Batter Up: Part 3, A Pinch Hitter [MF] [MF]

[Part 1 ](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/cqfc7p/batter_up_mf/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf)

[Part 2 ](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/didmyj/batter_uppart_2_press_box_fun_mf/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf)

So after Annie and I had our little romp at the ballpark, things were just normal and friendly. I definitely wanted to fuck her again, but there was no awkwardness between us. We hung out a few times just as friends but that was all for a while.

About a year went by and we didn’t see that much of each other. I had started dating another girl and Annie had taken herself off the market for a while. One day out of the blue she calls me and asks if we can grab some drinks. Of course I say yes and we set the date.

I arrive at a little hole in the wall bar and see Annie sitting in the corner booth already having ordered herself a drink. When she got up to give me a hug, I was shocked. That pudgy body that I saw not long ago was replaced with a tight, toned figure. Her chubby thighs were now thick, athletic thighs screaming to escape her tight jeans. Her plump tits were now perky, medium sized boobs only held up by a thin tank top.

“Annie, you look incredible!”

“ Thank you! I took the year off to do me and get some of my mojo back.”

“Well you certainly have got my attention”

She blushed and we hugged while I was trying to hide my now growing erection.

We sat and caught up a bit. I told her about how I had dated and broken up with a crazy girl who whole was excellent in the sack, stalked me at work and while with my other friends. We laughed about it and took down a few more drinks.

“Do you remember my sister?” Annie said.

“Of course, how could I forget her” I replied

Mary was Annie’s sister. She was 2 years younger and had been away at school. She was taller than Annie, probably about 5’7”, and was heavy set. Different than Annie was, Mary would fall into the BBW category. Big thick thighs, a bit of a belly, but an enormous set of tits to go with the package. I am guessing somewhere in the neighborhood of a G cup.

“Well she moved back to town and we got an apartment together down the street” she said.

“That’s cool. I always liked her. She was hilarious when she worked in the kitchen at the ballpark.”

“She always liked you too. In fact, I may have mentioned that you and I hooked up and she was a bit upset”

“Oh yeah, why?”

“Well she said she always had a bit of a crush on you”

“Haha well I hope that wasn’t awkward for you”

“No it wasn’t, I think it’s cute and plus, I can’t blame her for the crush.”

So we finish up our drinks and she invites me over to hang out the next night. So we hug and I plant a kiss on her cheek and head to my car.

The next day I show up at Annie’s new place. She’s got a little 2 bedroom apartment near where we worked at the ballpark. I didn’t see Annie’s car out front but I went up to the door anyways and knocked. To my surprise, Mary opened the door in a towel covering her upper body.

“Hey Mary,” I said as I gave her a quick hug.

“Hey, it’s good to see you! Annie has to run out for a bit but she said you would be coming over.” Mary replies trying to keep her enormous tata’s covered.

“I’m about to jump in the shower,” she said, “but you can hang here. I’m not sure when she’ll be back.”

I was a little annoyed that she didn’t tell me she wasn’t going to be there, but I sat back on the couch and relaxed for a bit. I heard the shower turn on down the hall and couldn’t help but think about Mary soaping up those giant tits. Part of me wanted to walk down the hall and try to peak in, but I stayed put on the couch.

A few minutes later I hear the water turn off and the door open shortly after. Then Mary emerges from down the hall with her hair up in a towel and another towel once again desperately clinging above her tits.

“She’s still not back huh? Well too bad for her” she said as she sat down on the couch next to me.

“ I agree!”

“So, just so this isn’t awkward, Annie told me you hooked up. And I’m guessing she told you that I used to have a crush on you.” Mary said.

“Yeah we hooked up. And used to have a crush, that’s kind of a relief,”. I said.

“Well, used to, still do, it’s a gray area. Still have to admit, a little jealous of her”

“What’s there to be jealous about, I’m nothing special.”

“That’s not what I’ve heard.”

“Oh really, how much has your sister told you?”

“Enough…”

She started to blush and her eyes moved down to my crotch. She started to squirm a little on the couch as did I.

“Hey, before she gets home, let me see what you are working with down there,” she said.

“Are you sure that’s a good idea,” I replied very surprised and cautious.

“It will be fine, I’m not asking you to fuck me in front of her. I just want to see your dick.”

“Alright well if I’m going to show you mine, you gotta show me yours”

Almost before I can finish the sentence, Mary stands up and drops her towel revealing the largest breasts I had ever seen in person. Additionally she had a nicely trimmed pussy hiding between a pair of thick thighs. Since she had fulfilled her end of the bargain, I stood and dropped my pants. Upon seeing her naked I was fully erect and pointing straight at Mary.

I by no means have a huge cock, but I have been told it is very pretty (that’s a story for another time). It is straight with no bend or anything with a shaft that transitions easily into a normal sized tip. Her eyes were locked on it and needless to say, mine were locked on her.

“You want to touch them” she said to me.

“Of course I do, but that might be taking it too far.” I said still staring at her tits.

“Come on it’s fine!” She said lightly shaking her tits back and forth.

“Alright a little squeeze couldn’t hurt.” I said walking toward her with my arms outstretched.

I put my hands around her enormous globes and gently squeezed. She closed her eyes and quietly moaned as my fingers moved her large nipples. While I was working her tits, her hand wandered now and gently grabbed my cock. She slowly started to jerk my cock. It felt amazing with her soft hand gently rubbing my cock.

Then my worst nightmare started to play out. The front door of the apartment opened and Annie entered. Mary and I both stopped and shot our gaze in the direction of the door.

At this point I was formulating excuses in my head as what was occurring but I couldn’t think of anything.

“What the fuck is going on!” Annie said more than slightly annoyed.

Mary and I just stood in silence, she still standing there naked and my cock still hanging out. We looked at each other then at Annie. The next thing that came out of Annie’s mouth was the last thing I expected to hear.

“Haha, nevermind, I knew this would happen! Why do you think I left you two alone.”

“What!?!?” Mary and I both said.

“I knew Mary still liked you and I knew if I left you two alone she was try to scratch that itch persay” Annie said.

“So you set this up?” I said still trying to wrap my head around this.

“I sure did. So now Mary, you got to see what you wanted to see and I got you warmed up and ready to go.”

“Wow, that was sneaky, and I like it. And I have to be honest, those aren’t too bad either.” I said motioning toward Mary’s still exposed tits.

“Yeah those things are hard to top. Let me see what I can do in that department,” Annie said grabbing my hand and leading me down the hall to her room.

So Annie led me down the hall to her room while her sister picked up her towel and went to her room. As soon as the door closed she was on me. My pants of course were already off so she took off my shirt. I subsequently started taking her clothes off as well. Her body was smokin. She still had that athletic building but her tits popped much more than before and she still had a round, toned ass.

She grabbed my cock and started to stroke it. I started to rub her pussy. She was already pretty wet. My cock felt so good in her hand. Unlike Mary, Annie really knew what she was doing. I stopped rubbing her now dripping wet pussy and I grabbed her ass. Then I lifted Annie up and she wrapped her legs around me. With her legs around my waist and her arms around me neck, I rubbed my cock on her clit and slowly put it in.

She bounced up and down on me and like the last time we fucked, she was very loud. I squeezed her ass and moved her up and down on my cock.

Then we moved over to her bed. I stayed on top of her while standing on the ground. Now I could really get a good look at her. Her pussy was spread wide by my cock and I could see the trimmed pubes as I went in and out of her. She squeezed my ass and pulled me as far in as my cock would go.

Annie then pushed me off of her and I laid down on the bed. She then squatted over me and guided my cock into her. With her hand on my chest she bounced up and down on my cock. This got tiring very quickly and then she kneeled with me still in her. This is my absolute favorite position. She rocked back and forth on my cock while I played with her clit. Then I pulled her face towards mine and we kissed. I grabbed her ass and bounced her up and down while we kissed.

“I’m gonna cum!” I whispered to her.

“Just cum in me!” She said back.

Right before I came I grabbed her ass and thrusted my cock as deep into her as possible and shot my load.

We cleaned up and took a shower. Then we went out to the couch to hang out and have some drinks. Mary joined us as well and we ended up having a nice little evening catching up and having drinks.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/dlnvwc/batter_up_part_3_a_pinch_hitter_mf_mf