I posted this to/r/dirtyconfessions but thought it might fit here as well. Let me know if there’s anything I can explain better or you have any similar stories! :)
A couple years ago I was in a dating grey area where I was seeing two girls at the same time and neither wanted to put a title on it, so I continued to see both. They were both well aware of each other, and essentially traded me back and forth from week to week or day to day depending on how their own relationships were going. One I would consider my gf, the other my fuck-toy, simply based on the politics of the relationships between us. The gf was a big fan of going on dates and staying overnight like a normal relationship, while the fuck-toy was more interested in sexting, meeting up to smoke, and quick booty calls. Ironically, the one I would consider my gf was the one more bound to her own relationship, and the fuck-toy the one who was more interested in a relationship with me – but could never make up her mind.
My fuck-toy would always complain about trying to keep her bf in line, and lamented that I gave her everything she needed without asking – I’ll admit that we did just seem to click on most levels. One night while we were high the topic got to cuckolding and I explained that I love the idea of cucking other men, but only for our pleasure, not the man being cucked. Maybe a bit slimey, I know. Without putting much thought towards it, I told her I wish I could “fill some slut up” and “send her home to get cleaned out”, not even realizing that I was suggesting something that could be a real possibility. She got very quiet and blushed, making it sorta awkward and I was worried I had said something wrong. She got up and started stripping in front of me, then looked me in the eye and just said “Okay” with a shy/sly smile. I was instantly erect and carried her into the bedroom – I wasn’t prepared at all, as things were apparently ‘getting better’ between them recently and we hadn’t fucked for a while as a result.
What followed was easily one of the top five fucks of my life. We already had insane sexual chemistry, but the filthy things coming out of her mouth, and the requests she demanded of me were on another level compared to what we had shared previously together. I guarantee the three day backlog of cum in me after not seeing either of them for a few days, plus the surprise and edging throughout the night, led to the largest load I’ve ever had the pleasure of experiencing.
Typically we’d finish a session with a team shower and high fives, but this time she excitedly got dressed and ran out the door before I had even gotten off the bed, saying “I’ll text you in a bit!!” as she left. An hour or so later I get a text and a couple picture messages, one being her panties just saturated in cum, and another of her fingering herself with my cum. The lone text saying “He had no idea! Thank youuu”. I got the full story the next day via text again – she had hopped in her car, driven directly to her bfs place and demanded that he lay on his bed so she could sit on his face. He never ate her out willingly, so she always had to ask for it and he would half-ass it at best. She played with her clit while on top of him until she came, and he didn’t even question why she was soaked at all. When she finished she got dressed and drove home to text me, amazed that some of my cum was still leaking out of her by the time she arrived.
That was my first time cucking another man, and I have to confess that I would feel a bit bad about it if he wasn’t such a loser. I miss that girl a lot.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/izrgym/28m_i_unintentionally_cucked_my_fucktoys_bf_mf
I had a girl do this to me, but unintentionally once, and it’s one of the hottest things I have ever experienced. She was basically just cheating on me, but I got so extremely turned on. Since that I have been craving this from every girl I’ve been with.