It’s 8 pm as I ring the doorbell of Sarah’s place. She’s a friend with benefits, without the friend part. In other words, we are just casually having sex once a week without anything more to it. We don’t have feelings for each other and we both know we have others besides each other too. Sarah asked if I could come over a little early cause she had other things to do afterwards.
She opens the door with her half long blonde hair and blue eyes. She’s wearing a white cropped top with shorts. She looks as stunning as always. I pull her close against me and I kiss her forehead. Hey you, I whisper in her ear and gently bite it. She let her head fall to the back and pants.
Suddenly you take a step back and ask me if I want something to drink. I’m confused, she had to do stuff later and that’s why she wanted me to be here early.
She closes her eyes and says.
“I just want to have some extra time with you today. I’ve got popcorn too.”
You tell me to sit down in the living room instead. I’m becoming scared, what if she developed feelings for me and want to ask for more? I’m not ready, I mean I don’t want that. I want to be free and I don’t feel the need to settle at all. In fact, we agreed on the sex without the relationship part and I’m pretty sure that I won’t develop those feelings for her.
She comes back with 2 sodas and a bowl with popcorn underneath her arm. She takes a seat next to me on the couch and I get on top of her and start to kiss her neck. Your hands aren’t eager to touch me back, so I back off and ask you what’s wrong.
You look at me and start to talk.
“Well, I went out with friends of me last night and we were talking about our dating/love/sex life. One friend of me was talking about her new lover and how much she loves him and about how great their sex life is. Her name is Jeanette, and the guy she described was you”.
She pointed her finger towards me and pressed it against my chest.
“We had one rule David, don’t fuck with each others friends. Look at what you did, you made her fall in love with you. The last time that you had sex with her was 3 days ago, and now you are here again? You know that will fuck her up entirely.”
I didn’t know, I honestly didn’t know. It wasn’t even my purpose to let someone fall in love with me. Five minutes ago, I thought Sarah had to confess to me that she had feelings for me. But in fact, it’s even worse. I’ve been having sex with a close friend of her and now Sarah feels betrayed. I like to have sex with Jeanette because she is willing to try everything I ask her to do. Now I know that she might be agreeing to it because she doesn’t want to let me down because she has feelings for me. Anyway, the sex with Sarah is way better because she is more confident about herself and is more skilled.
I raise my head, look in her eyes and say.
“I promise you that I didn’t know, I’ll cut it off with her. Let’s just enjoy each other tonight.” I take a deep breath and continue. “I don’t want to lose what we have, I want to make it up to you.”
I put a strand of hair behind her ear and I smile. She leans forward to grab her soda and takes a sip. The doorbell rings and I tell her to let it go and grab her waist with both of my hands. She gets up, so my hands are now around her hips as she turns around. My hands move to her ass when she looks over her shoulder and tell me she really needs to open the door. I try to pull her in but then she smiles playfully and says.
“I’ll be right back”.
I try to relax and eat popcorn. I hear Sarah chat with another female and the door closes. The weird thing is that I hear someone with heels walking in the hallway too. They go to the kitchen and I try to listen what the girls are talking about. After a few minutes I get up and grab my soda when I walk towards the kitchen. I lean against the doorpost as I watch Sarah talking with someone. The new woman is facing away and is wearing a tight short black dress. She has a really curvy body with a small waist. The fabric is really tight around her booty and her fit strong legs are showing beneath it. She’s pretty small, but her high black heels are hiding that. Her hair is dark brown and it is pulled back tightly and in a high pony tail.
I clear my throat and say hey. The woman in black turns around and I see her face for the first time. Fuck, I think to myself. This isn’t someone that I don’t know. I think her name was Sharon, we chatted before on tinder before she told me she was dating someone. But that’s around a year ago. Back then the tension was really strong and the chats were very sexual real fast. I smile awkwardly to her, and softly repeated myself saying hi. “Do you remem” but before I could finish my sentence Sharon start to talk towards Sarah while pointing a finger to me. “So this is the guy who’s having sex with your friend and that you want to teach a lesson?”
I interrupt them by asking what they mean with it. Sarah looks at me and says. “You said you want to make it up to me right?” I nod. Sarah smiles playfully. “Just say when it’s too much to handle for you.” She tries to keep a serious face, but she can’t. “Take your clothes off David.” I chuckle and say. “Only if you both do the same.” I take a sip of my drink while Sharon walks toward me. She grabs my drink and walks back to the counter shaking her hips a little too much. “Do what she says David, you really don’t want to misbehave near me.” Sharon’s voice sounds stonecold. I shiver and take my shirt off. I look up and the girls are looking at me and waiting for the rest. I kick my shoes off and unbutton my pants.
I hesitate and ask.
“What do you want from this?”
Sarah approaches me and look deeply into my eyes. “I want nothing out of this David, I just want you to realize not to play any games with my friends. Because if you will do, like you have, I will, or I should say we will, play games with you too.” She kneels down, right in front of me while keeping our eyes locked and she continues. “Take it off David”.
Seeing her on her knees right in front of me turns me on a lot. I want to feel her luscious lips around my cock. I undress myself entirely while looking in Sarah’s eyes. I hold my cock and move closer to Sarah’s mouth.
“Haha, not so fast David. Sarah, don’t forget why we are doing this. This isn’t about pleasing him. We are going to have fun with him, aren’t we?” I hear Sharon say behind me. She grabs Sarah’s hands and pulls her up. Sarah’s hands are sliding over Sharon’s tights dress, and revealing a bit more of her legs. Sharon leans in, and start to make out with Sarah.
Oh fuck, I think to myself. I bet they are going to enjoy each other and not letting me join in. I’ve wanted Sharon so badly last year, and now she’s playing games with me right here. I stretch out my arms, so I can touch both of the women. Sarah lets me, but Sharon quickly turns around and takes a step back. “Don’t touch me. Sarah, I want you to choose something from my bag and bring it back to me. Choose wisely.” Sarah walks away and I whisper. “Don’t you remember be, last year on twitter??” Sharon doesn’t react to it and starts to walk in a circle around me while checking me out from head to toe. She gently touches my leg with her finger. I smile back, but she doesn’t drop her ice cold appearance.
Sharon stops walking when she is right in front of me again and says.
“I don’t want you to turn around David. Just look straight forward. Can you do that for me?”. I nod, she continues. “Good. I don’t want you to say what it is Sarah, but did you manage to pick something?”.
Sharon walks away and I hear them both whispering towards eachother. I can’t make up anything out of it.
“Bend down and try to touch your toes”. It’s Sharon. Did she really forgot about me? Or is she just playing with my mind. Fuck, I want her right here and now. I tell her. “Why don’t you bend over that table so I can finally have you”. A sharp pain hits me right on my left ass cheek. I let out a “Fuck you” while I reach out to my ass to protect it. “Because I make the rules tonight David”. I love how serious and bitchy Sharon sounds like. She leaves me no other option then to listen to her. Sarah chuckles, she is clearly having a good time seeing me like this. I hear her footsteps approaching. She places 3 things in front of me on the ground. A chastity cage, restraints and a cane. I look at her in horror. Is she really…? She smiles back. “There was a lot to choose from David” she says “I couldn’t simply pick one so I’ll let you decide. But choose wisely since we could use the rest later on you whenever we want”. I’ve never used any of these so I’m not sure what to pick at all. I pick the chastity cage since they won’t let me have some fun anyway. It feels cold in my hands and I try to sound as calm as possible. “I’ve made my decision, let’s do this”. Sarah grabs the chastity cage out of my hands and puts it on. The cold metal feels really weird against my cock and it is slightly uncomfortable. But it doesn’t feel too bad and I’m glad that I chose for this.
“Follow us” Sharon says. They go to the living room and Sharon guides me to a corner. “I want you to stand here, looking at the wall, with your hands against the wall. Don’t you dare to turn your head around or to play with yourself. For how much you can in your situation. Do you understand?”. “Yes Sharon, no touching, no playing, no looking, just standing here until you tell me otherwise”. She slides her hand over my back and squeezes my butt gently.
They both sit down, and I hear them opening a bottle of wine. “So Sarah, you have told me the reasons to ask me to come tonight, but since I am here now and David is put away, let’s just enjoy our night and each other.
I hear them talking to eachother and as the time goes by I hear them drinking and laughing more. Suddenly I hear Sharon asking Sarah if she ever experienced with a woman before. I know Sarah hasn’t, but that it always was a fantasy of her. I hear Sharon talking “Just come and sit on my lap Sarah, I’ll go in the same pace as you go. Have fun with me..”. I hear them moving around and then some kissing sounds. I’m eager to watch, but I have to stand still. Sarah moans very softly, she always does when she’s enjoying it. “May I undress you?” Sarah asks politely. “Ofcourse you may, I told you to experiment with me, and I meant every word of that. I imagine the women standing, undressing eachother and kissing. I know how Sarah’s body looks like, but I can’t wait to see Sharon’s. I want to feel her perky tits and her round ass. It feels like the chastity cage becomes tighter. I hear Sarah giggling and then the sound of clothes dropping on the floor. Sarah is nervous, I hear it in the way she laughs. They sit down again, kissing and moaning softly. “Can I… Can I play with your boobs”, Sarah asks. I hear some movements and then someone is sucking on something. My mind wanders off. I need to see this. These two hot ladies playing with each other right behind me. I bet that Sarah is sucking on Sharon’s nipple. Biting it and softly twirling her tongue around it. Cupping her boobs with her hands.
I move closer towards the wall, I need something to touch my cock. But the chastity cage is preventing it. My dick hurts since the cage is preventing that I become hard. I lower my hands and try to undo the cage. It’s locked, I didn’t even notice that Sarah locked it before.
I hear the sweeping sound of a cane, a second too late to protect myself from it. It hits my ass and stings very bad. I look over my shoulder angrily and see Sharon with a smirk on her face. “Why did you do that?” I ask her to which she asks me where my hands were and where they should be. I try to explain myself that I want to join in on the fun. Sharon nods and says she understands. “Come here and I’ll let you join in on the fun part”. Something doesn’t sound right, but I have nothing to lose as well. She tells me to lay over the coffee table, while sitting on my knees. “But what’s the fun in that”, I ask. “You may watch this time, if you behave while enduring your punishment for not obeying”, Sharon says in a stern voice. Sarah giggles while playing with a strand of hair. She kneels down and ties my knees to the table legs. Then she crawls towards my front and does the same to my wrists. She gets in front of me, but facing away and slowly rise with her ass almost in my face. They stand in front of me and start making out again.
Sharon mumbles “punishment” as she bites Sarah’s neck. Sarah pushes her body further against Sharon’s and let out a soft moan. It’s incredible to see their boobs squished together with their hungry faces facing me. Sharon smirks towards me and pushes Sarah gently on the couch right in front of me. Sarah’s eyes meet mine and she spreads her legs teasingly. Sharon sits down next to her and does the same, revealing her pussy. I lock eyes with Sharon and she says with a soft tone in her voice. “Too bad you misbehaved David, you could’ve been playing with both of us. Look at how wet we are already”. She moves her right hand over to Sarah and strokes her cheek moving to her mouth. She lets Sarah suck on her fingers while she still locks her eyes with me. She slides down her fingers, and touches Sarah’s neck and move to her breast and play with them. She barely touches the skin of her boobs and Sarah starts to shiver. I look at my wrists and try to untie them. There is just no way that I can do it myself. I look at the women again, and Sharon is touching Sarah’s lower stomach now while Sarah lays down over the couch while standing on the tip of her toes to get her pussy closer to Sharon’s hand. Sharon starts to kiss Sarah’s neck and asks her if she really wants it. Sarah looks at me while she grabs Sharon’s hand and place is between her legs. Sharon starts to play with Sarah’s inner thighs and I know it’s one of her weak spots. I see that her pussy is extremely shiny by now and ready for my cock to enter. Sharon moves her hand closer to Sarah’s clit and start to circle around it. She moves her other hand to her own pussy and plays with her own pussy in the same pace. Making circles around their clits, gently touching their clits directly. Sometimes she goes in before playing with Sarah’s clit again. Sarah moans out loud by now. She’s clearly enjoying it. And everytime Sharon puts her finger inside of Sarah, Sarah thrusts her whole body into Sharon’s hand.
I try to thrust a little against the coffee table to feel some sort of relief. But it’s only becoming more painful as my cock really wants to break out of the chastity cage. Sharon looks at me and smirks. “Who of us would you want to fuck the most right now?” I’m annoyed because I’m tied down and in a chastity cage while they clearly are trying their best to make it as hard as possible for me. I look in her eyes and let out a low grunt and shoot back. “Why not both?”. Sharon laughs and move over to Sarah. She gets her left knee on the other side of Sarah and sits on her knees over Sarah now. I can clearly see both of their wet pussies right on top of each other. They start to make out, and Sharon is switching between playing with her own pussy and Sarah’s. “Like this David?” I’m defeated. This is too much to handle. I need them now. “Untie me. You won.” Sharon sits up and move next to Sarah and says “It’s up to Sarah to decide that. So what do you think Sarah?”. Sarah nods and says “Untie him.”
Sharon starts untying my wrists and I sit up while massaging my wrists. They hurt a bit from me trying to escape earlier. After she untied my knees, I stand up. “Sarah, unlock the chastity cage now please”. They sit both on their knees in front of me while unlocking my cock. Right as the cage come off, I grab my dick. It slightly hurts on the spots the metal was more tight. I grab both of the back of their heads and hold their hair. “I’m in charge now”, I say and they look at eachother and give an reassuring kiss. I stop them right away by pulling their heads from eachother. And I gently push Sarah’s head towards my cock. She looks at me eagerly before starting to suck on the tip of my cock. Sharon comes closer and start to lick and suck the left side of my shaft. Sarah moves to the side so that Sharon could suck the tip. They start switching it up, while sometimes quickly make out before I guide them to my cock again. It looks like a competition between the two of them. Each time they start to suck the tip, they try to get it in deeper.
“Lay on top of each other now.” I tell them. Sharon grabs Sarah’s hand and they move towards the kitchen table. Sarah gets up on the table with her feet dangling over the edge. Sharon gets in between her legs and play with Sarah’s pussy real quick. I clear my throat and say “It’s my turn now, get on top of Sarah, Sharon.” Sharon takes a step back right against me. She starts to move her hips and grind against my hard cock. I grab her boobs from behind and kiss her neck. I move my head towards her ear and whisper “Now.” She lets out a soft moan as I gently spank her ass once. She gets on the table too, and moves on top of Sarah. As soon as they start making out, I push myself slowly inside of Sharon. She places her head on top of Sarah’s boobs. Sarah strokes Sharon’s hair and says “I know he’s thick, just try to relax”. Sharon starts to suck on Sarah’s nipple as I slowly go deeper. I start to thrust slowly as she still needs to adapt to my thick cock. As soon she seems more relaxed and starts making out with Sarah again, I pull out and do the same to Sarah. Sarah is more used to me and after a few thrusts I move back to Sharon. She sits on her knees now and thrusts back into me. They teased me so much before so bad that I know that I don’t need a lot. I hold her hips and thrust deep inside of Sharon and she moans out loud. I cum while I pull back and the cum oozes out and drips over Sarah too. Sharon lets her head rest on Sarah and says. “Just let me know whenever he fucks up, it would be my pleasure to teach him a lesson again”. Sharon turns her head towards me and smirks.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/ifb7n4/the_fuckup