, pretending we were doing something wrong.
“What??”, she says turning her head to the side, visibly annoyed.
It was at this moment that I knew that she was fully committed into the fantasy. She actually believed someone else was fucking her mouth.
“Can I move this chair from your bedroom?”, I hear myself say.
“Sure.” she replies, expecting a response.
I move her hand from her back to her pussy and she smiles, moving her mouth to my cock. She’s going really hard at it. I’m no longer moving my hips and just merely holding her hair on my hand while she sucks and licks and gags on my cock. It’s a beautiful sight and if I’m not careful I’ll cum. Luckily for me the next recording comes in 5 seconds.
“Everything is in place. Let’s move on to the bedroom.” says the pre-recorded message.
I step away from her and move to her side, noticing that she has put her hand behind her back again. She’s an accomplice to the Chocolate persona and I admit that her naughtiness turned me on.
I reach down with my right hand, grab her gently by her moist fingers and help her up. With my left hand I grab the dildo and the phone and lead her to the bedroom.
I sit her close to the corner of the bed and pause to admire her sexiness. Her head is right at the height of my erect cock and I have no other choice but to press it to her mouth. I let her taste a bit of the chocolate flavor before stepping back.
“Now, take off those panties, lay on your back and show us how wet you are.”
She complies without complaining, first laying on her back and then pulling her legs up before sliding her panties off and staying like that, legs half spread. As she does this I place the dildo and the phone on the chair, and press play on another message. I have 15 seconds.
I move back in front of her and, not satisfied with how she spread her legs open, I open them further, pull her hands down to her pussy and make her spread her lips for me.
She. Is. So. Fucking. Wet.
Her juices are dripping down her slit down to her asshole. I can’t help myself and shove my tongue deep in her to taste her pussy. Then I slowly start licking all the way from the bottom and finishing in her clit. As she let’s out soft moans we hear my voice.
“Is he a good licker?” She nods through the moans. I then start licking her more intensely in the clit. She responds very well to this raising her hips against my mouth and moaning faster. I do this until I feel she’s really getting into it and then I stop.
“Nooo… it was feeling so good.” she says, her breathing heavy.
I move to the side of the bed where the chair is and grab the dildo. With my left hand I turn her head to it and let her suck a bit on the tip.
“Do you want him to lick you again?”
“I do.”
“Tell him what you want him to do to you.”
She looks in the direction of where Chocolate would be and says “I want you to lick and finger my pussy while I gag on my boyfriends cock.”
I smile. “Well, if you manage to stick four fingers inside you, he will.”
As I say this, she starts rubbing her pussy and inserts a single finger, going back and forth, warming herself up. She looks very sexy doing this and I move her head to the dildo and slowly start fucking her mouth. With my left hand I’m caressing her nipples under the bra, pinching them and squeezing her breasts occasionally. I’m not sure how long did I get lost in this, but I notice that she’s now slowly moving her hips and I see that she’s now up to three fingers insider of her, almost to the knuckles.
I move the dildo away from the mouth and attach it to the chair. “Can you do it? Only one finger away.”
She nods, biting her lower lip. I face her head again towards the dildo and nudge it slightly towards her mouth. “Suck on it gently. I don’t want to cum just yet.”, and I move to place myself in front of her open legs.
I arrive just in time to see her pushing the fourth finger inside her wet pussy. I let her move her hand back and forth a bit, enjoying the show. As she’s now all deep in to her knuckles, I move her hand away so that I have access to her clit.
I start licking her non-stop, sometimes going lower to the entrance of her pussy but never missing her clit. She’s still sucking the dildo but clearly getting lost in the pleasure. As she moves her mouth away from the dildo to let out a big moan, I stop licking and spin her so that she’s facing down. I pull her ass up and give her a nice smack, prompting her to give a little squeal.
Before allowing her to say anything I move over to her side and direct her mouth towards my cock. I expected her to shy away from my dick since it’s covered in her juices, however, she had other plans. Instead of pulling away, she licks my cock all the way from the root to the tip and on the sides. Then she goes deep on it. I’m completely mind-blown and never imagined her to be this dirty.
As she’s cleaning me up I grab the dildo and start teasing her pussy from behind. I don’t have a lot of reach but I’m able to tap her clit with it and push gently on her slit. As I do this, she pushes her hips back and I penetrate her with the dildo. I can feel on my cock the hum she makes when this happens.
I figure that I might as well make the most of this and start fucking her with the dildo. However, unless I bend my torso a bit, and risk ruining the fantasy while she’s pleasing me, I’m only able to push the dildo in a couple of inches. She also notices this and tells me to do it harder. I do it more vigorously for a few seconds but without managing to go any deeper.
Without taking the dildo off of her, I suddenly move away from her mouth making her do satisfying a pop sound with her mouth. I place myself behind her and remove the dildo slightly sideways as if I was being pushed. Then I grab her ass with both hands, spread her ass cheeks more than I had any right to do so, and shove my throbbing dick inside her pussy.
It feels amazing. She loses strength in her arms and falls face first in the comfy pillows. That doesn’t deter me and I keep pumping for a while. Her moans increase in intensity and I step away because I don’t want her to cum just yet.
“D-do you want me to fuck you like that? Doesn’t it hurt you?” I pretend to be shocked as if someone else just fucked her.
“It doesn’t. Fuck me harder.”, she dry swallows, her breathing heavy.
Now, at this point she can’t tell what I’m sticking inside of her so the only thing I can do to differentiate from Chocolate is change how I place my hands on her beautiful ass, without spreading her cheeks.
I proceed to continue fucking her as before. In and out, in and out. The only sounds filling the room are her moans, my skin on her skin and the wetness of her pussy.
I pick up the speed unsure if she already came or not.
“I think I’m coming.”, I tell her and hear no other reply but her continuous moans. I start going as if my life depended on it and suddenly give one strong push deep into her. Then I exhale loudly and wiggle my dick inside of her, waiting before pulling away. That’s right, as long as no one’s looking, we guys can also fake orgasms.
I take it out and tell her that I need to go clean up. However, instead of doing it, I close the door of the bedroom, staying inside. As she hears the door, she starts getting up on her arms and reaches out for her blindfold. I quickly grab her hand and guide her to my still erect cock. She was not expecting this at all and reluctantly gives a small lick on the tip. Then she gently sucks on it, as if unsure of what to expect, tasting the mix between the chocolate and her juices.
One again, I’m expecting for her to pull away but instead she starts jerking me off and sucking on the tip. As I thought that this couldn’t feel any better, she begins alternating between going as far as she can with her mouth and stroking me with both hands. I let her go at it for a couple of seconds while massaging her clit and fingering her slowly from behind. Having a condom sure extends my longevity, but there’s something about this scene that makes me feel that I might cum unexpectedly.
I step away from her mouth and place myself behind her, hoping to cool down a bit. I slap her ass and, once again, spread those cheeks farther than it would be sensible. I tease her pussy a bit until she begs for me to fuck her and I dutifully oblige.
I start off slowly, making her feel the full extension of my thrusts, pushing her a bit harder than necessary at the end so that she rocks forth and back. Then I tighten my grip on her ass and pull her towards me as I push forward making a lovely clapping sound. The interval between her moans shortens and she starts arching her back.
I let go off of her left cheek and grab her hair by the root, slightly pulling her head back. She responds by using her own left hand to spread her cheek. This drives me wild. I let go of her right cheek and tease her boobs a bit. She mimics her left hand and spreads her ass for me, exposing her asshole. One part of me tells me that she wants to do anal sex, the other tells me that it might be too many new experiences for one day. I decide on a compromise. I let go off of her breast and pass my thumb on her lips, prompting her to suck on it. Then, with that same thumb I start massaging her anus slowly in circular motions. No penetration today, I’ll save that for some other time.
She starts losing her mind and slowly falls forward, my grip on her hair the only thing keeping her from sinking her head on the pillows.
I figure that I won’t be lasting that much longer and she is very close to a second, maybe third orgasm.
I stop fucking her and lay down on the bed besides her. She takes the cue, climbs on my dick and starts grinding me, supporting herself on my chest.
I’ve never seen her this wild, moaning louder than ever and making the bed slam against the wall with her motions. I reach up with my head to kiss her neck and suck on her tits. I don’t even attempt to kiss her in the mouth since she doesn’t seem to have the necessary focus to kiss me back. However, she does take her hands from my chest and sort of hugs me by the back of the head.
I take this opportunity to lay down again on the bed, dragging her down on top of me. This position obviously makes it harder for her to keep grinding me, so I place her arms behind her back, grab her ass on a tight grip and go to pound town. She’s moaning, no, screaming with pleasure right besides my ear. In between moans she says “Don’t stop…” and that’s a huge trigger on me.
I feel like I’m starting to cum and fuck her faster, hoping that she also comes from this. I manage a couple of pumps before having to stop and unload my cum inside of her as I also feel her insides tightening in a familiar fashion. Thinking back I should’ve taken the condom off to give her a nice creampie, alas, my mind was elsewhere.
We’re both breathing heavily and I have a choice to make. I either leave the bedroom and come back in, pretending that the other guy just left, or take off her blindfold and reveal the ruse. The first option would further deepen the fantasy but it would definitely make her stop trusting me as much. The second option will expose everything and prevent me from pulling the same stunt again.
I love this girl and what we just did was only because she is willing to blindly fall backwards and let me catch her. Therefore, I gently remove her blindfold, studying her face trying to gauge what is going to happen next.
“I knew it!”, she says laughing and hitting me on the chest. We share a tender kiss and I’m beyond relieved that she didn’t storm out or look disappointed.
After cleaning ourselves we went back to the bed and chatted for hours about what had just happened between us. I told her about how I came up with idea, the trip to the store and my anxiousness on certain moments of our fantasy. In turn she told how she felt on the various phases of the experience, her fears and excitements and what she liked the most and the least. I had much to improve for next time…
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/k1nxav/my_first_fake_threesome_mf
This was sweet. And hot as hell. Nice read!