Foursome: We invited a third guy to help us fill her [Group]

It’s been fun writing this one. I’ve had to ask Aly a lot of questions in order to get things straight. Always the hard part of recounting a foursome—there are so many bodies!

**Month Before the Night**

Sam told Aly back in July that he was getting more into the idea of sharing her with multiple guys. They’d been in the hotwife lifestyle for four months at this point, and were feeling comfortable with her being shared. See previous posts. Aly decided one other guy joining us would be enough for this first experience. I offered to place the ad and field the responses. Neither of them wanted to have to deal with that initial, overwhelming response.

It wasn’t overwhelming though. Only thirty-nine replies. Most were what you’d expect: one-liners, guys claiming they’d ruin her, and some with only stats given. Nothing interesting. We narrowed it down to six guys. A first bench, and a second. Hope that doesn’t sound harsh. Three of the guys disappeared on us right away. Two of the others we liked a lot. Both were D names, so I’ll call them Dungeons and Dragons for the sake of having fun (they’re not here long; you won’t get annoyed). Dragons we liked a lot. He had the best response, was extremely flirtatious, looked good, and seemed very respectful. Then he vanished for five days. When he came back, he claimed to have been in the Boundary Waters without service. We said cool, told him he was the one we wanted. Then he vanished again. Still hasn’t come back. In that span of time, Sam and Aly have gone up north twice and returned. I don’t know what kind of canoe Dragons has, but godspeed to him.

Dungeons we liked, and still do. Definitely Aly’s type. He just wasn’t very flirtatious. We never got the feeling he really wanted to fuck her. In fact, he hardly messaged us about sex at all. Maybe he was playing it safe. We were on the fence with him, when Sam noticed another ad that was posted. A guy looking to watch a couple play. Sam messaged him, they all started chatting, and then Aly asked him (Adam) what he thought of joining a gangbang instead of just watching. 0-100 like that.

Adam was into it. He seemed respectful, reserved, had no set expectations. He was 28 (we’re 30 by the way) and athletic. Had a photo of his penis on a Reddit sub that Sam and Aly thought looked good, but wouldn’t ruin her for other men (?) We met with him mid-September at a bar near their place. I got there first, followed by Adam. We chatted for a bit and I answered any questions he had. The big one was, “So he’s okay with you seeing her alone?” He couldn’t quite believe that part. But yes, I am that lucky.

Sam and Aly arrived and it was a pretty quick hour of getting to know each other. Adam had been recently tested and hadn’t had a partner in several months. He was very quiet. Probably a little in disbelief still that the woman across from him wanted to take him and these two other guys all at once. But we all had a good time and then split up. As we were leaving, Aly kissed Adam on the cheek and then we started walking the opposite direction from him. Immediately we saw or I said something that made Aly say, loudly, “Yuck!” and we were still in earshot of Adam. We were positive he must have heard and thought she was talking about him.

“Well, you ruined it,” we told her. Thankfully that wasn’t the case.

I dropped Aly and Sam off at home, but we were all too horny after that and had a quick threesome to calm ourselves down. That sounds extremely casual, but that’s how it goes sometimes.

We set the date (and booked the hotel) for October 12th. Four weeks of waiting and building anticipation. In that time we had several more threesomes and one-on-one’s. Some of which I still want to write about, but I’ve been lazy. The goal was to get Aly’s ass prepped for DP. On October 10th I came over and accidentally started to slip into her ass. We went with it and I fucked her tight hole mercilessly. That was the last practice before Saturday.

**Saturday**

They got into their room at 4 on Saturday, and I joined them by 5. We told Adam to come over whenever, then we went to the bar and came back and began playing cards. I found out that before I got there, Sam had gone down on Aly, bringing her so close to the edge, but not quite letting her finish. Meanwhile he (and this will be important later) had not cum since Thursday. They were both extremely ready to get this going. Adam got there soon after and we started playing “Who’s the Biggest Pervert”, which is a pretty tame card game, but good for an icebreaker. I can’t say Sam or Aly learned anything new about me, and vice versa, but it gave Adam a good window into our kinks. And helped him loosen up. While Aly and Sam were excited, Adam seemed nervous. We added a strip element to the game eventually (because of course we did) and soon the guys were all in briefs and shirts, while Aly had only her panties and top. We allowed her to keep the top (it was cold) so long as she pulled it down over her tits.

I went to the bathroom once, came back, and found him and Aly kissing while Sam watched with the biggest grin. Then we put away the card game and broke out their spinner along with a board Aly wrote a few challenges on. I can’t remember all of them, but a couple stand out. Someone landed on Give A Lapdance, and ordered Aly to give me one. It was hard to resist pulling her down onto me and fucking her right there. But I did. Adam landed on Give A Kiss and was nice enough to have Aly make out with Sam. But while they were, I signaled Adam to start feeling her tits. That was the second intimate encounter between them that night. He massaged them briefly, feeling her piercing and giving her a couple firm squeezes while Sam kissed her.

We decided to move to the bed. We’d already told Adam that he could start out watching and join in whenever he felt comfortable. Sam and I took Aly to the bed while Adam stayed on the couch, then moved to a chair that was closer. This was my favorite part of the night, and talking about it with her later, one of Aly’s favorites.

Aly laid on the bed and I repositioned her so that Adam could have a good look at her pussy as Sam began to finger her. I kissed her, asked her if she was ready, and then Sam and I began kissing her tits. Once Sam pulled his hand from Aly’s pussy, I moved my mouth to take his place. Again, positioning myself so that Adam could hopefully see my tongue sliding along Aly’s already-wet lips. I didn’t look up at Adam much, so I’m not sure when or if he ever did take his shorts off and start stroking. The couple times I saw, he was still partially dressed.

Sam was naked now and began fucking Aly’s throat while I ate her out. I loved putting on a show. We switched eventually and I pulled Aly around and to the edge of the bed so that I could stand and fuck her face while Sam took his turn going down on his wife’s pussy. She came quickly—like a good husband should probably be, Sam was an expert at bringing her to the edge and over fast. It certainly helped that she was teased so much earlier that afternoon. Meanwhile, I was getting hard in Aly’s throat, hearing her moan around my cock as she came. As soon as she had, Sam began to fuck her. We didn’t want to give her any break. One of the goals was to go non-stop until she was begging for a rest. That didn’t exactly happen. Nor did strapping her to the bed (one of the cuffs was broken) or roughly “using” her like we had talked about. I was in a different headspace that night, Adam was pretty reserved, and we fell into a more relaxed foursome. Which is still sexy and a lot of fun. But for those expecting an all-out gangbang, that’ll have to be another time down the road.

After awhile of fucking her mouth and cunt, we opted to switch places. While I took my turn at Aly’s pussy, which was still quivering from her orgasm, she looked up at Adam and gave him the “Come here” motion. He stood, removing the rest of his clothes, and went to stand over her face, still off the edge of the bed. He was nearly hard, and began to work his cock into her mouth. For those wondering, I know some of you do, he was probably a good half inch longer than me (I’m 6.5 to his, let’s say, 7). Girthwise, he looked plenty thick. Aly said later we felt the same. So I can assume he’s at least 6 inches around. It was incredibly hot watching another thick cock slide into Aly’s mouth, and watching her adjust to accommodate it.

Watching it was too hot though. I didn’t fuck her long before I was ready to blow. We’d agreed earlier (Sam, Aly, and I) that we’d all take turns cumming on her the first round, so we could get a good photo for Reddit. So I pulled out and came just above her pussy and on her stomach. Sam offered Adam his wife’s hole next. I moved and Adam climbed onto the bed. We hadn’t told him about our intention in all cumming on her. And he looked a bit cautious with my cum still on her. So I offered a towel to wipe her up. That was something we were bummed about a bit later, but oh well. After we cleaned my cum off her, I got into position again at the end of the bed, with Aly licking our mixed cum off my cock. And Adam entered her for the first time. I wish, now, that I would have looked at either of their faces to see how they were reacting. But like Sam, I think I was busy watching it happen. He slid in and out easily, she was still so wet, and got a good rhythm going. Aly was moaning around my cock again, and I massaged her tits and slapped her face a few times. Just short of calling her a slut. Which she would have liked.

Adam didn’t last long either. A few minutes after he began fucking her, he pulled out and shot a couple ropes onto her stomach. We finally let Aly get fully onto the bed at this point. It’s a wonder she hadn’t passed out yet. Sam fucked her, no doubt feeling her pussy stretched out by the three of us. He took a break, and Adam was watching again, so I went down on Aly next. She was wet, warm, and so sweet. I wanted to make her cum again, so I lapped at her engorged lips and flicked my tongue over her clit. Eventually applying the right pressure and firmness and getting her to quake against my mouth. She tasted even sweeter after that.

Sam was back in the game at this point though, so he began fucking her while I switched to getting some oral attention from her. We pulled Aly to the side of the bed again (poor girl) and I fucked her throat while Sam reclaimed her pussy. Now remember how Sam hadn’t cum in a couple days? When he was ready, he pulled out, intending to cover his wife’s stomach and tits. The first couple ropes did that, and then a huge shot of cum rocketed up to hit me in the neck, while another couple splattered my stomach.

“Ah, fuck you!”

But of course I didn’t actually mind. Sam was laughing even before he was finished cumming. Aly meanwhile was fucking impressed at the load. And later on we remarked to each other how it was a good thing I was the one in that position, and not Adam. He may not have responded so coolly.

It was time for a rest and a reset. Aly laid between Adam and I on the bed, while Sam was on the other side of me. We checked in with Adam, making sure he was still good. Then, skipping past the great-but-not-relevant-to-this-story conversation the four of us had, we got into it again. Sam told Aly he wanted her to go back and forth on the three of us, sucking each of our cocks. She started with Adam’s, getting him fully hard again. She moved to me but I was having technical difficulties, and then to Sam. While she was sucking him off, I got behind her and started at her doggystyle. This was brief though, because we decided we wanted to try DP for the first time that night.

The original plan was to have me fuck her ass, Sam her pussy, and Adam her mouth. However, as I was still at half-mast, we switched it up. Aly climbed on top of Adam, sinking her pussy down around his fat cock. As she slowly rode him, Sam lubed her asshole and then buried himself into her. I moved to Aly’s mouth, hoping Adam wasn’t going to mind a dick within six inches of his face.

Aly had me hard again fast, and I was thinking I wanted to tag one of the other dudes out, but then I remembered we needed a video. I found my phone and got down behind the three of them and, well, here.

Sam was in control, pounding Aly’s tight hole while her pussy throbbed and soaked Adam’s cock. After a few minutes, Sam pulled out and Aly lay between the two of them. I showed them the video and we cheered and high-fived our success at finally filling all of Aly’s holes. Sam went to sit on the chair and, well, I’m not sure what he was doing. Aly asked Adam if he wanted to fuck her again, and he eagerly got into position. She was on her back, legs spread, as he slid into her. I kneeled at her face again and let her sloppily play with my cock while Adam found a great rhythm and began pounding her while Sam cheered from across the room. Obviously enjoying seeing his wife get taken.

“Cum in her pussy,” I said to Adam. “I want to feel her used cunt after you’re done.”

He didn’t though. After a bit he pulled out and I moved to take his place. I slapped Aly’s tits, called her a slut, and slammed her wet (so fucking wet, Jesus fuck) pussy until I came inside her. As I pulled out, I invited Adam to take her again, as he hadn’t cum yet and was still hard.

“Did you cum inside her?” he asked. Looking a bit concerned.

“Yeah. She can go shower first if you want.”

I absolutely did not mean that, and Aly told me the other day she almost laughed out loud, because she certainly wouldn’t have done that. Thankfully Adam didn’t request that, or knew I was kidding, and started to fuck her again.

“How does that cum-filled pussy feel?” Aly asked him between ragged breaths.

“It feels good,” Adam said. It must have, because before long he pulled out and sprayed her stomach again.

Time for another rest. Aly had taken four loads on her body, and one inside her at this point. Sam joined the three of us in bed and we hung out like that for awhile. And in fact, this was the only part of the night I felt jealousy, when Aly climbed under the covers with Adam and cuddled up against him for a few minutes. Hey, I can admit it.

We threw some clothes on—Aly a stunning soft-blue number that I loved seeing on her, but also wanted to rip off—and moved to the sitting area. We hung out for a bit longer, talked about…I actually don’t remember what. I was busy thinking I wanted another round before the night was over. It was only about 11 PM, but I was getting exhausted (terrible week behind me as it were) and Sam was getting the tired giggles. So after a bit we called it. Adam got his jacket and said his goodbyes while Aly took him to the door and gave him another long kiss, thanking him for joining us and fucking her.

Not long after Adam left, Aly and I got back into bed. Sam was ordering pizza as Aly was starving. Can you blame her? Aly and I made out, and for the first time that night I was able to fully appreciate every touch and each part of her body as my hands roamed over her. That’s the part they don’t tell you about gangbangs: it’s a lot of movement and shifting, rotating, finding positions fair to everyone. Not a lot of intimacy. Just primal fucking.

As someone who responds most to intimacy, this was what I needed. While earlier I was more of an observer, now I felt like I could fuck Aly like I wanted to. Sam noticed us getting more passionate, and came over to bash me against the head with a pan. Kidding! He joined the two of us as Aly moved down between my legs (I’m just now realizing how much head I got that night) and Sam reclaimed her pussy yet again. He fucked her hard, and she was having a hard time focusing on my dick. I took it out of her mouth and slapped it against her face instead, covering her with her own spit, asking her if she liked getting used by three cocks.

Sam blew another huge load inside her. How do I know it was huge? First, because it’s Sam. But after he pulled out, I threw Aly over and plunged into her creamy pussy, wanting to feel that warmth around me. I could feel Sam’s cum and hers worked out of her by my cock, rolling down my balls and splattering her inner thighs.

At this time (we must have been going at it for awhile) there was a knock at the door and Sam went to answer. The bed was only around a corner and fifteen feet from the door. I have no idea what the driver looked like, but once I heard a woman’s voice, I whispered to Aly, “We should invite her in.”

She looked at me like, “Yes!” but then also, “I’m not sharing you guys!” Which is not quite fair considering how the night had gone.

Sam brought the pizza in. Meanwhile, knowing Aly was probably starving by this point, I slowed down my rhythm. That’s what drives me over the edge: slow, full, purposeful motion. The sensation of feeling every inch of her stretched, cum-filled pussy around me brought me to the brink. I erupted into her for our final orgasm of the night.

We cleaned up, showered, hung out a bit while the two of them ate. Sam went and got into bed at this point, so I went over and gave him a hug. Then like Adam, Aly showed me to the door with a passionate, lingering kiss. And we said goodnight.

Couple final items I found out later: Sam woke Aly up a few hours later and fucked her again. Final reclamation, and an eighth load of cum for her.

I asked Aly how many times she came, and when. Again, it’s hard to remember everything at a gangbang. She told me she came twice, both pretty early. Once when Sam ate her out, finally letting her cum. And then again when I went down on her in between her getting fucked.

Poor Adam never got to taste her, we realized. Probably because we were fucking pretty quickly after getting started and tasting freshly-fucked pussy might not be something he’s into yet. But, he messaged us the next day saying he had a great time, and reiterated that to Aly again later in the week. It was a great experience, and one his coworkers would not believe.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/djuy8n/foursome_we_invited_a_third_guy_to_help_us_fill