My girlfriend and her sister’s nude habits – Part IV [M/F].

I think what happened last night warranted a new entry and not just an update.

Before I begin let me describe to you the layout of our apartment.
The front door is located pretty much in the center of the wall. When you come in the living room is to your left. I has two identical couches facing each other with a coffee table in the middle and a side table on the one end of both couches.

On the right is a coat closet, coat hooks kind like where you would stash your winter stuff. Just past that is a writing desk that belong the Erica and Erin’s mom.

Behind the living room is the kitchen, separating the two rooms is a counter with three stools. This is basically where I sit to do everything including work. Beside the kitchen is the dining room.
And finally the back wall where the kitchen is, is an opening to a hallway that leads to the bedrooms. The bathroom door is right in line with the front door and the hall opening. The room on the right is Erin’s and the one on the left is mine.

So know you have an idea how the apartment is laid out, let me proceed.

Erin texted me sometime in the afternoon to say that she’ll be home early and is looking at the clock counting down the minutes. I really did not think anything of it, except that it was a person excited to get off work. So I just texted back “k”.

I was working on a report that has to be submitted Friday morning so I was focused on that. Plus my I was waiting to hear back from home about my dad. I hate to say but the situation with Erin and Erica was pushed to the back of my mind.

Now there was something I requested from both Erin and Erica when I was at their home, that if I am working and I have my headphones on, it means please do not disturb me. For about 95% of the time this is respected. For the most part if Erica came home, saw me with my headphones on, she will lay a hand on my shoulder, kiss me on the cheek and walk away. Erin would just walk right pass me and not pay me any mind.

The hours flew by and Erin came home. I did not have my headphones on since I was alone. She came in, I said hi, she came over kissed me and went to her room without saying a word. Then I put my headphones on.

Erin was in her room for about an hour and I assumed she was taking a nap. Then my phone rang and it was my mom. I picked and in the middle of the conversation… Erin walks out of her room all made up, wearing the sexiest black lingerie I have ever seen with a pair black shiny heels.

I could have sworn my mom heard my jaw hit the counter. I started to lose my composure, and I finally had to tell my mom that my boss was calling me and I’ll call her right back.

Erin had a naughty smirk. “That’s right your boss is calling you.” I told her she looked beautiful. She was damn gorgeous. I have seen her get dolled up before, but she took it to a whole new level.

She smiled as she walked towards me. I started to stand up to receive her and she told me to stay seated. She turned my laptop around to see what music I was playing, she hit play and pulled the headphones off my laptop.

Learn to fly by the Foo Fighters started to play. Erin smiled and slowly swayed her hips looking me straight in the eye. I swear this was a wet dream come true.

As she was dancing she took my right hand and put my middle finger in her mouth, kissing, sucking and licking it. Then she took my hand and rubbed it on her left then right breast.

She then dropped my hand and turned around to show me her ass as she swayed more provocatively. She took both my hands on put it on her hips. I pulled her towards me and she smelled wonderful.

The song ended and she arched back until were we cheek to cheek and she said “Am I not worth the distraction?” I shook my head and smiled. She pulled back and looked at me with a sense of shock and asked “I’m not?”

I smiled and I said “Honey, you are were a distraction and a half.” Then I froze as I realized I called her “honey”. Erin smiled and put her arms around my neck and kissed me. Again it was a loving kiss. She stopped the kiss, looked deeply into my eyes and bit her bottom lip. I knew she was trying to decide if she was going to tell me something or not.

She knew I caught it and instead said “would you come to bed?”.
I stood up and I took her hand and we went to her bedroom.

I asked her to leave her lingerie on as we had sex. She was definitely beautiful. Very beautiful. I feel my knees weaken every time I looked at her. Her eyes closed, the pleasure in her face.

We were together for about three hours. Every second of it touching each other in every different way. Some of it loving, some of it playful, and some of it naughty. All were wonderful.

Erin fell asleep in my arms. I dozed off and woke up an hour later. I got up, took a shower, made coffee and went back to work. I figured it was about 11:30.

I saw the light in Erin’s room come on and about 5 minutes later she comes out of her room, goes to the bathroom. She took off her make up and then joined me in the kitchen. She was wearing a robe.

“Come back to bed” she said reaching her hand to me. I took her hand but I did not move from my chair. “I can’t honey I have to have this done by Friday.”.

“You called me honey again”. She said. I could not read the expression on her face.

I did not realize what I said. I waited for her to make the next move.

“I’m not Erica” she said.

“I know your not. You’re Erin”. I replied. I looked at her and noticed the tear falling from her eye. I pulled her close and held her.

It was then that she told me what she meant to say earlier when I caught her biting her lip.

“I love you. I always have.”

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/51rgd5/my_girlfriend_and_her_sisters_nude_habits_part_iv

76 comments

  1. I’m sorry to learn that this will be your last entry but I understand. Like I mentioned before I have followed your stories since your first post.

    Though your stories are hot, you have a way of making the reader understand and even feel what you are feeling through your good story telling.

    Good luck and I hope things work out for you, Erin and Erica.

  5. I haven’t commented on any of your stories, but I’ve followed them from the first one. Thank you for sharing this turn of events, you are a wonderful story teller. Have a good life, friend.

  7. Damn, leaving us with that kind of ending??? Hoping you will eventually do a post to let us know what happened.

  8. I too have followed your stories since the beginning. I think most of us knew that Erin had feelings for you based on your third post. Did you know? Did you just ignore it?

    Tread lightly even if the cards are on the table, use them wisely.

    Good luck to you. In the end I hope all three of you find happiness.

  11. Didn’t come here for the feels. I want my erection back.

    Jokes aside, despite this being a complicated situation, I will tell you this: All these feelings you’re feeling right now, and the ones that are generated in Erin, these are the moments you remember fondly over the years. Enjoy them.

  12. What a confusing and complicated life you live. I sincerely hope nothing but the best for you bud. Good luck and God speed!

  13. Great story, and I found it kinda funny that the last sex encounter you are going to leave us on is 1 where she is wearing lingerie. A story about girls who are comfortable being naked constantly and the last time you have sex in the story is with clothes.

  14. Please don’t let this be your last update ?, we need more! Your stories are so good. When I read them I feel like I can put my self in your place because of how well you explain and describe things ?

  15. Funny how life ends up sometimes. I started off in a relationship with my friend which ended due to having to move because of work, although we remained close afterwards.

    Fast forward a couple years later and her younger sister moves into the same city due to her studies and some situation ends up with her needing a place to stay which just ended up with us living together.

    A year later and I’m plowing her sister all over the place like you brush your teeth every day, all our social life was pretty much one and the same too. Due to our history we were never in a ‘relationship’ but it was essentially exclusive to each other anyway.

    Over time it ended up her sister was happy we were together since I was someone she and her family trusted. And I suppose time let the reality sink in for everyone. And we’ve now been married long enough to have a couple of kids in tow.

    Also sisters talk even if it takes some time, because some of those tricks that happen in the bedroom either they are genetic or they talk about more than we think they do.

  16. I read and re-read what I posted earlier and it made me think that pussy footing around the situation is not help you any so I decided to take the gloves off.

    I know this is not an advice column, but reading your stories has had me invest some emotional feelings on how this might end.

    First, the world is full of stories of people loving the wrong person for the right reason or loving the right person for the wrong reason. Now I don’t know which one you are and you seriously need to find out.

    With that being said do not tell Erin that you love her back until you are a 100% sure that you do love her and not the way she makes you feel right now. Otherwise you are fooling yourself and hurting Erin in the end.

    Now is the time to think, double think, triple think, over think. Put a pause in the enjoying the moment. Erica left a giant hole in your life and Erin is there to fill it.

    My advice, work on this alone. Obviously, having a beautiful naked woman around you makes you lose you focus. Joking aside, I can tell you that loving her back is the best thing to do but we are not in a Tom Hanks/ Meg Ryan movie.

    In reality, the best thing to do is to figure out what is best for you and be honest about it, use your head with a little help from your heart but leave your dick out of it.

  17. I wish you luck. And lots of wisdom.

    I understand your need for time to think. Maybe we’ll hear how you played your cards much later.

  18. I literally feel like I’m the one dating Erica and Erin. Your posts are amazing. Jealousy has definitely caught the best of me.

    I hope things work out for you but shouldn’t you two have a chat with Erica at some point in time?

  19. This was an amazing read man, you’ve offered some very intimate insight into your life. Thank you for sharing this experience with all of us. I’ve also followed your story since the first post, I hope everything works out for you. At the end of the day you should follow your heart and do what you think is best for you, you’re a sold guy. Stay strong amigo.

  54. Holy fuck this messed me up. Goodbyes get me like a mother. Plus with no closure for the story. Please update a few months down the line. Best of luck OP. Truly, best of luck.

  56. Not much for gonewild, but at this point i do not care, i love what you have written and i can only hope that whatever path you decide to take, you take it with confidence in your own assuredness.

    I will say please don’t let this be your last post on the subject, i can say with some clarity that those of us who have followed from your first post wouldn’t want to leave this story unfinished

  57. As with most things on the internet, I have no way to tell if this is true or not. That said it was a great read, I read all 4 parts today. Fuck Nicholas Sparks, you made me feel down there as well as in my heart. I do hope this is genuinely true cuz it does make a pretty great love story, one we don’t even know the full ending to, maybe Erica will want to get back with you who knows. But i hope you are able to figure out what you want to do and what is best for you. Please don’t let this be the last post ever, we all must know how it ends. We are all here for you man.

  58. Ah man, another great saga cut off too soon. Thanks for the wild ride good sir. Best of luck with the situation.

  61. this isn’t messed up. It’s not weird. I must say, I have Never seen a bunch of more supportive comments from DaHouse. That’s saying something! I think you have really touched everyone here.

    An observation = things between some sisters can be.. like an alien lifeform. Including the way stuff works out “between them”.

    I say that with the best humour.

    I would suggest that Erin will be the one to talk all this through with Sis. After all, you more or less officially parted ways with Erica in any case yes?

    So theoretically you could be seeing.. anyone.

    Things take time to develop. (I’m talking about the way you feel) Let it develop. Or not. But leap in and see how it goes.

  62. Like everyone else, I can honestly say your stories have been absolutely amazing. And I wish you the best in figuring out what to do. I know it seems like an impossible decision to have to make, since you’re consistently drawing away from Erica and to Erin. But compare the feeling you had for Erica back then and Erin now. Best of luck buddy.

  63. What an emotional roller coaster. I won’t try to echo the advice everyone has already said, because it will be just that – an echo.

    You write very well, OP. Which would lead me to believe you think a lot about what you write. I think you’ll do well to think behind the content much more than about the construction after all of this development.

    I almost hope this is all fake, just so nome of the 3 of you actually have to go through any of this. I wish you all the best of luck. I hope it all settles and everyone’s happy and this comes to pass as a beautiful memory in a decade or more. If this truly is your last entry, OP, good luck. You’re definitely in a sticky situation.

  64. If you did write another part, it could be called

    My girlfriend and her sisters farm habits

  66. I hope for the best for you and with whatever happens I hope you find that happiness in your heart. Like some of these other posts have said follow what your mind wants not heart nor penis. If she(Erin) truly makes you happy and you want to pursue a relationship with her then go for it.

    I know you said this would be your last post but I hope you give us an update sometime in the near future. Good Luck OP!

  67. Thank you all so much for the support. When I wrote the first entry, it was from the perspective of a guy who could not believe his luck. It was the the closest thing to living in the Playboy mansion as I could get.

    Back then all I expected to get in response (in this particular order) was “BULLSHIT” or “way to go”. And I get some of both.

    By the second entry it was becoming, more “give us more”.

    My purpose for writing the third entry was to update people who were following the story. I did not mean for it to get as emotional and you can actually read it from the beginning when I started it as “so that happened”.

    Like most people who got hurt I tried to convince myself that I was okay. And the third entry was about me having sex with Erin feeding on the premise since the beginning of my entries, “is he going to nail both sisters?”

    I thought that writing the third entry was going to be some sort of therapy and telling myself that I wasn’t hurt as much as I knew I was.

    However, recalling the events with Erica, taking myself back to the farm, re-experiencing our dying days the emotions just flowed out of me.

    The joy I thought I had when I found a kindred spirit in Erin who shared my and understood my grief and my loneliness.

    Last night Erin and I talked. It was really more like Erin spoke to me and this time she really laid the cards down on the table.

    She told me something that shook my world, because I have never heard anything like it before in my life.

    She said “You have given me the chance to tell you and show you that I love you. Now please give me the chance to make you love me.”

    I told her that I have to think about it this weekend because there are things I need to work out. She said she knew where I was emotionally and that she understood.

    Both Erin and Erica are wonderful people. They are both beautiful, kind, affectionate and thoughtful. Erica is more playful, witty and fun. While Erin is more sincere, loving and thoughtful. Best way to illustrate this is Erica will hold you, kiss you passionately and then the very next second will be playfully biting your nose. Erin will hold you, kiss you passionately, probably 10 seconds longer than Erica will and then look deeply in your eyes for about 5 seconds.

    But now Erica is focused on what she feels is much bigger than me and her. She has blinders on and she can only see one goal. Her goal is something I cannot lead nor follow so I just got out of the way. For that reason I had to let her go.

  68. Well this post chain brought me from being a lurker to a name carrying member, so that’s something.

    I won’t give you advice unless you need it, but really there is some great stuff here for advice otherwise.
    I will say that I’ve been in a startlingly similar situation with 2 girls who might as well have been sisters (bffs from diapers) and i ended up right where you’re at after a near-exact chain of events.

    Best of luck and it sounds like you have a good head on your shoulders.

  69. I’m mobile so I won’t make this very long, but for the sake of relationships/sanity/happiness among all three of you, you need to take a 6 month break from Erin to make sure that what you have now is real and not just loneliness.
    Erica needs to know that her sister didn’t steal her man as soon as she was out of the picture, you need to decide if you’re truly over Erica and find out if Erin is a surrogate for Erica/someone to stop you from being lonely or someone you genuinely want to be with and Erin needs to preserve her relationship with her sister by not immediately jumping in bed with her sisters bf and she also needs to prove that this isn’t some sisterly jealousy thing as in she wants what her sister had vs just wanting you because you’re amazing.

    You can’t make all those things happen without true separation and time to think without being distracted.
    If it’s meant to be, Erin will still be ready down the line but if it’s not, this has the potential to blow up and blow up badly.

  70. I started reading all your post for the same reason everybody reads this posts to get a nut out of it. But now I’m more emotional invested that i like to admit. I had a feeling that Erin liked you from the beginning but didn’t really think it was love. The way she is acting it’s like a dream come true for her. Right now you are confused because of the break up so your feelings are not really there if that makes sense. Erin might have a bubble pop because at the end your going to need some time alone to think. I’m hoping we get an update on the future. Good luck

  71. From the very first post, I got the impression that, as she was known then, GFS had a crush on you. No reason for her to be that invested in her sister’s relationship that early. Yet she continued to. And no matter what she says about her nudism, there’s no way that was an “every boyfriend” thing with her allowing herself to be naked in front of you.

    I never figured that when those feelings boiled over it would be such a beautiful thing.

  72. Update: Erica knows. Erin told her last night (Friday, 9/9).

    Will update when I get back home on Wednesday.

  73. I remember stumbling across your first post and thinking, “Wow, that lucky bastard!”

    You have been on one hell of an emotional roller coaster that I am sure these writings don’t even begin to give us insight into.

    Others have given their advice, so I will also add mine: You have to ask yourself whether you think breaking up with Erica was a mistake. Not whether you still love her, or vice versa, but whether breaking up with her was a bad move. Did she still love you more than anything? Could you convince her to leave the farm? Could you adapt to the farm? If the answer is no; then unfortunately you need to move on.

    That leaves Erin. If you have any romantic feelings for her – and by the way you describe her in your writing, I think you care for her more than you lust for her – I think you should give her a chance. Yes, Erica may get hurt. In the end though, someone will get hurt in the end of this, maybe multiple people. If I was in your situation, I would ask Erin to be my girlfriend, but require myself or her to call Erica and tell her what we planned to do – so she doesn’t feel betrayed by her sister. I think you’d be surprised, I assume Erica already suspects a relationship between you two may already be in the works.

    I really hope to hear what happens, be it another post or via a short private message on Reddit.

  74. Good luck with everything… I hope that your heart sings true and that everything works out.

  75. Am I the only one here chomping at the bit to read more. Not even for the Sex, just the story itself is that interesting. I came here to fap…. Instead I found a wonderful story. Thank you good sir, and keep it up for as long as you can.

  76. Like a few people in this thread, I was a lurker and after reading your stories I had to sign up so I could comment. But before that, I just wanted you to know that 2 months ago my then fiancee and I called off our wedding. Her name was Erica.

    I started reading your first post on the day it came out and you and I having partners with the same name became a novelty that I considered cool. I even teased my then fiancee about how cool it would have been if her sister was named Erin (instead of Heather). She looked at me quizzically, not understanding why.

    Last Saturday was the first time I read parts 2, 3 and 4. Reading part 2 had me excited for you. I found myself wanting to shake your hand and wish you good luck. I could not wait to read the next part.

    Part 3 had me crying. Not only did you bring me to the farm house with you and Erica as you were breaking up, you also took me back to when me and my Erica parted ways. You described the very same emotions I felt when I left her house. I wanted to stop reading but I couldn’t, I had to know what would happen next.

    When you first described having sex with Erin I was mad at you for betraying Erica. I thought to myself that you are just like every other douche bag out there that give men a bad rep. And still I kept reading. I ended part 3 thinking that you are a tool.

    What the hell, I have gone this far I might as well read part 4 and I was glad I did. You gave me hope. I saw that you were not a tool and you wanted to do the right thing for both sisters. When you called Erin honey the second time and she said she was not Erica, your answer was brilliant. I don’t know if that was something you came up with on the fly or something you thought long and hard before you said it. And her reaction was priceless. The last sentence was what gave me hope.

    Now like some have mentioned here, I have no way of knowing if this is true or not. But either way I must tell you that I wish I was in your shoes. Either as a man with the love of two beautiful women or a person who has as vivid an imagination as you. Your ability to make the reader see through your eyes is great. But the ability to make the reader feel what you are feeling through your story telling is what makes it exceptional.

    I am eagerly awaiting for your update on Wednesday. I hope it turns out well. Good luck, OP.

Comments are closed.