[MF][MF] Truth or Dare?

We were all home from College for the summer. Me [Jake] my friend Scott and the girls we both had liked forever Becky and Jodi.

Somehow Scott had managed to get the girls to come over to his Mom’s property for a bonfire out by a small personal pond that was right behind the house that night. We had all partied there before and it was the place we all went to drink and stay out of town troubles.

His mom was home but always kept to herself. As long as we cleaned up and did not destroy anything I think she felt better knowing where we were and what we were doing. Plus she made snacks. So game on.

Scott and I had prepped all afternoon setting up coolers, icing down the beer and mowing the lawn. The usual. We both showered and noticed the girls pulling up around 6pm.

It was hot out but usually cooled off in the evening. The girls dressed for the day time heat. Jodi stepped out from the passenger side. She had on a black bikini top and low riser shorts. Her blond hair was pulled back in a pony tail. Becky rounded the front of the car, her flip flops popping showing off her blue toe nail polish matching Jodi’s. Both girls had tan skin kissed by the sun. My eyes followed her legs up to her skimpy shorts that were rolled down exposing the top of her swim suit. Her stomach was toned and she had a naval piercing that set it all off. Her chest fit her body well and was covered by her blue bikini top. Her brown hair was french braided. The top of their heads were about 6″ taller than the roof of her VW bug as they walked over. The girls could have been confused as sisters with how much they looked alike.

We greeted the girls and walked them down to the make-shift party site. Scott’s mom came outside to set out snacks. She asked Scott if that was enough or were more people coming. Scott paused and told her no, it would just be us. The girls seemed to be surprised at this information and shot each other a glance. I chimed in quickly “Here have a beer” and handed them both a cold bottle. They seemed to just go with it and we all soon started drinking as his mom went back inside.

We were all having fun drinking. I had the girls laughing. Scott was playing his radio recorded mixed tape he had made special for the evening. I was on fire duty. Life was good. The girls started dancing together a little as the sun went down. We were all feeling good when Scott suggested, out of the blue, we play truth or dare…

The girls seemed game and we all sat down by the fire. Scott had made his way over to Jodi and Becky must have liked my humor and plopped down next to me. It all started innocent at first. Simple truths. Easy dares. Until Becky said she dared the boys to take off our shirts. Jodi looked shocked at this request then busted up laughing. She said you guys should!!! We are showing way more than you are!!!
I did not have a problem with it. I had a good build and was not afraid to use it. It was actually rare that I even had a shirt on. Lol. Scott complied as well. He was not much taller than the girls and about a foot shorter than me. He was fit enough though and made up for his lack in physique with a good tan of his own. The girls seemed pleased. Life was good.

It was my turn next. The girls seemed to be hoping for truth. I thought that might be for the best and began to ask the girls if they had ever….Scott chimed in.

“HOLD UP!!!” “I don’t think so” “You cannot let them off the hook that easy?”

I have known Scott long enough to play off his banter.

“C’mon Scott, these girls are too chicken shit to do a dare!”

Becky stood up and looked at me.

“GO FOR IT!!” “Just don’t pussy out when we dare you guys!!!”

Jodi shyly nodded in agreement.

“OK” both of you jump in the water right now!!!”

The girls stood up and kicked off their flops. Becky slowly slid off her shorts revealing one of the best asses I had ever seen. She made sure I gave her my full attention. She pulled suit out of her ass crack and smiled before turning and kicked her shorts to me. The girls walked arm in arm to the water. They jumped in off the dock with no hesitation. Scott looked at me and said “Nice dare dumbass” clearly wanting something more extreme.

The girls came back soaking wet. Clearly plotting our demise. They sat back down as their bodies glowed against the light of the fire. I knew the water was cold. They had goose bumps to prove it. Becky put her cold hands on my body causing me to jump.

It was Jodi’s turn. And we were both fucked.

“I think you two need to go in the house and grab us some blankets. We are freezing!”

“Easy enough” I said.

“Yeah. But come back naked and streak around to the far side of the pond and swim back!”

“FUCK” I froze.

“I Knew you guys would pussy out!” Becky replied.

Scott said “Lets go”

We got in the house grabbed some blankets and made it to the back door.

Scott said “Do NOT fuck this up for me!” I nodded.

We started to undress by the door when his mom walked by. She just quickly turned around and said “REALLY GUYS???” Laughed and walked away shaking her head. She was/is cool.

We broke out of the starting gate like olympic runners. We passed the laughing girls throwing them the blankets. Made it to the other side, dove in and started swimming. It was cold. I regretted it as soon as I jumped in. My cock and probably my balls shrank up inside me. The final reveal was not going to be impressive. When we reached the other side each girl was sitting wrapped in a blanket. As I reached Becky, half covering myself with my hand, the girls went into a laughing hysteria. No doubt noticing the shrinkage. Becky opened her blanket so I could quickly sit between her legs. She wrapped me up with the blanket. I looked over to see Jodi was nice enough to do the same for Scott. They felt warm. Life was good.

We stopped daring after that and fell into the warmth of the girls. The lights in the house were now off. Our clothes were inside but nobody was in a hurry for us to get them. Soft, cold hands eventually moved around to the our fronts under the blankets. Rubbing our chests and slowly down to our laps. Scott and Jodi got up after awhile. They walked over to the paddle boat and went for a ride. When they were out of sight Becky repositioned herself to face me. Her thin bikini bottoms grinding on my now warmed up cock. I placed my hands on her face and began kissing her. I kissed down to her neck and shoulder. Her top straps fell forward as I smoothly untied them. She dug her nails in my back as I bit her tan shoulder. I slid my hands down to her back releasing her top. I quickly threw it off to the side. She pushed me back to the ground and began kissing me hard. Her breasts pushed against my chest as I moved my hands to her ass. I started to slide her bottoms down, but she had to assist do to our position. They were cast aside. She laid back down over me and slightly to the side. She placed her leg on my cock as we bagan to kiss again. She gave me one last hard kiss and lowered her head under the blanket taking me with her mouth. She was fantastic.

In the distance I could hear the paddle boat make shore. I pulled Becky up and she sat sideways on my lap. Our two partners in crime walked up together wrapped in their blanket and resumed their previous sitting position.

“Hey guys! What were you guys doing out on the paddle boat?”

Scott smiled at Becky’s queation. Jodi noticed our state and must have seen Becky’s suit that was thrown on the ground. She laughed and threw her bikini on the ground to match. We all laughed. Scott said he needed to grab something and started getting up. I got a front row seat to Jodi’s body as Scott left. She seemed to still be struggling with her shyness, but let us have a little peek before covering back up. Becky let out a “HELL YEAH GIRL!” causing her friend to put her head under the cover. She was smoking hot though. Scott was not gone long and just simple threw me a condom.

By that time everyone was just ready for whatever. I laid Becky back and kissed my way down to her wetness. She grabbed my hair and guided me into position. She was moaning and getting wetter and wetter. Thankfully she pulled at me signaling she wanted me before I suffocated under the blanket. I put on the condom and eased up and began to kiss her. I slowly entered her a little at a time making sure she would enjoy me inside her. I began to go faster and deeper. I looked over to see Scott was also having luck. But they had lost the blanket and the shy girl from before was now on all fours and he was taking her from the back. She was really enjoying it and was rubbing between her legs. She looked perfect. I noticed Becky was watching them also. She must have been really turned on by her shy friend getting fucked like that. She rolled me over letting the blanket fall as she mounted me. The sweat on her breasts now glistened from the fire. She rode me hard. Watching her friend. Kissing me. I could tell she was getting close. She started moaning louder and slowed down because her body was failing her. I grabbed her hips slightly lifting her. Scott and Jodi watched as I thrust upward inside Becky, making loud wet sounds as she fought through her convulsions. She started screaming and said “OHH FUCK JAKE!!!” I could not take it anymore either, lifting her hips and crashing her into me a few times while we came. We both fell into each other spent.

I stayed inside her as we watched our friends fuck. It was hot it was animalistic. Scott flipped her over and really started fucking her hard and fast. Her toes curled and she squealed as she came on his cock. This set him off and he kept pumping until he could no longer take it. He pulled out ripped the condom off and came on her belly. It drove her crazy. Fucking hot as hell. Life was good.

We all took a swim to clean off. The girls hung out with us for awhile longer. Then they had to leave.

This is only my third story. Hope you like it!!!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/gm8thk/mfmf_truth_or_dare