A recent dirty penpal post about gloryholes brought back a funny memory of college. It also was the first time I’ve ever publicly sexually explored with another man. Growing in a strict religious household where there is homophobia and repression of sexual desires, it really left me yearning sexual connections in college. After fooling around and getting more confidence with women, I had this experience with a friend of mine in his room in a frat house. You can read about some of my previous college sexual experiences in my history, but this story happened during my Junior year of college.
Look for the ** to skip to the sexy part
My best friend, Matt, from high school and college was a frat and lived in their house on frat row. He was popular and played on our college’s baseball team and fairly attractive. He was dating Steph, a free-spirited brunette, about 5’11” and very petite, with probably 32Bs and a fairly dainty ass that matched her frame. They had a fairly open relationship and they honestly seemed more like FWBs but called each other BF/GF. My buddy is 6’1″, broad shoulders and was pretty built given how much he worked out for baseball.
The story is only funny because despite my buddy’s large frame, he was always fairly self conscious about the size of his dick. By all means, he was fairly average, but since he was so big, his 4.5-5in cock looked pretty small. Even compared to my average cock of about 5.5-6in, he was fairly self conscious. We grew up together and have been pretty honest and open with each other about nearly everything including cock sizes. In high school, we even compared sizes soft and hard.
Anyways, back to the story. I’m invited to a frat party at the end of our Winter quarter with a Toga Party Theme. I drape myself in a white bedsheet being tied up only with some random rope I had leftover from some of my camping gear. I show up and we end up having a few beers and play some beer pong with other friends. More dudes keep showing up drowning out the guy:girl ratio and a few of us make our way up to Matt’s room to smoke and drink more.
Steph, Matt, Josh (frat brother), and Gina(friend of Josh’s) were in the room passing around a bong and talking about finals since were were all in similar classes in the health sciences when things started to turn more sexual as things often do. Since were were all wearing bed sheets as part of our outfits, we had the brilliant idea to just lay ourselves on the ground to make the floor the bed.
**Skip to Here**
As soon as we got on the ground, Josh and Gina start making out super intensely while Steph, Matt and I watched across the floor. Steph then gets the idea to take off her toga dress/bedsheet to make a partition between us so they can have some privacy. We look at each other and both nod our heads in agreement. She slips out of her bedsheet and uses the 2 loft beds on opposite ends of the room and tucks the corner under the mattress to hold it up. Steph was now just in her matching bra and panties, I remember them being white with black polka dots. She then starts hungrily making out with Matt as I leaned against the wall beginning to feel my cock stiffen under my toga. I had never done anything this public before and hadn’t even done any type of group play and felt extremely uncomfortable at first. Steph must have sensed my apprehension for what was going on because she looked over at me and said to not be shy. She reached for my hand and started kissing me just as hungrily as she was with Matt. I opened my eyes and Matt was giving me the thumbs up as Steph started to reach for the rope of my toga. She untied me and began to slip my shoulders out. Matt began taking his toga off as well and soon we were all in our underwear making out back and forth sharing Steph.
Steph stops and calls out to Josh and Gina, “do you guys want to play a game?” Josh and Gina’s head pop out around the bedsheet and say sure. They definitely were both naked behind the bedsheet as they hid their bodies. Steph then tells the guys to all stand on one side of the sheet and the girls on the other. Matt was a little embarrassed at first since he was not confident with others in the room about his cock size, but Steph motioned to Matt to take his underwear off and he complied. I felt embarrassed for him at first but then seeing Steph strip naked was all I needed to re-focus my attention. We slip out of our underwear revealing our raging boners. She tells us to stand next to the sheet and before we know what is happening, Steph lifted up the sheet only above our cocks. I then see 2 sets of hands wandering between all three of us playing with the tips and fondling our balls. I look over at Matt and we make kind of awkward eye contact that smile and laugh at how crazy this is.
Steph and Gina then start sucking Matt and Josh while Steph is stroking my dick. I’m getting crazy close to cumming and warn Steph that I’m getting close. She then stops sucking Matt and starts stroking my cock faster while sucking the tip. I almost fall going weak in the knees as I begin having one of my stronger orgasms to date. Steph swallowed every drop then went back to sucking Matt off. Matt cums and then Josh both into Gina and Steph’s mouths as we all went back to laying on the floor laughing at how ridiculous that was. Matt and I still joke about it to this day as the first and last time I get to see his small cock in action.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/iqwqzi/my_first_group_sex_experience_mfm