“Oh fuck…….oh fuck” I whispered as my eyes darted back and forth trying to process what had just happened.
“Dad are you in there with Lilly?” Tara said as she knocked again on the door. “Better think of something fast” the demonic voice said. “Ummm……….ummm, yes Tara I am here with Lilly” I said while staring at Lilly’s still glazed over eyes. “Oh well can I come in then?” Tara said in a concerned tone. “NO!!!……….I mean no, I hit my head pretty hard in the pool. Their is blood and I don’t think you would want to see that Tara.” “Ew Dad!! Are you all right!!” Tara said nervously. “Yes sweet heart I am okay. Lilly is still looking for a bandaid. Go back to the pool it shouldn’t be much longer.” “Oh….oh okay dad” I press my ear against the door too make sure that she was indeed going back to the pool.
“Nice save Ol Marty boy” the demonic voice said impressed. “This is it! What ever you are. You’re over as soon as I figure out a way to fix this” I say to myself. “Their is now way out Marty. You gaped this poor innocent teenager girls asshole beyond repair” the demonic voice said mockingly. “I can’t! I just fuckin can’t do this anymore!” I say to myself as tears roll down my face. “Marty don’t blame yourself. Lilly wanted that full 11 inches inside her rectum or else she wouldn’t have squirted like a broken fire hydrant” the demonic voice said trying to calm Marty down. “I’m just gonna blow my fucking brains out because I am not hurting anyone anymore” I say to myself defeated and broken.
“Whoa there Marty lets dial it back a bit. If this is about Lilly she deserved it Marty” the demonic voice said concerned. “DESERVED IT!?!?! No one deserves to be raped!” I say to myself. “Marty I know you’re dumb but you are not blind. This girl blackmailed you into having sex. She threatened your life. If anything you prolapsing her ass was self defence” the demonic voice said. “…………I’m opening up this window and jumping out and letting my head break into a million pieces like humpty dumpty” I say to myself as I motion towards Lilly’s bedroom window. “Okay, okay Marty jeez. That was………insensitive of me to say but I can fix this. Let me help you and once I do I will be gone forever” the demonic voice said annoyed. “Gone?” I say to myself. “Yes Marty……gone” the demonic voice says.
“Okay then. What do I do?” I say to myself exhausted. “Well first we need to get rid of this girls bed sheets. You don’t have time to clean her pussy juice and your cum off them so find something to put them in” the demonic voice says. I scramble around Lilly’s room looking for something to store her ruined bedsheets in. I open her closet and look down. “A suitcase!” I say to myself with excitement.
“That’s perfect Marty. Now take those sheets and shove me in there” the demonic voice says. I carefully try move the bed sheets from under Lilly who is still unconscious on her bed in a all fours position with cum still leaking out of her ass. The sheets make sloshing noises as I try pull them from underneath Lilly. “Mmmh” Lilly groans as I try to pull her bedsheets away from her. “It’s okay Lilly. You had an accident and I need get these bedsheets okay?” I say to her in a reassuring tone. After some more careful pulling I finally get the bedsheets away from her. I look at them in disgust as I watch Lilly’s pussy juice and my cum mix together as it runs down the ruined bedsheet and to the floor.
“This looks like a teenage boys gym sock” I say to myself as I pack her bedsheet into the suitcase. I clean up the floor and make my way towards Lilly’s door when I hear. “Wait! Marty…..you forgot something” the demonic voice says sternly. “What?…..what is it now I wanna get out of here!” I say to myself. “Turn around you idiot” the demonic voice commands. I turn around and realize what I missed. In my scramble to get Lilly’s sheets packed and her floor cleaned I forgot one crucial detail. Lilly’s ass was still leaking with my cum. “You’re gonna have to clean that up Marty” the demonic voice says. “What! I can’t clean cum out of my daughters friends ass!” I say to myself in shock. “Fine. Good luck telling the cops how your baby gravy got stuck in her ass then” the demonic says in a aggravated tone. “Lord please forgive me for what I am about to do” I say to myself.
I walk towards Lilly. Her body is soaked in sweat and she’s quivering. I grab a towel and gentle place my right hand on her ass and hold the towel to my side with my left. Her ass is just a blown out mess. I begin to gentle wipe the cum from her ass with the towel. “Ahhhhh” Lilly quietly moans. I can feel her asshole pulsating around my fingers as I move them deeper with the towel to clean the remaining cum still leaking out. “You gotta get in deeper Marty to get all that out” the demonic voice says. “I’m not fisting Lilly’s ass” I say to myself in disgust. “Well you have to be thorough or else it’s over for both us” the demonic voice says. “God damn it! Fine!” I say a loud. I close my eyes to not witness what I am about to do. I slowly inch my four fingers wrapped in the towel deeper into her ass. I feel Lilly’s ass suck and squeeze my fingers as if she was inviting them inside. I now have four fingers inside her ass up to the knuckle. “Well that wasn’t too bad. I say to myself. “You gotta get that thumb in there Marty” the demonic says. “Can you calm down? You have no patience” I say to myself annoyed. “Okay Marty take your sweet time. Good luck explaining to Tara how your hand ended up in Lilly’s ass because you took too long” the demonic voice said. “Okay, okay just let me do this slowly. I don’t want to hurt her anymore then I already have” I say to myself. “Clocks ticking Marty” the demonic voice says.
I slowly press my thumb into her ass so it can join my other four fingers. “It’s getting tight now” I say to myself. “Marty she took your entire 11 inch dick up her ass. Stop treating your hand like it’s a bull in a china shop and hurry the fuck up!” the demonic voice demanded. “Alright, alright” I say to myself as I feel beads of sweat drip down my for head. I begin to put pressure on my hand trying to get it farther into Lilly ass but it won’t budge. “It’s stuck” I say to myself. “Are you fucking kidding me Marty? Try harder!” the demonic voice cries out. I put my full body weight into my hand trying to make it move but it won’t. “My hand can’t move any further” I say to myself defeated. “Fuck this I’m taking over. I gave you a chance to redeem yourself Marty and you blew it” the demonic voice said. “Wait wha-” before Marty can finish his thought the demon takes control of Marty like he did before. “I’m so tired of fixing all you’re messes” the demon says as he successfully gets Marty’s whole hand in Lilly’s ass to clean out his cum. Just then the demon hears a noise.
“Splusshhhhhh” the demons hears as he looks under Lilly. “God dammit are you squirting again? Marty just fucking cleaned your bed!” “I……..I’m sorry Marty” Lilly said in a quivering voice. “Hold on I can fix this” the demon says as his eyes scan the room to find a solution to Lilly squirting pussy problem. He spots a garbage can next to Lilly’s bed. “Perfect” the demons says as he places it underneath Lilly’s pussy to catch her squirt. “Now squirt in there you whore! No more squirting on your bed young lady” the demon says as squirt juice continues to flow out of Lilly’s pussy with each thrust of Marty’s fist. “Yes sir Marty” Lilly says in a mumbled voice with her face still buried in her sheets. “You know for someone who doesn’t like getting fucked in the ass. You sure do squirt like someone who does” the demon says in between pumps of his fist. “D……don’t…don’t say stuff like that Marty. That will make me cum more” Lilly says trying to catch her breath.
“What? you mean telling you how much your teen ass loves your Daughters Dads fist in it is gonna make you cum more?” “Y…..yes…please don’t say anything else. I don’t no how much more squirting my pussy can take” Lilly says sheepishly. ” Well how else am I gonna clean Marty’s cum out of your ass?………I’m not gonna let him get caught for this Lilly” the demon says as he furiously starts pumping her ass with his fist as he tries to clean and simultaneously fuck it at the same time. “AGHHHHHHHH!!” Lilly scream as she lifts her head and arches her back trying to take the pleasure of Marty’s fist jack hammering her asshole. “Look at you? I’m milking your cunt juice out of you by punching your ass. What would your parents think of you if they knew this made you cum so hard?” the demon voice asked. Lilly grabbed a pillow from her bed and bit down on it to muffle her screams of ecstasy as Marty’s keep assaulting her ass with his fist. “All done” the demon said as he ripped Marty’s hand out of Lilly’s ass causing one last final jet of pussy juice to blow out of her urethra and into the now full garbage can before passing out again.
“Okay Marty she is all cleaned up” the demon said as he exited his body. Marty clasped to floor trying to catch his breathe. “Fucking, Tell me next time you are gonna do that!” I said a loud between gasps for air. Exhausted from fisting Lilly’s ass. “Well then don’t be an incompetent waste of space and I won’t high jack your body next time” the demon said proudly. “I can’t believe I just fisted my best friends daughters ass” I say to myself in disbelief. “Me either Marty. But seeing that spoiled sluts ass made me so mad I just had to do it” the demon said. “You didn’t have to make me rape her ass with my fist. It was almost clean” I say to myself. “Well almost clean isn’t good enough when you rape a girls ass. I’m not getting locked up with you because your too proud to get the job done” the demon says coldly.
“What am I gonna do with this?” I say to myself as I look at Lilly’s garbage can filled to the top with her pussy juice. “Keep it as a trophy for a job well done!” the demon says jokingly. “I’m dumping this in the toilet” I say to myself as gather up the towel I used to clean my cum out of Lilly’s ass and shove it in the suit case with her ruined bedsheets. I pick up her garbage can trying not to spill it and head for her bedroom door. I gently open the door and sneak out as I shut it behind me. I creep down the hallway trying to keep the garbage can steady. I don’t want any of Lilly’s pussy juice on the floor.
I find a bathroom and make my way inside. I pour Lilly’s squirt into the toilet and flush it. I close the lid and sit on the edge of the toilet and put my hands in my face trying to compose myself. “Marty we don’t have time for this. You can grieve about how you fisted Lilly’s ass another time but Tara is waiting for you” the demon said. I take a deep breath “you’re right” I say to myself as get up and walk over to the mirror and stare at my worn out face that now looks like it’s aged decades from all the stress this voice in my head has put me through. “You can do this, you can do this!” I say to my reflection. I grab and the garbage can and the suitcase and open the bathroom door and head outside to meet Tara by the pool.
I make my way to Tara who is sitting at the edge of the pool with her feet in the water and her arms crossed at her side. “She looks pissed” I say to myself as I approach her. “Where the fuck were you dad!”. I dropped the garbage can stunned. “Whoa don’t use that tone with me!” I say. “Whatever dad let’s just go. You ruined Lilly’s pool party for me!” Tara said as she storms off to the car. “I can’t believe my daughter just cursed at me” I say to myself disappointed. “Marty you just fucked and anally fisted an 18 year old girl, just pick up the garbage can and get out of here and be glad the she didn’t ask anymore questions” the demonic voice said. I do as the demonic voice commands and pick of Lilly’s garbage can and head for the car. Hoping Tara doesn’t enquire further of what happened in Lilly’s room on the car ride home.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/gkcwde/those_big_green_eyes_part_5