This happened years ago when I was casually seeing someone in college.
My FWB at the time (we’ll say her name was Rose) was a cute, petite/curvy girl (pic of her in comments). After a few hookups, we discussed trying other things in the bedroom. The word threesome came up, and Rose asked “what kind?” At the time, I only wanted 2 girls. She said she would be down, but in exchange for one with 2 guys. I hesitated at first, but ultimately agreed (MFM will be “part 2”).
We finally managed to find a girl we liked and arranged for one weekend where her and I could do one of them on Friday and one on Saturday.
Rose was nice enough to have the girl join first. She liked girls but was also new to girls, and ironically, so was the girl we found to join (new to girls, that is). Friday night, we met her at a coffee shop in walking distance of my apartment. The other girl (Katie) was blonde, a bit thicc and definitely nervous. We talked some and asked if she wanted to come back, which she shyly said yes. We get back and all sit on the couch together. I was in the middle of Rose and Katie, trying to break the tension. Katie and Rose had agreed on the rules of which, since she (Katie) was a bit apprehensive, they were ok with minor physical stuff (touching boobs and butt if it happened) but no kissing. I obviously didn’t mind being the center of attention, but also felt like I was forcing them to do stuff. I gave them the option to call it off, but they said they wanted to try at the very least.
Rose and I started fooling around some, with Katie watching, and I even switched over to kiss her and fool around some. I swapped back and forth and convinced everyone to start getting naked. Rose and Katie were in their bras and underwear in front of each other, Rose wearing a black bra and green cheeky panties, and Katie had a lacy white bra and blue lace panties, and were nervous about being naked in front of another girl. After some convincing, I got them to take their bras off at the same time and got them a bit more comfortable. They admitted that the other each had nice boobs, and Katie said that Rose even looked good, laughing all the while and slowly enjoying themselves.
I got Rose suck me on the couch, as Katie started watching some and rubbed herself underneath her underwear. I told Katie to come join, and she did, but ONLY when Rose was done sucking and would hold her hair back. Even though she didn’t kiss Rose, Katie definitely got some of her toungue/saliva. Rose and I started fucking on the couch, me laying her on her back and slipping off her panties revealing her bush (we both liked it and lucklily Kaite didn’t mind), while Katie stood behind me, arms on my shoulders and kissing my neck, commenting how hot it was, especially for seeing another girl’s naked body for the first time in person for her. Rose sucked herself off of me afterwards, and I asked Katie if she wanted a turn. She hesitated, but ultimately said yes. She slid off her panties, revealing a trimmed bush (neater than Rose’s), which Rose and I both complimented, and got on top of me while Rose held my dick up, letting Katie slide on and getting a slight feel of Katie’s ass (which Katie later said felt but ultimately was ok with it). Katie rode me while Rose sat next to us, while rubbing her clit, and leaning in to kiss me some occasionally. Rose got as far with Katie as touching her butt and thighs, rubbing them some as Katie fucked me.
We swapped positions and partners on and off, taking a break in between to hydrate, and finished after close to an hour, where Katie let me cum on her tits. We even offered to let Katie stay the night, but she had an early breakfast with her parents the next day and wanted to clean up and such. We figured she was over us and just wanted to bail, since she got dressed shortly afterwards and left. Rose and I texted her afterwards to say how much fun we had, and, after a few hours, we finally heard back. Katie admitted that she liked it as well as a new experience. She even said the next time, she would be willing to do a bit more touching to warm up to everything. Better than nothing.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ib4hgx/my_awkward_threesome_mff
No pic in comments yet!