[MFF] My Girlfriend – “Guess who’s back”

For those who missed it:

Here is part one of the new chapter:

My Girlfriend – A New Chapter from gonewildstories

Here is part two of the new chapter:

[MF] My Girlfriend… Honeymoon’s Over (?) from gonewildstories

Here is part three of the new chapter:

[MF] My Girlfriend – Doing it in a Magical Place from gonewildstories

And all five parts of the initial story.

Here’s part one: https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/4hhvtt/my_girlfriend_and_her_sisters_nude_habits/

Here’s part two: https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/4j1qkr/my_girlfriend_and_her_sisters_nude_habits_part_ii/

Here’s part three: https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/51flec/my_girlfriend_and_her_sisters_nude_habits_part/

Here’s part four: https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/51rgd5/my_girlfriend_and_her_sisters_nude_habits_part_iv/

Here’s part five: https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/52qhsu/my_girlfriend_my_girlfriend_and_her_sisters_nude/

I started writing this update soon after the incident happened but have been tied down by Thanksgiving, work and the very short work week last week. However I had the chance to finally finish it today and I hope you all who have followed my stories enjoy it. This is going to be one hell of a roller coaster ride.

On a Thursday afternoon a couple of weeks ago, I was trying to finish up a proposal for a possible client when I got a face time call from Erin. I looked at the clock and it said 4:30. It was either of two things, she’s on her way home or she’ll be working late.

I answered the phone.

“Hi Honey. Heading home or working late?” I asked.

“Neither” she answered. “But look who dropped in.” She swung the phone around and it was a welcome sight.

“Hello Darling. Missed me?” It was Reena. But of course being Reena I had to get the first rib in.

“Damn. Just when I thought we finally got rid of you” I said.

“You ass!!!” She replied.

“It’s great to see you. How long are you in town?” I asked.

“Only until Tuesday. My whole family is here to attend a wedding.” She answered.

Erin turned the phone around to her again and said that after work they are going to Reena’s favorite restaurant for some dinner and drinks and if I was to meet them there. Regretfully I pretty much played hookie that morning (damn you Titanfall 2) so I did not get much work done and as much as I wanted to, I had to decline. But I did ask Erin to bring Reena over after they were done. She said she will.

I wasn’t sure if I was going to get a repeat of the last time that I saw Reena but I was hopeful. If it happens or not really depended on Erin. But I decided to get ready anyway. Took a shower (a long shower), shaved and really groomed myself.

At a little past 10, I heard the door open and Reena came in first. She came over, gave me a hug and a quick peck on the lips. Erin came in about 5 seconds behind her. I said hi and we kissed. I asked how dinner was and Reena said she thinks they had an off night since the food was not as good as she remembered.

I asked if I could get her anything and Erin said that we have a bottle of sweet rose’ that she bought last weekend and it was chilling in the fridge. Reena thought that sounded good and asked if I can open it. I did and poured each girl a glass. Since I am not a big fan of sweet wines I opened a beer. I toasted Reena ad told her it was great to see her. The three of us clicked our drinks and Reena reached over to give me a hug and a kiss on the cheek and thanked me for the toast.

We moved to the living room and turned on the stereo for a little music. Reena told us that she was in town with her family to attend a family friend’s wedding and though she really does not like the girl getting married, it’s a very big deal for her family to be there (apparently that is a big thing to Indian families). The whole ceremony was going to be two days with the wedding on Friday and the reception on Saturday.

Pretty soon the wine bottle was empty and I was opening up a second one. A lot of laughter and good times. It was great to have Reena back. I must admit I missed us hanging out. By the end of the second bottle, I knew both girls were starting to… well, be uninhibited.

Reena was starting to get very “touchy”. It started with her holding Erin’s hand, then rubbing Erin’s leg. Half a bottle later she was hugging and kissing her on the cheek and at least once on the lips. I knew Erin wasn’t entirely comfortable with it and though giggling, excused herself to go to the bathroom.

Then Reena focused her attention on me. She and Erin have been sitting on one couch and I was sitting on the opposite one. Reena came over and sat next to me. She told me she missed us hanging out and she started to rub my leg. I told her the same and she hugged me and laid her head on my shoulder.

Erin came back from the bathroom and sat on the opposite couch. Reena was still holding me and I looked at Erin. She smiled and shrugged her shoulders. As if on cue Reena lifted her head and kissed me on the lips. Through the kiss, I tried to look at Erin and though she did nothing to stop it I did notice her trying to avert her eyes.

Reena stopped the kiss and looked at Erin. “Can we share him tonight?” she asked. Erin took a long sip of wine and then said “sure.” I caught the uncertainty in her voice. Reena went back to kissing me as I reached out my hand to Erin. I heard her put her glass down and sat next to me and Reena. I broke the kiss with Reena and started to kiss Erin. I knew I wanted to give Erin most of the attention. Reena started to kiss my neck and move her way to my ear. Erin held my head tight as if she did not want to let go. I was not sure if Reena noticed this and decided to go downstairs. She unbuckled my belt unbuttoned and unzipped my pants and pulled my cock out. I felt her kiss it a few times before she put it in her mouth. Erin and I continued to kiss. Erin moved to my ear, and whispered “tell me you love me, please tell me that you love me.” as if she was pleading. I told her “I loved her so much and that she was my world”. She told me she loved me and that she will always love me. At this point I was getting quite confused. Did she want me to stop Reena? But then Erin moved down to share my dick with Reena.

Erin put me in her mouth and Reena brushed her hair and kissed her on the cheek and moved to nibble on her ear and then to her neck. Watching them made me so horny I thought I was going to cum a lot sooner than I wanted to. I pulled Reena up to me and I pulled her shirt off. She unclasped her bra and fed me her left nipple. Erin was watching us the whole time. She stood up, took off her shirt and her bra, then her pants and underwear. She got on my right side and pushed her right nipple to my mouth. Reena backed off and proceeded to undress. When she was done, she pulled my pants off and took me back in her mouth. Erin pulled my face towards her, told me she loved me and then kissed me again.

Reena decided that she wanted me inside her. She stradled me and guided my dick inside her. Once again her tightness was a very pleasant surprise. As Reena rode me, Erin and I continued to kiss and Reena reached for Erin’s breast and put her nipple in her mouth. Erin’s eyes shot wide open. She looked at Reena as Reena sucked and licked her left nipple. Erin arched her back and pulled my head towards her right one. Reena and I sucked and licked her nipples. I touched her pussy and she was very wet. I put a finger in her and she started moaning with pleasure.

A few minutes later she grabbed Reena’s hair and pulled her hair back… “My turn” she announced. Reena got off of me and Erin told her to suck my dick. Reena did as she was told. After about 30 seconds Erin told her that was enough and Reena pulled back. Erin stood up, turned around and lowered her ass on my dick. Erin held me inside her for about 15 seconds and then started to bounce.

Reena was in awe. I heard her say “oh my” when she saw what Erin was doing. Erin was moaning and moaning loud. If you asked me It sounded more like she was exaggerating her moans. She laid back on me and we kissed. Reena sitting on my left side, bent over and started to suck on Erin’s breast while I put a finger inside Reena. Erin took my other hand and placed it one her clit. I played with her and she started to moan even louder. I had to stop Erin from bouncing because I did not want to cum yet and my dick throbbing in her ass drove her crazy. I kept playing with her clit and pretty soon she started cumming. Her ass gripping me as she came was just a wonderful feeling.

She reached her arm around and held me as she kissed me. She stood up and told Reena that she should finish me off. Reena asked her how having anal felt and she she said it felt wonderful. Then I heard Reena ask her “Can I try it?”. Erin smiled and said “sure”. But wait. Then she went to the bathroom, came out with a soapy wash cloth. She gave the washcloth to Reena and told her to clean my dick off first. Reena did as she was told and after Erin was satisfied, she handed Reena a condom and told her to put it on me. Then Erin put some lube on my dick and had Reena rub it on.

She told Reena it would be better if started out on top and Reena agreed. She lowered herself down slowly and if I thought her pussy was tight… her ass was another definition. I thought she would tear off the condom. But because of the lube, I slid right in. I think Reena thought it was painful. Erin told her to take it easy and take her time but my dick throbbing was not helping. After about 15 seconds she pulled me out. I must admit I was more than a little bit disappointed. I really enjoyed the tightness of her ass. Reena whimpered and said she was sorry. I told her it was fine and she should rest. Then it occured to me that I have a very good chance of getting blue balls so I reached out my hand to Erin and she knew what I wanted.

She pulled off the condom and then put some lube on my dick and started to give me a hand job. After about 30 seconds of that, I told her I wanted her pussy. She smiled and I laid her down on the couch and got on top off her. Reena came up from behind me and started to nibble on my ear. She whispered that she wanted to watch me cum on Erin and I knew what she was going to do. I pulled out at the very last second and came on Erin. My cum was from below her belly button to some on her breast. Reena teasingly bit my earlobe and said “Good boy”. Then proceeded to lick my cum off of Erin. It was a beautiful sight.

Pretty soon all three of us were exhausted and headed to bed. I woke up the next morning with Reena on my right side still sleeping. I heard Erin on the phone telling somebody that she was feeling under the weather and was going to be working from home. She hung up and went to the bathroom. 10 seconds later I heard the shower come on. Reena woke up and said good morning to me and kissed me on the cheek. She started to fondle my dick and she kissed my neck. Next thing I knew she put me in her mouth. I pulled Reena up to me, kissed her and laid her on the bed. I got on top of her and put my dick in her pussy. She pulled my face towards her and we started to kiss. The sex was more passionate than I expected. Erin got out of the shower, dried off, came to our room, saw what Reena and I were doing stood there and watched us for about 5 seconds and then got some clothes and walked out of the bedroom. Somehow in my gut, I knew something was wrong but my lust for what was going on at the moment had me focused on the task at hand. Pretty soon I finished inside Reena. We kissed and she asked if I mind if she jumps in the shower. I told her to go ahead. I wanted to check on Erin.

Erin was sitting in the dining room working on her laptop with her back towards me. I thought she was crying. I asked if she was okay and she said she was “fine”. I came around and saw her face and she was crying. I reached for her and she put her head on my shoulder and she went on full sob crying. I asked her what was bothering her. She said that she was mad. But she did not know who to be mad at. If she was mad at me for having sex with Reena. If she was mad at Reena. Or if she was mad at herself for letting it happen. Then she told me how sorry she was and to please forgive her.

It scared me to the core. In a way it brought me back to the conversation I had with Erica at the farm. The crying, the confusion, the apologies. I was very afraid to ask why she was apologizing. I ran through the scenarios in my head. And I decided I was not to going to let her go without a fight. I love Erin and I was not ready to give her up. I took a deep breath and braced myself.

“Why are you apologizing?” I asked.

She continues to cry and every millisecond she did not answer made me more scared. After what seemed like an eternity she finally answered.

“I should have been honest with you. The first time we had a three way, it was my gift to you and I thought I was okay with it. The fact that one of my best friends was leaving just made me think about enjoying the time I had with her. But the more I saw you with her, the more I knew I was not okay with it. I did not like seeing you with another woman.

Last night, I knew it was going to happen. I did not want it to happen but I let it happen. Why? I don’t know. But I should have told you. And then seeing you two this morning was just too hard.

I love you and it might be selfish, but I don’t want to share you at least not anymore.”

She was not being unreasonable. Truth be told, I’d never get into a three way with Erin and another man. I do not want to share her.

She said she knew that I wouldn’t have done if I knew how she felt, but somehow was afraid that I would be mad at her or something. I asked her why would she think that and she said she did not know.

Somewhere in that conversation, I had realized that Erin has some deep emotional wounds that I may not know about. Why was she trying to please me inspite of her inner objections? It seemed to be something that is important to her. For me to accept her by giving me what she thinks I want. Though some people might find that endearing, I see it as harmful to her and possibly to our relationship in the long run. And I love her very much and do not want to be the source of her harming herself. I had to be careful.

I told her she did not have to apologize and if I knew what she was feeling I would not have done it. She was not being unreasonable. I held her tight and I promised never to do it again and I will always be hers, all hers.

She asked me to promise and I did. I told her I loved her and that she was my world.

Reena came out of the bathroom naked with her hair wrapped in a towel. She aked Erin if she could borrow a robe. Erin told her where to get it and about a minute later she joined us in the dining room. She saw the Erin had been crying and asked what was wrong. Erin shook her head and Reena asked “was it something I did?”. I was not touching that with a 10 foot pole.

“Erin, if I did something that was out of line please tell me. It was not my intention to hurt you.” Erin hugged her friend and they cried on each others shoulder for a few minutes.

Erin pulled back and said to Reena, “I’m sorry but this is the last time that the three of us will ever be intimate again”.

Reena nodded and again apologized.

Everybody was silent for a few minutes. Erin broke the tension by asking if anybody was hungry. I don’t think anybody was in the mood to eat but we all agreed to get some breakfast at a diner down the street.

The silence in the car ride was deafening all the way to the diner and even when we sat down. Erin again broke the tension.

“Guys, we had a great night together and regardless of how I felt, let’s just be happy and not end it on a sour note”. I smiled and kissed on her on the forehead as Reena held her hand and tried to smile. Once again she apologized. The mood was noticably lighter after that but still things were not the same. Reena picked up the tab for breakfast and asked if we would take her back to her hotel. We did and again the car ride was silent.

We got to her hotel and both Erin and I gave Reena a hug. I had a strong feeling that this would be the last time we would see her. Things have definitely turned awkward. This made me sad. Reena was a good friend and even without the sex, I loved hanging out with her. She was a lot of fun and had a very good sense of humor. I knew that I was going to miss her.

We got back in the car and Erin held my hand. She once again apologized. I gripped her hand and kissed it and told her that everything was alright. She smiled and then kissed my hand.

We got home and when I went to the bathroom, saw Reena had left her underwear on the floor. Seeing where it was, I knew it was unintentional. Erin was in the dining room answering some emails. I told her about it and she really did not care.

Sunday. Erin came into our bedroom with a basket of clean laundry and asked if I could help her fold some stuff. I didn’t mind and we talked as we folded. The last thing in the basket was a pair of panties that I knew was not Erin’s. Erin took it and started to fold it.

“What are you going to do with that?” I asked.

Erin did not answer.

Above her closet she had a a plastic container that she put mementos in. She reached for the container opened it and put the panties in there. Then she closed it and put it away.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/5g4wgg/mff_my_girlfriend_guess_whos_back