Two Sisters in One night… Then the older sister again about a week later. And then again about 5 years later. [MFF]

About 10 years ago when I was a young, dumb, and full of cum young man [M21], I lived in my childhood home all by myself. My parents had moved to another state and I was a server in college, so they let me stay in the house. Needless to say, my house was the party house (you know how servers get down). I was, reluctantly, in a relationship with a girl I worked with. She was nice and kind and all, but I wasn’t wanting to be in a relationship at the time.. the only reason we were is because I came home drunk one night and just said sure let’s go for it… But I digress.

I had a separate group of friends who lived down the street that had parties of their own. This is where I met the sisters… Let’s call the older one Sarah [F early 20s] and the younger one Jessica [F 18 or 19]. Sarah was blonde and that sort of sexy cute. Not a model looking bombshell, but damn pretty and confident, which made her even sexier. Jessica was slim with a tight athletic body, and wore glasses that gave her that sexy nerdy librarian vibe. I had spoken to Sarah a few times before but I knew she had a boyfriend so there wasn’t much happening there. Her sister Jessica was more quiet but sweet. We spent a lot of time just chatting about random shit on the sofa. It wasn’t too flirty, but I had the sneaking suspicion that she was at least a little bit into me.

During Halloween of that year I had a party at the house. It was a rager… Dozens of people in the house, the kind of party that you have to squeeze between people to get to where you needed to be. I had three separate TVs in the living room for video games, enough liquor to send everyone into a coma, plenty of weed upstairs to smoke on the roof, the works. Sarah and Jessica both came with my other friends, and they came looking HAWT. Sarah had a sexy cat outfit on, nothing too revealing but hugged her figure nicely. Jessica came in a sexy taxi costume, complete with a super short skirt.

My girlfriend at the time was of course there (we ended up breaking up like 3 days later), and she didn’t like Sarah. During one of my previous parties she had gotten to my place after work, and Sarah was sitting next to me on the couch and it pissed her off cuz she was “too close”. There were like 5 or 6 people jammed onto the couch, so it wasn’t anything naughty, but whatever. Anyways, Sarah made sure to steer clear of me during the Halloween party. Once everyone started getting drunk, there was a point during the party when my gf, her friend and I were standing in front of the staircase talking. Sarah, Jessica, and a few others walked by us to go upstairs and as they passed I felt Jessica brush against me slightly. As they walked up, I glanced up and I could see Jessica’s tight little ass in a thong peeking out from under her short skirt. I looked at her face, and sure enough she was looking down at me with a smile on her face. #game on

Some time later, a bunch of us were taking shots and Jessica ended up right next to me. After we downed it, I turned towards the sink to put my glass down, and muttered quietly to Jessica “meet me on the front porch”. Without a word, she put her glass in the sink and walked towards the front door. I said whatever to my gf at the time, and after a minute walked outside. Jessica stood there and without saying anything we walked around the side of my house. I led her across the backyard and around to the side of a neighbor’s house. She immediately put her hands on me and we went to work. I pulled down her costume so her tits were out and pulled her thong straight off. I bent her over the ac unit and just shoved myself inside of her. She let me hit it for a while before she turned around and laid in the grass. I put my cock in her mouth and finger fucked her for a bit until I climbed on top and kept going at it. When we had first started she told me to make sure I don’t cum in her, but now she was moaning for me to cum inside. In hindsight, clearly not the best idea, but whatever it all obviously worked out. I came deep in her and stayed on top of her making out for a while. We stood up, got dressed, made sure to tell each other to keep it to ourselves, and walked seperate ways back to the house. We were gone maybe 10 minutes tops, a nice sexy little quickie.

We came back to a party in full swing. the rest of the night her and I kept stealing little glances at each other but nothing else came of it. It was probably around midnight at this point. My girlfriend’s friend was already wasted off of her ass and throwing up so my girlfriend needed to take her home and was coming back. During this, at some point I walked upstairs to my bedroom and I heard something in the bathroom. I went in there and saw Sarah and her boyfriend smoking a joint and blowing it out the window. I didn’t mind I just wanted to smoke a bit. After I had hit it a couple of times her boyfriend wanted to go back downstairs and play beer pong so he left us there to finish the joint. It only took us a few more Puffs to finish and after we did we stood there talking for maybe a minute. I turned off the light in the bathroom and as I went to walk out Sarah took my hand and I turned around and she asked me to stay. I got the hint immediately and we just started making out. I didn’t close and lock the doors, I wasn’t paying attention at all I didn’t care at the moment. After making out for a bit I just pulled up her skirt and started grabbing on her ass cheeks. She reached out and started tugging on my cock. it didn’t take long for me to turn her around bent over the sink and just start getting it from behind. I remember her moaning a little bit too loudly but we didn’t get caught so everything worked out. After a few minutes she said we needed to stop so her boyfriend or my girlfriend didn’t get suspicious of where we were. She fixed her clothes got everything set up in the mirror and walked out. I stayed behind and fixed my costume and washed myself up a bit. I was up there long enough because as I was walking out of my bathroom and to the bedroom door, I see her coming back in the room and closing and locking the door behind her. She came right towards me and started kissing me until I backed up and laid on the bed with her on top of me. She pulled my dick out and sat on top of it and rode the ever living hell out of me. We went at it for what I thought was a ridiculous amount of time until I started to cum. To my surprise when I told her she hopped off got on her knees and sucked my cock until I came in her mouth. I had never came in a girl’s mouth up to that point so it was extra awesome for me. When she finished we kind of laughed about it.. she went to the bathroom to clean up I went to the hallway bathroom to clean up and walked downstairs. It didn’t dawn on me until much later when I was sober that I had just hooked up with two sisters within maybe an hour of each other, and I might potentially have an awkward conversation with one or both of them coming soon.

The night went on, everyone went home blah blah blah. A week or so later my friend and I went to the bar and of course we ran into Sarah and her boyfriend. We say what’s up to them and the first thing out of Sarah’s mouth is “you fucked my sister”. I kind of stood there staring for a second trying to gauge but thankfully she had kind of a shit eating grin on her face. She repeated that phrase a couple more times I guess to drive the point home. We ended up laughing with her and her boyfriend and playing pool a little while later. At some point someone had decided that we needed some weed, and I decided to make the drive back to my house to get it. It was literally a 3-minute drive so I wasn’t worried. Out of nowhere Sarah said that she would go with me. I remember thinking she was going to give me an earful for hooking up with her sister an hour before her but then I was also thinking why would your boyfriend let you go get weed with some other dude. But she was quick on her feet and told her boyfriend that she had to take a shit and didn’t want to do it in a bar public restroom. We cracked up but apparently that was the perfect thing to say because 10 seconds later we were getting in my car and heading to my place. In the car she made a couple of snide comments about me hooking up with her sister and making sure I didn’t tell anybody and wasn’t going to tell anybody which I obviously wasn’t.

We got to my place and walked inside. I went upstairs and grabbed the weed which took me all of 20 seconds and I expected her to be in the bathroom by the time I came back down. when I came downstairs she was sitting on the arm of the sofa and I looked at her confused for a second. The house was dark and she told me to “come here” and it instantly clicked in my head. I wasted no time and walked over there and started kissing her madly. I sat on the sofa and she got on top and rode me for a good little while. I flipped her around, ate her from behind for a bit and started hitting it doggy style. She asked if she could lay on her back and I climbed back inside of her. After a little bit she started saying “come for me baby, come”… Which is like the hottest thing. I told her I was about to come and when I did I felt her hands grip my back and she squeezed her legs tight around me. I was expecting to pull out and have her suck it again but as it was coming closer and closer I was pushing harder and harder she just kept saying come come while gripping me. So I ended up blowing my load right inside of her. she kept wiggling her pussy around my cock for a little while we kissed passionately. After a beat we got up looked at each other, chuckled a bit, and got dressed. She got herself cleaned up in the bathroom and everything and we went back to the bar. When we got back, both my friend and her boyfriend were like damn it took you long enough. Again without missing a beat she said sorry I had to throw up a bit but I feel much better now, which my friend and her boyfriend accepted without question.

For the next few months Sarah and I continued to fuck each other’s brains out any opportunity we had. She even told me that she had sex with me way more often than her boyfriend. I had broken up with my girlfriend at the time a few days after the Halloween party so I was always free and available in my house so she came over there. She was on birth control or so she said so I honestly typically just came inside of her. It ended when I moved out of state, but lo and behold when my friend got married and I went back to be one of his groomsmen, who do I see at his wedding but Sarah and her boyfriend… Who is now her husband. My friend got married outdoors in this really beautiful area that had a path for walking through the trees. At some point during the reception I was walking down the path texting an old flame of mine that still lived there in the hopes of leaving the wedding and having some fun with her, and I heard some feet behind me. Sarah was catching up to me with a couple of drinks. We walked for about 10 minutes talking about the past and the parties and shit. We came to this little gazebo area that was dark and we decided to have a seat. We could see the wedding area and people in the distance but unless someone walked the path, turned down the small path that led to the gazebo and straight walked into the gazebo they wouldn’t have seen us. we stood up to walk back to the reception area and I gave her a hug. As soon as we started hugging I felt that sexual tension. She was wearing a strapless pretty dress with her back showing. I could feel her skin underneath my fingers which she seemed to enjoy. I gave her a kiss on the cheek and then figured fuck it, and started kissing on her neck. She immediately reciprocated and started kissing me madly. We slinked back inside the gazebo I sat on the bench and she straddled me. There was a lot of heavy grinding until she finally lifted up her dress enough for me to grab on her thighs and her ass. She wasted no time and pulling my cock out and sliding on top of it. She slowly road me for what seemed like an eternity until I was about to come. She hopped off and let me come in her mouth. Afterwards she laughed that she wasn’t on birth control anymore and her and her husband were trying for a kid.

I still talk to Sarah every once in awhile. And she still sends me random nudes. I know as an adult you’re supposed to leave the past in the past… But she is one piece of my past that I will 100% forever keep.

Apologies for the length of this post. I was just sitting here reliving it as I was typing ?

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/fi5i0j/two_sisters_in_one_night_then_the_older_sister