This story happened a long time ago, but it’s funny enough to share. My writing style tends to get a little long so I’ll mark the beginning of the sexy stuff with dashes across the page.
The story involves four people; Rachel, Lauren, Anthony and myself. Anthony and myself were both early 20s, the girls were both 20. Quick descriptions:
Rachel – average height (5’5”ish), proportionate weight (maybe 130ish) C cups, good curves, blonde hair just a little past shoulder length
Lauren – short (5’2”ish) tiny (maybe 105ish), a cups with a cute little ass and long blonde hair.
Anthony – 6’3” 220, very muscular gym regular, light brown hair
Me – 6’ even 185, not as big as Anthony but I was in great shape at the time (before I evolved into my current dad bod) ??♂️
Ok, on the the story.
Anthony and I had just finished up a slow pitch softball game and decided to stop by the bar on the way home and have a few cold ones with some of our teammates. We had won a close game against a team we had never beat and were in celebration mode. We were both in the last year of college and pretty broke, but my boss said he was picking up the tab so we knew it was about to get wild.
Fast forward a few hours and we were both feeling no pain when Lauren started texting me. I worked with both her and Rachel and they wanted us to come over to her parents place. Rachel had just broken up with her boyfriend and they wanted to hang out and drink. Since they were both 20, obviously the bar was out of the question.
I showed Anthony the texts and we quickly agreed to meet them over there in an hour. Both of us badly needed to shower…
We ran back to his apartment and rinsed off quickly, threw on some clothes & deodorant and we were off. Lauren told me to call her when we were close and park a couple houses down the block. Her parents were home, but asleep, and definitely wouldn’t approve of two guys dropping by at midnight.
I pulled up and this house was MASSIVE. We parked a few houses down as requested and walked around to the side of the house and through to the back yard where there was a guest house. Rachel and Lauren had been hanging out back there and drinking a little bit. Apparently Lauren was living in the guest house while she was home for the summer.
———————————————————————
Anthony and I walked in, I introduced him to the girls and we all started playing drinking games. The conversation got sexual quickly… Lauren was immediately drawn to Anthony and I had been flirting with both girls as work for months so I had no real preference. Again, Rachel had just broken up with a long term boyfriend and was possibly looking for a rebound. I had no shame (still don’t) and was more than willing to be her rebound. Lauren brought up the breakup first…
“I can’t believe he broke up with those tits,” she said looking up at me. “She has porn star boobs”.
I grinned and said I didn’t believe it. She was wearing a loose t shirt and our work uniforms didn’t really show anything off.
“Prove it!” Lauren yelled out. “Show them.”
Rachel shyly pulled her shirt up to reveal no bra, and indeed a perfect set of tits. Both me and Anthony were impressed with her ample and perky boobs. She also had very proportional nipples, which I definitely loved. I feel like bad nipples can ruin otherwise nice tits.
Lauren reaches over and cupped both boobs and said how jealous she was of them. Then she looked up at us and said she didn’t want to show us hers next to Rachel’s.
We fed her some line about wanting to see them anyways, but she refused for now.
The game continued and Anthony pulled a “never-have-I-ever card.
He looked at Lauren and said, “never have I ever made out with a girl on the first night I met her.” (Which I happen to know is total bullshit, but a smooth move none the less).
Lauren was notoriously perpetually horny and she took the cue and jumped into his lap and started grinding on him as they made out. I took this as my chance to make a move and went over next to Rachel.
She mentioned that they were really getting after it and maybe we should move to the other room. I looked over at them and saw Lauren start to reach down Anthony’s pants and agreed.
She grabbed me by the hand and led me into the next room and pushed me down on the bed and pulled her shirt off showing those perfect tits again. I was immediately hard. We were both pretty drunk, but we started making out and removing clothes. I moved from her mouth down to each breast and worked a finger into her pussy, she was already pretty wet. She pushed me back and pulled my boxers off springing my erection free.
She gasped and told me it was the biggest she’d ever seen. I found out later it was only the second she’d ever seen but I didn’t know at the time so it gave me all kinds of confidence. I know I’m not small, but I also know I’m not a porn star. Lol
Anyways… she climbed on top and started to ride me bareback, but after only a few seconds she got visibly upset and stopped. She wasn’t over her ex, and as horny as I was, I had to stop. She started to apologize, I was trying to be a nice guy so I gave her the blanket to put over herself and told her it was no big deal and I understood. We decided to see what the other two were up to, I was hoping they were going at it and it would rekindle what we had going.
We opened the door and Anthony and Lauren were awkwardly sitting on opposite ends of the couch. Rachel and I looked at each other and then back at them.
“What happened? Anthony did you fart or something?” I asked.
“Fuck no,” he replied. “I drank too much”
Lauren, clearly disappointed, blurted out, “He can’t keep it up!”
We ended up leaving, the night a complete failure.
Apparently, Rachel then told Lauren what happened to us because Lauren texted me again about 10 mins after we left saying it was too bad neither of us got what we were hoping for and that we should’ve hooked up.
I replied that the night was still young and that I could come back because Anthony was passed out cold.
She agreed, I dropped him off and raced back over.
Things happened quickly. We had a quick awkward exchange when I got there, but she reached forward and grabbed my cock through my shorts and told me to follow her into her room, where I had been earlier.
I eagerly followed her. As soon as we got into her room she pulled my shorts off and went straight to her knees. She was impressed with my size too and immediately took it into her mouth working the shaft with her hand.
I knew I wasn’t going to last long if she kept going, her technique was amazing. I picked her up, laid her on the bed, pulled her shorts and thong off and dove into her soaking wet pussy tongue first. She squirm and squealed with delight.
After a few minutes she told me she wanted the real thing. I stood at the edge of the bed and entered her tight little hole. I was fairly inexperienced at the time, so all I was focusing on was not cumming and trying to give her one good orgasm.
She climbed on top, facing me and started riding while playing with her clit. I moved her hand away and replaced it with my thumb and she started to buck forward. I reached up with my other hand and held her upright while I kept thumbing her clit and she climaxed hard. I felt the warm rush over my crotch and knew I had at least accomplished enough to where I could cum without feeling too guilty.
She knew I was close so she got back down on her back and started talking dirty about how she wanted me to try to break her in half with my cock. It took me about two pumps before I had to pull out. She sat up, grabbed my cock and emptied it all over her tongue and face.
She used the tip of my cock to push every drop on her face into her mouth and swallowed all of it. I had never experienced anything like that before and I cannot even describe how sexy it was…
We cleaned up, I went home and saw her at work two days later. It was a little awkward at first, but we hooked up a couple more times before the summer ended and we both went back to school. I didn’t tell Anthony for a long time what happened, I thought he’d be pissed, but we both laugh about it now.
Hope y’all enjoyed!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/f2qqij/two_girls_in_the_same_night_kinda_a_funny_story
Way to seize the opportunity. Lemons —> Lemonade.